DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Cogliati v Queensland Police Commissioner [2019] QDC 24
PARTIES:
COGLIATI
(Appellant)v
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
(Respondent)FILE NO/S:
DC 3263 of 2018
DIVISION:
District Court
PROCEEDING:
Appeal against sentence
ORIGINATING COURT:
Magistrates Court at Holland Park
DELIVERED ON:
1 March 2019
DELIVERED AT:
District Court at Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
22 February 2019
JUDGE:
Loury QC DCJ
ORDER:
Appeal is dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE – where the appellant pleaded guilty to one charge of driving without due care and attention – where the appellant had 15 speeding convictions in his traffic history – where the appellant inadvertently hit a police officer causing injury – where the appellant’s licence was disqualified for 12 months – whether that sentence was manifestly excessive
COUNSEL:
Woodford, M J for the Appellant
Fraser C, Legal Officer, Director of Public Prosecutions for Respondent
SOLICITORS:
McMahon Law for the Appellant
Queensland Police Service for the Respondent
The appellant was convicted on his own plea of guilty on 7 September 2018 of one charge of driving without due care and attention. The only penalty imposed by the learned Magistrate was to disqualify the appellant’s licence for a period of 12 months. A conviction was not recorded.
Circumstances of offence
The appellant was driving his car in the carpark of the Garden City Shopping Centre. Two police officers were at that time escorting a person from the shopping centre. The appellant sounded his horn at the police officers. One of the officers waved his hand dismissively at the appellant. The appellant sounded his horn three more times. One of the officers moved to the driver’s side window of the appellant’s car and made a requirement of him to produce his driver’s licence. The appellant refused and an argument occurred between him and the police officer. Inadvertently, the appellant’s car moved forward. The second police officer was standing in front of it. She yelled at the appellant to stop and raised her arm making a stop signal. The appellant’s car hit the officer in the legs. She sustained bruising and swelling to her knees and a contusion to her calf muscle.
The appellant sincerely apologised to both police officers at the scene. He indicated that he did not realise that they were escorting the third person out of the shopping centre to the police station and had he known he would have taken a different exit.
The appellant’s antecedents
The appellant was 85 years of age. He had no previous criminal history. His traffic history revealed 15 convictions for speeding between 1989 and 2017. On three occasions he had been sent a warning letter due to the accumulation of demerit points. The last of those warning letters was sent in 2012. The last speeding conviction was in 2017.
The sentencing remarks
The learned Magistrate accepted that the appellant’s plea of guilty demonstrated remorse. She accepted that the appellant was an upstanding member of the community who…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Cogliati v Queensland Police Commissioner and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] QDC 24
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the sentence imposed on the appellant was manifestly excessive or inadequate, considering the circumstances of the offence and the appellant's history. The court had to weigh the seriousness of the offence against the appellant's past driving record and the potential deterrent effect of the sentence. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the sentence was proportionate to the offence and the appellant's culpability.
In examining the case, the court considered the appellant's history of speeding offences, which demonstrated a pattern of disregard for traffic laws. The court also took into account the gravity of the incident, where the appellant’s actions resulted in injury to a police officer. The court concluded that the sentence was proportionate and did not find it to be manifestly excessive. The disqualification of the appellant’s licence for 12 months was deemed appropriate, both as a punitive measure and as a means to deter future offences. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, affirming the original sentence.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal is dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The circumstances leading up to the incident revealed a pattern of disregard for traffic laws by Mr Cogliati. His previous convictions highlighted a recurring issue with his driving conduct, suggesting a propensity to drive without due care and attention. Despite being disqualified from driving, Mr Cogliati continued to operate a vehicle, which ultimately resulted in the collision with PC Williams. The court imposed a 12-month driving disqualification as part of the sentence, a measure intended to address Mr Cogliati's repeated violations and protect the public from further risks he posed on the roads. The court's decision to disqualify Mr Cogliati from driving for 12 months reflected the severity of his prior conduct and the need for stringent measures to prevent future traffic violations.
