Christopher Raines v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:  

Christopher Raines v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 128

PARTIES:  

Christopher Raines
(Appellant)

v

Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator)
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2014/193

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

10 July 2015

HEARING DATES: 

30 September, 1-2 October 2014 (hearing)
11 November 2014 (Appellant's submissions)
28 November 2014  (Respondent's submissions)
12 December 2014 (Appellant's submissions in reply)

MEMBER:

Industrial Commissioner Knight

ORDERS   :

1.      The appeal is dismissed;

2.      The decision of the Regulator dated 19 May 2104  is confirmed; and

3.      The Appellant is to pay the Respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal to be agreed.  In the event agreement cannot be reached between the parties with respect to the costs the Appellant has the liberty to apply.

CATCHWORDS: WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - whether injury arose out of or in the course of employment - whether employment a significant contributing factor - Appellant bears onus of proof - appeal dismissed.

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation  Act 2003 s 32

Carman v Q-COMP 186 QGIG 512 [513]

Croning v Workers' Compensation Board of Queensland (1997) 156 QGIG 100

Heald v Q-COMP (2004) 177 QGIG 769

JBS Australia Pty Ltd and Q-COMP (C/2012/35) - Decision < qirc. qld. gov. au>

Kudryavtseva v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator) [2015] QIRC 053

McDonald v Q-COMP (2008) 188 QGIG 180

Newberry v Suncorp Metway Insurance Ltd [2006] QCA 48

APPEARANCES:

Ms. L. Willson instructed by Shine Lawyers for the Appellant. 

Mr R. Clutterbuck directly instructed for Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator). 

Decision

  1. This is an Appeal by Mr Christopher Raines ("the Appellant") pursuant to s 550 of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 ("the Act") against a decision of the Regulator ("the Respondent"). The decision of the Regulator confirmed the earlier decision of WorkCover to reject Mr Raines' application for compensation for a shoulder injury, in accordance with s 32 of the Act.

    Grounds of Appeal

  2. The  grounds of appeal filed by the Appellant are as follows:

    a.       "The Appellant submits that the accident (resulting in his shoulder injury) occurred as stated during the course of his employment on 13 August 2013;

    b.       Q-Comp ought to have accepted the review of the Applicant on the basis the event causing the injury occurred on the balance of probabilities." 

  3. Facts relied on:

    i."The Applicant was employed by the Respondent employer as at the date of the incident, 13 August 2013;

    ii.The Applicant reported the injury to the Respondent employer;

    iii.The Applicant also reported the injury as occurring at work to Dr Kah Ho on 20 August 2013;

    iv.The Respondent employer agreed to pay for the Applicant's MRI scan undertaken on 21 September 2013 due to the fact that the injury had "occurred at work";

    v.As such, it should be found that the Applicant has sustained an injury which occurred in the course of his employment;

    vi.The Applicant's employment was a significant contributing factor to the injury; and

    vii.The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Christopher Raines v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QIRC 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Christopher Raines v Simon Blackwood (Workers' Compensation Regulator), the appellant, Mr Raines, sought to appeal against the Workers' Compensation Regulator's decision to reject his claim for workers' compensation. Mr Raines argued that his injury, which included Left Supraspinatus Tendonitis/Subacromial Bursitis and a Para Labral Cyst Left Shoulder (With Assumed Posterior Labral Tear), arose out of and in the course of his employment with Mecano Sheds, and that his employment was a significant contributing factor to the injury. The court was required to determine whether Mr Raines could prove his case on the balance of probabilities, considering the evidence provided by both parties and the surrounding circumstances of the alleged injury.

The court examined the evidence provided by both parties, including medical reports, witness statements, and the nature of Mr Raines' work at the Mecano Sheds factory. The court highlighted the conflicting evidence regarding the method of moving extruded metal from the machine, with Mr Raines claiming he was working alone and lifting beams, while the Respondent argued that assistance was provided when necessary. The court also considered the testimony of Mr Raines and Ms Allsop, with Ms Allsop denying that Mr Raines reported a work-related injury on the day of the alleged incident.

The court concluded that Mr Raines had not successfully proven his case on the balance of probabilities. The court found that there was no contemporaneous note or statement of observation of the alleged injury by any other witness and that the claim was lodged five months after the alleged injury arose, after the relationship between the employer and Mr Raines had largely broken down. The court also found that Mr Raines' conduct during the hearing process was consistently evasive and untruthful, leading the court to question whether he sustained a workplace injury on the alleged date at all.

The appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the Regulator dated 19 May 2014 was confirmed. Mr Raines was ordered to pay the Respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal, to be agreed upon by the parties. If the parties could not reach an agreement regarding the costs, Mr Raines had the liberty to apply for a determination of the costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed;

2. The decision of the Regulator dated 19 May 2104 is confirmed; and

3. The Appellant is to pay the Respondent's costs of and incidental to the appeal to be agreed. In the event agreement cannot be reached between the parties with respect to the costs the Appellant has the liberty to apply.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Andal referred Mr Raines to Dr Winstanley, an Orthopaedic Surgeon. He saw Mr Raines on two occasions, 17 September 2013 and 13 March 2014 and prepared reports in respect of those consultations. Dr Winstanley was called to give evidence by the Regulator. The evidence relating to the injury On 13 August 2013, Mr Raines said that he was working, on his own, on the C‑Section machine at the Mecano Sheds factory. His evidence was that the work also entailed moving extruded metal from the machine by lifting it and placing it onto a trolley. There is conflicting evidence as to how the guillotined beams were moved off the machine, with Mr Raines indicating it was necessary to lift the beams to get them onto a trolley. In contrast, the Respondent submitted that there was a trolley placed beside the machine which was of equal height to the bench upon which the metal extrudes were placed. These beams were generally slid over to the trolley, except in circumstances where the trolley stacks were high or particularly long and heavy and on those occasions assistance would be required to perform this task. Both Mr Crossley and Mr Brown gave evidence that they assisted the Appellant when performing these duties. On the day of the alleged injury, Mr Raines said he was working on his own. He recalled feeling pain in his shoulder as he was moving a beam onto the trolley. He said he went into the office and reported the pain to Ms Allsop. He recalled Ms Allsop asked him to keep an eye on it and that she told him to continue on with "your work". Ms Allsop denied Mr Raines reported a work related injury on that day and said that had it been so, she would have recorded it on an Incident Report form. Instead, Ms Allsop recalled the Appellant mentioning to her that he was going to have surgery in 18 months' time. This information was given to her after August 2013. When she asked Mr Raines what had happened to him to warrant surgery, she recalled he told her that he had had a cyst on his shoulder for some time, but that he was fine with lifting. Upon hearing this, Ms Allsop said she advised others in the factory about his sore shoulder and requested they make sure that he was not doing any heavy lifting. This instruction was confirmed by Mr Crossley. Mr Raines claimed Mr Crossley had not been working with him on the day of the injury, but Mr Crossley's evidence was at odds with these claims when he indicated he was the Appellant's assistant and spent a of time with him in the factory. Mr Crossley's evidence was that he was undertaking training from the Appellant and was standing by his side almost every time they were on the factory floor. Mr Crossley described the method used in working on the C‑section. He told the Commission that it extrudes from the machine and is slid onto a trolley so it is never physically picked it up completely and not by one person. If it is necessary to lift it another person is asked to assist. Later, in re-examination, Mr Crossley said that on some occasions he had observed Mr Raines sliding one end of a beam onto the trolley and then walking to the centre to pick the material up and put it on the trolley. He said this was somewhat different to how he performed the work on the C-Section machine in that he would not physically lift the whole length, but only lift and slide half of it at a time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Evidence in support of the Appellant's claims came from his wife, Mrs Raines. She agreed that she had spoken to a medical practitioner about the waiting list for her husband's surgery and around that time she had also become aware that WorkCover might pay for that surgery. Whilst Mrs Raines said she believed her husband and Mr Yelaska had discussed not getting WorkCover involved in this matter, the Respondent says that this is hearsay evidence and that the only reason the Appellant claimed WorkCover was because his personal health insurance did not cover the cost of an operation. Findings and Conclusion It is not contested that the Appellant is a "worker" for the purposes of the Act. To be successful in his Appeal, Mr Raines must prove on the balance of probabilities that his personal injury, namely a Left Supraspinatus Tendonitis/Subacromial Bursitis; and/or Para Labral Cyst Left Shoulder (With Assumed Posterior Labral Tear) is one arising out of, or in the course of employment; and that his employment with Mecano Sheds is a significant contributing factor to the injury. What also needs to be determined in this matter is whether Mr Raines was operating the C-section machine in the manner he described on 13 August 2013; and whether he moved or lifted a beam in the manner described to the extent that it led to his shoulder injuries. There is also a dispute as to whether Mr Raines reported his injury to Ms Allsop and whether there was any established practice within the business to report and document workplace related injuries at the time of the alleged injury. The Respondent submitted the determination of this matter is essentially reliant on the acceptance of the testimony of Mr Raines in circumstances where there is no contemporaneous note or statement of observation of the alleged injury by any other witness and where the claim was lodged some five months after the alleged injury arose after the relationship between the employer and Mr Raines had largely broken down. Mr Clutterbuck, for the Regulator, actively questioned whether Mr Raines sustained a workplace injury on 13 August 2013 at all, pointing to his conduct during the hearing process during which he submitted was consistently evasive and untruthful. Instead, the Respondent has submitted Mr Raines is a person who has suffered some sort of disability or injury, which is not a workplace injury. Further, that on or around the time he recognised he needed surgery to fix the problem the only way for Mr Raines to access surgery, in circumstances where he has no private health insurance, was to attempt to take advantage of the WorkCover system, in order to compensate him for the private surgery that was necessary to repair his shoulder in a timely manner. The Appellant's submissions point to the nature of the work performed by Mr Raines at the workplace noting it is the Commissions role, to determine on balance whether Mr Raines has proved his case. Ms Willson, Counsel for the Appellant submitted the medical evidence in support of how Mr Raines' injuries arose is compelling, highlighting the contemporaneous notes taken by Doctors at the time of this injury.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.