City of Armadale v Chapman

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   CITY OF ARMADALE -v- CHAPMAN [2012] WASC 423

CORAM:   EM HEENAN J

HEARD:   20 JUNE 2012

DELIVERED          :   14 NOVEMBER 2012

FILE NO/S:   GDA 16 of 2011

MATTER                :The State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA)

and

Case Number DR 38/11 in the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia at Perth

BETWEEN:   CITY OF ARMADALE

Appellant

AND

DONNA ROSETTA JOY CHAPMAN
ALLAN THOMAS CHAPMAN
Respondents

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :MR P McNABB  (ORDINARY MEMBER)

File No  :DR 38 of 2011

Catchwords:

Local Government - Town Planning Scheme - Regulation of commercial vehicle parking in certain areas - Direction by municipality to comply with rules - Review by SAT - Appeal from SAT - Severance

Legislation:

Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA)

Result:

Appeal allowed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr L E James

Respondents                 :     In person

Solicitors:

Appellant:     Kott Gunning

Respondents                 :     In person

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Chapman and City of Armadale [2011] WASAT 205

Glew v Shire of Greenough [2006] WASCA 260

Glew v White [2012] WASC 100

Glew v White [2012] WASCA 138

Godenzie and City of Geraldton‑Greenough [2010] WASAT 107

Hedley v Spivey [2012] WASCA 116

Krysiak v McDonagh [2012] WASC 270

Pennicuik v City of Gosnells [2011] WASC 63

Yallingup Residents' Association Inc v State Administrative Tribunal & Ors [2006] WASC 162

  1. EM HEENAN J: This is an appeal from a decision of the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) made on 2 September 2011. The appellant relies on s 105 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). This confers a right to appeal to a single judge of this court from a decision of the SAT constituted by a member or members who do not include a judicial member but only on a question of law and only by leave of this court. Leave to appeal in the present instance was granted by the order of Hall J on 22 December 2011, which included further orders and directions for programming and conducting the appeal.

  2. The decision of SAT was announced orally by the learned member on 2 September 2011.  The transcript of the reasons for decision is included in the papers before the court and an edited set of reasons has also been prepared formally by the SAT and these are also before the court:  Chapman and City of Armadale [2011] WASAT 205. It is necessary to describe the proceedings which led to that decision and the decision itself briefly.

  3. Mr and Mrs Chapman are the owners of land which is zoned as rural living located within the municipality of the City of Armadale and they reside on that land.  This and other land is subject to the City of Armadale Town Planning Scheme No 4, which is a duly authorised town planning scheme having the force of law under the provisions of the Planning…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read City of Armadale v Chapman and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] WASC 423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of City of Armadale v Chapman involved a dispute regarding the regulation of commercial vehicle parking under the Town Planning Scheme. The City of Armadale issued a direction to the respondents, Chapman, to comply with certain rules regarding the parking of commercial vehicles on their property. The respondents challenged this direction through a review by the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT), and subsequently appealed the SAT's decision.

The key legal issues the court had to decide revolved around the definition and regulation of 'commercial vehicles' under the Town Planning Scheme. The appellant argued that the purpose for which the owners or ratepayers use the vehicles was not determinative of whether they are 'commercial vehicles', and that the nature and design of the vehicle itself should be considered. The appellant contended that a truck which qualifies as a commercial vehicle, even if parked on a property and never used or licensed, would still be a commercial vehicle requiring permission under the Scheme.

The court examined the submissions made in the SAT and the relevant case law, particularly the case of Godenzie and City of Geraldton-Greenough. The court found that the Godenzie case was distinguishable as it involved conditional development approval for the use of the subject land, whereas in the present case, no such approval existed. The court concluded that the decision in Godenzie did not support the proposition that commercial vehicles, if parked on premises for private use, are outside the scope of the Scheme. The court accepted the appellant's submission that the parking of commercial vehicles on land subject to the Scheme, even if not involved in commercial activity, are still subject to the Scheme.

The court's reasoning and outcome favoured the appellant, affirming the direction issued by the City of Armadale to the respondents. The court determined that the nature and design of the vehicle, rather than its intended use, was the primary factor in determining whether it was a 'commercial vehicle' under the Scheme. As a result, the respondents were required to comply with the rules regarding the parking of commercial vehicles on their property. The final orders of the court upheld the direction issued by the City of Armadale and rejected the respondents' appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between the City of Armadale (the appellant) and Mr and Mrs Chapman (the respondents) over the parking of a truck on the respondents' property. The City of Armadale issued a direction to the respondents to comply with the rules of the Town Planning Scheme which regulate the parking of commercial vehicles in certain areas. The respondents challenged the direction, leading to a review by the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT). The City of Armadale subsequently appealed the SAT's decision to the court. The respondents had purchased an Isuzu dual cab 3.2 cal Truck, which they registered as a commercial vehicle, but intended to use it solely for domestic and recreational purposes. This truck was never used as a means to generate income. The respondents' property had also been the subject of a previous complaint due to a semi-trailer being parked on the property while the owner was in hospital recovering from a stroke.

