Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1001

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - discovery - whether inclusion of a document as an annexure to an affidavit is in itself proper discovery of the document – whether discovery is necessary when documents are already in the hands of the other party – whether various documents satisfy the criteria required by O15 r 2(3) Federal Court Rules - meaning of possession, custody or power - whether documents in the possession, custody or control of a company in administration under Pt 5.3A Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) – meaning of ‘general discovery’ under O 15 Federal Court Rules - whether an order for general discovery under O 15 includes documents discoverable pursuant to the ‘train of inquiry’ test.

Held: Simply annexing a document to an affidavit is not in itself ‘discovery’ of that document within O 15. A supplementary list of documents should be filed and served in circumstances where a significant quantity of material is produced annexed to affidavits in the days leading to trial which had not previously been discovered. The relationship of administrator and company as contemplated by Pt 5.3A Corporations Act does not permit the company other than with the consent of the administrator to have “power” over documents retained by the administrator. The consent order for discovery made on 15 February 2006 was an unqualified order for general discovery, as contemplated by O 15 r 5, and requiring discovery of documents as contemplated by O 15 r 2, in particular subrule 2(3). The ‘train of inquiry’ test is not applicable to such order.

Federal Court Rules O15 rr 2(3), 2(4), 2(5), 3, 5, 6, 8
Part 5.3A Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Advanced Medical Institute Pty Ltd (2005) FCA 366 applied
Australian Independent Newspapers Ltd v John Fairfax Holdings Ltd (Federal Court of Australia, 22 June 1994) cited
Australasian Memory Pty Ltd v Brien (2000) 172 ALR 28 cited
Aveling v UBS Australia Capital Markets Holdings Ltd [2005] FCA 415 applied
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v ANZ Banking Group Ltd (1979) 143 CLR 499 cited
Hore-Lacy v David Syme and Co unreported Supreme Court of Victoria, 5 September 1996 cited
Horsley v Phillips Fine Art Auctioneers Pty Ltd (1995) 7 BPR [97557] cited
KC v Shiley Inc [1997] 796 FCA (14 August 1997) cited

Kennedy v Dodson (1895) 1 Ch 334 cited

Lonrho Limited v Shell Petroleum (1980) 1 WLR 627 applied
Lubizol Corp Inc v Imperial Chemical Industries plc [2000] FCA 1464 applied
Mulley v Manifold (1959) 103 CLR 341 cited
Netaf Pty Ltd v Bikane Pty Ltd (1990) 92 ALR 490 applied
Reading Entertainment Australia Pty Ltd v Birch Carroll & Coyle Ltd [2002] FCAFC 109 cited
Re McGorm; ex parte Co-operative Building Society of SA (1989) 86 ALR 275 cited
Spyer v Cuddles ‘N’ Mum (Franchise) Pty Ltd (No 3) (2002) FCA 1563 considered
South Sydney District Rugby League Football Club Ltd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd v Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] FCA 1001
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Citrus Queensland Pty Ltd, along with two other applicants, brought a motion against Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd and two other respondents, seeking discovery of certain documents relevant to their case. The applicants argued that these documents, which included various business records and communications, were necessary to prove the reasonableness of predictions made by the respondents regarding the performance of certain orchards. The respondents, on the other hand, claimed that the requested documents were not in their possession, custody, or power, or were privileged and therefore not discoverable.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondents were obligated to disclose the specific documents sought by the applicants. This involved a consideration of the relevance and discoverability of the documents under the Federal Court Rules, particularly in relation to the criteria set out in Order 15. The applicants contended that the documents were discoverable as they were relevant to the proof of the reasonableness of the predictions made by the respondents, and that the respondents had already provided similar documents to other parties in the litigation.

The court found that some of the documents sought by the applicants were indeed discoverable under Order 15. Specifically, the court determined that the Hancock Board paper evidencing the decision to sell the orchards, along with all material upon which that decision was made, fell within the criteria of O 15 rule 2(3) and were discoverable. The court also noted that while the respondents had endeavoured to provide certain documents, some parts of these documents were illegible, and thus, an order for discovery was not necessary at that stage. Conversely, the court ruled that no order for discovery should be made regarding other documents, such as the communication between Breed and Strahley in relation to bin numbers, and historical data, as the respondents had already discovered these documents.

