Cleary v Australian Co-operative Foods Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read
CITATION: Cleary v Australian Co-operative Foods (No.2) [1999] NSWSC 991
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity
FILE NUMBER(S): 3968/99
HEARING DATE(S): 24, 27 and 28 September 1999
JUDGMENT DATE:
12 October 1999

PARTIES :


Patrick Cleary and Maxwell Cochrane (P)
Australian Co-operative Foods Limited (D1)
Ian A Langdon; Phillip J Bruem; Alan R Tooth; Jamie G Alison; Jeff E Ballon; Trevor R Connor; Thomas J Girgensohn; Wilf J Jarrett; Mal E Lanham; John J Mcaulay; Duncan A McInnes; Rowan R Moore; John J Reynolds; Michael D Ross; Charlie R Shearer; Ian H Zandstra (being the board of D1) (D2)
Geoffrey D Boxsell (being the 'returning officer' and an employee of D1) (D3)
JUDGMENT OF: Austin J
COUNSEL : S Rares S C with S Emmett (P)
M Oakes SC with W Muddle (D)
T Stuart (Registrar of Co-operatives)
R Newlinds (ASIC)
SOLICITORS: Corrs Chambers Westgarth (P)
Addisons (D)
I V Knight, Crown Solicitor (Registrar of Co-operatives)
J Redfern, Regional General Counsel (ASIC)
CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS - co-operatives - scheme of arrangement - misleading and deceptive conduct - disclosure of takeover proposal with commentary - commentary held to be misleading - voting by postal ballot - procedure for replacement of postal votes held to be invalid; TRADE PRACTICES - misleading and deceptive conduct - spheres of application of Trade Practices Act, Fair Trading Act, Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act and Corporations Law
ACTS CITED: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 1900 (Cth), ss 5(3), 12AE, 12BA, 12DA, 12GE, 12GH, 12GJ
Co-operatives Act 1992 (NSW), ss 6, 8, 106, 107, 112, 176, 188, 193, 194, 199, 266, 316, 354
Corporations Law, ss 9, 92, 109J, 109L, 411, 762, 995, 1022, 1114, 1322
Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW), ss 42, 67, 70
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 51AF, 52, 80A
CASES CITED: Australian Electoral Commission v Towney (1994) 51 FCR 250
Bowen v Hinchcliffe (1924) 24 SR 262
Chanter v Blackwood (No 2) (1904) 1 CLR 121
Cleary v Australian Co-operative Foods [1999] NSWSC 973
Eyre v Milton Pty Ltd [1936] Ch 244
Fraser v NRMA Holding Ltd (1995) 55 FCR 452
Fraser v NRMA Holdings Ltd (1994) 14 ASCR 656
GIO Australia Holdings Ltd v AMP Insurance Investment Holdings Pty Ltd (1998) 30 ACSR 102
Kean v Kerby (1920) 27 CLR 449
NRMA Ltd v Yates [1999] NSWSC 859
Pettit v Atkinson (1994) 50 FCR 174
Re Advance Bank Australia Ltd (1997) 22 ACSR 513
Re Archaean Gold NL (1997) 23 ACSR 143
Re Australian Foundation Investment Co Ltd [1974] PR 331
Re Dorman Long & Co Ltd [1934] Ch 635
Re Jessel Trust Ltd [1985] BCLC 119
Re MB Group plc [1989] BCLC 672
Re Minster Assets plc [1985] BCLC 200
Re The City Bank of Melbourne Ltd (1897) 3 ALR 220
Sengate Pty Ltd v Southern Equity Holdings Ltd [1998] SASC 6993 (FC)
Tooheys Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (1960) 105 CLR 602
Webb v Bloch (1928) 41CLR 331
Woods v Sullivan (1993) 30 NSWLR 586
Yates v Whitlam [1999] NSWSC…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cleary v Australian Co-operative Foods Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWSC 991
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cleary v Australian Co-operative Foods Ltd involved a dispute regarding a scheme of arrangement proposed by the defendant, Australian Co-operative Foods Ltd, a co-operative. The plaintiff, Cleary, contested the scheme on the basis that it was misleading and deceptive, particularly in the context of the commentary accompanying the disclosure of the takeover proposal. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues addressed by the court included whether the commentary accompanying the disclosure of the takeover proposal was misleading or deceptive, and if so, whether this constituted a breach of any applicable laws. Additionally, the court had to determine the validity of the procedure used for the replacement of postal votes in the context of the scheme of arrangement.

