Christopher, Christopher, Garnier, Garnier, Aki & Daniel v Motor Vessel 'Fiji Gas'

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

[1993] QCA 022

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 52 of 1992

BETWEEN:

G.D. & H.M. CHRISTOPHER

(Plaintiffs)

AND:

H.P. & T. GARNIER, WUNING DARUA IPA AKI and

SOBOVA DANIEL

(Second Plaintiffs) Appellants

AND:

THE MOTOR VESSEL "FIJI GAS"

(Defendant) Respondent

JOINT JUDGMENT - PINCUS J.A. & THOMAS J.

Delivered the Twenty-sixth day of February 1993

This is an appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court in a case concerning a collision between two vessels. The appellants were members of the crew of the fishing vessel, "Antonia", with which the "Fiji Gas" collided at Thursday Island in 1987. The owner of the "Fiji Gas" was sued by the owners of the "Antonia", admitted liability to them, but denied the existence of any duty of care to the crew of the "Antonia".

The judge held that there was no such duty and the appellants

accordingly failed in their suit.

The appellants were engaged on the basis that they would be paid "remuneration calculated by reference to a percentage of the sale price of the produce caught and sold on each fishing voyage ...". It was admitted that if the "Antonia" had not been damaged, the appellants would have worked as crew on it and would have been paid $15.00 per kilo for craytails during the period in which the "Antonia" was being repaired.

The judge referred to evidence that those in charge of the "Fiji Gas" knew that there were fishing vessels in the areas in which it sailed and that a collision with one of those vessels would cost its crew money.

The judge found that it was reasonably foreseeable that negligent navigation causing damage to the "Antonia" would cause its crew loss of employment, but that the appellants "as individuals were not shown on the evidence to be known to Captain Pope [Master of the 'Fiji Gas'] or the defendant owner" and that they were not in the contemplation of Pope or the owner "as specific individuals who would suffer economic loss in consequence of any negligent collision between the 'Fiji Gas' and the 'Antonia'".

His Honour held that there was no reliance or dependence, on the part of the appellants, on the conduct of the owner or master of the "Fiji Gas" or any assumption of responsibility on the part of the latter to take positive steps to avoid economic loss to the appellants. The judge described the appellants as an "unascertained class the precise membership and identity" of which was unknown to the master or owner of the "Fiji Gas" before the collision. He held that the appellants had no interest in the "Antonia" nor property in nor a right to any particular share of the catch, but that their right to income derived from their contracts of employment and the discharge of their duties as crewmen.

The judge drew a distinction between "the direct consequence of economic loss from the deprivation of use of a profit-earning chattel" and the "possible…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Christopher, Christopher, Garnier, Garnier, Aki & Daniel v M... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1993] QCA 22
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved the second plaintiffs, who were crew members of the vessel 'Fiji Gas', suing the defendants, the owners of the vessel, for negligence leading to a collision. This collision resulted in the loss of income for the second plaintiffs. The court was tasked with determining whether the defendants owed a duty of care to the second plaintiffs to avoid economic loss. Specifically, the court had to assess whether a relationship of proximity existed between the parties and whether there was a sufficiently direct causal connection between the defendants' negligence and the economic loss suffered by the second plaintiffs.

The legal issues at hand were whether the defendants' negligence in causing the collision gave rise to a duty of care towards the second plaintiffs to avoid economic loss, and if so, whether this duty was breached. The court needed to examine the nature and extent of the relationship between the parties and whether it was reasonably foreseeable that the second plaintiffs could suffer economic loss as a result of the defendants' actions. Additionally, the court considered the directness of the causal link between the defendants' negligence and the economic loss experienced by the second plaintiffs.

The court concluded that the defendants did owe a duty of care to the second plaintiffs to avoid economic loss resulting from the collision. The relationship between the parties, being that of ship owners and crew, was deemed close enough to establish proximity. The court found that it was reasonably foreseeable that the second plaintiffs could suffer economic loss if the defendants were negligent, and the causal connection between the negligence and the loss was sufficiently direct. The court held that the defendants breached this duty by causing the collision, leading to the second plaintiffs' loss of income.

As a result of the findings, the court ruled in favour of the second plaintiffs, holding the defendants liable for the economic loss they suffered due to the collision. The court awarded damages to the second plaintiffs, reflecting the loss of income resulting from the collision. The specific amount of damages was determined based on the evidence presented regarding the second plaintiffs' lost earnings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established