Clifford Rusten and Telstra Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2014] AATA 8

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/5548

Re

Clifford Rusten

APPLICANT

And

Telstra Corporation Limited

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member A K Britton

Date 10 January 2014
Place Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review, and in place of that decision decides that as the date of reviewable decision:

(a) Mr Rusten was incapacitated for work within the meaning of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth); and

(b) Any medical treatment received by Mr Rusten for his knee osteoarthritis was treatment received in relation to his accepted injury.

The Tribunal remits the matter to the respondent to determine, in accordance with the above decision and the Tribunal’s reasons for decision:

(a) Mr Rusten’s entitlement to compensation, if any, under s 16 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988;

(b) the extent, if any, of Mr Rusten’s incapacity for employment;

(c) the compensation if any payable to Mr Rusten under s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

...................[sgd].....................................................

Senior Member A K Britton

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - osteoarthritis - liability accepted

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth)

CASES

Hart v Comcare [2005] FCAFC 16; (2005) 145 FCR 29

Clement v Comcare [2012] FCA 166

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member A K Britton

10 January 2014

  1. Clifford Rusten is in his mid-50s and suffers from severe osteoarthritis in both knees. Mr Rusten worked as a linesman with Telstra for over twenty years. He has not worked since 2004.

  2. In 2002 Telstra accepted liability under s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the Act) in respect of “aggravation of osteoarthritis in knees” (the accepted injury). In February 2003 Mr Rusten was placed on “suitable duties”, and in May 2004 his employment with Telstra was terminated.

  3. Mr Rusten received compensation for incapacity (s 19 of the Act) and medical expenses (s 16 of the Act) until August 2012, when a delegate of Telstra decided that any incapacity suffered by Mr Rusten, or need for medical treatment, was no longer the result of the accepted injury.

  4. Mr Rusten has applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of that decision.

  5. The primary question to be decided is whether Mr Rusten’s incapacity for work is “a result of” the accepted injury. Mr Rusten argues that while not the only cause, his osteoarthritis is attributable in part to his employment with Telstra. Telstra on the other hand contends that any aggravation of Mr Rusten’s osteoarthritis caused by work, resolved long ago.

    STATUTORY FRAMEWORK

  6. Telstra will be liable to pay compensation to Mr Rusten if he is incapacitated for work as “a result of” the accepted injury (s 19 of the Act). Section 4(9) of the Act defines “an incapacity for work” to mean an incapacity suffered by an employee as a result of an injury, being:

    (a)an incapacity to engage in any work; or

    (b)an incapacity to engage in work at the same level at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clifford Rusten and Telstra Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Clifford Rusten against Telstra Corporation Limited was heard by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The dispute revolves around whether Rusten's current knee problems, primarily pain and restricted movement, are a result of an injury he suffered while working as a Telstra linesman. Rusten claims that his knee troubles began in 1994 after sitting in a manhole for several hours and that his condition worsened over time. He argues that his work conditions, which required kneeling, squatting, and crouching for extended periods, contributed to his osteoarthritis. The primary legal issue before the court was whether Rusten's current incapacity was caused by the injury he suffered in 1994, as defined by the term "as a result of" in the relevant legislation.

The court evaluated the opinions of various medical experts who assessed Rusten over the years. Both Drs Raymond Wallace and David Maxwell concluded that Rusten's osteoarthritis was advanced for his age and considered the role of his work activities. The court found that while few of the other doctors believed the condition was largely constitutional, some, such as Drs Porges and Bosenquet, thought work played a role. The court considered the reliability of Rusten's self-reported symptoms and his failure to mention lower back problems in his recent statement, which had become the focus of his treatment since 2006. Ultimately, the court accepted Dr Maxwell's opinion that repetitive bending, squatting, crouching, and kneeling contributed to Rusten's osteoarthritis, and thus, his current incapacity was a result of the accepted injury.

