Clarke v Channel 9 South Australia Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

CLARKE v CHANNEL 9 SOUTH AUSTRALIA PTY LTD & ORS (NO 2)

[2006] SADC 139

Judgment of His Honour Judge Lovell

21 December 2006

DEFAMATION

Defence of fair comment - whether particulars sought to justify "public interest" are confined by the meanings pleaded by the Plaintiff.

Clarke v Channel 9 South Australia Pty Ltd & Ors [2006] SADC 87; Manock v Channel Seven Adelaide Pty Ltd [2006] SASC 322, discussed.

CLARKE v CHANNEL 9 SOUTH AUSTRALIA PTY LTD & ORS (NO 2)
[2006] SADC 139

Background

  1. The Defendants by Proposed Third Further Amended Defence plead particulars of Public Interest as part of the defence of Fair Comment. The Plaintiff challenges particulars 5.20 to 5.41. These particulars are identical to the particulars 4.3.1 to 4.3.22 that I dealt with in relation to the question of justification in Clarke v Channel 9 South Australia Pty Ltd & Ors.[1] In that judgment I also dealt with the question as to whether those particulars could be pleaded as part of the defence of fair comment when the particulars were not contained within the publication nor were notorious.

  2. The matter that now falls to be decided was not argued before the Learned Master. I agreed, upon the application of both parties, to hear the matter without referring it to the Masters list.

    Defence of Fair Comment

  3. To make out a defence of fair comment, the following must be established: that the matter or words in question were comment rather than a statement of fact; that the comment related to a matter of public interest; that the comment sufficiently indicated the facts on which it was made; that those facts are true or protected by privilege; and that the comment is fair in the sense that any fair minded person could express the opinion in question honestly.[2]

  4. The defence of fair comment is only available with respect to comments on matters of public interest, the rationale being that free discussion of such matters promotes the “common weal”.[3]

    [3] Gillooly, The Law of Defemation in Australia and New Zealand.

    Arguments

  5. Mr Swan, who appeared on behalf of the Defendants, argued that it was for the Defendants to establish that the matter was one of public interest and the topics of public interest should not be unduly confined. He argued that he was not confined by the imputations or nuances pleaded by the Plaintiff when particularising the matters relied upon by the Defendants relating to the question of public interest. Thus he argued, to establish the public interest the Defendants could plead and then rely on matters that it could not rely on, for example, in its defence of justification.

  6. Mr Swan argued that the public interest topic in this case is the conduct of an elected Member of Parliament, his relationship with his defacto and the administration of justice. The particulars sought to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clarke v Channel 9 South Australia Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SADC 139
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The District Court of South Australia dealt with a defamation case where the plaintiff, Clarke, challenged particulars pleaded by the defendants, Channel 9 South Australia Pty Ltd and others. The defendants sought to rely on the defence of fair comment and argued that the particulars they proposed to add to their defence were relevant to establishing the public interest aspect of their defence. Clarke, however, argued that the public interest must be identifiable within the meaning of the comment as pleaded by the plaintiff and that the defendants could not go beyond the comments to justify the public interest. The court had to decide whether the defendants could rely on certain particulars to establish the public interest aspect of their defence of fair comment, and whether they were confined by the meanings pleaded by the plaintiff.

The court considered the legal principles underpinning the defence of fair comment and whether the particulars in question could be used to establish the public interest. The court noted that for the defence of fair comment to succeed, the defendants must establish that the comment was on a matter of public interest, among other things. The court also considered the argument that the public interest must be identifiable within the meaning of the comment as pleaded by the plaintiff and that the defendants could not go beyond the comments to justify the public interest. The court found that the particulars in question did not address the imputations alleged by the plaintiff and that they raised matters which were substantially different to the imputations pleaded by the plaintiff. Therefore, the court held that the defendants could not rely on those particulars to establish the public interest aspect of their defence of fair comment.

The court found that the particulars that the defendants sought to use in relation to the question of "public interest" also did not address the imputations alleged by the plaintiff. The court held that the defendants could not go beyond the comments to justify the public interest. The court found that the proposed amendment to the defence would not be allowed. The court noted that it would hear the parties as to the form of the orders and the question of costs. The outcome of the case was that the defendants could not rely on the particulars in question to establish the public interest aspect of their defence of fair comment, and the court disallowed the proposed amendment to the defence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established