| DETERMINATION OF APPEAL PANEL | |
| CITATION: | Coghlan v NSW Trains [2023] NSWPICMP 609 |
APPELLANT: | Craig John Coghlan |
RESPONDENT: | NSW Trains |
| APPEAL PANEL | |
| MEMBER: | Richard J Perrignon |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Roger Pillemer |
| MEDICAL ASSESSOR: | Greg McGroder |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 23 November 2023 |
| CATCHWORDS: | WORKERS COMPENSATION - Appeal from assessment of whole person impairment (right hip); whether the assessor erred in deducting one third for pre-existing degeneration; Held – Medical Assessment Certificate confirmed. |
BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION TO APPEAL
The appellant worker, Mr Coghlan, appeals from the Medical Assessment Certificate of Medical Assessor Gothelf dated 4 July 2023. He examined the worker on 22 June 2023, and assessed a 13% whole person impairment (13% right lower extremity – hip; 0% scarring) as a result of injury on 3 August 2019.
On that occasion, Mr Coghlan had experienced sudden pain in the right hip joint while descending steps on the side of a train at work. He came to total right hip replacement surgery at the hands of Dr Limbers on 28 May 2020.
Medical Assessor Gothelf diagnosed aggravation of pre-existing, and previously asymptomatic, arthritis in the right hip, demonstrated by MRI scan dated 19 August 2019. He assessed a 20% whole person impairment (right lower extremity – hip), from which he deducted one third for the pre-existing arthritis pursuant to s 323 of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998.
The appellant submits that the Medical Assessor erred in making the deduction of one third. He says that there should have been either no deduction, or a deduction of one-tenth as the extent of the deduction was difficult or costly to determine.
No error is alleged in respect of the assessment of 20% whole person impairment (right hip), or of scarring.
The appellant accepts that the injury consisted in the aggravation of a pre-existing condition, be it arthritis diagnosed by the Medical Assessor and Dr Poplawski who was qualified by the appellant, or hip dysplasia diagnosed by Dr Vote who was qualified by the insurer.
The Appeal Panel conducted a preliminary review of the Medical Assessment Certificate in the absence of the parties and in accordance with the NSW Workers Compensation Guidelines for the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (4th edition) (the Guidelines).
Submissions
The parties made written submissions which have been taken into account. They are not repeated in full, but are summarised briefly below.
The appellant worker submits as follows:
(a) Prior to injury, the right hip was asymptomatic. Symptoms were caused by injury. In the absence of injury, the worker would either not have needed total hip replacement, or needed it at a later stage in his life.
(b) Impairment is measured by the effects of the surgery – in this case, being a “fair result”.
(c) As the surgery resulted from aggravation of the pre-existing condition, it follows that impairment ‘would not have been as great as a result of the arthritic condition’.
(d) Impairment results from the work injury, because injury rendered symptomatic a previously asymptomatic arthritis…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Coghlan v NSW Trains and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWPICMP 609
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the tribunal was whether the assessor's deduction of one third for pre-existing degeneration was justified under the applicable legislative framework. The plaintiff argued that the deduction was inappropriate and that it unfairly reduced the compensation he was entitled to receive. The tribunal needed to determine whether the assessment complied with the relevant statutory provisions and whether the deduction was supported by the medical evidence presented.
In rendering its decision, the tribunal examined the Medical Assessment Certificate and the evidence provided by the medical practitioners. The tribunal found that the certificate correctly identified the extent of the impairment and the impact of the pre-existing degeneration on the plaintiff's overall impairment. The tribunal was satisfied that the assessor had appropriately applied the statutory guidelines and that the deduction was warranted based on the medical evidence. Consequently, the tribunal upheld the original assessment, confirming that the deduction for pre-existing degeneration was correctly applied.
The tribunal's decision concluded that the plaintiff's appeal was without merit. The tribunal confirmed the original assessment of whole person impairment, which included the deduction for pre-existing degeneration. This decision upheld the integrity of the workers' compensation system by ensuring that compensation awards are based on accurate and fair assessments of impairment.