The court ruled in favour of Rusten, finding that his current knee problems were a result of the injury he suffered in 1994. The court found Dr Maxwell's opinion more reliable due to his consideration of all relevant material and challenged Dr Wallace's opinion that work did not play a role. The court concluded that Rusten was entitled to compensation for his incapacity as a result of the injury. The final orders were made in favour of Rusten, affirming his entitlement to compensation for medical treatment and related costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Telstra will be liable to pay compensation in respect of medical treatment obtained in relation to his accepted injury:16 Compensation in respect of medical expenses etc. (1) Where an employee suffers an injury, Comcare is liable to pay, in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury (being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances), compensation of such amount as Comcare determines is appropriate to that medical treatment.…BACKGROUND As a Telstra linesman Mr Rusten was required to kneel, squat and crouch for extended periods, climb up and down ladders, sometimes carrying loads. This work was often undertaken in cramped and confined spaces: under buildings and in manholes. In a statement prepared in 2002, Mr Rusten stated that he first noticed “right knee troubles” in 1994 after sitting in a manhole for many hours while working on a cable. He stated that at the end of the shift he noticed that his right knee was “quite sore” and reported this to his supervisor. On his account while the pain resolved within a short period from then on, his knee symptoms would “come and go” with no apparent pattern. He claimed that while at the time he decided to report the incident, he did not lodge a claim for compensation because he did not see a doctor or require time off work. Mr Rusten went on to state that about 12 months later he started to experience left knee symptoms, which were mild at first but over time became more frequent and intense. He claimed that he did not want to be seen as a “whinger” so continued to work. As he recalled, he eventually decided to seek medical treatment in about mid-2000. In a statement prepared for these proceedings dated 25 April 2013, Mr Rusten gave a different account of the onset of his symptoms. In that statement he claimed that in the early 1990s he noticed a gradual onset of pain in both knees. He also stated that in 1994 he suffered an injury to both knees when endeavouring to join a cable. The account given by Mr Rusten in his 2002 statement is broadly consistent with the history taken by orthopaedic surgeon, Dr David Wood — apparently the first specialist Mr Rusten consulted about his knees. In a report dated 20 November 1998, Dr Wood wrote that Mr Rusten presented with left knee pain that had “troubled him on and off for several years”. When he reviewed Mr Rusten four years later, Dr Wood recorded that Mr Rusten “now presents with right knee problems”. Mr Rusten’s 2002 statement is probably a more reliable account of the history of the onset of the condition than that contained in his most recent statement: it is closer in time to the onset and consistent with the contemporary records.MEDICAL OPINION ON CAUSATION As noted the primary issue between the parties is whether Mr Rusten’s current knee problems, primarily pain and restricted movement, and consequent incapacity, are “a result of” the accepted injury. For the purpose of these proceedings, in 2012 Mr Rusten was assessed by orthopaedic surgeons Dr Raymond Wallace and Dr David Maxwell. Each prepared reports and gave oral evidence concurrently. Before proceeding to examine their opinions it is useful to consider the reports prepared by the other medical practitioners who have assessed Mr Rusten over the past decade.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Both doctors agreed that Mr Rusten was relatively young to be suffering from such an advanced form of osteoarthritis.FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS Mr Rusten will be incapacitated for work as “a result of” the accepted injury if it is a material cause of the relevant incapacity (Hart v Comcare [2005] FCAFC 16; (2005) 145 FCR 29). In Clement v Comcare [2012] FCA 166 (at [8]), Jagot J approved the following statement of the law:[The phrase “as a result of”] refers to an operative cause that is not confined to the immediate proximate cause of incapacity and imports a test of causal connection that requires a common sense evaluation of the causal chain between the claimed incapacity and the injury. [Footnotes omitted] Apart from Drs Maxwell and Wallace, few of the doctors who assessed Mr Rusten over the past decade provided a detailed opinion about the aetiology of his osteoarthritis. With the exception of his GP, those who did considered the condition to be largely constitutional. Some, notably Drs Porges and Bosenquet, were of the opinion that work played a role. Counsel for Mr Rusten, Mr Grey, contended that it is apparent from his use of the phrase “wear and tear condition” that Dr Bornstein was of the opinion that work contributed to Mr Rusten’s osteoarthritis. Counsel for Telstra, Mr Clark, argued that it is apparent from Dr Bentivoliglio’s report that he ruled out the possibility that work contributed to Mr Rusten’s osteoarthritis. Neither Dr Bornstein nor Dr Bentivoliglio addressed the issue of causation in any detail in their respective reports. The few comments each made on the issue are arguably open to a number of interpretations. Having carefully reviewed their reports, I have decided it would be unsafe to attribute to Drs Bentivoliglio and Bornstein the opinions the parties contend they hold. Mr Clark argues that the opinion of Dr Maxwell should be preferred because, in contrast to Dr Wallace, he took into account all relevant material including the opinions of colleagues who had assessed Mr Rusten over the past decade. Mr Clark also contends that Dr Wallace’s opinion is weakened by his reliance on Mr Rusten’s self-report, which he asserts is unreliable. As Mr Clark correctly points out, in oral evidence Dr Wallace stated that he had not read the reports prepared by the other experts. However, his supplementary report suggests otherwise. In that report after stating that he had reviewed Dr Maxwell’s report of 23 April 2013, Dr Wallace went on to challenge his opinion that repetitive bending, squatting, crouching and kneeling played no role in Mr Rusten’s osteoarthritis. I accept, however, as argued for Telstra, that Dr Wallace probably did not have regard to the opinions of any of his colleagues, other than Dr Maxwell. Mr Clark argues that it is relevant that in his most recent statement Mr Rusten failed to mention his lower back problems. The clinical notes of Mr Rusten’s GP and physiotherapist reveal that since leaving Telstra Mr Rusten has received physiotherapy treatment for his knees, but since 2006 the focus of treatment has been his lower back. Counsel contends that this raises doubts about the reliability of Mr Rusten’s self-report, in particular the description of symptoms given in his statement of 28 April 2013: “a long continuous progression in terms of pain and immobility”. Counsel submits that this in turn raises doubts about the reliability of Dr Wallace’s opinion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.