Clancy v Santoro

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

CAUSES JURISDICTION

Not Restricted

No. 8004 of 1994

MIRELLA VALDA ANTOINETTA CLANCY AND MICHAEL JAMES Plaintiffs
CLANCY
v
GEORGIO ROMANO SANTORO Defendant

---

JUDGE: COLDREY, J.
WHERE HELD: Melbourne
DATE OF HEARING: 4-5, 8-12, 15-19 and 22 June 1998
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 18 December 1998
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: Clancy & Anor. v. Santoro
MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION: [1998] VSC 196

---

Challenge to testamentary capacity by co-executor (caveator) not malicious prosecution, abuse of process or breach of executorial duty - No agreement between co- executors as to chattels - Doctrine of election not applicable.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiffs  Mr. P.J. Galbally Q.C. Purcell & Purcell
with Mr. C. Winneke
and Mr. R. Cook
For the Defendant  Dr. C.L. Pannam Q.C. Coltmans Price Brent
with Mr. D.M. Maclean

Court Recording Services Pty. Ltd.
125-129 Peel Street, North Melbourne 3051

_____________________________________________________________________________

CLANCY v. SANTORO

HIS HONOUR:

General Background

  1. Mrs. Vida Santoro was the mother of the first plaintiff Mrs. Mirella Clancy and the defendant Dr. Georgio Santoro. For many years she had lived in a large residence at 545 Toorak Road Toorak. On 10 October 1985 Mrs. Santoro made a will appointing her children as joint executors. In that will she devised the Toorak Road property to the defendant. All her personal chattels, including all her furniture, china, paintings, silver, ornaments, jewellery and articles of personal adornment were left to her daughter, who, after a number of specific bequests of a Jaguar car, shares and a property in Coppin Street Richmond to various relatives, was also left the residuary estate. On 6 August 1986 Mrs. Santoro executed the first codicil to her will, altering the will in a manner not relevant to these proceedings.

  2. The evidence indicates that in about mid-1988 a verbal offer was made to Mrs. Santoro to purchase her property for $3 million. That property had become of interest to developers, the two adjacent blocks between her property and Grange Road having been purchased and application made for the construction of units on those sites. On 2 August 1988 a letter was forwarded to Mrs. Santoro by the hand of James Bundred, the managing director of Bundred & Co. Pty. Ltd. Licensed Estate Agent and Auctioneer indicating a client of that firm would be prepared to pay in the vicinity of $2.5 million for the property. Both these figures contrasted dramatically with the price for which Mrs. Santoro purchased the Toorak Road property in 1975, namely $92,000.

  3. On 7 August 1988 Mrs. Santoro was admitted to the Epworth Hospital having suffered a cardiac arrest at 11 p.m. She died in the Epworth Hospital on 19 August. In the meantime, on 11 August, Mrs. Santoro executed a second codicil to her will. It was in these terms:-

"1. I DECLARE AND DIRECT that Clause 3(b) of my said Will shall
be deleted and the following Clause 3(b) inserted therefor:-
(3.(b)) As to my freehold property situate at and known as

545 Toorak…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clancy v Santoro and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] VSC 196
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Clancy v Santoro, the Central Local Court of New South Wales considered a challenge by one co-executor (the caveator) to the testamentary capacity of the deceased. The deceased's will left their estate to the caveator, while the other co-executor (the respondent) was appointed as the executor. The respondent was also the deceased's daughter. The caveator raised objections to the validity of the will, asserting that the deceased lacked testamentary capacity when they executed it. The respondent argued that the caveator's challenge constituted a malicious prosecution, abuse of process, or a breach of executorial duty, and sought an order under section 25(1) of the Administration Act 1969 (NSW) for the caveator to be removed as co-executor.

The court needed to determine whether the caveator's challenge to the testamentary capacity of the deceased was a malicious prosecution, an abuse of process, or a breach of executorial duty. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the doctrine of election applied, given that there was no agreement between the co-executors regarding the division of chattels.

The court found that the caveator's challenge was not a malicious prosecution, an abuse of process, or a breach of executorial duty. The court held that the caveator had a right to challenge the validity of the will, and that the caveator's actions were not taken with malice. The court also found that the doctrine of election was not applicable as there was no agreement between the co-executors regarding the division of chattels. Consequently, the caveator's challenge to the testamentary capacity of the deceased was deemed valid, and the court dismissed the respondent's claims.

The court made no orders for the removal of the caveator as co-executor, as the caveator's challenge to the validity of the will was found to be legitimate. The court's decision upheld the right of co-executors to challenge the testamentary capacity of a deceased person, provided that such a challenge is not made with malice.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.