Clarke and Civil Aviation Safety Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

Clarke and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2023] AATA 2628 (18 August 2023)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/2669

Re:Adam Daniel Clarke

APPLICANT

AndCivil Aviation Safety Authority

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President Boyle

Date:18 August 2023

Place:Perth

The decision made by the Respondent on 29 April 2020 to refuse to grant the Applicant the relevant civil aviation authorisations under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) is affirmed.

.............[Sgd]...........................................................

Deputy President Boyle

CATCHWORDS

CIVIL AVIATION – authorisations under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 – Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 – whether defence force qualification is at least equivalent to civilian aviation authorisation – whether applicant is entitled to be granted civil authorisation based on defence qualifications – Tribunal not satisfied that the defence qualifications are at least equivalent to authorisations sought – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 4

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 29(2)(b)(i)

Air Navigation Act 1920 (Cth) s 3A

Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 3, 8, 9, 20AB, 98

Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth) rr 11.055(1A), 11.068, 61.010, 61.035, 61.275, 61.285, 61.1175, 61.1235, 61.1250, 141.125

Mutual Recognition Act 1992 (Cth) s 29(1)

CASES

Cau  v Victorian Building Authority [2022] FCA 45

Victorian Building Authority v Cau [2023] FCAFC 120

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Civil Aviation Safety Authority, Part 61 Manual of Standards Instrument 2014 (current as of 18 May 2021)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Boyle

18 August 2023

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks the review of a decision by the Respondent (CASA) made on 29 April 2020 (the Decision) to refuse to grant the Applicant certain civil aviation authorisations under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) (CAAct).

  2. Pursuant to s 31(2) of the CA Act, a decision to refuse to grant an authorisation is reviewable by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

  3. While the Decision was made and communicated to the Applicant on 29 April 2020, CASA did not provide a written statement setting out its findings and reasons for the Decision until 6 April 2021.

  4. The Applicant lodged the application for the review of the Decision with the Tribunal on 28 April 2021, that is within 28 days after the receipt of the written statement setting out the findings and reasons for the Decision. I am satisfied that the application was lodged within the time prescribed by s 29(2)(b)(i) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) and that the Tribunal has the power to review the Decision.

  5. By the Decision, CASA refused to grant nine authorisations sought by the Applicant.
    Prior to the commencement of the hearing, CASA conceded that a number of the authorisations sought by the Applicant should be granted and the Applicant advised that he no longer pursued certain authorisations. The authorisations still in dispute are:

    (a)Flight Instructor Rating: Grade 1 training endorsement (FIR-Grade 1);

    (b)Flight Instructor Rating Instructor rating training endorsement (FIR-FIR);

    (c)Flight Instructor Rating with multi-engine aeroplane class rating instructor training endorsement (

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clarke and Civil Aviation Safety Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] AATA 2628
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Applicant against a decision of the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) to refuse to grant him certain civil aviation authorisations. The Applicant sought to rely on his extensive qualifications and experience gained while serving in the Australian Defence Force (ADF) to demonstrate that these ADF qualifications were at least equivalent to the civilian authorisations sought, as required by the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (CASR).

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Applicant's ADF flight crew qualifications and experience were sufficiently equivalent to the specific civilian aviation authorisations he was seeking. This required an assessment of the nature and extent of the activities authorised by each type of qualification, rather than merely comparing flight hours or general experience. The court had to determine if the ADF qualifications met the threshold of being "at least equivalent" to the civilian authorisations under CASR 61.285.

In reaching its decision, the court drew guidance from the Federal Court's approach in *Victorian Building Authority v Cau*, which interpreted the concept of equivalence under the Mutual Recognition Act 1992. This involved focusing on the "activities authorised to be carried out under each registration" and identifying whether these professional activities were substantially the same. The court found that ADF qualifications are generally type-specific, whereas the civilian authorisations sought, such as the Flight Instructor Rating Multi-engine aeroplane class rating instructor training endorsement (FIR-MEAI), were class-specific. The court concluded that the Applicant's ADF instructor qualification on the F/A-18, while involving a multi-engine aircraft, was not a qualification to train instructors, nor did the ADF possess a qualification equivalent to the multi-engine class rating.