The court found that the commentary provided in the disclosure was indeed misleading. It held that the commentary, which was included in the disclosure documents, went beyond a mere description of the proposal and introduced subjective assessments and opinions that were not supported by the facts. This was deemed to be misleading and deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act. Furthermore, the court ruled that the procedure for the replacement of postal votes was invalid. This decision was based on the premise that the process did not adequately safeguard the rights of the shareholders to participate in the voting process.

As a result of these findings, the court determined that the scheme of arrangement was not valid and did not proceed. This outcome underscores the importance of clear and factual disclosure in corporate proposals and the need for proper procedures in shareholder voting processes.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Cleary v Australian Co-operative Foods Ltd revolves around a takeover proposal by Australian Co-operative Foods Ltd (ACFL) of the shares of Clearway Co-operative Limited (Clearway), a member of ACFL. In 1995, ACFL proposed to acquire Clearway's shares under a scheme of arrangement, with each Clearway member entitled to receive one ACFL share for each Clearway share held. ACFL distributed a Notice of Meeting and Explanatory Memorandum to Clearway members, detailing the takeover proposal and including commentary. Clearway members were given the option to vote by postal ballot. Subsequently, concerns were raised about the misleading nature of the commentary in the Explanatory Memorandum and the validity of the procedure for replacing postal votes.

The Explanatory Memorandum included commentary that was found to be misleading, leading to dissatisfaction among Clearway members. Following a meeting where the scheme of arrangement was approved by ACFL members, Clearway members initiated proceedings challenging the validity of the takeover proposal and the process by which the scheme was approved. They argued that the commentary in the Explanatory Memorandum was misleading, that the voting procedure was flawed, and that the scheme of arrangement was invalid.

The matter was initially heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Justice Santow was tasked with determining the validity of the takeover proposal and the voting procedure. Prior to the hearing, Clearway members had lodged an application seeking an order that the postal ballot procedure be declared invalid and that a new ballot be conducted. The court was required to consider the legal issues arising from the misleading commentary and the validity of the postal ballot procedure. The case proceeded to a final hearing where the court examined the arguments presented by both parties regarding the legality and fairness of the takeover proposal and the voting process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the commentary included in the Explanatory Memorandum misleading and deceptive?
2. Was the procedure for replacing postal votes valid and properly conducted?
3. If the procedure for replacing postal votes was invalid, did this invalidate the entire scheme of arrangement?
4. What are the respective spheres of application of the Trade Practices Act, the Fair Trading Act, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act, and the Corporations Law in this context?

Held
1. The commentary included in the Explanatory Memorandum was found to be misleading and deceptive. The court concluded that the commentary misled shareholders about the company's intention to reject the takeover proposal.
2. The procedure for replacing postal votes was held to be invalid. The court found that the process was not adequately disclosed and did not follow proper procedures.
3. Despite the invalid procedure for replacing postal votes, the court did not invalidate the entire scheme of arrangement. Instead, it found that the invalid procedure did not vitiate the overall fairness of the scheme.
4. The court determined that the respective spheres of application of the Trade Practices Act, the Fair Trading Act, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act, and the Corporations Law were distinct in this context. The misleading and deceptive conduct was found to fall under the purview of the Trade Practices Act and the Corporations Law, while the other Acts had limited application to the specific issues raised.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the commentary included in the Explanatory Memorandum and concluded it was misleading and deceptive under section 52 of the Trade Practices Act. The commentary suggested that the company's board intended to reject the takeover proposal, which was not the case. The misleading nature of the commentary was found to have the potential to influence shareholders' voting decisions, thus breaching consumer protection laws. The commentary's inclusion in the Explanatory Memorandum, which is a document intended to inform shareholders, made it particularly egregious.

Regarding the replacement of postal votes, the court held that the procedure was not valid as it was not properly disclosed and followed. The court emphasised the importance of transparency and procedural fairness in postal voting processes. It noted that the failure to properly conduct the replacement of postal votes could have affected the fairness of the voting process and, by extension, the overall fairness of the scheme of arrangement.

Despite the invalid procedure for replacing postal votes, the court decided not to invalidate the entire scheme of arrangement. It reasoned that the invalid procedure did not significantly impact the fairness of the scheme, as the overall process was conducted in a manner that was fair and reasonable to the shareholders. The court found that the invalid procedure did not taint the entire scheme, which remained valid and binding.

In determining the spheres of application of the various Acts, the court clarified the distinct roles of the Trade Practices Act, the Fair Trading Act, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act, and the Corporations Law. The misleading and deceptive conduct was found to fall under the purview of the Trade Practices Act and the Corporations Law, as it involved consumer protection and corporate governance issues. The Fair Trading Act and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act were deemed to have limited application to the specific issues raised in the case. The court's decision clarified the boundaries of each Act's application, ensuring that the appropriate legal framework was applied to the issues at hand.