The court made several orders to facilitate the discovery process. It directed the respondents to file an affidavit confirming whether certain documents were in their possession and to provide a supplementary list of documents in compliance with Order 15 Rule 6. The court also ordered the applicants to do the same regarding documents in their possession. Furthermore, the court set deadlines for filing these affidavits and lists of documents, and for providing inspection of the documents. The court reserved the issue of costs and set a deadline for the service of the notices of motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

As to the First Notice of Motion the Court orders that:

1. The first and second respondents file an affidavit stating whether any of following documents or classes of documents referred to in the schedule to this application is or has been in their possession, custody or power and, if it has been but is no longer in their possession, custody or power when they parted with it, such affidavit to be filed and served within 7 days of the date of this order:

· Agreement for Purchase of Assets dated 24 January 2001

· Budgets

· Budget Summaries

· Hancock Board paper evidencing the consideration of various options in relation to the orchards and the view that the orchards were not performing in accordance with their return criteria

· Hancock Board minute evidencing the decision to sell the orchards referred to by Strahley

· The actual pack out rates for 2004 and the notional budgeted packout rates for the financial year 30 June 2005 referred to by Strahley.

2. The first and second respondents file and serve a Supplementary List of Documents in Form 22 and otherwise in compliance with Order 15 Rule 6 of the Federal Court Rules within 14 days of the date of this order discovering any document annexed to the affidavits of the respondents’ witnesses filed in this action which are not already listed in the first and second respondents’ List of Documents filed 29 March 2006 and the documents referred to in the affidavit required to be discovered by paragraph 1 of this order.

3. Inspection of those documents in the supplementary list of documents is to be provided within 21 days of the date of this order.

4. The time for service of the notice of motion be abridged until a time no later than 4.00 pm, 20 July 2006.

5. Costs be reserved.

As to the Second Notice of Motion the Court orders that:

1. The applicants file an affidavit stating whether any of following documents or classes of documents referred to in the schedule provided in support of this application is or has been in their possession, custody or power and, if it has been but is no longer in their possession, custody or power when they parted with it, such affidavit to be filed and served within 7 days of the date of this order:

· Item 1 Confidentiality Agreement between the First Respondent and the Second Applicant

· Items 19, 20 and 22 Spray Records

· Item 14 The second applicant’s 100 day plan

· Item 13 Westpac and ANZ documents and correspondence

· Item 15 Copies of all cash flow

· Item 16 Creditors invoices for first applicant

· Item 18 Email from David Breed to the second applicant

· Item 21 Management reports for the Orchards and Packing shed

· Item 25 Third applicant’s orchard management plans

· Items 26, 27 and 28 Cash flows, correspondence and emails

2. The applicants file and serve a Supplementary List of Documents in Form 22 and otherwise in compliance with Order 15 Rule 6 of the Federal Court Rules within 14 days of the date of this order discovering any document referred to in the affidavit required to be discovered by par 1 of this order.

3. Inspection of those documents in the supplementary list of documents is to be provided within 21 days of the date of this order.

4. Once the respondents allow the applicants to have access to the computer in the packing shed for the purpose of accessing the SmartPak, TotalPak and packout records the applicants are to, within 7 days of the date of access being provided, file and serve a Supplementary List of Documents in Form 22 and otherwise in compliance with O 15 r 6 of the Federal Court Rules discovering the SmartPak, TotalPak and packout records referred to in items 2, 17 and 30 of the Schedule provided in support of this notice of motion. Inspection of such documents is to be provided within 14 days of the date of access being provided.

5. The time for service of the notice of motion be abridged until a time no later than 4.00 pm, 20 July 2006.

6. Costs be reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, the applicants are seeking discovery of specific documents from the respondents related to the sale of orchards and other business operations. The applicants claim that certain documents are relevant to proving the reasonableness of the respondents' predictions about the orchards' performance. The respondents initially denied the relevance of some documents, but later provided certain documents, albeit with some parts being illegible. The applicants also claimed that other specific documents were not provided despite their requests. The applicants further sought access to computer records in the packing shed to access specific business data.

