Clarke, M.W.F and Clarke, W.P.J

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

In the marriage of CLARKE, M.W.F. and CLARKE, W.P.J.

(1986) FLC ¶91-778

Other publishers' citations: (1986) 11 FamLR 364

Full Court of the Family Court of Australia at Brisbane.

Judgment delivered 10 December 1986.

Before: Fogarty, Lindenmayer and Nygh JJ.

Fogarty and Nygh JJ.: We have had the opportunity of reading the judgment of Lindenmayer J. and agree that the appeal should be allowed and with the orders he proposes.

The basic issue in this case is whether the requirement in sec. 48(2) that the parties ``lived separately and apart for a continuous period of not less than 12 months'' means that the parties should during that period maintain both the fact of separation and the intention to sever the marital relationship or whether both should come together in a resumption of cohabitation in order to end the state of separation. If the former is the right interpretation, the learned trial Judge was correct in concluding that a reconciliation of the parties, whether followed by a resumption of cohabitation or not, put an end to separation since reconciled spouses clearly no longer have an intention to sever the marital relationship. It would also follow that his Honour was correct in concluding that sec. 50(1) was inapplicable since it refers only to interruption of the period of separation by resumption of cohabitation.

In relation to desertion, it was well established that both the intention to desert and the fact of desertion had to coexist for the requisite period: Crowther v. Crowther (1951) A.C. 723. But this principle did not apply by analogy to the ground of separation as it existed under sec. 28(m) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1959.

In Macrae v. Macrae (1967) 9 F.L.R. 441, the New South Wales Court of Appeal had to consider an unusual fact situation. The parties had separated on 14 November 1957. Thereafter the parties each desired a resumption of cohabitation, but failed to agree on a suitable residence. In 1958 they agreed on a site and plans for a house, including colour schemes, but the purchase fell through by the fault of the vendor. The parties never actually resumed cohabitation.

Herron C.J. said at p. 446:

``Once this state of living separately and apart was established nothing less than a resumption of cohabitation could put an end to it. Mere negotiation is not a substitute. Nor did the mere intention of the parties to resume cohabitation put an end to the situation.''

At p. 448 the learned Chief Justice distinguished the law relating to desertion from that of separation on the ground that the former included a notion of continuance without justification with intent which was not in his Honour's view present in the latter. See also the remarks of Sugarman J.A. at p. 457 to the effect that ``attempts by one or both of the parties to restore it (i.e. the marital relationship)'' are not sufficient, and Walsh J.A. at p. 464.

This statement of the law in relation to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clarke, M.W.F and Clarke, W.P.J and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1986] FamCA 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Full Federal Court heard an appeal concerning a dispute between M.W.F. Clarke and W.P.J. Clarke. The precise nature of the dispute is not detailed in the provided text, but it involved a matter brought before the Full Federal Court for determination.

The central legal issues before the Full Federal Court were not explicitly stated in the provided text. However, the composition of the bench, consisting of Fogarty, Lindenmayer, and Nygh JJ., suggests that the appeal likely involved complex questions of law, potentially relating to administrative law, corporate law, or another area within the Federal Court's jurisdiction.

The reasoning of the court and the legal principles applied are not detailed in the provided text. Therefore, it is not possible to explain the court's decision-making process or the legal framework it relied upon.

The final orders or outcome of the appeal are also not specified in the provided text.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established