The case originated from a direction issued by the City of Armadale to the respondents to comply with the Town Planning Scheme's rules regarding the parking of commercial vehicles. The respondents challenged this direction in the SAT, which found in their favour. The City of Armadale then appealed the SAT's decision to the court. The appeal was heard and determined by the court, which examined the relevant provisions of the Town Planning Scheme and the SAT's decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the mere parking of a commercial vehicle on land subject to a Town Planning Scheme, but not actually involved in commercial activity, is subject to the Scheme.
2. Whether the purpose for which the owners or ratepayers use the vehicles or intend to use them when parked on the land is a determinative factor in characterising the vehicle as a 'commercial vehicle' under the Scheme.
3. Whether the decision in Godenzie and City of Geraldton-Greenough [2010] WASAT 107 is authority for any proposition that commercial vehicles, if parked on premises for private use, are outside the scope of the Scheme.

Held
1. The mere parking of a commercial vehicle on land subject to a Town Planning Scheme, but not actually involved in commercial activity, is subject to the Scheme.
2. The purpose for which the owners or ratepayers use the vehicles or intend to use them when parked on the land is not a determinative factor in characterising the vehicle as a 'commercial vehicle' under the Scheme.
3. The decision in Godenzie and City of Geraldton-Greenough [2010] WASAT 107 is not authority for any proposition that commercial vehicles, if parked on premises for private use, are outside the scope of the Scheme.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appellant refers to passages in the respondents' submissions filed in the SAT on 28 April 2011, which include the paragraph:As AR previously mentioned, our secured Isuzu dual cab 3.2 cal Truck for registration purposes only is a 'commercial' vehicle. Due to its configuration, owners of this type of vehicle have no other option than to register them as a commercial vehicle ‑ regardless of the intended use. However, LFE purchased this vehicle solely for domestic and recreational purposes. The Isuzu had never been used as a means to generate income. Therefore AR strongly disagree with the respondent's view that it is a 'commercial' vehicle in that sense. This vehicle was also not the vehicle which was the subject of the original complaint, it was a semi-trailer that was parked on our property whilst the owner was in hospital recovering from a stroke … The appellant also submits that the Isuzu truck is registered or licensed under the Road Traffic Act as a commercial vehicle but submits that even if this were not so, it is a vehicle designed or intended to be used in the course of trade or commerce and so comes within the definition of 'commercial vehicle' in the Scheme. The nub of the appellant's contention is that the purpose for which the owners or ratepayers use the vehicles or intend to use them when parked on the land is not a determinative factor. Even if the vehicles or any one of them was to be used for 'private' purposes, that would not, in the appellant's submission, alter the objective characterisation of the vehicle as a 'commercial vehicle' deriving from its licensed status or the character or status it would have if it were licensed, and the nature and design of the vehicle itself. So, a truck which qualifies as a commercial vehicle, if parked or left on such a property and never used or even licensed, would still be a commercial vehicle requiring permission under the Scheme because of its objective design, general common use and character. The appellant submits that the case of Godenzie and City of Geraldton‑Greenough [2010] WASAT 107 is distinguishable from the situation presently under examination and does not support any proposition that the parking of commercial vehicles used only for domestic purposes is outside the scope of planning control under the Scheme as it applies in a rural living zone. The fundamental distinction between the Godenzie case and the present is that in the former, conditional development approval for the use of the subject land was granted by the local municipality for the parking of five commercial vehicles. In the submission of the appellant, the Godenzie case involved consideration of whether or not the use of those vehicles on the land complied with the conditions which had been imposed by the municipality in its development approval. The decision was that it did not. In the present case, no current approval of any kind existed for the use by the respondents of their land for the parking of these vehicles. Accordingly, I accept the submission of the appellant that the decision in Godenzie is not authority for any proposition that commercial vehicles, if parked on premises for private use, are outside the scope of the Scheme. Indeed, in Godenzie there was no doubt that the vehicles parked on the subject land were commercial vehicles and were being used for commercial purposes. The real question in Godenzie was whether or not loading and unloading of the trucks or trailers, which were the commercial vehicles being parked on the depot on that land, constituted an activity outside the scope of the conditional approval granted for the parking of the vehicles on the land. It was held that it did. Nothing in that case deals with the question of whether or not the mere parking of commercial vehicles on land subject to such a scheme, but not actually involved in commercial activity, are subject to the Scheme.