Consequently, the court was not satisfied that the Applicant's ADF qualifications were at least equivalent to the authorisations sought. Accordingly, the decision of CASA to refuse the four specific authorisations was affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Clarke and Civil Aviation Safety Authority involves an application by the Applicant, a former Australian Defence Force (ADF) officer, to have his military qualifications recognised for the purpose of obtaining civilian aviation authorisations under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998. The Applicant left the ADF in 2015 and has since worked as a contractor overseas, including instructing roles with the Saudi Air Force and operating civilian aircraft in support of defence contracts. He is currently instructing at a conversion unit in Saudi Arabia, training pilots who have little flying background and are not native English speakers. The Applicant's experience in these roles led him to apply for civil aviation authorisations, which he believed his military background qualified him for.

The Tribunal heard evidence from the Applicant and three other witnesses: Gary John Maxwell, Ray Gregory Simpson, and Dr Anthony Alfred Stanton. The Applicant's evidence outlined his extensive experience in various military and civilian roles, and he argued that his ADF qualifications were equivalent to the authorisations sought under the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations. He detailed his instructing roles and the challenges of training non-native English speakers, emphasising the skills and knowledge he had acquired that he believed were transferable to civilian aviation. Mr Maxwell, another experienced RAAF officer, provided additional testimony regarding his own qualifications and experience, corroborating the Applicant's assertions about the skills required in instructing roles.

The Tribunal's decision, however, found that the Applicant's ADF qualifications were not equivalent to the civil authorisations he sought. The Tribunal determined that the ADF qualifications were type-specific rather than class-specific, and there was no direct equivalence between the military qualifications and the civilian authorisations. This conclusion was based on the specific requirements of each authorisation and the nature of the ADF qualifications, which did not align with the sought civilian authorisations. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision made by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority on 29 April 2020, denying the Applicant's application for the authorisations.

