Clyne, Re P.L. O'Brien, Ex Parte J.W.

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

CATCHbIORDS

BANKRUPTCY - Public ex

:am

lmatlon of bankrLpt - Ob~ectlon

to

questlon regardlng overseas bank accounts

- nether questlon

1 s relevant to purpose of examination

- Relevance of

clrcumstance that answer

to question may cause someme to take

crlmlnal proceedings agalnst bankrupt

- Relevance of poor

health of bankrupt - Posslble effect of answer u2on pending

Applicatlon In respect of admlnlstratlon

of estate.

Bankruptcy Act 19€6

s . 6 3

Re Pacret C19277 2 Ch. 8 5 , Re Atherton C19127

2 KB 251,

Hardlnq (19811 57 FLR 320 applled.

P.929 of 1983

Re PETER LEOPOLD CLYXE;

ex parte JOHN WILLIAlY O'BRIEN

Wllcox J.

Sydney

5 February 1985

I N THE

F DERAL

COURT

OF AUSTRALIA

) )

GENERAL DIVISION

BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE

STATE

OF

)

N O .

p .929

of

19a3

)

NEbT SOUTH

WALES

AND

)

>

THE AUSTRALIAii

CAPITAL

TERRITORY

)

-

RE :

FETER

LEOPOLD

CLPNE

Bankrupt

EX PARTE:

JOHN NILLIAM 0 ' BP IEN

Trustee

CORAM :

NILCOX

J .

DATE:

5 FEBRUARY 1586

PLACE :

SYDNEY

MINUTE OF rJRDE?S

THE

COURT

FIMES

THAT:

1.

The questim as to whether or nor; a telex Searlnq date

9

March 1983 was sent by the debtor, Peter Leopold

Cl:rne,

to which questlon an 05~ectlon

was made on behalf

of the

sald debtor and overruled by a Deputy Reglstrar cf the

Federal Court of Bustralla, is 3 proper questlon.

2 .

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

1.

The bankrupt,

Peter

Leopold

Clyne,

answer

the

sald

questlon.

2.

The matter be referred back to the said Deputy

Registrar

for a ccntlnuatlon of the publlc esaminatlon of the

bankrupt under 5.69 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966.

NOTE :

Settlement and entry of orders is dealt wlth by

Sankruptcy Rule 1 2 4 .

IN THE FEDERAL COTJRT OF AUSTRALIA

)

)

GENERAL DIVISIOM

) )

BFSJKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF )

No. F.929 of 1983

)

NE31 SOUTH

WALES

FND

) )

THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

1

-

RE:

DETER LEOPClLD CL'INE

Bankrupt

EX PARTE:

.JOHN GiILLIAM 0

' BRIZPI

Trustee

COR-XY:

WILCOX

J.

m:

5 FEBRUARY 1986

PLACE

: SYDNEY

EXTEMPORE RFASONS FOR JUDGMENT

There is currently proceedmy- before a Deputy

Registrar of thls Court the public examination under

s.69 of

the Bankruptcy Act 1966 of 'eter

Leopold Clyne. The publls

examlnatlon went for some days

clurlng 1985 and was then

adlourned.

A period sf six days, the first of whlch 1 s

to-day, vas allocated

by the Deputy Peglstrar for the

completion of the public examinatlon.

2 .

Eetween the date upon

whlch the public examination

was ad~ourned

last year and the present date the trustee ln

bankruptcy and his sollcitor

~ourneyed

to Austria and there

obtamed certain mformation In relation to bank accounts and

assets said to be owned by, or under the control of, the

bankrupt, Peter Leopold Clyne. Certaln assets were brought

back to Australla and Mr Clyne has filed

an Appllcatlon In

this Colurt in

which he claims that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clyne, Re P.L. O'Brien, Ex Parte J.W. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1986] FCA 32
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia was called upon to determine the validity of an objection raised by Peter Leopold Clyne, a bankrupt, against a question posed by the trustee, John William O'Brien, during a public examination under Section 69 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. The specific question pertained to a telex message dated 9 March 1983, which the trustee sought to verify as having been sent by Mr Clyne. The trustee had obtained information regarding Mr Clyne's overseas bank accounts and assets in Austria, which led to the question about the telex. Mr Clyne, through his counsel, objected to answering the question on several grounds, including relevance, potential incrimination, his health condition, and the impact on a pending application concerning the Austrian assets. The court had to decide whether the objection was justified and whether the question was extraneous to the examination's purpose.

The court addressed the objection by first considering the broad scope of Section 69(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966, which mandates the examination of a bankrupt's conduct, trade dealings, property, and affairs. The court emphasized the trustee's duty to uncover all available property for distribution among creditors and the public interest in ensuring the bankrupt's conduct is scrutinised. The court found that the question about the telex was pertinent to the examination's purpose, as it could reveal undisclosed property or conduct relevant to the bankrupt's financial affairs. Additionally, the court ruled that the potential for incrimination, as argued by Mr Clyne's counsel, did not exempt the bankrupt from answering the question, in line with Section 69(12) of the Act. The court also dismissed the relevance of Mr Clyne's health condition and the potential prejudice to his pending application as insufficient grounds to avoid answering the question.

The court concluded that the objection was not valid, and the question was proper. Consequently, the court directed Mr Clyne to answer the questioned telex-related query and referred the matter back to the Deputy Registrar for the continuation of the public examination. The court's decision underscored the importance of comprehensive public examinations in bankruptcy proceedings and reinforced the trustee's authority to seek detailed information from the bankrupt, notwithstanding any potential adverse consequences for the bankrupt in other legal proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.