Citibank Savings Ltd v Nicholson & Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

CITIBANK SAVINGS LTD V NICHOLSON & ORS (2261/93)

CITIBANK SAVINGS LTD V PIRROTTA & ORS (1928/94)
CITIBANK V PIRROTTA & ORS (2260/93)

Full Court
Cox Mullighan and Williams JJ

Williams J

These appeals are brought by leave of a single judge of this Court with respect to costs orders which have been made in civil proceedings.  The orders deal with the successful mortgagee’s costs of action awarded by the trial judge against mortgagors in two actions.

The form of the mortgage document as now relevant is common to both actions.

The question at issue upon the appeals instituted by the mortgagee concerns the way in which the cost orders should be expressed.  The unsuccessful mortgagors (who have cross appealed) assert that they should only be liable for costs upon a party and party basis; the mortgagee asserts that it should be entitled to a more beneficial form of order so as to reflect a contractual entitlement which it claims under the mortgage in each case.

The form of mortgage contains an agreement which expressly makes provision for the mortgagee’s costs "as between solicitor and client to be paid by the mortgagor". The mortgagee contends that it should be entitled to recover the whole of the amount in respect of which the mortgagee would otherwise be out of pocket by reason of the proceedings.

It is apparent from the reported cases that some confusion has developed as to the meaning of the term "as between solicitor and client" when applied to legal costs. (See Ricks v White (1995) 2 QdR 302 at 306).

Morgan and Davey’s Costs in Chancery (1865) at pp1-2 identifies the various modes of taxation which may be undertaken when a taxation of costs as between solicitor and client is proposed. The long-standing practice associated with solicitor and client taxations has given rise to principles which have "hardened into law" and have become part of the law of South Australia (see the judgment of Philp J in Re Price Deceased, Union Trustee Co of Australia Ltd v McCorrie (1941) St R Qd 205 at 209). Those principles must now be applied to the mortgage agreement.

The order of the trial judge now under appeal in each action provides that the mortgagors shall pay to the mortgagee "its costs of action to be taxed as between solicitor and client". 

In delivering reasons for his decision on the costs question, the trial judge made the following observation with respect to submissions made by the mortgagee’s counsel -

"Mr Hoile for Citibank has put the argument that Citibank is entitled to solicitor and client costs on an indemnity or common fund basis, that is, all such costs as might have been reasonably incurred by Citibank...."

and later

"...it seems to me that if the draftsman of the document uses the expression "solicitor and client", it would be wrong to substitute another formula.  It would be wrong to substitute the words "solicitor and own client", or to add the words "reasonably incurred".…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Citibank Savings Ltd v Nicholson & Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6603
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Citibank Savings Ltd v Nicholson & Ors and related matters, the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia considered the nature and extent of costs recoverable by a mortgagee from mortgagors. The mortgagees, Citibank Savings Ltd, sought to recover their legal costs incurred in enforcing the mortgages on the mortgagors' properties. The mortgage agreements contained a clause stipulating that the mortgagors would pay the mortgagees' costs "as between solicitor and client". The mortgagors argued they should only be liable for costs on a party and party basis, while the mortgagees claimed they were entitled to a more beneficial form of order reflecting their contractual entitlement under the mortgage.

The Full Court examined the meaning of the term "as between solicitor and client" and the principles governing the taxation of such costs. The Court noted the confusion that had arisen in interpreting this term and emphasised the importance of considering the parties' intentions in the mortgage agreement. The Court concluded that the phrase "solicitor and client costs" in the mortgage agreements indicated that the mortgagors intended for the mortgagees to be fully indemnified for their costs, provided those costs were reasonable. The Court found that the trial judge's order for costs "as between solicitor and client" should be varied to require the mortgagors to pay the mortgagees' costs "as between solicitor and own client" to reflect the intention of the mortgage agreements.

The Court allowed the mortgagees' appeals and dismissed the mortgagors' cross-appeals. The orders of the trial judge were varied to require the mortgagors to pay the mortgagees' costs "as between solicitor and own client". The Court held that the mortgage agreements clearly intended for the mortgagees to be indemnified for their costs, and the phrase "solicitor and client costs" should be interpreted in that light.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.