City Plan Services Ltd v Sydney City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
City Plan Services Ltd v Sydney City Council [1999] NSWLEC 186
          PARTIES
APPLICANT
City Plan Services Ltd
RESPONDENT
Sydney City Council
          NUMBER:
10860 of 1998
          CORAM:
Sheahan J
          KEY ISSUES:
Section 56A Appeal :- duty to act rationally and reasonably - whether a test for the exercise of discretion needs to be identified - duty to give reasons - whether binding on Commissioners of this Court
          LEGISLATION CITED:
Land and Environment Court Act 1979
Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979
          DATES OF HEARING:
07/22/1999
          DATE OF JUDGMENT DELIVERY:

08/11/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT
Mr J B Maston (Barrister)
SOLICITORS
Taylor Kelso

RESPONDENT
Mr W R Davison SC
SOLICITORS
Dunhill Madden Butler


    JUDGMENT:

IN THE LAND AND Matter No: 10860 of 1998


ENVIRONMENT COURT Coram: Sheahan J


OF NEW SOUTH WALES 11 August 1999

CITY PLAN SERVICES LTD

Applicant

v

SYDNEY CITY COUNCIL

Respondent

Introduction

1. This is an appeal pursuant to s 56A of the Land and Environment Court Act 1979 (“ the Court Act ”) against a decision of Senior Commissioner Jensen on 1 April 1999.

2. City Plan Services Pty Ltd had sought, in accordance with s 96 of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (“ the EP&A Act ”), to modify a condition imposed on a consent for a redevelopment of what was formerly the Sydney Eye Hospital at 50-72 Sir John Young Crescent, Woolloomooloo.

3. The condition was said to have “ the effect of requiring the applicant to reconstruct the footpath, kerbing and guttering ” adjoining the subject site to “ a greater or lesser extent ”. The extent of the work required was to depend upon the findings of a study undertaken by the applicant.

4. This application was deemed to be refused, pursuant to s 82 of the EP&A Act, and the applicant appealed against this refusal.

5. Senior Commissioner Jensen allowed the appeal, and replaced the relevant condition with one which apportioned the responsibility for the paving work, effectively making the applicant responsible only for providing 30 per cent of the paving in the immediate vicinity of the total development of the applicant.

6. The role of the Court with respect to this appeal is not to re-consider the merits of the Senior Commissioner’s decision. Rather, the Court must determine whether the learned Senior Commissioner has fallen into an error of law .

The Grounds of Appeal

7. The grounds of this appeal by the Council, are as follows:

1. The Senior Commissioner erred in law in having found that the subject proceedings were to be distinguished from Progress & Securities v North Sydney Council and identified no test for the exercise of his discretion in place of Progress Securities .

2. The Senior Commissioner erred in law in imposing condition 31 shall be replaced by the following:


        ‘ Condition 31

(a) The Applicant shall carry out a dilapidation survey of the public footway adjoining the site and submit it to the Council…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read City Plan Services Ltd v Sydney City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 186
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Land and Environment Court of New South Wales was called upon to consider an appeal by Sydney City Council against a decision of Senior Commissioner Jensen, who had modified a condition of a development consent granted to City Plan Services Ltd for the redevelopment of the Sydney Eye Hospital site. The primary issue was whether the Senior Commissioner exercised his discretion in an accountable manner and whether he satisfied his judicial duty to provide reasons for his decision.

The Sydney City Council argued that the Senior Commissioner failed to identify any test for the exercise of his discretion and did not provide sufficient reasons for his decision, both of which they claimed constituted errors of law. The applicant, City Plan Services Ltd, countered that the Senior Commissioner appropriately distinguished the case from Progress and Securities Pty Ltd v North Sydney Municipal Council and applied a reasonable test in exercising his discretion. They also argued that the Senior Commissioner provided sufficient reasons for his decision.

The Court found that the Senior Commissioner was correct in distinguishing the case from Progress and Securities Pty Ltd v North Sydney Municipal Council based on factual differences. The Court also concluded that the Senior Commissioner did not commit an error of law by failing to explicitly state a test for the exercise of his discretion, as he implicitly applied a test of reasonableness. Additionally, the Court held that the Senior Commissioner provided adequate reasons for his decision, noting that the reasons should be sufficient to demonstrate the lawfulness of the decision and should not be scrutinized too narrowly given the nature of the tribunal.

In conclusion, the Court found no error of law in the Senior Commissioner’s decision and dismissed the appeal with costs. The Court emphasized that the Senior Commissioner acted judicially, rationally, and reasonably in exercising his discretion and provided adequate reasons for his decision.