Coathurst Pty Ltd v Dune Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Coathurst Pty Ltd to application under section 92 of the Act by Dune Holdings Limited to remove trade mark number 709581(25) - Dunes (Logo) - in the name of Coathurst Pty Ltd.

Delegate: Iain Campbell Thompson
Representation: Opponent: Tracey Savage of Spruson & Ferguson
Applicant: Andrew Fox of Counsel instructed by Nicola Scheepers of Griffith Hack, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys
Decision: 2015 ATMO 115
S92 application for partial removal – Trade Mark has been used during the Relevant Period in relation to the Goods

Background

  1. In this matter Dune Holdings Limited (‘the Applicant’) applied on 10 October 2013 under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) for the partial removal under paragraph 92(4)(b) of a trade mark from the register of trade marks in respect of ‘footwear and headgear’ (‘the Goods’) within the registration which appears below:

Registration No:  709581
Priority Date:  30 May 1996
Goods/Services:  Class 25: Clothing surf wear, footwear head gear

(‘the Goods’)

Trade Mark:  

(‘the Trade Mark’)

  1. Although it is of no consequence to this decision I will remark now that it is the words ‘Rash Pro’ that might be seen under the word ‘DUNES’ in the Trade Mark.  I will also mention now that I read the Goods as being ‘Clothing, surf wear, footwear, head gear’.

  2. On 24 December 2013 the owner of the Trade Mark, Coathurst Pty Ltd, (‘the Opponent’) filed Notice of Intention to Oppose the application for removal; this was followed on 22 January 2014 by its Statement of Grounds and Particulars which states:

    1. The Opponent had an intention to use the Trade Mark at the filing date. In fact, the registered Trade Mark has been used in Australia during the three years ending on 10 September 2013 (the Relevant Non-Use Period) in connection with clothing, footwear and headgear products in Class 25.

    2. The Opponent has used trade marks consisting of or containing the word "DUNES", in Australia continuously since at least 1989. The Opponent has continuously used the registered Trade Mark in Australia since at least 2000.

    3. The Trade Mark has been continuously used on the Opponent's website during the Relevant Non-Use Period, in connection with a broad range of goods including clothing, footwear and headgear products in Class 25. The Trade Mark has also been continuously used during the Relevant Non-Use Period in connection with clothing, footwear and headgear products sold via the Opponent's retail store.

    4. It is noted that the Applicant for Removal of the Trade Mark is the owner of pending Application Nos. 961910 DUNE in Class 25, 1165753 DUNE in Classes 18, 25 and 35, and 1209554 DUNE LONDON in Class 35. Each of these marks cover goods or services the same or similar to the Class 25 goods covered by the Opponent's registration 709581. Further, the Removal Applicant was unsuccessful in a previously application for removal of the Trade Mark (see (2011) ATMO…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Coathurst Pty Ltd v Dune Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 115
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Coathurst Pty Ltd (the Applicant) and Dune Holdings Limited (the Opponent) were involved in a dispute concerning the probity of evidence presented by the Applicant. The matter came before Iain Campbell Thompson.

The central legal issue was whether a particular piece of the Applicant's evidence, specifically a photograph of a "fin sock" bearing a trade mark, was of doubtful probity. If it was, the Applicant argued that all of its evidence should be viewed with heightened suspicion. The court was required to determine if the alleged obliteration of a darker area above the trade mark indicated a spurious attempt to establish use of the trade mark on footwear.

The court considered the Applicant's submission that the darker area in the photograph might be an obliteration over which the trade mark was affixed to falsely demonstrate use. However, the court found that other explanations were equally plausible, including the possibility that the dark area was an artefact of the photograph, or that the trade mark was applied to generic footwear by the Opponent itself, either by affixing a sticker or by supplying stickers to a manufacturer. The court concluded that the mere fact that the trade mark might have been applied by the Opponent did not necessarily imply nefarious intent. Therefore, the court determined that questions concerning the probity of the "fin sock evidence" did not warrant treating all of the Applicant's evidence with anything other than the normal degree of circumspection.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence in this matter is comprised of the following declarations:Evidence in SupportGreg Sandmann made on 7 May 2014 together with Exhibits GS-1 to GS-7 and Confidential Exhibits GS-8 and GS-9 (‘Sandmann Declaration’)Evidence in AnswerAparna Watal made on 7 May 2014, together with Annexures AW-1 to AW-24 (‘Watal Declaration’).Evidence in ReplyBrecht Robert Olga Valcke dated 15 October 2014, including Exhibits 1 to 12 (‘Valcke Declaration’). My understanding of the Applicant’s argument is that it submits that one item within the Applicant’s evidence is of doubtful probity and that, consequently, all of the Applicant’s evidence should be considered with that in mind. Accordingly, I think it appropriate to look first at that particular piece of evidence and assess whether the Applicant’s submission has merit. The evidence that the Opponent alleges is of questionable probity is the picture of an article of footwear which appears below and is contained in the Sandmann Declaration Exhibit GS-4: I have adjusted the contrast in the above picture of a ‘fin sock’ so that the darker area is more visible. The essence of the Applicant’s submission is that in the picture the darker area above the Trade Mark may be an obliteration over which the Trade Mark has been affixed in order to spuriously establish use in relation to an article of footwear. This might be so; however, there are other possible explanations such as:· The dark area may be an artefact brought about by shadow, reflection or the nature of the photograph or camera;· The article of footwear may be one of hundreds which bore another sign such as (for example) the generic words ‘fin sock’ all of which have had the generic words obliterated and the Trade Mark affixed to them for sale by the Opponent The Applicant points to one of its items in evidence to establish that the Trade Mark, as it appears on the fin sock, may be on a sticker which is easily affixed to articles which appear in exhibits to the Sandmann Declaration – this is (states the Watal Declaration) on a pair of thongs (footwear) which was ordered from the Opponent by a Mr Alvin Ortega whose relationship with the Applicant is not stated: Again, the sticker may be affixed to the thongs (footwear) by the Opponent who has ordered the thongs in bulk from a manufacturer without any trade mark affixed to them in order to itself affix the Trade Mark. Or, indeed, the Opponent could have supplied the stickers to the manufacturer. Because the sticker may have been attached to the fin sock or thong (footwear) by the Opponent does not necessarily mean that it was attached by the Opponent or, that, if it was attached by the Opponent there was any nefarious motive in that action. Thus I do not consider that questions concerning the probity of ‘the fin sock evidence’ should cause me to consider the Opponent's evidence with anything other than the normal degree of circumspection. Exhibit GS-3 to the Sandmann Declaration shows the Trade Mark in use on:· Surf tops

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.