City Plan Services Pty Ltd v Woollahra Council

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: City Plan Services Pty Ltd v Woollahra Council [2004] NSWLEC 73
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
City Plan Services Pty Ltd

RESPOPNDENT
Woollahra Council
.
FILE NUMBER(S): 11210 of 2003
CORAM: Moore C
KEY ISSUES: Construction and Interpretation - Development Consent :-
Modification of consent
Demolition and re-instatement
Substantially the same development
.
LEGISLATION CITED: Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
.
CASES CITED: Vacik Pty Limited v Penrith City Council [1992] NSW LEC (unreported);
Thomas v Pittwater Council [2003] NSWLEC 19;
Moto Projects No 2 Pty Limited v North Sydney Council [1999] 106 LGERA 298;
.
DATES OF HEARING: 1 March 2004
EX TEMPORE
JUDGMENT DATE :
03/02/2004
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT
Mr P McEwen SC
INSTRUCTED BY
Taylor Kelso

RESPONDENT
Mr M Connell, solicitor
Michell Sillar



JUDGMENT:


IN THE LAND AND


ENVIRONMENT COURT


OF NEW SOUTH WALES

11210 of 2003

Moore C

2 March 2004

City Plan Services Pty Ltd

Applicant

v

Woollahra Council

Respondent

1. This is an appeal pursuant to s 96(6) of the Environmental Planning Assessment Act 1979 (the Act) against the refusal, by Woollahra Council (the council), on 29 July 2003 of an application pursuant to s96(2) to modify development consent for 417/2001 for works at 29A Manning Road, Double Bay (the site) which is described in the s 96(2) application as being Lot 1 DP 90176 and Lot 1 DP 302386.

2. The s 96 application describes the proposed modification works as being “to allow for the reconstruction of walls and some footings that have been demolished in their original form which were to be retained by the original development application”.

3. The Statement of Environmental Effects, for the original consent, described the proposed works as being, inter alia:


        • at the ground floor - removal of some internal walls and reconfigure internal layout; and
        • at the first floor the removal of some internal walls and reconfigure the internal layout.
      Finally, the architect’s description of the works in the statement of environmental affects is relevantly described as:
        While maintaining the majority of the external building fabric with imposed to incorporate a contempory foyer space with large windows to the street and a proper roof.

4. The application has two facets, both of which have to be tested against s 96(2)(a) of the Act, for the applicant to succeed. These elements are, in essence, reinstatement of that which has been demolished in excess of the original consent; a rearranged layout for the first floor and an additional bedroom, walk in wardrobe and en-suite bathroom in the roof cavity and extension to the first floor rear dining area. Section 96’s provisions being contain three gates to permit modification, the widest of those gates is being s 96(2) – which is that sought to be availed of in the present application. It reads, relevantly:


      2. A consent authority may on application be made by the applicant or any other person entitled to act on a consent grant by…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read City Plan Services Pty Ltd v Woollahra Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWLEC 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

City Plan Services Pty Ltd sought an appeal against the Woollahra Council's refusal to modify development consent for works at 29A Manning Road, Double Bay. The proposed modifications included the reconstruction of walls and footings that had been demolished and a rearranged layout for the first floor, with an additional bedroom, walk-in wardrobe, and en-suite bathroom in the roof cavity and an extension to the first floor rear dining area. The central legal issue was whether the proposed modifications amounted to a substantially similar development to that which had been consented to in December 2001, as required under section 96(2)(a) of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979.

The court held that the key to determining whether the proposed modifications were substantially the same development as the original consent lay in both qualitative and quantitative assessments. The court considered that the original consent permitted the retention of a significant portion of the building's structure, while the proposed modifications involved extensive demolition and reconstruction of almost the entire building. According to the evidence, only a small fraction of the originally approved structure remained intact, and the proposed reconstruction required the re-creation of the building rather than its refurbishment. The court concluded that the modifications were not substantially the same development as the original consent because the scale and nature of the demolition and reconstruction were significantly different.

The court dismissed the appeal and upheld the council's decision to refuse the modification of development consent. The extensive demolition and reconstruction proposed by the applicant did not meet the requirement of being substantially the same development as that for which consent was originally granted. Therefore, the applicant's application to modify the development consent was denied, and the orders were made accordingly.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.