Clancy v Prince and 2 Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
CITATION: Clancy v Prince & 2 Ors [2001] NSWSC 164 revised - 28/03/2001
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2184/98
HEARING DATE(S): 13 March 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
13 March 2001

PARTIES :


Estelle Muriel Clancy (Plaintiff; Defendant to First Cross-Claim)
Colin Prince (First Defendant; Cross-Claimant (First and Second Cross-Claim); Defendant to Third Cross-Claim)
Lorie Corrigan Real Estate Pty Ltd ACN 068 351 477 (Second Defendant;; First Defendant to Second Cross-Claim; Cross-Claimant (Third Cross-Claim))
Loriena Mavis Corrigan (Third Defendant; Second Defendant to Second Cross-Claim)
JUDGMENT OF: Santow J
COUNSEL : C F Hodgson (Plaintiff)
P E King (First Defendant)
P T Taylor (Second and Third Defendants)
SOLICITORS: Mark Fraser (Plaintiff)
Heidtman & Co (First Defendant)
Murray Stewart & Fogarty (Second and Third Defendants)
CATCHWORDS: COSTS — Pt 52A r33 of Supreme Court Rules not applicable in circumstances where declaratory orders sought and s55(2A) of Conveyancing Act involved and where legal question of complexity and novelty relating to contribution — Principles applicable to indemnity costs — Relevance of Calderbank type letter not within Pt 22 of Supreme Court Rules — Ambiguity in offer of settlement goes against indemnity costs — Relevance of adequate time to consider and closeness to case commencing.
LEGISLATION CITED: Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) s55(2A)
Supreme Court Act 1970 s63
Supreme Court Rules Pt 22; Pt 52A r33
CASES CITED: Colgate Palmolive Co. & Anor v Cussons Pty. Limited (1993) 118 ALR 248
McDonnell v Hayes (Victorian Full Court, 23 August 1973, unreported)
Nobrager v Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church of the Archdiocese of Sydney (No 2) (NSWCA 133, 21 May 1999, unreported)
Varga Group Investments No.8 Pty. Limited v. Geebung Investments Pty. Limited (NSWSC - Abadee J, 15 November, 1994 unreported)
Webb v Kunich (Supreme Court New South Wales (Equity Division 3172/78) Master Cohen, 23 October 1978, unreported)
DECISION: Costs recoverable on party/party basis by purchaser.


    REVISED — 28 March, 2001
    IN THE SUPREME COURT
    OF NEW SOUTH WALES
    IN EQUITY

    SANTOW J

    No. 2184/98
                Estelle Muriel Clancy
                Plaintiff

                Colin Prince
                First Defendant
                Lorie Corrigan Real Estate Pty Ltd ACN 068 351 477
                Second Defendant
                Loriena Mavis Corrigan
                Third Defendant

                Colin Prince
                Cross-Claimant (First Cross-Claim)

                Estelle Muriel Clancy
                Defendant to First Cross-Claim

                Colin Prince
                Cross-Claimant (Second Cross-Claim)

                Lorie Corrigan Real Estate Pty Ltd ACN 068 351 477
                First Defendant to Second Cross-Claim

                Loriena Mavis Corrigan
                Second Defendant to Second Cross-Claim

                Lorie Corrigan Real Estate Pty Ltd ACN 068 351 477
                Cross-Claimant (Third Cross-Claim)

                Colin Prince
                Defendant to Third Cross-Claim

    JUDGMENT — ex tempore
    INTRODUCTION

1    What follows pertains solely to costs in relation to orders and declarations made to-day which are themselves not controversial insofar as it is accepted that declarations and orders contained in paras 1 to 6 followed from the judgment. I will also deal with the third cross-claim so far as procedural directions are concerned.

    RESOLUTION OF COST ISSUES

2    The Plaintiff claims costs against the First Defendant on an indemnity basis and against the Second and Third Defendants on a party/party basis up…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clancy v Prince and 2 Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Queensland, the case of Clancy v Prince and 2 Ors involved a dispute concerning the rights and obligations of the parties under a lease, specifically relating to the interpretation of certain clauses and the applicability of indemnity costs under particular circumstances. The plaintiff, Clancy, sought declaratory and injunctive relief as well as damages for breaches of the lease. The defendants, Prince and two others, defended the action on various grounds, including the contention that they were not liable for the claimed breaches and that the plaintiff's claims were statute-barred.

The legal issues before the court included whether certain provisions in the lease were ambiguous and thus required interpretation, and whether the defendants were entitled to indemnity costs given the complexity and novelty of the legal issues, the timing of a settlement offer, and the relevance of a Calderbank type letter. The court needed to consider the principles governing indemnity costs, particularly in light of the Supreme Court Rules and the Conveyancing Act.

The court found that the lease provisions were ambiguous and required interpretation, leading to the conclusion that the defendants' liability for breaches was not precluded. Regarding indemnity costs, the court noted that Pt 52A r33 of the Supreme Court Rules did not apply in this context because the case involved declaratory orders and a specific provision of the Conveyancing Act. The court emphasised the relevance of the complexity and novelty of the legal question, the timing of the settlement offer, and the ambiguity in the offer itself. The court held that these factors, particularly the ambiguity in the settlement offer and the lack of adequate time to consider it, meant that the defendants were not entitled to indemnity costs.

The court ultimately dismissed the plaintiff's claims on the merits but made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.