City of Melbourne v Barnett

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL Not Restricted
No. 6534 of 1998
CITY OF MELBOURNE Appellant/Defendant
v
DOROTHY MAY BARNETT Respondent/Plaintiff

---

JUDGES: BROOKING, CHARLES and CHERNOV, JJ.A.
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 20 October 1999
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 21 October 1999
MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION: [1999] VSCA 171

---

Torts – Negligence – Highway authorities – Misfeasance – Nonfeasance – In respect of what matters – Injury to user of footpath – Whether repair by defendant authority of hole in pavement constituting misfeasance – Whether evidence of repair.

Judge's conduct of trial – Judge's comments concerning witnesses.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant  Mr. B.D. Bongiorno, Q.C. Ligeti Partners
Mr. C.M. O'Neill
For the Respondent  Mr. T.J. Casey, Q.C. Holding Redlich
Mr. J.F. Carmody

BROOKING, J.A.:
CHARLES, J.A.:
CHERNOV, J.A.:

  1. There are poker machines at the Welcome Stranger Hotel at 128 Bourke Street, Melbourne. On 27 June 1996, Mrs. Dorothy Barnett travelled by bus from her home at Garden City in order to spend the evening playing them. At about 7 p.m. the bus in which she was travelling pulled up in front of the Welcome Stranger. There is a footpath between the building line of the hotel in Bourke Street and the roadway, and the kerb of the footpath is made of bluestone. As Mrs. Barnett put her left foot to the ground, her shoe went into a hole some 2 inches deep in the bluestone kerbing (she said in evidence her foot "fitted into it") and she fell forward onto her hands, twisting her ankle as she fell. Mrs. Barnett had not seen the hole before she stepped into it. Photographs of the bluestone kerb and the hole show that a jagged piece of bluestone roughly fitting a human foot in size, had broken away from the bluestone kerbing.

  2. Unfortunately Mrs. Barnett broke her left ankle and suffered other injuries in this fall. She then sued the City of Melbourne in negligence as being the authority in which was vested care and control of the footpath and as an occupier pursuant to Part IIA of the Wrongs Act 1958. In particular she alleged that the City had constructed or maintained the footpath in such a way that the pavement had a hole in it, failed to give adequate warning of the presence of the hole, and failed to repair the footpath. The action came on for hearing in the County Court at Melbourne before a judge alone on 2 June 1998. The plaintiff's counsel argued that the defendant had been negligent in failing to repair or properly repair the hole. For its part, the defendant argued that it had no obligation to repair the hole as the hole came into existence in consequence of non-feasance rather than misfeasance, and accordingly submitted that it was not liable to the plaintiff. After hearing evidence on 2, 3, 4 and 5 June 1998, the judge on 3 July 1998 gave judgment for the plaintiff. His Honour awarded the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read City of Melbourne v Barnett and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] VSCA 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of City of Melbourne versus Barnett dealt with a claim of negligence against a local government authority for an injury sustained by the plaintiff while using a footpath. The plaintiff alleged that the local council was negligent in failing to repair a hole in the pavement, which caused her to trip and injure herself. The dispute came before the court to determine whether the council's failure to repair the hole constituted misfeasance or nonfeasance, and whether there was evidence of any repair work being carried out.

The court had to decide if the local council's failure to repair the hole in the pavement amounted to misfeasance or nonfeasance. The distinction between misfeasance and nonfeasance is crucial in negligence cases involving public authorities, as it determines the standard of care owed by the authority to the public. Additionally, the court had to assess whether there was any evidence presented that the council had repaired the hole in question, which would have implications for the council's liability.

In delivering the judgment, the court found that the local council's failure to repair the hole in the pavement did not constitute misfeasance, as there was no evidence of any repair work being carried out. The court held that the council's duty was to maintain the footpath in a reasonably safe condition, but the absence of evidence of repair did not automatically render their failure to repair a negligent act. The court emphasised that the plaintiff had not provided sufficient evidence to establish that the council had knowledge of the hole and failed to act upon it. Consequently, the court dismissed the plaintiff's claim.

As a result of the court's findings, the plaintiff's claim against the local council was dismissed, and no orders were made in favour of the plaintiff. The court's decision underscored the importance of evidence in establishing a public authority's liability for injuries sustained by members of the public due to defects in public infrastructure.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established