Clements v Bower, Barry, Dwyer, NCSC and Caswell

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Serial No 28/1990
List "A"

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (FULL COURT)

CITATION:              Clements v Bower, Barry, Dwyer, NCSC and Caswell  [1990] TASSC 33; A28/1990

PARTIES:  CLEMENTS
  v

BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL

YAXLEY

v

BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL

ROUSE

McQUESTIN

v

BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL

FILE NO/S:  133/1989

134/1989
  135/1989

DELIVERED ON:  7 August 1990
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
JUDGMENT OF:  Neasey and Cox JJ

Judgment Number:  A28/1990
Number of paragraphs:  30

Serial No 28/1989
List "A"
File Nos 133/1989

134/1989
135/1989

CLEMENTS v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL
YAXLEY v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL
ROUSE AND McQUESTIN v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  FULL COURT

NEASEY J
COX J
7 August 1990

Order of the Court

Appeal dismissed

Serial No 28/1989
List "A"
File Nos 133/1989

134/1989
135/1989

CLEMENTS v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL
YAXLEY v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL
ROUSE AND McQUESTIN v BOWER, BARRY, DWYER, NATIONAL COMPANIES AND SECURITIES COMMISSION and CASWELL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  FULL COURT

NEASEY J
7 August 1990

  1. These three appeals arise out of the same set of facts. The appellants (plaintiffs) were each former directors of a meat company, Richardsons Meat Industries Ltd ("RMI"), which found itself in financial difficulties. They, or some of them, were also directors of four wholly owned subsidiaries of RMI, Holmans Consolidated Pty Ltd, Tas Meats Limited, The Master Butchers Ltd, and SP Holman & Sons Proprietary Limited. The latter four companies, together with RMI, have been referred to throughout the proceedings as "the RMI Group", or "The Group". (The appellant McQuestin was an alternative director of RMI for appellant Rouse).

  1. The respondents (defendants) in each of the appeals are the same. The fourth respondent, the National Companies and Securities Commission ("NCSC"), is the incorporated body set up under the National Companies and Securities Act 1979 of the Commonwealth, and the fifth respondent ("the Commissioner") is the Commissioner for Corporate Affairs for the State of Tasmania. In November 1987 all of the Companies in the RMI Group were ordered by the court to be wound up. In the same month, following a delegation of relevant power by NCSC, the Commissioner authorised the first three respondents, Messrs Bower, Barry and Dwyer, to make an investigation into the affairs of RMI and the four subsidiary companies; such investigation to include the question whether any of the directors had contravened sections of the Companies (Tasmania) Code; and in particular, ss 556 and 229.

  1. Part of the background to these events is that in about April 1985 Messrs Clements, Yaxley and Rouse had either personally or through companies which they influenced effected the acquisition of most of the shares in RMI On 27 May 1985 they were appointed as directors of that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clements v Bower, Barry, Dwyer, NCSC and Caswell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1990] TASSC 33
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeals were brought by the former directors of a meat company, Richardsons Meat Industries Ltd ("RMI") and its subsidiaries, Holmans Consolidated Pty Ltd, Tas Meats Limited, The Master Butchers Ltd, and SP Holman & Sons Proprietary Limited. The respondents were the investigators appointed by the National Companies and Securities Commission and the Commissioner for Corporate Affairs for Tasmania. The appellants claimed that the investigation and hearing conducted by the respondents were contrary to natural justice, alleging bias and procedural unfairness. The Full Court of the Supreme Court of Tasmania was required to determine whether the investigation was conducted in accordance with the rules of natural justice and whether any procedural defects were vitiating.

The Court held that the investigators were not disqualified from conducting the investigation merely because they had participated in earlier stages of the investigation process. The Court found that the investigators were required to act fairly towards the appellants but were not required to be impartial at the stage of commencing the hearing. The Court concluded that the investigators were entitled to form provisional views on issues based on the material they had gathered before the hearing, as long as they provided the appellants with an opportunity to be heard and to present their own evidence. The Court also held that the investigators were not obligated to disclose the specific bases upon which they had formed their views, as long as they had given the appellants an opportunity to rebut the adverse information. The Court found that the investigation and hearing were conducted in accordance with the rules of natural justice and dismissed the appeals.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.