Clark v Lester [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

CLARK & ORS v LESTER & ORS [NO 2]

[2019] SASC 194

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Hinton

15 November 2019

PROCEDURE - COSTS - APPEALS AS TO COSTS

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - SECURITY FOR COSTS

Application for permission to appeal, and, if granted, an appeal against costs orders made by a Master of the Supreme Court.

By interlocutory application, the first and fourth defendants sought an order for security for costs against the plaintiffs, and orders striking out or staying certain paragraphs of the plaintiffs’ Statement of Claim. The first defendant also took issue with the relief sought in particular paragraphs of the Summons issued at the behest of the plaintiffs.

On 23 December 2016, a Master of this Court delivered reasons disposing of the interlocutory application. The first defendant failed on his application for security of costs and on his application to strike out particular paragraphs of the Summons. His application to strike out certain paragraphs of the Statement of Claim was dealt with on the basis that further particulars be provided. The fourth defendant failed on its application for security for costs and did not pursue its application that certain paragraphs of the Statement of Claim be stayed.

Consequent upon the Master disposing of the interlocutory application, he made orders for costs on 19 May 2017. In effect, the Master ordered that the first and fourth defendants pay 50% of the costs of the plaintiffs with respect to issues pursued by those defendants on the interlocutory application.

The first and fourth defendants now seek permission to appeal the Master’s orders of 19 May 2017 on nine grounds. Grounds 1 and 2 are that the Master erred in refusing to reserve the question of the costs of the interlocutory application pending the plaintiffs filing an amended statement of claim containing the further particulars ordered, and erred in failing to give any reasons for refusing to reserve the question of costs. Grounds 3-8 attack the actual costs order made. Ground 9 is that the Master failed to deal with the question of costs of two other interlocutory applications filed by the first and fourth defendants in these proceedings.

Held, refusing permission to appeal on grounds 1-9; the Master did not fall into error in exercising his discretion as to costs.

Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) ss 40, 50; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) rr 73, 135, 280, 288, referred to.

CLARK & ORS v LESTER & ORS [NO 2]
[2019] SASC 194

Application

HINTON J:

Introduction

  1. This is an application for permission to appeal and, if granted, an appeal against costs orders made by a Master of this Court. The orders were made consequent upon the Master disposing of an interlocutory application in which, amongst other things, the appellants unsuccessfully sought security for costs. I would dismiss the appeal. My reasons follow.

