CITATION: Civic Video Pty Ltd v Garfell Nominees Pty Ltd [2008] NSWDC 3 HEARING DATE(S): 4/2/08 - 5/2/08
JUDGMENT DATE:
5 February 2008JURISDICTION: Civil JUDGMENT OF: Rolfe DCJ DECISION: 1. On the Statement of Claim, Verdict and Judgment for the Defendants.
2. On the Amended Cross-Claim, pursuant to Section 87 (2)(a) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) declare the whole of the agreement pleaded in paragraph 30 (i) of the Statement of Claim void ab initio.
3. Direct the exhibits be returned forthwith to the parties.CATCHWORDS: Determination of Separate Issue - Franchise Agreements - Renewal or Extension - Application of Franchising Code of Conduct - Breach - Illegality - Consequences LEGISLATION CITED: Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules
Trade Practices (Industry Codes - Franchising) Regulations 1998 (Cth)CASES CITED: Ketchell v Master of Education Services Pty Ltd (2007) NSW CA 161
Anderson Ltd v Daniel (1924) 1KB 138PARTIES: Civic Video Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Garfell Nominees Pty Ltd (1st Defendant)
John & Joe Vambaca (2nd Defendants)FILE NUMBER(S): 1231/07 COUNSEL: J K Chippindall (Plaintiff)
D L Williams SC with S W Balafoutis (1st & 2nd Defendants)
JUDGMENT
1 On 27 March 2007 the plaintiff commenced proceedings against Garfell Nominees Pty Ltd as 1st defendant and John and Joe Vumbaca as 2nd defendants, claiming damages up to $750,000 plus interest and costs.
2 The plaintiff was the operator and franchisor of video stores which included the supply of videos, equipment and systems.
3 On 11 January 2001 the plaintiff entered into two franchise agreements with the 1st defendant. One agreement dealt with the video store at Venture Plaza, 19 Howard Avenue DeeWhy and the second agreement dealt with the video store at Corner More and Albert Roads Harbord. The 2nd defendants were parties to each agreement in their capacity as guarantors and indemnifiers of the 1st defendant’s obligations to the plaintiff.
4 Both franchise agreements were for a term of five years commencing on 1 May 2000. They expired on 1 May 2005.
5 On or about 23 February 2005 a meeting took place between representatives of the parties. At the meeting there was discussion about whether the 1st defendant would enter into further franchise agreements in relation to both stores on amended terms. There is a factual dispute about what was said at the meeting and in subsequent telephone conversations. In this respect, however, the plaintiff alleges (para 21 of the Statement of Claim) as follows:
- “21. At the meeting the plaintiff offered and the 1st defendant accepted that the agreements be renewed provided that the plaintiff would agree to variations of them to which the plaintiff agreed.”
6 The plaintiff prepared fresh agreements, but although none of these was signed by the defendants, the plaintiff alleges that the defendants agreed to a “continuation” of the old franchise agreements as amended. Specifically, in paragraph 30 of the Statement of Claim the plaintiff pleads its case as follows:
“30. In the events that have happened…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Civic Video Pty Ltd v Garfell Nominees Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] NSWDC 3
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the conduct of the parties amounted to a lawful renewal or extension of the franchise agreement and whether the original agreement had been terminated. Additionally, the court needed to ascertain if the Franchising Code of Conduct was contravened in the process of renewing the agreement and what consequences, if any, arose from such contravention.
The court held that the renewal of the franchise agreement was not valid as it did not comply with the Franchising Code of Conduct, rendering the purported renewal illegal. Furthermore, the court found that the original agreement was not terminated by the parties' conduct but remained in effect until the date of the purported renewal. Consequently, the court determined that the purported renewal was void ab initio, and the original agreement was not terminated by operation of law.
The orders included a verdict and judgment in favour of Garfell Nominees Pty Ltd on the original claim and an amended cross-claim. The court declared the agreement pleaded in paragraph 30(i) of the Statement of Claim to be void ab initio and directed that the exhibits be returned to the parties.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. On the Statement of Claim, Verdict and Judgment for the Defendants. 2. On the Amended Cross-Claim, pursuant to Section 87 (2)(a) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) declare the whole of the agreement pleaded in paragraph 30 (i) of the Statement of Claim void ab initio. 3. Direct the exhibits be returned forthwith to the parties.