Clark and Shire Of Chittering

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

STREAM:   COMMERCIAL & CIVIL

ACT: HEALTH ACT 1911 (WA)

CITATION:   CLARK and SHIRE OF CHITTERING [2008] WASAT 30

MEMBER:   JUDGE J CHANEY (DEPUTY PRESIDENT)

MR T CAREY (MEMBER)

HEARD:   13 NOVEMBER 2007, FURTHER WRITTEN SUBMISSIONS 21, 23 NOVEMBER 2007

DELIVERED          :   11 FEBRUARY 2008

FILE NO/S:   CC 803 of 2007

BETWEEN:   MILTON JAMES CLARK

Applicant

AND

SHIRE OF CHITTERING
Respondent

Catchwords:

Health ­ Certificate of occupancy ­ Conference centre ­ Effect of earlier planning approval ­ Whether planning approval limited number of occupants ­ Earlier proceedings assumed limitation of numbers as part of planning approval ­ Whether applicant estopped from arguing against assumption ­ Whether planning approval within power.

Legislation:

Health (Public Buildings) Regulations 1992 (WA), reg 9, reg 9A
Health Act 1911 (WA), s 36(1), s 178, s 178(1)
Shire of Chittering Town Planning Scheme No 5, cl 3.3.3, cl 3.5.2, cl 3.6.2, cl 3.7.1, cl 3.7.2, cl 3.8.15, cl 3.8.17.3, cl 3.9.4, cl 3.10.2, cl 3.11.2, cl 3.12.2
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 9

Result:

Application allowed
Certificate for 69 people ordered

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant:     N/A

Respondent:     N/A

Solicitors:

Applicant:     McLeods

Respondent:     Hardy Bowen

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Clark and Shire of Chittering [2005] WASAT 175

Clark and Shire of Chittering [2007] WASAT 218

Medical Board of WA v Mustac [2006] WASAT 178

Port of Melbourne Authoritv v Anshun Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 589

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL: 

Summary of Tribunal's decision

  1. Mr Milton Clark applied to the Shire of Chittering for a certificate of approval for a function centre under the provisions of the Health Act 1911 (WA). The Shire imposed a condition on the certificate limiting the number of persons to be accommodated in the function centre to 20. It did so on the basis that the Health Act certificate should reflect a limitation on the planning consent for the original construction of the conference centre. The Shire contended that the planning consent was limited to use of the function centre only by guests staying at the farm stay facility also operated by Mr Clark on the subject land. Mr Clark sought a review of that decision by the Tribunal.

  2. It was agreed that, but for the alleged limitation on the planning consent, there was no reason why a Health Act certificate should not issue for a maximum of 69 persons, being the number sought by Mr Clark. The Tribunal examined the history of Mr Clark's planning application which involved earlier proceedings in the Tribunal. The Shire argued that the earlier proceedings, which had been determined on an assumption shared by all involved in the proceedings that the original planning approval was limited to farm stay guests using the conference centre, precluded Mr Clark from now arguing a position contrary to that assumption. Having examined the full history of the various dealings between Mr Clark and the Shire, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Clark should not be precluded from arguing that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clark and Shire Of Chittering and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASAT 30
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Clark and the Shire of Chittering involved a dispute over the legal restrictions on the number of patrons at a function centre. The matter was heard by the Western Australian State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). The central issue was whether the function centre was subject to a restriction on the number of patrons due to a previous planning approval or due to issue estoppel from a previous tribunal decision.

The tribunal was required to decide if the earlier proceedings, which assumed a limitation on the number of occupants as part of the planning approval, estopped the applicant from arguing against this assumption. Additionally, the tribunal had to determine if the planning approval granted on 13 November 2003 was within the power of the Shire Council and if it legally restricted the number of patrons.

