Christopherson v Road Transport Authority (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CHRISTOPHERSON v ROAD TRANSPORT AUTHORITY (Administrative Review) [2023] ACAT 69

AT 93/2022

Catchwords:               ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – review of decision – Road Transports (Driver Licensing) Regulation 2000 – Medical standards for licensing and clinical management guidelines – definition and interpretation of “Assessing fitness to drive” in the Guidelines – whether the applicant meets the standard required by the Guidelines for the horizontal extent of her visual field – decision confirmed – application for interim or other orders dismissed

Legislation cited:        ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 68

Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Act 1999 ss 6, 7
Road Transport (General) Act 1999 s 16

Subordinate

Legislation cited:        Road Transports (Driver Licensing) Regulation 2000 ss 78A, 87

Cases cited:Bergild v Road Transport Authority (No 2) [2018] ACAT 8

Bergild v Road Transport Authority [2017] ACAT 80
Construction Occupations Registrar v B&T Constructions (ACT) Pty Ltd & Ors [2015] ACAT 24
Kelly v Roads Corporation (VicRoads) [2016] VMC 1
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li [2013] HCA 18
Rajak v Road Transport Authority [2008] ACTAAT 18
Thomson v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2009] ACAT 38

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Austroads, Assessing fitness to drive for commercial and private vehicle drivers (2022)

Tribunal:Member W Hawkins

Date of Orders:  10 November 2023

Date of Reasons for Decision:      10 November 2023

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY          )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL     )          AT 93/2022

BETWEEN:

JOANNE CHRISTOPHERSON
Applicant

AND:

ROAD TRANSPORT AUTHORITY
Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Member W Hawkins

DATE:10 November 2023

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

  1. The decision under review dated 10 November 2022 is confirmed.

  2. The applicant’s application for interim or other orders is dismissed.

    ………………………………

Member W Hawkins

REASONS FOR DECISION

Introduction and Background

  1. Joanne Christopherson (the applicant) sought review of a decision of the Road Transport Authority as decision maker (the respondent) to confirm, on internal review, its original decision to suspend her driver licence (the decision under review) pursuant to section 87 of the Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Regulation 2000 (the Regulation).

  2. The applicant sought to have her driver licence reinstated, with the condition of an annual review by an ophthalmologist to assess her ability to retain a driver licence, and to have all reasonable transport costs incurred by her during the period of the suspension to be reimbursed to her by the respondent.[1] The applicant did not press for the reasonable transport costs during the hearing and limited her application to the review.[2]

    [1] Application for Review of a Decision dated 4 November 2022, page 2

    [2] Transcript of proceedings dated 18 August 2023, page 7, line 20-page 8, line 35

  3. The applicant, whilst visiting the United States, was diagnosed with bilateral retinitis pigmentosa following a routine optometry visit to obtain new frames in September 2021. Retinitis pigmentosa is a degenerative eye condition that bilaterally results in progressive loss of vision, including visual field loss, impaired contrast, and light sensitivity.[3] The diagnosis of retinitis pigmentosa…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Christopherson v Road Transport Authority (Administrative Re... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] ACAT 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, in this case, sought to challenge the decision of the Road Transport Authority to cancel her driver’s licence. The dispute was reviewed by the tribunal, which was tasked with determining whether the applicant’s licence should indeed be cancelled based on the evidence presented. The applicant argued that she met the standards required for a driver’s licence, supported by the expert evidence of Professor Grigg, an expert in inherited retinal diseases. The respondent, however, relied on the evidence of Dr Beaumont, who held a contrary view regarding the applicant’s fitness to drive.

The primary issue for the tribunal to decide was the validity of the ophthalmological opinions presented by both parties. Professor Grigg opined that the applicant met the standards for a driver’s licence, suggesting she could safely drive with certain restrictions. Conversely, Dr Beaumont held that she did not meet the necessary standards. The tribunal had to weigh these conflicting expert opinions and determine which assessment was more reliable and aligned with the statutory guidelines provided by the respondent.

The tribunal found that the decision to uphold the cancellation of the applicant’s licence was justified. Despite Professor Grigg’s expert opinion, the tribunal concluded that the respondent’s reliance on Dr Beaumont’s evidence was more consistent with the statutory requirements and guidelines. The tribunal ultimately determined that the applicant’s condition did not meet the necessary standards for a driver’s licence, thereby confirming the respondent’s decision.

The tribunal dismissed the applicant’s application for interim or other orders, including her request for payment of part of Dr Beaumont’s fees for giving evidence. The decision under review, which upheld the cancellation of the applicant’s licence, was confirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

1.

The decision under review dated 10 November 2022 is confirmed.

2.

