Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs [2022] AATA 1332 (24 May 2022)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2019/5637 & 2019/5638      

Re:Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd

APPLICANT

AndComptroller-General of Customs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member A Poljak

Date:24 May 2022

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

....................................[SGD]....................................

Senior Member A Poljak

CATCHWORDS

HOME AFFAIRS – Customs – Tariff Concession Order (TCO) – whether the subject goods meet the terms of the relevant TCOs – relevant law and material considered – decision under review affirmed.

CASES

Brand Developers Aust Pty Ltd and Chief Executive Officer of Customs [2015] AATA 215
Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gevaert Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 389

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A Poljak

24 May 2022

  1. These proceedings concern the application of certain Tariff Concession Orders (TCO) to goods being continuous filament wound glass reinforced polyester jacking pipe and continuous filament wound glass reinforced polyester pipe (Pipes) and continuous filament wound glass reinforced pipe fittings (Fittings).

  2. Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd, the applicant, claims the Pipes are classified to tariff subheading 3917.29.00 and are eligible for Tariff Concession Order (TCO) 0516757. The applicant claims the Fittings are classified to tariff subheading 3917.40.00 and are eligible for TCO 0108274.

  3. TCO 0516757 provides “PIPES, EPOXY RESIN, GLASS FIBRE REINFORCED”.

  4. TCO 0108274 provides:

    FITTINGS, PIPE, epoxy, fibreglass reinforced, being ANY of the following:

    (a) couplings;
    (b) elbows;
    (c) tees;
    (d) reducing tees;
    (e) reducers;
    (f) flanges;
    (g) nipples

  5. It is not in dispute that the goods are appropriately classified under tariff heading 3917.29.00 (for the Pipes) and 3917.40.00 (for the Fittings) respectively. However, the respondent contends that the Pipes and the Fittings fall outside the relevant TCOs, which refer to “epoxy resin” and “epoxy” respectively, because they are made from unsaturated polyester (UP) resin pipe, not epoxy, and do not precisely fit the description in the TCOs.

    Consideration

  6. The composition of the goods is not in dispute. The Fittings and Pipes are glass reinforced polyester (GRP) based on vinylester resin. Vinylester resin is a common name for a series of unsaturated resins that are prepared by the reaction of a monofunctional unsaturated acid, typically methacrylic acid, with epoxy resin.

  7. Mr Rohan McLellan, Managing Director of the applicant, provided a statement in these proceedings dated 31 March 2020. He states that the disputed goods are GRP, “a plastic with a matrix of reinforced fibres and fine materials including sand, glass fibre and thermosetting resins.” Mr McLellan correctly identifies epoxy resin and vinylester resin as different substances and states that the disputed goods are coated by vinylester resin, which “is a form of resin which is produced through the reaction of unsaturated carboxylic acid, such as methacrylic or acrylic acid and an epoxy resin. As such, vinyl-ester resins are derivatives of epoxy resins.” He states, GRP pipes have overlapping uses with pipes described as glass reinforced epoxy pipes (GRE). This overlap…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 1332
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of *Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd and Comptroller-General of Customs*, the Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a dispute concerning the application of Tariff Concession Orders (TCOs) to certain pipes and fittings. The applicant, Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd, contended that its glass reinforced polyester (GRP) pipes and fittings, which are based on vinylester resin, should fall within the scope of relevant TCOs that refer to "epoxy resin" or "epoxy". The Comptroller-General of Customs argued that the goods did not meet the terms of the TCOs because they were made from unsaturated polyester (UP) resin pipe, not epoxy, and therefore did not precisely fit the descriptions provided in the TCOs.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the subject goods, specifically pipes and fittings made from vinylester resin, satisfied the requirements of the applicable TCOs which specified "epoxy resin" or "epoxy". The applicant argued that because vinylester resin is produced by reacting an unsaturated carboxylic acid with an epoxy resin, the goods were, in essence, derived from epoxy resin and thus met the TCO description. The applicant further submitted that the TCOs should be interpreted to include goods containing a resin derived from epoxy resin, even if the epoxy resin itself had undergone further chemical reaction.

The Tribunal reasoned that while vinylester resin is a derivative of epoxy resin, the goods in question were not made of glass fibre reinforced epoxy resin, nor did they contain any epoxy resin in their final composition. The Tribunal found that the vinylester resin, being a distinct chemical substance with different properties from epoxy resin, meant that the goods did not meet the specific terms of the TCOs. The Tribunal concluded that TCOs do not apply to goods made from a different plastic derived from epoxy resin, particularly when that derived plastic possesses a different chemical composition and distinct physical properties.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, holding that neither of the relevant TCOs applied to the pipes and fittings manufactured by Clover Pipelines Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The disputed goods are not made of glass fibre reinforced epoxy resin, nor do they contain any epoxy resin. The subject goods do not meet each of the terms of the TCOs and therefore neither TCO applies to the Fittings and Pipes. The TCOs do not apply to goods made of a different plastic derived from epoxy resin, which has a different chemical composition and different physical properties.Decision The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is not in dispute that the goods are appropriately classified under tariff heading 3917.29.00 (for the Pipes) and 3917.40.00 (for the Fittings) respectively. However, the respondent contends that the Pipes and the Fittings fall outside the relevant TCOs, which refer to “epoxy resin” and “epoxy” respectively, because they are made from unsaturated polyester (UP) resin pipe, not epoxy, and do not precisely fit the description in the TCOs. Consideration The composition of the goods is not in dispute. The Fittings and Pipes are glass reinforced polyester (GRP) based on vinylester resin. Vinylester resin is a common name for a series of unsaturated resins that are prepared by the reaction of a monofunctional unsaturated acid, typically methacrylic acid, with epoxy resin. Mr Rohan McLellan, Managing Director of the applicant, provided a statement in these proceedings dated 31 March 2020. He states that the disputed goods are GRP, “a plastic with a matrix of reinforced fibres and fine materials including sand, glass fibre and thermosetting resins.” Mr McLellan correctly identifies epoxy resin and vinylester resin as different substances and states that the disputed goods are coated by vinylester resin, which “is a form of resin which is produced through the reaction of unsaturated carboxylic acid, such as methacrylic or acrylic acid and an epoxy resin. As such, vinyl-ester resins are derivatives of epoxy resins.” He states, GRP pipes have overlapping uses with pipes described as glass reinforced epoxy pipes (GRE). This overlap is possible as result of the shared characteristics of the GRE and GRP pipes. Mr McLellan explains that “vinylester resin has the same appearance, handling properties and curing characteristics as conventional polyester resins however, the corrosion resistance and mechanical properties of vinylester resin are significantly better”. He states that “Vinylester resins are also stronger and more resistant that conventional polyester resins”. He states further, “As vinylester resins are more resistant to corrosion and less prone to water damage they are often used on products which are likely to be exposed to water or other liquids.” The applicant contends that the TCOs apply to the Fittings and Pipes as they are based on vinylester resin, which is prepared from the reaction of monofunctional unsaturated acid with an epoxy resin. They are thus made from epoxy resin, reacted with another substance to produce vinylester resin. The applicant contends that the goods do not need to meet the description literally; the goods must meet the description of the relevant TCO precisely upon the proper interpretation of the TCO. The applicant submits that goods that contain a resin derived from epoxy resin meet the TCO description because they do contain epoxy resin. That the epoxy resin has been reacted with something else does not change that epoxy resin was introduced at some earlier stage in the production process. The applicant contends that this is not inconsistent with the language of the TCOs. That is especially the case with TCO 0108274, which refers generally to “epoxy”.