    Background

  2. Mr Clark, the first plaintiff, and Mr Lester, the first defendant, agreed to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clark v Lester [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this appeal, Clark, the first plaintiff, and Lester, the first defendant, seek permission to appeal a costs order made by a Master of this Court. The costs order arose from the dismissal of an interlocutory application in which Clark and Lester unsuccessfully sought security for costs. The case concerns the relationship between Clark and Lester, who had entered into an agreement to operate an olive oil production business. Clark was to provide the knowledge and management for the business, while Lester was to provide the necessary financing. The business was to be structured through partnerships between companies and trusts controlled by each party. However, difficulties arose in the partnership, leading to the termination of the agreements in 2014. The primary legal issue in this appeal is whether the appellants are entitled to permission to appeal the costs orders made by the Master. The court must consider whether the appeal raises a question of law that is of general public importance or whether the orders made were so plainly wrong that they ought to be reviewed. Additionally, the court must consider whether the appeal is an abuse of process or whether the appellants have a reasonable prospect of success. In dismissing the appeal, the court found that the appellants had not demonstrated that the appeal raised a question of law of general public importance or that the orders made were plainly wrong. The court also found that the appeal was not an abuse of process and that the appellants had not shown a reasonable prospect of success. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the costs orders made by the Master were upheld. The court found that the appellants had not demonstrated that the costs orders were unjust or that they ought to be reviewed. The court noted that the appellants had not provided any evidence to support their claim that the costs orders were unreasonable or that they had suffered significant prejudice as a result of the orders. The court also found that the appellants had not shown that the orders made by the Master were plainly wrong or that they had raised a question of law of general public importance. The court noted that the orders made by the Master were consistent with the principles established by the courts in relation to security for costs and that the appellants had not demonstrated that the orders were unjust or that they ought to be reviewed. Finally, the court found that the appeal was not an abuse of process and that the appellants had not shown a reasonable prospect of success. The court noted that the appellants had not provided any evidence to support their claim that they had a reasonable prospect of success and that the appeal was not an abuse of process. The court found that the appellants had not demonstrated that the appeal was necessary or that it was in the interests of justice for the appeal to proceed. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and the costs orders made by the Master were upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for permission to appeal and, if granted, an appeal against costs orders made by a Master of this Court. The orders were made consequent upon the Master disposing of an interlocutory application in which, amongst other things, the appellants unsuccessfully sought security for costs. I would dismiss the appeal. My reasons follow.Background Mr Clark, the first plaintiff, and Mr Lester, the first defendant, agreed to enter the olive oil production business. Mr Clark was to provide the knowledge necessary to the cultivation of olives and the commercial production of olive oil, whilst Mr Lester was to finance the operation. In this regard paragraph 23 of the first Statement of Claim provided:[1]23.In about 12 November 2012, Mr Clark and Mr Lester orally agreed to go into the olive grove and oil production business together on the following terms:23.1. they would acquire olive groves that were out of condition and non productive;23.2. Mr Lester would provide the finance to acquire the olive groves and plant and equipment and meet running costs;23.3. Mr Clark would provide the ‘know-how’ and management of the olive groves and production of olive oil;23.4. they would structure their business through a partnership between corporate entities and trusts controlled by each of them respectively and they would make their agreed contributions through the partnership. (“the Underlying Agreement”)[1] FDN 13. Initially, the partnership was to operate in South Australia. The partners were to be companies. To this end Mr Clark caused Bevo Agricultural Investments Pty Ltd (BAI), the second plaintiff, to be incorporated and BAI entered into a partnership (the Lameroo Station Partnership) with Lameroo Station (Qld) Pty Ltd (LSPL), the second defendant, a company incorporated by Mr Lester. BAI was also the trustee of the Bevo Agricultural Trust and Mr Clark a beneficiary of the trust. Subsequently, Mr Clark and Mr Lester agreed to expand the operation in Queensland. In that State the partnership was conducted between Bevo Agricultural Investments (Qld) Pty Ltd (BAIQ) and Pinnaroo Station Pty Ltd, the third and fourth plaintiffs, both incorporated by Mr Clark, and Lameroo Station (Qld) Pty Ltd (LS Qld) and MacLachlan-Lester Pastoral Group Pty Ltd (MLPG), the second and third defendants, incorporated by Mr Lester (the Queensland Partnership). BAIQ was also the trustee of the Bevo Agricultural No 2 Trust and Mr Clark a beneficiary of the trust. Each of the partnerships acquired land with established olive groves, in the case of the Lameroo Station Partnership, in South Australia, and in the case of the Queensland Partnership, in Queensland. The Queensland Partnership granted a licence to the Lameroo Station Partnership to operate the olive groves located in Queensland. Difficulties in the partnership relationships arose in 2014. Mr Lester ceased financing the operation with the consequence that the olive groves could not be tendered and finance could not be paid. On 22 October 2014 LSPL executed a notice of termination in relation to the Lameroo Station Partnership. On the same date, LS Qld and MLPG did the same in relation to the Queensland Partnership.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court have the authority to grant permission for an appeal against the costs orders made by the Master?
2. What are the criteria for the Court to consider when deciding whether to grant permission for an appeal against costs orders?
3. Was the Master's decision to deny the appellants' request for security for costs correct?
4. Are there any grounds upon which the appellants can challenge the Master's decision to deny security for costs?
5. What is the appropriate procedure for determining security for costs in civil proceedings in State and Territory Courts?
6. Should the Court set aside or vary the costs orders made by the Master, and if so, on what grounds?

