City of Mitcham v Ansaar

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

CITY OF MITCHAM v ANSAAR & ANOR

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Debelle

17 March 2006

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING - ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING - DEVELOPMENT CONTROL - CONTROL OF PARTICULAR MATTERS - SUBDIVISION - PRINCIPLES GOVERNING CONSENT OR APPROVAL

Application to divide land for residential purposes - land located in Adelaide foothills - intent of Development Plan - extensive excavation required - relevance of like forms of division of land - whether subdivision similar to past subdivisions encouraged by Development Plan - held, grant of development consent set aside - appeal allowed.

Environment Resources and Development Court Act 1993 s 30; City of Mitcham Development Plan 2003 Council Wide Principles 24, 44, 45, 46, 144, 145, 146, referred to.
City of Mitcham v Freckmann (1999) 74 SASR 56, applied.
City of Mitcham v Pearce [1999] SASC 518, considered.

CITY OF MITCHAM v ANSAAR & ANOR
[2006] SASC 78

Land and Valuation Division

  1. DEBELLE J.        This is an appeal from the decision of a Commissioner of the Environment Resources and Development Court (“the Environment Court”).  The appeal is to a single judge of this Court pursuant to s 30(1)(b) of the Environment Resources and Development Court Act 1993.

  2. The respondents own a parcel of land within the area of the City of Mitcham (“the Council”).  They applied to the Council for provisional development plan consent to divide an allotment of land into four allotments to be used for residential purposes.  The division of the land also included a small road, effectively a cul-de-sac, to provide access to the new allotments.  The respondents later amended their plan to reduce the number of allotments to three.

  3. The Council refused the application.  The appellants appealed to the Environment Court.  The appeal was heard by a Commissioner who allowed the appeal subject to 37 conditions.  The Council has appealed to this Court against the decision of the Commissioner.

    The Relevant Development Plan

  4. The respondents lodged their application to divide the land on 16 May 2003.  The relevant Development Plan was dated 20 September 2001.  An amended version of that plan was gazetted on 12 November 2002 but it was not published as a consolidated version until 5 June 2003.  The provisions relevant to the determination of the issues in this appeal are identical in each the 2001 and the 2003 plan, save for the numbering of the Objectives and Principles of Development Control.  The parties and the Commissioner therefore referred to the terms of the later plan.  There is no need for this Court to do otherwise.

    The Subject Land and Locality

  5. The Commissioner’s examination of the subject land and locality was not in dispute and this summary is taken from it.

  6. The subject land is within the Residential (Foothills) Zone.  As its name suggests, that zone stretches across parts of the foothills of the Mount Lofty Ranges.  The subject land is in the foothills which are south of Clapham and Torrens Park.  The land…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read City of Mitcham v Ansaar and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 78
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of City of Mitcham v Ansaar, the applicant sought approval for a subdivision of land located in the foothills of Adelaide. The proposed development involved the creation of three residential lots, necessitating extensive excavation to form a cul-de-sac and provide access to the individual allotments. The steep topography of the land required significant earthworks, which raised concerns about the visual impact, environmental consequences, and compliance with the Development Plan's objectives and principles.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the proposed subdivision was suitable for its intended use, given the required earthworks and topographical constraints, and whether the necessary cut and fill operations conflicted with the objectives and principles set forth in the Development Plan for the Residential (Foothills) Zone. The court was tasked with balancing the applicant's right to develop the land against the need to preserve the character and environmental integrity of the area.

The court found that the proposed subdivision would result in substantial earthworks, including a vertical cut of up to 4.6 metres and the construction of retaining walls exceeding 1.5 metres, which exceeded the limits set by the Development Plan. The excavation would also involve the removal of remnant native vegetation, which was not in keeping with the objective of minimising visual and environmental impact. The court held that the proposed development did not align with the desired character of the zone and would result in a significant alteration of the natural ground levels, contrary to the principles intended to regulate earthworks in residential developments. Consequently, the court set aside the grant of development consent and allowed the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J
The subject land rises steeply from Belair Road. The maximum grade of the pavement of the proposed cul‑de‑sac is 18 per cent. It levels out at the head of the cul‑de‑sac and provides access to the three allotments. It is necessary to make extensive excavation to form the cul‑de‑sac and to provide access to each allotment. The vertical cut adjacent to the boundaries of Lots 1 and 2 varies up to a maximum of 4.6 metres. The cuttings will lean back from the road and be supported by a crib wall 1.5 metres high with stone above it. It is likely that extensive excavation will also be required to accommodate a dwelling on each allotment.The Council’s Decision The Council had refused development consent on three grounds, namely·As a result of the visual impact from earthworks and associated retaining walls and the removal of remnant native vegetation, the proposed development is not in keeping with Objective 1 of the Residential (Foothills) Zone.·The proposal is at odds with the Desired Character Statement for the Residential (Foothills) Zone and therefore at odds with Principle of Development Control 1 of the zone.·Retaining walls required for the earthworks associated with the construction of the public access road will exceed 1.5 metres. The proposed development is therefore not in accordance with Council Wide Principle of Development Control 24.The Issues in the Environment Court The Commissioner identified two central issues in the appeal as being:·The extent to which the proposed division will be suitable for its intended use for three dwellings having regard to the earthworks necessary to access each allotment and the topographical constraints on the siting and design of future dwellings.·The extent to which the cut and fill necessary to form the road (taking into account the plan in Exhibit A2) conflicts with the Objectives and Principles for the Residential (Foothills) Zone and the Statement of Desired Future Character and those Council Wide Principles intended to regulate earthworks generally in respect of residential development and land division specifically.The Development Plan There is one Objective only for the Residential (Foothills) Zone. It is in these terms:Objective 1: Development comprising detached dwellings at low densities where the site area, design, siting and appearance of development takes account of the particular topography of the area such that any development has minimal visual and environmental impact.That Objective is followed by a statement of the Desired Character of the Zone, to recite its terms:Residential (Foothills) Zone comprises [sic] the southern portions of the suburbs of Pasadena, Panorama and Torrens Park and portions of Lynton, Bedford Park and Mitcham …This zone is characterized by two main distinguishing features. The first relates to the topography of the area which ranges from gently undulating to very steep. The elevation of the area gently increases as the Adelaide plains merge with the foothills of the Mount Lofty Ranges. The second relates to the age of the housing stock; constructed primarily since the 1960’s and 1970’s; its condition is generally very good.As a result the area has a relatively modern character with some very large homes built on generous allotments usually in excess of 600 square metres. Considerably larger allotments occur in the steeper portions of the area. Many houses are two-storey or split‑level in design. Commanding views are available from the most elevated sections of the area, and consequently those areas are also quite visible from many viewing points on the flatter Adelaide plains and elsewhere.The character of the zone should substantially remain the same, and new dwellings of similar density should continue to be developed in the area. Where appropriate new sites may be created for dwellings. However, considerable attention should be given to the impact of any subsequent development on the privacy and amenity of existing properties, and the appearance of the development if it is in a highly visible and prominent location. New development should also preserve and reinforce the environmental qualities of the area by avoiding interference with natural drainage lines and creeks, remnant vegetation, and minimising alteration to the natural ground levels.Due to the age and condition of housing in the area and the steep topography in some parts, the zone is generally not suited to any higher density form of residential development than that already prevailing. Opportunities for dwellings with smaller site areas, which would add to the range of housing choices in the policy area, may be appropriate on relatively flat sites where environmental and amenity impacts are likely to be negligible.Of particular relevance is the fourth paragraph of this statement. I will return to it.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J