Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Category:
Catchwords
Number of paragraphs:
28
Counsel for the Appellant:
The appellant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondents:
Mr T Reilly
Solicitor for the Respondents:
Australian Government Solicitor
ORDERS
NSD 1310 of 2017
BETWEEN:
CMR16
Appellant
AND:
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND BORDER PROTECTION
First Respondent
IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
Second Respondent
JUDGE:
GLEESON J
DATE OF ORDER:
19 JUNE 2018
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The appeal be dismissed.
2.The appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
GLEESON J:
This is an appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia (“FCCA”) dismissing an application for review of a decision of the second respondent (“IAA”). The IAA’s decision was made on 16 August 2016, and in turn affirmed a decision of a delegate of the first respondent (“Minister”) to refuse the appellant a Safe Haven Enterprise visa (“SHEV”): CMR16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] FCCA 1715.
The notice of appeal contains the following single ground of appeal:
The [FCCA judge] committed a legal error in dismissing my case. The judge failed to consider all of the grounds that was raised and [failed] to consider arguments put forward by my representative.
Particulars
a.Reasons for dismissing my application is yet to be published, therefore I am unable to formulate grounds of appeal.
b.More details will be provided once reasons for dismissing my case is published that [sic]
The FCCA judge’s reasons were published on 2 August 2017. Despite what is said in the particulars to the notice of appeal, following the publication of the judge’s reasons, the appellant did not file written submissions, or any other document identifying any specific ground of appeal. The appellant did however file an affidavit affirmed on 18 April 2018 with four documents attached. The Minister’s written submissions stated that none of the documents were before the delegate or IAA. Accordingly, the Minister submitted the documents are not relevant to establishing jurisdictional error by the IAA (or error by the FCCA judge) and are inadmissible.
At the hearing of the appeal, the appellant appeared with the assistance of a Tamil interpreter.
BACKGROUND FACTS
The facts and history of the matter were summarized by the FCCA judge at [2] and [3]…
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CMR16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:
The appeal in CMR16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection involved a 24-year-old Sri Lankan national, CMR16, who had arrived in Australia as an unlawful maritime arrival and applied for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (SHEV). The application was refused by a delegate and the decision was subsequently affirmed by the Immigration Appeals Authority (IAA). The Federal Circuit Court of Australia (FCCA) dismissed CMR16's appeal against the IAA's decision, and CMR16 now appealed to the Federal Court of Australia. The central issues in the appeal were whether the FCCA judge had made any errors in law or procedure that warranted the appeal being allowed.
The Federal Court of Australia found no grounds for allowing the appeal. The court held that the FCCA judge had properly considered the evidence and submissions before the IAA and had not erred in affirming the IAA's decision. The court emphasised that the question for determination was whether the FCCA judge had made an error in law or procedure, not whether the IAA's decision was correct. The court further noted that the new evidence presented to the Federal Court was not relevant to the appeal, as it had not been before the FCCA. Consequently, the Federal Court dismissed the appeal and ordered CMR16 to pay the Minister's costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal be dismissed.
2. The appellant pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
At the hearing of the appeal, the appellant appeared with the assistance of a Tamil interpreter.BACKGROUND FACTS The facts and history of the matter were summarized by the FCCA judge at [2] and [3] of his Honour’s reasons as follows:2.The applicant is 24 year old Hindu of Tamil ethnicity and a national of Sri Lanka. On 28 August 2012, he arrived in Australia as an unlawful maritime arrival. On 20 October 2015, he lodged an application for a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (SHEV) and attended an interview on 17 March 2016. On 10 June 2016, a delegate refused the visa. The matter was then referred to the Authority. Applicant’s claims for protection3. The applicant’s claims may be summarised as follows:a)in 2005, when he was about 14 years old, the applicant moved to Colombo, where he worked in a jewellery shop until his departure in 2012. He returned to visit his village in 2007, and at that time his cousin (ST) was taken and detained by the authorities for approximately three years because of his alleged family connection to Kalithas (also known as Colonel Stalin), who was a commander in the LTTE. His family and ST have been blacklisted;b)when ST was finally released in 2010, he went to live in Colombo with the applicant;c)in 2011, the Tamil Makkal Viduthalai Puligal (TMVP) (a paramilitary group) came in search of the applicant, leading him to flee Sri Lanka in 2012;d)the applicant’s mother reported that in early 2015, people in plain clothes, who may have been police or from the Karuna group, came to his house to enquire about Kalithas, and about ST who came with him to Australia. In April 2015, four people wearing Sri Lankan Army uniforms came to his parents’ home again in search of Kalithas. The applicant believed Kalithas was killed by the Sri Lankan Army; ande)the applicant will be targeted because of his close connection to an LTTE official (Kalithas), the police will not protect him and no matter where he goes in Sri Lanka he is at risk of harm. The applicant did not mention these claims at the entry interview as he was afraid the Australian government would inform the Sri Lankan government.DELEGATE’S DECISION At [4] of his Honour’s reason’s, the FCCA judge summaries the reasoning and conclusions of the Minister’s delegate as follows:a)the delegate did not believe that Kalithas/Colonel Stalin existed, or that if he did exist, that the applicant was imputed with a political opinion/targeted because of that connection. The applicant admitted he had never spoken to Kalithas or even made his acquaintance and the delegate found his evidence was vague. There was no information through open sources which indicated the existence of Kalithas. The arrest of ST and not the applicant in 2007 suggests that the applicant was not of interest to the authorities. The applicant has never been harmed or targeted by the authorities and they had no interest in the applicant on account of his claimed relationship to Kalithas (the delegate also found that his family has not been blacklisted, as claimed);b)the applicant’s fear of persecution as a result of his Tamil race is not well-founded – any discrimination he might encounter would not amount to persecution;c)the delegate accepted that the applicant would be considered a failed asylum seeker upon return. However, any treatment he may encounter would not be discriminatory and would be as a result of laws of general application. He may be temporarily detained, fined and released, but because he has no profile, he will not suffer persecution. He did not attract obligations under the Refugee Convention; andd)finally, any societal discrimination on account of his race, and any remand and fine for illegal departure, would not amount to significant harm, so the applicant did not attract complementary protection obligations.IAA PROCESS AND DECISION