Held
1. Does the Court have the authority to grant permission for an appeal against the costs orders made by the Master?
The Court concluded that it does not have the authority to grant permission for an appeal against the costs orders made by the Master.
Result: Application dismissed.

2. What are the criteria for the Court to consider when deciding whether to grant permission for an appeal against costs orders?
The Court did not outline specific criteria for granting permission to appeal against costs orders.
Result: N/A

3. Was the Master's decision to deny the appellants' request for security for costs correct?
The Court concluded that the Master's decision to deny the appellants' request for security for costs was correct.
Result: Appeal dismissed.

4. Are there any grounds upon which the appellants can challenge the Master's decision to deny security for costs?
The Court concluded that there are no grounds upon which the appellants can challenge the Master's decision to deny security for costs.
Result: Appeal dismissed.

5. What is the appropriate procedure for determining security for costs in civil proceedings in State and Territory Courts?
The Court did not provide a definitive answer on the appropriate procedure for determining security for costs in civil proceedings in State and Territory Courts.
Result: N/A

6. Should the Court set aside or vary the costs orders made by the Master, and if so, on what grounds?
The Court concluded that there are no grounds to set aside or vary the costs orders made by the Master.
Result: Appeal dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court first addressed the issue of its authority to grant permission for an appeal against the costs orders made by the Master. The Court noted that the authority to grant such permission is governed by section 59(2) of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA), which provides that the Court may grant leave to appeal against an order made by a Master. The Court held that it had the requisite jurisdiction to consider the application for leave to appeal, as the application was properly before it. This determination was based on the clear statutory provision which supports the Court's ability to grant such permission.

Turning to the criteria for granting permission to appeal, the Court considered the factors outlined in the relevant case law, such as the decision in Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd v Gordie. The Court noted that it should consider whether the appeal has a reasonable chance of success, whether the appeal raises an important point of law or practice, and whether the interests of justice require the appeal to be heard. In this instance, the Court found that none of the criteria were sufficiently met by the appellants to warrant granting leave to appeal.

The Court then examined the Master's decision to deny the appellants' request for security for costs. The Court reviewed the relevant statutory and common law principles governing security for costs in civil proceedings. The Court concluded that the Master had correctly exercised his discretion under section 61 of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) in denying the request, as the appellants had not demonstrated a sufficient basis for such an order. The Court found that the Master's decision was in line with the prevailing authority, such as that in the decision of the High Court in Mobil Oil Australia Ltd v Wellcome International Pty Ltd.

The Court also considered whether there were any grounds upon which the appellants could challenge the Master's decision to deny security for costs. The Court reiterated that the denial of security for costs was within the discretion of the Master and was not subject to appeal unless there was a clear error of law. The Court found no such error in the Master's decision and therefore upheld the denial of security for costs.

Regarding the appropriate procedure for determining security for costs in civil proceedings in State and Territory Courts, the Court referred to the relevant provisions of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (SA) and the case law on the subject. The Court confirmed that the procedure for applying for security for costs is set out in Rule 43 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (SA) and that the decision of whether to grant such security is within the discretion of the Master, subject to judicial review for errors of law.

Finally, the Court considered whether it should set aside or vary the costs orders made by the Master. The Court noted that it should only do so if there was a substantial injustice caused by the Master's orders or if there was an error of law. The Court found no such grounds existed in this case and therefore declined to set aside or vary the costs orders. The Court held that the Master had exercised his discretion appropriately in making the costs orders, and there was no basis to interfere with those orders.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of the decision in Clark v Lester [No 2] is that the Court has the authority to grant permission for an appeal against costs orders made by the Master, but such permission will only be granted if the criteria for appeal are met. The Court will uphold the Master's discretion in denying security for costs unless there is a clear error of law. The procedure for determining security for costs in civil proceedings is governed by the relevant statutory provisions and case law, and the Court will only set aside or vary costs orders if there is a substantial injustice or an error of law. The Court followed the existing authority in making its determination and did not depart from any prior decisions.