Clayton v Fischer

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

[1993] QCA 323

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 31 of 1993

Brisbane
[Clayton v. Fischer]

BETWEEN:

D'ARCY PHILLIP CLAYTON

(Plaintiff) Respondent

- and -

GWENDOLYNE FISCHER

(Defendant) Appellant

The President
Mr Justice Pincus

Mr Justice Demack

Judgment delivered 06/09/93

Joint reasons for judgment by the President and Demack J..
Pincus JA. dissenting.

APPEAL ALLOWED WITH COSTS TO BE TAXED. JUDGMENT IN FAVOUR OF THE RESPONDENT IS SET ASIDE. A NEW TRIAL LIMITED TO THE ISSUE OF DAMAGES IS ORDERED. THE COSTS OF THE FIRST TRIAL ARE RESERVED TO THE TRIAL JUDGE.

CATCHWORDS: DAMAGES - Causation - Conflict between evidence of experts cross-examined at trial and reports of experts not called - Whether court could choose between conflicting testimony.

Counsel: 

Mr. R.D. Pack for the appellant Mr. R. Myers for the respondent

Solicitors: 

Messrs. McInnes and Wilson as town agents for Messrs. Roberts, Leu and North for the appellant

Messrs. Thompson, King, Connolly as town agents for Connolly Suthers for the respondent

Hearing Date: 08/06/93
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 31 of 1993

Before The President
Mr Justice Pincus
Mr Justice Demack

[Clayton v. Fischer]

BETWEEN:

D'ARCY PHILLIP CLAYTON

(Plaintiff) Respondent

- and -

GWENDOLYNE FISCHER

(Defendant) Appellant

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE PRESIDENT AND DEMACK J.

Judgment delivered 06/09/93

This is an appeal against a judgment given in the Trial Division on 10 February 1993 awarding the respondent damages of $168,731.95. Liability was admitted at trial and the

appeal is concerned only with the quantum of the damages

awarded.

Mr. Clayton, the respondent, was born on 11 January

1942. In 1964, he was hit in the small of the back by a

gave evidence that he obtained complete relief from this
back injury after two visits to a chiropractor. However,
according to a report dated 23 October 1986, he told Dr.

bag of cement, causing injury to his lower back. Mr. Clayton suffered intermittent pain as a result of this incident but obtained relief every few years from another doctor.

In 1969, Mr. Clayton started a business of custom-

making picture frames, which was his primary source of
income until he stopped in 1987. He was also a keen and
proficient archer and earned some income teaching archery
and selling archery equipment.

On 11 August 1977, Mr. Clayton was admitted to the

Princess Alexandra Hospital in Brisbane because of anterior chest pain. He was discharged on 17 August 1977. Dr. R. A. Douglas, a physician, examined the hospital records and, in his report of 15 January 1990, stated that there was no evidence that the pain was of cardiac origin. It was written up in the hospital records as "chest pain ? cause".
On 15 June 1981, Mr. Clayton saw Dr. Watson in relation
to an accident that had occurred about two weeks prior. He
had slipped on stairs, jarring his spine, and complained of
pain in the low back, hips, groin and buttocks. Although he
had improved…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clayton v Fischer and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1993] QCA 323
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was against the quantum of damages awarded to the respondent, D'Arcy Phillip Clayton, by the trial judge in a personal injury claim. The appellant, Gwendolyne Fischer, was found liable and the only issue on appeal was the amount of damages awarded to the respondent. The respondent claimed that he suffered a minor injury in a motor vehicle accident in 1983, which caused him to develop a variety of symptoms, including pain in various parts of his body and psychological issues. The trial judge found that the respondent's complaints were "by and large the result of the trauma sustained" in the 1983 accident, and awarded damages of $168,731.95. The appellant challenged this finding, arguing that the evidence did not support the conclusion that the respondent's current condition was largely due to the 1983 accident.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment in favour of the respondent, and ordered a new trial limited to the issue of damages. The Court found that the trial judge's conclusion that the respondent's current condition was largely due to the 1983 accident could not be supported by reference to the trial judge's reasons. The evidence presented was conflicting and it was not appropriate for the Court to form a lay view of the seriousness of the respondent's injuries in the accident and prefer the medical evidence which was most consistent with that view, rejecting contrary evidence. The Court held that there was no satisfactory basis upon which it could choose between the conflicting testimony of witnesses. The appeal was allowed with costs to be taxed, and the judgment in favour of the respondent was set aside. A new trial limited to the issue of damages was ordered, and the costs of the first trial were reserved to the trial judge.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.