Clements Marshall Consolidated Limited v ENT Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

TASSC A1/1988

CITATION:               Clements Marshall Consolidated Limited v ENT Limited [1988] TASSC 17; A1/1988

PARTIES:  CLEMENTS MARSHALL CONSOLIDATED LIMITED
  v
  ENT LIMITED

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
FILE NO/S:  M536/1987
DELIVERED ON:  7 January 1988
JUDGMENT OF:  Neasey J

Judgment Number:  1/1988
Number of paragraphs:  29

Serial No 1/1988
List "A"
File No M536/1987

CLEMENTS MARSHALL CONSOLIDATED LIMITED (Applicant)
v ENT LIMITED (Respondent)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  NEASEY J

7 January 1988

  1. On 17 December 1987 an interim injunction was granted ex parte on the application of Clements Marshall Consolidated Limited ("Clements") against ENT Limited ("ENT"), restraining the latter company until 23 December 1987 from dispatching to shareholders of Clements offers referred to in a Part A statement purporting to constitute a take–over scheme. The Part A statement was registered by the Commissioner for Corporate Affairs for Tasmania as delegate of the National Companies and Securities Commission ("the Commission") on 3 December 1987. On 23 December the parties agreed that I should hear and dispose finally of Clements' originating application filed on 16 December. In that application, Clements sought declaratory and injunctive relief against ENT upon a number of grounds, alleging that the Part A statement contravenes certain provisions of the Companies (Acquisition of Shares) (Tasmania) Code ("the Code") and, further or in the alternative, contains false information.

  1. At the same hearing on 23 December 1987, ENT, the respondent in the first proceeding, produced its own originating application, which had been filed in the court on that day, seeking a declaration that its Part A statement registered on 3 December does comply with the Code; and alternatively, a declaration pursuant to s48 of the Code that the Part A statement and offer by the applicant have full force and effect and be treated as complying with the Code, if the court should find that they contravene provisions of the Code in certain respects. The parties further agreed that the two applications should be heard together, and that both be determined finally. It was also agreed that the evidence before the court in the application by Clements should be taken to be evidence in the application by ENT for relief under s48.

  1. Clements is a company incorporated in Tasmania, having an authorised share capital of $10,000,000, divided into 20 million shares or "stock units" of 50 cents each. The issued share capital of Clements consists of 18,055,990 ordinary shares of 50 cents each, fully paid up, and 225,000 "employee shares" of 50 cents each, paid to 1 cent. ENT is also a company incorporated in Tasmania, and is a major shareholder in Clements. By its Part A statement registered on 3 December 1987, ENT proposes to make offers constituting a take–over scheme under the Code to all holders of shares in Clements, offering to purchase 25 per cent of each holding respectively.

  1. The Part A statement registered by the Commission and served on Clements on 3 December last is accompanied by a copy of one of the proposed offers. ("Clements"…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clements Marshall Consolidated Limited v ENT Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1988] TASSC 17
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Clements Marshall Consolidated Limited (CMC) sued ENT Limited over a takeover bid that CMC claimed contravened the Corporations Code. The dispute came before the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issues involved whether ENT's bid for CMC shares breached the Code, specifically under sections 16(2)(b) and 16(2)(d). The first issue was whether the offer to acquire CMC shares was made under a take-over scheme as required by the Code. The second issue was whether the Part A statement, which ENT served on CMC, was accurate and complied with the Code's requirements.

The court held that ENT's offer to acquire CMC shares was indeed part of a take-over scheme, thereby falling under the Code's purview. However, because the offer was not limited to one class of shares, it constituted a contravention of section 16(2)(b) of the Code. Although the offer appeared commercially sensible and fair, the court found the contravention significant enough to not be excused. Regarding the Part A statement, the court found it materially misleading because it did not accurately reflect ENT's entitlement to CMC shares, breaching section 16(2)(d) of the Code. The court concluded that these breaches were substantial enough to warrant the application of the Code and could not be excused.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The consideration question Para 16(2)(b) requires in substance that offers to acquire shares are made under a take–over scheme for the purposes of the Code if, and only if:– Thus on the consideration issue there is a contravention of subs 16(2)(b), and ENT applies under s48 that such contravention should be excused by the court. This contravention or failure to comply bears some relation to the class of shares question; in the sense that, where the offer is not confined to one class of shares, it is difficult to eliminate further contraventions of this kind. This is in my view a not inconsequential contravention of the schematic design of the Code, even if the offers for the employee shares themselves accord with commercial sense and fairness, and for reasons which are in substance the same as those given in respect of the class of shares question, I am not satisfied that the contravention ought to be excused by the court. The false or misleading information question The issue arises in this way. Paragraph 16(2)(d) provides in effect that in order for a take–over scheme to be valid under the Code, the offeror must, not earlier than 28 days and not later than 14 days before the offers are dispatched, serve on the target company a Part A statement relating to the offers. "Part A statement" is defined by s6 as meaning "a statement in writing that complies with the requirements of Part A of the Schedule and of subsection 16(2A)". Subsection 44(1) provides, inter alia, that where a statement which purports to be a Part A statement served under para 16(2)(d) in a take–over offer contains matter which is false in a material particular or is materially misleading in the form or context in which it appears, that is an offence by a person to whom the subsection applies. (See subs 44(5)). The Schedule to the Code sets out many detailed requirements as to the contents of Part A statements. One of those requirements, by paragraph 1(c) of Part A of the Schedule, is that the statement shall set out full particulars of the shares in the target company to which the offeror is entitled or, if there are no such shares, set out a statement to that effect. Subsection 48(3) applies the remedial powers of the court to Part A statements because it provides, in part, that where a document purporting to be a Part A statement is served on a company, does not comply with all the requirements of Part A of the Schedule, and the court is satisfied on application by the person by whom or on whose behalf the document was served that the non–compliance was due to inadvertence, mistake or circumstances beyond his control, and that the non–compliance ought to be disregarded, or is satisfied on any other grounds that the non–compliance ought to be disregarded, the court may make an order directing that the document shall be deemed to be, and at all relevant times to have been, a Part A statement. The Part A statement served by ENT on the target company, Clements, on 3 December 1987 contains in paragraph 5 thereof, under a heading, "ENT Entitlement to CMC Shares or Marketable Securities", and after setting out ENT‘s entitlement for the purposes of the Code to shares in Clements, the following averment:–