Clover Corporation Limited v Tobias (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Clover Corporation Limited v Tobias (No 2) [2020] FCA 1710

File number(s): VID 1265 of 2019
Judgment of: O'CALLAGHAN J
Date of judgment: 27 November 2020
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – search order – where applicants’ solicitors inspected certain seized documents in redacted form – whether applicants’ solicitors should be granted leave to inspect unredacted versions of those documents and others – where further pleadings contemplated and no application made for discovery
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 7.42
Cases cited:

Aristocrat Technologies Australia Pty Ltd v Global Gaming Supplies Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1707

Brooks Sports, Inc v Paul’s International Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 1000

Bucyrus (Australia) Pty Ltd v ANI Mining Services Ltd [1999] FCA 1193; 45 IPR 643

Clover Corporation Limited v Tobias [2020] FCA 1244

Findex Group Ltd v iiNet Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1567

Findex Group Ltd v McKay [2019] NSWCA 93

Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC v Bega Cheese Limited (No 3) [2018] FCA 1023

Lamond (No 4) [2017] FCA 820

Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd v Kalra (No 3) [2008] FCA 1201

Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd v Kalra [2009] FCAFC 57

Microsoft Corporation v Goodview Electronics Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 754; 46 IPR 159

Mobil Oil Australia Ltd v Guina Developments Pty Ltd [1996] 2 VR 34

Rauland Australia Pty Ltd v Johnson (No 2) [2019] FCA 1175

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 46
Date of hearing: 10 November 2020
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr IP Horak with Ms LE Davis
Solicitor for the Applicants: Piper Alderman
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr SJ Minahan
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Hicks Oakley Chessell Williams
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr B Carew
Solicitor for the Respondents: Meerkin & Apel

ORDERS

VID 1265 of 2019
BETWEEN:

CLOVER CORPORATION LIMITED ABN 85 003 622 866

First Applicant

NU-MEGA INGREDIENTS PTY LIMITED ABN 98 102 460 739

Second Applicant

AND:

PETER FREDERICK TOBIAS

First Respondent

PHARMAMARK NUTRITION PTY LTD ABN 59 145 305 040

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

O'CALLAGHAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 NOVEMBER 2020

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 4 December 2020, the respondents identify those documents referred to as “Listed Things” in the report of Mr Benjamin Gardiner provided to the parties on 4 October 2020 in respect of which they wish to claim legal professional privilege.

2.By 4 December 2020, the respondents make any reasonable redactions to take into account claims of confidentiality in respect of the 1,247 documents identified by Mr Gardiner as Listed Things.

3.By 9 December 2020, Mr Grant Whitely of KordaMentha provide the applicants’ solicitors with access to the documents referred to in paragraph 2 of these orders, save in respect of any documents the subject of a claim to privilege (pursuant to paragraph 1).

4.Any documents that are redacted pursuant to paragraph 2 be accessed by the applicants’ solicitors pursuant to the confidentiality…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clover Corporation Limited v Tobias (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1710
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Clover Corporation Limited (Applicants) brought proceedings against Tobias and Pharmamark (Respondents) seeking damages and an account of profits, among other things. The Applicants allege that Mr Tobias breached various duties owed to them by providing confidential information and assistance to Pharmamark, a competitor, after leaving their employment. The Applicants obtained a search order against the Respondents, which permitted a search of the Respondents’ premises and the seizure of certain documents. The Applicants’ solicitors inspected some of the seized documents in redacted form, but sought leave to inspect the unredacted versions of those documents, as well as other documents they had not yet inspected in any form. The Respondents objected to the application. The court had to decide whether the Applicants’ solicitors should be granted leave to inspect the unredacted versions of the documents and other documents that they had not yet inspected in any form.

The court considered the purpose of the search order and the balance of convenience. The search order was intended to facilitate the Applicants’ discovery of documents relevant to their claims, and to prevent the destruction or concealment of evidence. The court held that the Applicants’ solicitors should be granted leave to inspect the unredacted versions of the documents they had already inspected in redacted form, as this would assist in determining whether those documents were relevant to the Applicants’ claims. The court also held that the Applicants’ solicitors should be granted leave to inspect other documents that they had not yet inspected in any form, as this was necessary to determine whether those documents were relevant to the Applicants’ claims. The court noted that the Respondents had not made any application for discovery, and that further pleadings were contemplated.

The court made orders granting the Applicants’ solicitors leave to inspect the unredacted versions of the documents they had already inspected in redacted form, as well as other documents they had not yet inspected in any form. The court also made orders regarding the identification and redaction of documents claimed to be privileged, the review of documents that were not clear, and the resolution of objections to disclosure. The court listed the proceeding for a case management hearing in February 2021 and reserved costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 4 December 2020, the respondents identify those documents referred to as “Listed Things” in the report of Mr Benjamin Gardiner provided to the parties on 4 October 2020 in respect of which they wish to claim legal professional privilege.

2. By 4 December 2020, the respondents make any reasonable redactions to take into account claims of confidentiality in respect of the 1,247 documents identified by Mr Gardiner as Listed Things.