The applicant’s application for interim or other orders is dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant advanced the following argument in respect of Professor Grigg:(a)He is an expert in relation to inherited retinal diseases and the author of a number of papers, including the applicant’s condition of retinitis pigmentosa.(b)He examined the applicant on three occasions.Professor Grigg’s evidence and opinions As previously mentioned, Professor Grigg wrote a number of reports; provided a statement/report for the proceedings dated 13 June 2023 (Professor Grigg’s report);[35] and gave evidence. [35] Witness statement of Professor J Griggs dated 13 June 2023 In Professor Grigg’s report, he said:(a)He initially consulted with the applicant in September 2022 and took a relevant history of the applicant’s diagnosis of retinitis pigmentosa. He found that it was “mild late onset”.(b)He conducted an Esterman visual field test with both the fixation and the roving form. The test with fixation was “borderline”, and the roving test showed 130 degrees, which met the standards for a driver licence in New South Wales.(c)That due to the retinitis pigmentosa, he would limit driving to daylight hours.(d)That, after discussing the Guidelines, driving is a “dynamic process with the head and eyes continuingly scanning the environment”.(e)After considering a 2022 study of the predictive value of the Esterman Visual Field test on the on-road driving test, that they were not conclusive, and that this highlighted that fitness to drive requires measuring the functional peripheral vision. The aim of measurement is to assess whether an individual can drive safely and be aware of their environment and hazards. This assessment of peripheral vision relies upon normal movement of the head and eyes. In Professor Grigg’s oral evidence at the hearing on 18 August 2023, he said:(a)After referring to the Guidelines and a consideration of the visual field criteria, the requirement for an “open” licence is 110 degrees on the estimate, and if the result is less than that, then consideration can be given for a “restricted” licence.(b)If there is an estimate of binocular visual field with fixation and the assessment is 90 degrees, then that result automatically leads to a restricted licence.(c)If other circumstances need to be taken in account, there are a number of tests described in the Guidelines that may be considered in order to determine whether a person is safe to drive with a restricted licence. One of the tests is the binocular Esterman visual field. Important is central visual vision and that is different from what is measured with monitored fixation.(d)On the fixed test, the applicant had at least 70 degrees on the horizontal, but she had 110 degrees vertically. The applicant had very well-preserved central vision, so when the functional test of the roving Esterman was considered, the applicant met the criteria for a restricted licence, but with a main restriction of not driving in the evening.(e)Retinitis pigmentosa has an individual progression and can progress slowly. Although it was once thought to only develop during teenage years and early twenties, it is now accepted that it can develop at any age including in the 50 to 70 years age bracket. The normal progression is over decades rather than weeks, months, or years.[36][36] Transcript of proceedings dated 18 August 2023, page 82, line 24-page 83, line 42

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 10 November 2022, the respondent issued a ‘notice of decision at internal review’ (the decision under review or decision). The decision under review upheld the decision to cancel the applicant’s licence.[15][15] Attachment 20 – ‘Notice of decision at internal review’ dated 10 November 2022 to Applicant’s submissions On 9 November 2022, the applicant filed an application for review of a decision (the application). Although the application predated the decision under review, the tribunal ordered that the decision of 10 November be taken as the decision under review.[16][16] See Orders dated 7 December 2022 A hearing was held on 18 August 2023. Subsequent to the hearing, the applicant filed an application for interim or other orders (interim application). Directions were made concerning the filing of evidence and submissions concerning the interim application. In essence, the interim application sought payment of part of Dr Beaumont’s fees for giving evidence at the hearing. The interim application will be considered more fully below. In addition to the interim application, the applicant filed an invoice from Professor Grigg related to his giving evidence at the hearing, and the respondent filed submissions on 29 September 2023. The applicant represented herself with the assistance of her sister, Judy Swann. The respondent was represented by Dean Ager, of counsel who was instructed by Brad Marler of the ACT Government Solicitor’s office. Also in attendance was Rebecca Wilson and Guiseppe Mangeruca on behalf of the respondent. The Tribunal’s function on review is to consider anew the question whether the applicant’s licence should be cancelled, based upon the evidence presented at the hearing. For this reason, the Tribunal received evidence in addition to the evidence available at the time the decision under review was made regarding the applicant’s suitability to hold a driver licence. The additional documentary or further evidence included:(a)Tribunal Documents filed 25 November 2022.(b)Applicant’s bundle of documents, including submissions and attachments, filed 16 June 2023 (some documents were available at the time of the decision and were considered, and additional documents were not available at the time and will be separately referred to where necessary).(c)A statement/further report from Dr Beaumont dated 10 July 2023.(d)Respondent’s submissions filed 14 July 2023.(e)Professor Grigg and Dr Beaumont both gave oral evidence and were cross examined. Ultimately, the primary issue concerned the opposing ophthalmological opinions of Professor Grigg and of Dr Beaumont. The applicant relied upon Professor Grigg, who was of the opinion that the applicant met the standards for a licence, whereas the respondent relied upon the opinion of Dr Beaumont, who did not. The opinions of Professor Grigg and of Dr Beaumont are further considered below. For convenience, the Tribunal generally adopts the headings used by the applicant. The Tribunal summarises the submissions as follows.Respondent’s application of the Guidelines

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.