The tribunal reviewed the background of the planning approval granted on 13 November 2003, which was subject to conditions, including a condition limiting the use of the conference centre to guests of the farm stay or visitors arriving by coach bus. The applicant, Mr Clark, argued that this approval did not impose any restriction on the number of patrons for the conference centre. The tribunal assessed whether the previous decision, Clark and Shire of Chittering [2005] WASAT 175, should be given effect in limiting the use permitted under the 2003 approval.

The tribunal found that Mr Clark was not prevented by the 2003 planning consent from accommodating 69 persons and that the previous decision should not limit the use permitted under the 2003 approval. The tribunal allowed the application and set aside the refusal decision, directing the respondent to issue a certificate of approval under section 178(1) of the Health Act 1911, allowing a maximum accommodation of 69 persons.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is allowed and the refusal decision is set aside. 2. The decision of the respondent notified by letter to the applicant dated 17 April 2007 is set aside. 3. The respondent shall issue a certificate of approval under s 178(1) Health Act 1911 providing for a maximum accommodation of 69 persons.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

JUDGE J
Is the function centre subject to a legal restriction on patron numbers by virtue of the decision in Clark and Shire of Chittering [2005] WASAT 175 (by way of issue estoppel), or by the virtue of the planning consent on 13 November 2003 or a combination of both? An immediate question which arises is whether or not this Tribunal is able to consider and rule on the import of the planning consent granted on 13 November 2003 in light of the Tribunal's decision in Clark and Shire of Chittering [2005] WASAT 175 (the Clark decision). Further, is this Tribunal able, as Mr Clark urges upon it, to rule that its earlier decision is invalid, or otherwise disregard it? A copy of the application document which initiated the proceeding culminating in the Clark decision was Annexure MJC8 to Mr Clark's affidavit sworn 10 September 2007. It recited that it was "an application under s 8A(1) of the Town Planning and Development Act 1928 (WA): Refusal of application under town planning scheme" and that the decision sought to be reviewed was made by the Chittering Shire Council on 9 February 2005. The "decision sought" was expressed to be:"That Council comply with the Officer's recommendation in the agenda item 6.2.4 for the Council Meeting of 9th February 2005. 'That Council grant planning approval for a reception centre at Lot 101 Kay Road, Bindoon with no limitations [sic] on the use of the reception centre to farmstay guests only.'" In Mr Clark's "grounds for appeal" reference was made to the statement in the letter from the Chittering Shire dated 15 September (2004) that the function centre was approved on the basis it was for use by guests of the farm stay accommodation only, and that "an application to open to the general public" (obviously a reference to the application for planning consent which followed the 15 September 2004 letter) was rejected. The grounds for appeal referred to a number of planning reasons for which the application has been rejected, and in each case provided a short statement as to Mr Clark's answer to the Council's assertions. The issue for decision by the Tribunal was identified by it at [18] in the Clark decision. The Tribunal said "the issue for decision by the Tribunal, based upon the characterisations, decisions and approach by both parties to date, concerns the exercise of a discretion, whether upon conditions or not, to extend the potential use of the conference centre to cater for some 69 persons; ie, its actual physical capacity". Mr Clark's argument comes down to his assertion that he was not prevented by the planning consent of 13 November 2003 from accommodating 69 persons, with the consequences that his application was redundant and that the Clark decision ought not, by any of a number of devices, be given the effect of limiting the use permitted under the 13 November 2003 approval. In order to assess Mr Clark's contention, it is necessary to review the background to the application which led to the Clark decision. Mr Clark's evidence as to what occurred was not in dispute. He said that, when he received the Shire's letter of 15 September 2004 refusing his certificate of occupancy for 69 persons, he was shocked. He said that he was "certain that the 13 November 2003 approval had not imposed any restriction on the number of patrons for the conference centre." That belief appears to have been induced by the events surrounding the Council's resolution of 13 November 2003. The application for consent had been the subject of a report by a Council officer. That report contained a recommendation that consent be given subject to a number of conditions, including condition 2 which read:"Use of conference centre to be limited to guests of the farm stay or visitors arriving by coach bus".

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: JUDGE J