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
At [4] of his Honour’s reason’s, the FCCA judge summaries the reasoning and conclusions of the Minister’s delegate as follows:a)the delegate did not believe that Kalithas/Colonel Stalin existed, or that if he did exist, that the applicant was imputed with a political opinion/targeted because of that connection. The applicant admitted he had never spoken to Kalithas or even made his acquaintance and the delegate found his evidence was vague. There was no information through open sources which indicated the existence of Kalithas. The arrest of ST and not the applicant in 2007 suggests that the applicant was not of interest to the authorities. The applicant has never been harmed or targeted by the authorities and they had no interest in the applicant on account of his claimed relationship to Kalithas (the delegate also found that his family has not been blacklisted, as claimed);b)the applicant’s fear of persecution as a result of his Tamil race is not well-founded – any discrimination he might encounter would not amount to persecution;c)the delegate accepted that the applicant would be considered a failed asylum seeker upon return. However, any treatment he may encounter would not be discriminatory and would be as a result of laws of general application. He may be temporarily detained, fined and released, but because he has no profile, he will not suffer persecution. He did not attract obligations under the Refugee Convention; andd)finally, any societal discrimination on account of his race, and any remand and fine for illegal departure, would not amount to significant harm, so the applicant did not attract complementary protection obligations.IAA PROCESS AND DECISION At [5] of his Honour’s reasons, the FCCA judge noted that, on 6 July 2016, the applicant’s representative sent five items to the IAA for its consideration. The documents included a photograph purporting to be of Colonel Stalin and three page submission, referring to the delegate’s disbelief in the existence of Kalithas/Colonel Stalin and stating, among other things that the banner in the shot showed his name and that if a short extension of time was permitted, the applicant would have the banner translated. At [6] of his Honour’s reasons, the FCCA judge summarised the reasoning and conclusion of the IAA, affirming the decision under review as follows:a)it noted that the submission was a reiteration of protection claims addressing the delegate’s reasoning. To the extent that [t]he submission discusses information which was before the delegate and responds to the delegate’s reasoning, the information is not “new” as defined in s.473DC(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Migration Act) and the Authority had regard to it;b)in relation to the documents attached to the submission, the applicant did not explain why these could not have been provided to the delegate, why it was credible personal information which was not previously known and how it may have affected the applicant’s claims. Section 473DD(b) was not met and there were not exceptional circumstances to justify consideration of it;c)apart from Kalithas, nobody in the applicant’s family was an LTTE member or supporter. As the Authority did not accept that Kalithas existed, was an LTTE member, that the applicant was related to him, or that he or ST were of interest to the authorities due to a family connection to Kalithas. It accepted that ST was arrested and may have been detained for three years and that it may have been due to his imputed support of the LTTE, but not that he was required after his release in 2010 to report, or in fact reported, to the TMVP. The applicant registered his address in Colombo and so the authorities would have been able to find him - yet he experienced no problems there. He also obtained a passport legally in 2012. The applicant was not of interest to the authorities, TMVP or the Karuna group, and does not face a real chance of persecution for imputed links to the LTTE;d)the Authority did not accept that the applicant would be targeted/face a real chance of persecution upon return to Sri Lanka because of his Tamil ethnicity or because he is a Tamil from the east;e)as for his connection to ST, country information does not suggest that persons are at risk merely because they are related to another person with imputed links to the LTTE. No other family members have been questioned, detained or tortured and when the authorities came for ST, they did not take the applicant. The claim that he is at risk because of association with ST is therefore purely speculative and he does not face a real chance of persecution for this reason;f)as a failed asylum seeker, he would be charged and may be held for a short time on remand. He will not be subject to mistreatment during this processing and the law applied is one of general application and it is not selectively applied. Although conditions on remand may be poor, they do not rise to the level of significant or serious harm. He will be issued with a fine and released or may be released on his own personal surety. Considered individually and cumulatively, the applicant does not face a real risk of persecution; andg)any societal discrimination the applicant would face and/or treatment whilst being processed and on remand as an illegal departee/failed asylum seeker, including poor prison conditions, would not amount to significant harm.FCCA PROCEEDING
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appellant also submitted that his youngest brother was in hiding in Sri Lanka, having suffered violence at the hands of Sri Lankan authorities. In support of this submission, the appellant pointed to the documents annexed to his affidavit affirmed on 18 April 2018. These included a police report regarding this incident, an image of a policeman on a motorcycle outside the family’s home, images of the youngest brother lying injured in hospital and a Sri Lankan surgeon’s report concerning the brother’s treatment. The appellant admitted that these documents were not before the delegate, IAA or FCCA.Consideration The documents submitted by the appellant to this Court are not relevant to the question for decision, which is whether the FCCA judge made an appellable error in dismissing the appellant’s application for judicial review of the IAA’s decision. Accordingly, I cannot take them into account in considering the appeal. The appellant did not identify any appellable error by the FCCA judge. Having considered the reasons of the FCCA judge, I do not see any basis for thinking that there was any appellable error. Accordingly, the appeal should be dismissed. Costs should follow the event.