3. By 9 December 2020, Mr Grant Whitely of KordaMentha provide the applicants’ solicitors with access to the documents referred to in paragraph 2 of these orders, save in respect of any documents the subject of a claim to privilege (pursuant to paragraph 1).

4. Any documents that are redacted pursuant to paragraph 2 be accessed by the applicants’ solicitors pursuant to the confidentiality undertakings contained in the orders made on 18 March 2020.

5. By 9 December 2020, the parties send to Mr Gardiner a joint communication requesting that he:

(a) perform a further review of the 1,552 documents identified as “Not Clear”;

(b) perform that review in accordance with paragraphs 3 to 9 of the protocol attached to the orders dated 24 June 2020; and

(c) consult the Technical Expert as contemplated by paragraph 5 of the protocol if this would assist him to resolve the status of the documents,

and advising him that if he requires further technical assistance in order to resolve the status of the documents, the parties will confer as to how that assistance should be provided, and by whom.

6. By 23 December 2020, the parties confer with the aim of resolving any objections to disclosure as referred to in paragraph 1, or agreeing upon a process to resolve them.

7. By 22 January 2020, the applicants file and serve any reply to the respondents’ defences.

8. The proceeding be listed for a case management hearing on a date to be fixed in February 2021.

9. Liberty to apply.

10. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants’ lawyers have access to redacted versions of some of the documents. That position was reached more or less by agreement. The applicants now seek an order, over the objections of the respondents, that their lawyers be given access to unredacted versions of those documents, and to other documents that they have not yet inspected in any form.Background The applicants conduct a business that involves manufacturing, refining and selling ingredients for use in infant formula, supplements and children’s foods. They employed the first respondent (Mr Tobias) from around June 1994 to 28 August 2019. On 1 September 2019, Mr Tobias took up employment with the second respondent (Pharmamark), the applicants’ competitor. The applicants commenced this proceeding on 21 November 2019. By their statement of claim dated 3 July 2020, they allege, among other things, that Mr Tobias has provided confidential information and assistance to Pharmamark in breach of various duties, and that Pharmamark has been complicit in these breaches. They seek, among other things, damages and an account of profits. On the day that the applicants commenced the proceeding, they also applied for and obtained a search order against the respondents. The search order permitted a search party, supervised by an independent lawyer, to enter the respondents’ premises and to copy or seize certain “listed things”. The search party was to include independent computer experts (KordaMentha), who were permitted to make copies of the respondents’ computer hard drives and to search them for listed things. Where there was a dispute about whether some item was a listed thing, the independent lawyer was to hold it for safekeeping pending resolution of the dispute. The “listed things” were set out in a schedule to the search order, as follows:1.Documents (whether in tangible and/or electronic form) recording or evidencing (in whole or in part):(a) the applicants’ product formulations,(b) the applicants’ manufacturing equipment,(c) the applicants’ manufacturing specifications,(d)the applicants’ manufacturing processes (including processing steps and operating set points),(e)the applicants’ manufacturing equipment configuration, and (f)the applicants’ manufacturing control documents,where that thing [is] related to the production of encapsulated oil powders (Applicants’ Confidential Information).2.External storage devices (including USB storage devices) on which is stored any document recording or evidencing (in whole or in part) the Applicants’ Confidential Information.3.Online storage services on which the Respondents have stored, or caused to be stored, any document recording or evidencing (in whole or in part) the Applicants’ Confidential Information.4.Any correspondence or communication in tangible and/or electronic form between [Mr Tobias] and any one or more of:(a) [Pharmamark];(b) Guy Drummond;(c) Ravi Desu,transferring, disclosing or otherwise communicating (in whole or in part) the Applicants’ Confidential Information.5.Online email accounts with any correspondence or communication between [Mr Tobias] and any one or more of:(a)Pharmamark;(b) Guy Drummond; or(c) Ravi Desu,transferring, disclosing or otherwise communicating (in whole or in part) the Applicants’ Confidential Information.6.Documents, whether in tangible and/or electronic form, including plans, specifications, drawings or correspondence, in any way relating to the planning, design, construction or set up of:(a)a manufacturing plant of, or to be used by or on behalf of, Pharmamark; or (b)manufacturing equipment of, or to be used by or on behalf of, Pharmamark in a manufacturing plant,which refer to or incorporate the Applicant[s’] Confidential Information.7.Documents evidencing the employment or other engagement of [Mr Tobias] by Pharmamark.8.Documents, whether in tangible and/or electronic form, which relate to or evidence any contract, arrangement or understanding between [Mr Tobias] and any one or more of:(a)Pharmamark; or (b)Guy Drummond; or (c)Ravi Desu,in connection with the planning, design, construction or set up of:(d)a manufacturing plant of, or to be used by or on behalf of Pharmamark; or (e)manufacturing equipment of, or to be used by or on behalf of, Pharmamark in a manufacturing plant,which refer to or incorporate the Applicant[s’] Confidential Information.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established