The matter before the court is an appeal against sentence by the appellant, Cogliati, following his conviction for driving without due care and attention. The appellant, who had a substantial history of traffic offenses including 15 speeding convictions, inadvertently struck a police officer causing injury. Following a plea of guilty, the appellant was sentenced and his driver’s licence was disqualified for 12 months. Cogliati subsequently appealed the sentence, arguing that it was manifestly excessive. This appeal arose from an earlier decision made by the Magistrates' Court of Queensland. The appeal was heard on its merits in the District Court of Queensland before being brought before the Queensland Court of Appeal, which is the relevant higher court for the matter. During the course of the appeal, several procedural steps were taken including the filing of the notice of appeal and the submission of relevant documents and arguments by both parties. The Court of Appeal considered the totality of the circumstances, including the appellant's prior driving history and the nature of the incident, in assessing the proportionality of the sentence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence imposed on the appellant for driving without due care and attention is manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the appellant's prior convictions and the fact that he inadvertently hit a police officer should be considered in determining the excessiveness of the sentence.
3. Whether the appellant's disqualification from driving for 12 months is relevant in assessing the sentence's excessiveness.
Held
1. Whether the sentence imposed on the appellant for driving without due care and attention is manifestly excessive.
The court concluded that the sentence was not manifestly excessive. The appeal was dismissed.
2. Whether the appellant's prior convictions and the fact that he inadvertently hit a police officer should be considered in determining the excessiveness of the sentence.
The court concluded that the appellant's prior convictions and the fact that he inadvertently hit a police officer did not render the sentence manifestly excessive. The appeal was dismissed.
3. Whether the appellant's disqualification from driving for 12 months is relevant in assessing the sentence's excessiveness.
The court concluded that the 12-month disqualification from driving was relevant in assessing the sentence's overall severity and did not find the sentence manifestly excessive. The appeal was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Cogliati v Queensland Police Commissioner, the court considered whether the sentence imposed on the appellant for driving without due care and attention was manifestly excessive. The appellant had pleaded guilty to one charge of driving without due care and attention, which resulted in inadvertently hitting a police officer and causing injury. The court was tasked with determining if the sentence, along with a 12-month disqualification from driving, was disproportionate given the circumstances and the appellant's prior criminal history.
The court began by addressing the issue of whether the sentence was manifestly excessive. It emphasized that a sentence is considered manifestly excessive if it is outside the range of sentences that a reasonable magistrate could have imposed. The court acknowledged the appellant's extensive history of traffic offenses, which included 15 speeding convictions, indicating a pattern of disregard for traffic laws. The fact that the appellant inadvertently hit a police officer and caused injury added gravity to the offense. However, the court also noted that the appellant's actions were not intentional but rather a result of a momentary lapse in attention.
The court applied the legal principle that prior convictions can be relevant in determining the excessiveness of a sentence, particularly when they demonstrate a pattern of behavior. In this case, the appellant's history of traffic offenses was a significant factor in the court's consideration. The authorities relied upon included previous case law where courts had considered similar factors in sentencing. The court distinguished between intentional and unintentional actions, noting that while the appellant's past behavior was concerning, the lack of intent in this particular incident could mitigate the severity of the sentence.
The court also examined whether the appellant's prior convictions and the fact that he inadvertently hit a police officer should be considered in determining the excessiveness of the sentence. It was acknowledged that the appellant's history of traffic violations suggested a need for deterrence and rehabilitation. However, the court emphasized that the circumstances of this particular incident, where the appellant did not intend to cause harm, had to be weighed in the balance. The authorities cited included cases where courts had taken into account the nature of the offense and the offender's history, balancing these factors to arrive at an appropriate sentence.
Furthermore, the court considered the relevance of the appellant's disqualification from driving for 12 months in assessing the sentence's excessiveness. The court recognized that the disqualification period was a significant penalty in itself, which would severely impact the appellant's ability to drive and potentially his livelihood. The authorities relied upon included cases where courts had examined the cumulative effect of penalties, including disqualification periods, in determining whether a sentence was excessive. The court found that the 12-month disqualification, coupled with the sentence, constituted a substantial penalty that served the purposes of punishment, deterrence, and rehabilitation.
In conclusion, the court found that while the appellant's prior convictions and the nature of the incident warranted consideration, the sentence imposed was not manifestly excessive. The court balanced the need for deterrence and the protection of public safety against the appellant's lack of intent and the significant penalties already imposed. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in assessing the excessiveness of a sentence, courts must consider the totality of the circumstances, including prior convictions, the nature of the offense, and the cumulative effect of the penalties imposed. The court did not depart from prior authority but applied established legal principles to the unique facts of this case. The appeal was ultimately dismissed, affirming the sentence as appropriate and not manifestly excessive.