Clements v Bower; Yaxkley v Bower; Rouse and McQuestin v Bower

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

Serial No 59/1989
List "A"

CITATION:              Clements v Bower; Yaxkley v Bower; Rouse and McQuestin v Bower [1989] TASSC 60; A59/1989

PARTIES:  CLEMENTS
  v
  BOWER
  BARRY
  DWYER
  NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION

CASWELL

YAXLEY
  v
  BOWER
  BARRY
  DWYER
  NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION

CASWELL

ROUSE
  McQUESTIN
  v
  BOWER
  BARRY
  DWYER
  NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION
  CASWELL

TITLE OF COURT:     SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:            ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  859/1988

860/1988
  861/1988

DELIVERED ON:          7 November 1989
JUDGMENT OF:           Wright J

Judgment Number:  A59/1989
Number of paragraphs:  66

Serial No 59/1989
List "A"
File Nos 859/1988

860/1988
861/1988

CLEMENTS v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION AND CASWELL
YAXLEY v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION AND CASWELL
ROUSE AND McQUESTIN v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION AND CASWELL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  WRIGHT J

7 November 1989

  1. The Statement of Claim in each of these three actions is in substantially the same terms. It alleges that in or about November 1987, the fifth named defendant Caswell, ("the Commissioner") was the Commissioner for Corporate Affairs for the State of Tasmania and he, as delegate of the National Companies and Securities Commission, ("the Commission") authorised the first three defendants, Bower, Barry and Dwyer ("the Investigators") to make investigation into the affairs of Richardsons Meat Industries Ltd, Holmans Consolidated Pty Ltd, Tas Meats Ltd, The Master Butchers Ltd, and SP Holman & Sons Pty Ltd, ("the RMI Group"). The four last named companies were wholly owned subsidiaries of Richardsons Meat Industries Ltd ("RMI"). The investigation was to include the question of whether or not the directors of the named companies had contravened certain sections of the Companies (Tasmania) Code. The Investigators were authorised by the Commissioner to conduct a hearing for that purpose and they were required to report thereon to the Commissioner.

  1. The plaintiffs allege that the authorisation of the Investigators to conduct a hearing was contrary to natural justice in a number of ways. It is claimed that:

a)prior to the appointment the Investigators had already formed views that the companies in the RMI Group were unable to pay their debts, and had formed views that breaches of s556 of the Code had likely, or possibly occurred;

b)the Investigators had, prior to their appointment formed views adverse to the plaintiffs that they were possibly or likely in breach of s556 of the Companies (Tasmania) Code; and

c)the Investigators promoted and participated in the setting up of the investigation and the hearing and thereby adopted the role of accusers, Investigators and tribunal members.

  1. It was further alleged that at all material times the plaintiffs, Clements, Yaxley and Rouse were directors of one or more of the relevant companies and that the plaintiff McQuestin was an alternate director for Rouse. It was also alleged that at all material times it was the intention of the Commissioner, or alternatively, the Commission, to determine after the receipt and consideration of the report, whether to bring proceedings against the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clements v Bower; Yaxkley v Bower; Rouse and McQuestin v Bow... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1989] TASSC 60
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, Clements, Yaxley, and Rouse, and McQuestin, sued the Investigators, Bower, Barry, and Dwyer, the Commissioner, and the Commission, alleging that the Investigators had conducted an investigation into the affairs of the RMI Group in breach of natural justice and with bias against the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs sought declarations, injunctions, and other orders to restrain the Investigators from proceeding with the investigation. The defendants denied the allegations of bias and breach of natural justice. The court considered the evidence and submissions of both parties and found that the Investigators had not breached natural justice or acted with bias. The investigation was purely inquisitorial, and the Investigators were not required to observe the strict rules of natural justice applicable to judicial or quasi-judicial proceedings. The Investigators had given the plaintiffs adequate notice of their adverse findings and an opportunity to respond. The court dismissed the plaintiffs' claims and ordered the defendants to pay costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established