This matter came before the Civil Aviation Tribunal (the Tribunal) following an application by the Applicant, who sought a review of a decision made by the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA). The Tribunal's role was to determine whether the qualifications held by the Applicant under the Australian Defence Force (ADF) were at least equivalent to the civil aviation authorisations sought under the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998. The matter was not a first-instance hearing but a judicial review of a decision made by CASA on 29 April 2020. The Applicant had previously engaged in an administrative review process with CASA, which resulted in the decision that his ADF qualifications did not meet the requirements for the sought civil authorisations. This decision was subsequently affirmed by the Tribunal, which found that the activities authorised under the Applicant’s ADF qualifications did not align with those authorised under the civil authorisations sought. The Tribunal's review involved careful consideration of the evidence presented by the Applicant and other witnesses, including their respective experiences and qualifications in both military and civilian aviation contexts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following witnesses gave evidence at the hearing:(a)The Applicant;(b)Gary John Maxwell(c)Ray Gregory Simpson; and (d)Dr Anthony Alfred Stanton.The evidenceThe Applicant The Applicant’s evidence at the hearing was to the following effect. He left the ADF full-time in 2015 and has since worked as a contractor overseas in flying and non-flying roles. Over the last five years the Applicant has spent three years in in the Middle East instructing at various levels with the Saudi Air Force, as well as a stint for 12 months operating the Lear 35 in support of defence contracts as a civilian pilot. He described the work that he is presently doing in Saudi Arabia as working at a conversion unit with trainees who have completed basic training on the PC-21s, the same aircraft that is used by RAAF. The trainees have at that point completed about 70 hours flying on the Hawk 165, the same aircraft used by the RAAF for the same role, and are then trained to operate on the F15. They end up with 200 hours to 250 hours flying having come from no flying background. This is the usual practice in Saudi Arabia. The Applicant described the difficulty in instructing Arabic speaking pilots (he does not speak Arabic and English is the trainees’ second language) with little background in flying. Asked to describe the difference between instructing ADF pilots and civilian pilots, the Applicant’s evidence was that in his current instructing role things happened a lot more quickly and there is less time to react and address problems and correct errors. He described it as follows:[12]APPLICANT: …So that time is compressed and then the added complexity of being second language English is that you need to process any errors and then give corrections to the trainee so that they can listen to it in English, convert it back to Arabic, and then action that obviously close to the ground at high speed, so – yesMR WHEELER: Okay. So a challenging moment?APPLICANT: Yes.[12] Transcript at 43. The Applicant was taken by his counsel through his relevant experience relating to each of the authorisations sought. In each case, the Applicant’s evidence was to the effect that his experience on ADF aircraft within the parameters and context of ADF training and operation would equip him with the relevant skills at or above the required level to undertake the functions and responsibilities attaching to the civil authorisations. Further, the Applicant’s evidence was that he satisfied the requirements, including flight hours, of CASR 61.1235 for the training endorsements. Mr Maxwell gave evidence at the hearing and also provided a witness statement.[13] Like the Applicant, Mr Maxwell has had a long and distinguished career in the RAAF starting in Officer Training School pilot’s course in June 1993. He was awarded a Conspicuous Service Medal 2018 and Medal of the Order of Australia (Military Division) in 2003. From 2017 to the present, he has been an instructor with 79SQN in Williamtown on the Hawk 127. Prior that that role, Mr Maxwell was, amongst other postings, 88SQN Commanding Officer running the Air Warfare Instructor training course (July 2016 - October 2017), 3 SQN Executive Officer operating F/A18s (July 2014 - July 2016) and Fighter Combat Instructor and examiner instrument rating 2OCU RAAF Williamtown (January 2010 - October 2011). Mr Maxwell’s civilian employment includes pilot 747-400 (SO) and B737-800 (FO) (October 2004 - present).[13] A1.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Flight Instructor Rating Multi-engine aeroplane class rating instructor training endorsement (FIR-MEAI) is an endorsement for flight training for a class rating training. The Applicant relies on his qualification as an instructor on the F/A-18 which is a multi-engine aircraft. That ADF instructor’s qualification, however, is not a qualification to train instructors which is the endorsement sought. Further, the ADF does not have a qualification equivalent to the multi-engine class rating. The ADF qualifications are type-specific, not class-specific. Again, there is no equivalence between the ADF qualification relied on and the endorsement sought.DECISION In the case of each of the authorisations sought by the Applicant, for the reasons set out above, I am not satisfied that the ADF qualification held by the Applicant is at least equivalent to the authorisation sought as required by CASR 61.285 for the Applicant to be taken to meet the requirements for the grant of the authorisations. Accordingly, the decision made by the Respondent on 29 April 2020 insofar as it relates to the four authorisations sought, is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to Flight Instructor Rating Multi-engine aeroplane class rating instructor training endorsement, it is because the ADF qualifications are type specific, and the Applicant has experience on so many types and situations, that makes him qualified to be awarded the privilege of this class rating training endorsement.CONSIDERATION It is unfortunate that there is no specific judicial consideration of the approach to be taken in assessing whether ADF flight crew qualifications are at least equivalent to the civilian authorisations. Some guidance, however, can be found in the recent Federal Court Full Court judgment in Victorian Building Authority v Cau[2023] FCAFC 120. In Cau the Full Court was considering Part 3 of the Mutual Recognition Act 1992 (Cth) (MR Act). The Full Court described at [1] the operation of the MR Act as follows:Part 3 of the [MR Act] provides a mechanism by which a person who is registered for an occupation in one State is entitled to registration in the equivalent occupation in another State after notifying the local registration authority of the other State. The local registration authority may refuse registration in the other State if the authority decides that the occupation in which registration is sought is not an equivalent occupation and equivalence cannot be achieved by the imposition of conditions. Section 29(1) of the MR Act provides:An occupation for which persons may be registered in the first State is taken to be equivalent to an occupation for which persons may be registered in the second State if the activities authorised to be carried out under each registration are substantially the same (whether or not this result is achieved by means of the imposition of conditions). At [6] of Cau, in describing the approach taken by Colvin J at first instance,[19] an approach with which the Full Court agreed, the Full Court said:The primary judge found (all emphasis in original) that words used in the phrase "'activities authorised to be carried out under each registration' ... direct attention to the activities that comprise the nature and extent of the occupation being registered" (at J [11]). He explained that the "activities" to which reference is made in that phrase are not "activities that may be authorised by reason of the fact of registration or in consequence of registration" but "activities that can be carried out under the registration of the occupation. His Honour held that "the activities being carried out under the registration are those professional activities that form part of the occupation" (at J [12]). The distinction his Honour drew, then, was between s 29(1) as requiring equivalence in specified functions which are authorised to be performed by registered persons, for example the statutory function of issuing building permits, and s 29(1) as requiring equivalence in the broader occupational activities that a person may undertake if registered.[19] Cau v Victorian Building Authority [2022] FCA 45.