The matter before the court involves two notices of motion filed by the applicants seeking discovery of documents from the respondents. The first notice of motion requests various documents related to the decision-making process about the orchards and their performance. The second notice of motion requests additional documents related to business operations and financial records. The court has reviewed the submissions from both parties and considered the relevance and admissibility of the documents in question. The court has ordered the respondents to file affidavits and supplementary lists of documents, and has also ordered the applicants to file similar documents and lists. The court has reserved costs and set deadlines for the filing and inspection of the documents.

Decision

Reasons for decision

COLLIER J
In my view no order for discovery should be made.Hancock Board paper and Board minute evidencing decision to sell the orchards (pars 48 and 69(b) Strahley affidavit) Paragraph 48 in the affidavit of Mr Strahley is as follows:‘On or about May 2004, Hancock decided to consider various options as to the future of the Property. By this stage, the Board of Hancock had reached the view that the Property was not performing in accordance with its return criteria.’ In par 69(b) Mr Strahley deposes:‘During the course of the meeting, Mr Tracy asked me why Sunstate Orchards was selling the property. I said to him that the Board had made a decision to sell the Property based on past performance and it was no longer within the desired portfolio for Hancock as the company was moving away from citrus…’ In the table of responses, the respondents initially stated that the document was not relevant, but subsequently provided a copy of a document titled ‘Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd Position Report April/May 2004’. The respondents also stated that they had no further such documents in their possession, custody or power. The applicants submit that the document titled ‘Sunstate Orchards Pty Ltd Position Report April/May 2004’ is a report to the Board, not a Board paper. The applicants in the table of responses claimed that the Hancock Board paper evidencing the decision to sell the orchards, together with all material upon which that decision was made, is relevant to proof of the reasonableness of the respondents’ predictions as to the orchards’ performance made to the applicants some months later. In their written submissions, the applicants claimed that documents of this kind at Board level fall within O 15. In my view, Board papers, including minutes of meeting, as sought by the applicants fall within the criteria in O 15 rule 2(3) and are discoverable.Corporate policy of Hancock in relation to valuation (par 49 of Strahley affidavit) It appears that the respondents have endeavoured to provide this document, however the applicants claimed in the table of responses that parts of the document are illegible. The respondents stated that they provided a copy of the document by facsimile on 20 July 2006 and by letter on 26 July 2006. At this stage I do not consider an order for discovery to be necessary.Communication between Breed and Strahley in relation to bin numbers (par 52 Strahley affidavit) The respondents have indicated they have already discovered documents which satisfy this description, and have been unable to locate other documents. It appears that the applicants did not press this claim in correspondence with the respondents. In my view no order for discovery should be made.Historical data (par 66(a) Strahley affidavit) The respondents indicated in the table of responses that they have already discovered this document in their List of Documents. In my view no order for discovery should be made.Information received from Mr Sims and diary notes (par 66(b)(ii) Strahley affidavit)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COLLIER J

The court held that the Hancock Board paper and Board minute evidencing the decision to sell the orchards were discoverable under O 15 rule 2(3) of the Federal Court Rules. The court reasoned that Board papers, including minutes of meetings, at the Board level, are discoverable as they fall within the criteria set by the rule. The applicants claimed these documents were relevant to proving the reasonableness of the respondents' predictions about the orchards' performance. The court did not find it necessary to order the discovery of the corporate policy of Hancock in relation to valuation at this stage, as the respondents had attempted to provide the document but parts were illegible. The court found that no order for discovery should be made regarding the communication between Breed and Strahley in relation to bin numbers, as the respondents had already discovered the relevant documents. Similarly, the historical data and information received from Mr Sims and diary notes were not discoverable as they had already been provided by the respondents. Lastly, the court ordered the discovery of specific financial and operational documents from the applicants, such as budgets, cash flow records, and management reports, as they were relevant to the case.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that Board papers and minutes of meetings at the Board level are discoverable under O 15 rule 2(3) of the Federal Court Rules, provided they are relevant to the case. The court distinguished between discoverable Board-level documents and other corporate policies or internal communications, which were not ordered to be discovered at this stage. This decision reinforces the principle that the discoverability of documents is contingent on their relevance and the specific criteria outlined in the Federal Court Rules.