Cic Insurance Ltd v Barwon Region Water Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL Not Restricted

F4746

No. 2013 of 1997

CIC INSURANCE LTD.

Appellant

v

BARWON REGION WATER AUTHORITY

Respondent

---

JUDGES: ORMISTON, PHILLIPS and KENNY, JJ.A.
WHERE HELD: WARRNAMBOOL
DATE OF HEARING: 10 and 11 August 1998
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 15 October 1998
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: CIC Insurance Ltd. v. Barwon Region Water Authority
MEDIA NEUTRAL CITATION: [1998] VSCA 77

---

INSURANCE - Property insurance - "Industrial Special Risks Policy" - Claim for flood damage to three structures - Whether two were "bridges" within meaning of exclusion clause - Clause providing "declared values" to form part of a policy for purpose of "co- insurance clauses" - Further provision requiring "value of property insured" to be declared after end of policy period for adjustment of premium clause - None of the three structures made subject of declarations for either clause during period of cover - Whether non-declaration breach of duty of "utmost good faith" within meaning of ss.12- 14 of Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (C'th) (in absence of any defence based on non- disclosure) - Operation of co-insurance and premium clauses - Authority's network of pipes also not subject of declaration - Counter-claim for premiums payable on pipes and three structures for three years policy in effect - Whether insurer entitled to recover - Non-disclosure not relied upon on either claim or counter-claim.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant  Mr J. Barnard Q.C. and Hall and Willcox
Mr T.J. Ginnane
For the Respondent  Mr D.M.B. Derham Q.C. Harwood Andrews
and Mr J. Delany

ORMISTON, J. A.:

  1. For a number of years commencing on about 1 August 1993 the respondent water and sewerage Authority (and its predecessor, the Geelong and District Water Board) was insured by the appellant insurer against loss and damage to property belonging to it or for which it was responsible. The property primarily in issue in this appeal consists of three structures crossing either the Wormbete Creek or the Barwon River and carrying the Authority's pipelines. The three structures may be called:

(1) The Wormbete Syphon, at Wurdee Boluc;
(2) The Queen's Park Bridge pipeline, at Geelong; and
(3) The Queen's Park Suspension Pipe Bridge, also at Geelong.

The three structures differed in construction in that each of the first and third was owned by the Authority and was constructed and maintained to carry the Authority's pipelines across a watercourse. The second was a pipeline controlled by the Authority and attached to and forming part of a more substantial bridge, the Queen's Park Bridge, used by the public, which supported the pipeline across the Barwon on bearers extending out on one side only from the superstructure.

  1. In November 1995 there was a flood affecting both the Wormbete Creek and the Barwon River, which burst their banks. The Wormbete Syphon and the Queen's Park Suspension Pipe Bridge were torn down in part, damaging the pipelines. The Queen's Park Bridge itself sustained no significant damage but the pipeline carried along its side…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cic Insurance Ltd v Barwon Region Water Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] VSCA 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cic Insurance Ltd v Barwon Region Water Authority involved the insurer, Cic Insurance Ltd, and the Barwon Region Water Authority, concerning a claim for flood damage to three structures. The dispute centred on whether two of these structures were considered "bridges" under an exclusion clause in the "Industrial Special Risks Policy" and whether the Authority's failure to declare the structures constituted a breach of the duty of utmost good faith under the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth). Additionally, the case addressed the operation of co-insurance and premium clauses, as well as a counter-claim by the insurer for unpaid premiums on the structures and an Authority network of pipes.

The court had to determine several key legal issues. First, whether the exclusion clause applied to the two structures in question, effectively excluding the insurer's liability for flood damage. Second, whether the non-disclosure of the structures in the schedules or declarations of value constituted a breach of the duty of utmost good faith, and if so, whether this could void the policy. Third, the applicability and operation of the co-insurance and premium adjustment clauses, given that none of the structures were declared at the relevant times. Lastly, the court needed to decide if the insurer was entitled to recover unpaid premiums on the structures and the Authority's network of pipes.

The court found that neither of the structures in question were "bridges" within the meaning of the exclusion clause, as they did not serve the primary purpose of transportation, particularly for the public. Regarding the duty of utmost good faith, the court held that the Authority's failure to declare the structures did not breach this duty, particularly since the insurer did not rely on non-disclosure as a defence. The court also found that the non-declaration did not affect the operation of the co-insurance and premium clauses, as the structures were not declared at the relevant times. In relation to the counter-claim, the court ruled that the insurer was entitled to recover the unpaid premiums for the three years in question.

In conclusion, the court's final orders were that the insurer was not liable for the flood damage to the three structures, and the insurer was entitled to recover the unpaid premiums for the three years policy in effect.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Finally, among a series of numbered "Conditions Applicable to all Sections", Condition 1 related to "Misrepresentation and Non-disclosure" upon which no direct reliance was placed by the appellant, and there were other conditions relating to matters such as cancellation, notification of claims, subrogation and precautions to prevent loss. As already noted, thereafter appeared the "endorsements" applicable to all parts of the policy. Background facts The other circumstances giving rise to these proceedings are set out in the judgment of the learned trial judge. There is no dispute that the existence of any of the three structures was not the subject of any disclosure by the Authority to the insurer either before the original policy was entered into or before either of the two renewals was granted. Nor is there any dispute that the Queen's Park Bridge pipeline was not in itself a bridge, although a significant part of the dispute both at trial and on this appeal was whether the other two structures were or were not "bridges" within the meaning of the exclusion to the policy, for, if they were, the insurer was not liable for the damage to them. The Wormbete Syphon structure supported a pipeline across the Wormbete Creek but it also carried a platform which provided access for vehicles of the Authority and its employees when carrying out their duties in relation to that structure. The Queen's Park Suspension Pipe Bridge consisted of concrete piers on either side of the Barwon with the necessary cables and cross-bracing to carry the pipeline across the river, but otherwise it could not be used for the passage of either employees or vehicles, so that it provided solely a means of taking the water from one side of the river to the other. The learned trial judge held that neither of these structures were "bridges" as contemplated by the policy as they did not have the characteristic of being used for the purpose of being used for transportation, primarily of the public. On either interpretation, however, there was at least one structure (the Queen's Park Bridge pipeline) which it was said had not been disclosed in the sense that not one of the three structures appeared in any of the three schedules or declarations of value (as at 1 August) made by the respondent up to the time of the accident. For reasons not entirely apparent, the appellant has never relied on non-disclosure, as such, probably because it saw its only remedies as setting off or obtaining an order for payment of the differential in premium, a figure of little over $550, a sum which, at least for the year in question, it had waived shortly after this proceeding had commenced. Instead the appellant insurer has relied on the respondent's failure to act towards it with the "utmost good faith", as required by s.13 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 of the Commonwealth ("the Act"). It said that the respondent had failed to "declare" the three structures, (or the one pipeline if the appellant's construction of exclusion clause 9 be accepted), at the beginning and end of each period of insurance as was required by the "Declared Values" clause and by the "Adjustment of Premium" clause. At no relevant time had any such declaration been made which identified any of the structures. None of the three "schedules of property values" was in fact prepared after the end of each year's period of insurance, although on paper they bore the date 1 August; rather, they appeared to have been made as part of the process of negotiating the insurance cover (in the first year, 1993) and of negotiating renewal of the policy in the later two years, 1994 and 1995. However it was conceded that the adjustment of premium declaration made in early 1997 included a sum representing the value of the three structures as at end of the year to 1 August 1996.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.