Choppair Helicopters Pty Ltd v AMT Helicopters Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

[2022] QCA 264

COURT OF APPEAL

BOND JA

Appeal No 10330 of 2022
DC No 2012 of 2018

CHOPPAIR HELICOPTERS PTY LTD  Appellant/Respondent
ACN 087 863 723
TRADING AS THE HELICOPTER
GROUP PTY LTD

v

AMT HELICOPTERS PTY LTD  Respondent/Applicant
ACN 006 385 324
TRADING AS AIRWORK
HELICOPTERS

BRISBANE

MONDAY, 19 DECEMBER 2022

JUDGMENT

  1. BOND JA:  On 1 August 2022, Barlow QC DCJ[1] published his reasons for judgment in Choppair Helicopters Pty Ltd v AMT Helicopters Pty Ltd [2022] QDC 169. His Honour ordered that there be judgment for AMT on Choppair’s claim.

    [1]As his Honour then was.

  2. On 29 August 2022, Choppair lodged an appeal from that judgment.  On 1 November 2022, AMT applied for security for costs of the appeal and that application was resolved by a consent order on 18 November 2022 that:

    (a)Choppair pay security for costs in the sum of $35,000 by 4.00 pm on 25 November 2022; and

    (b)until the security provided by that order was provided, the parties to the appeal should not take a further step in the appeal without leave of the Court of Appeal.

  3. Choppair failed to pay that security as ordered and AMT applied for an order pursuant to UCPR r 774(b) or alternatively in this Court’s inherent jurisdiction for an order dismissing the appeal.

  4. For the following reasons, that application should succeed.

    Factual background

  5. Choppair accepts the description of the factual background in AMT’s written submissions before me at [2] to [19].  I record that description below (footnotes omitted, emphasis in original):

    “In June 2014, a company related to Choppair, imported a second hand AS 350BA Airbus helicopter from Cambodia. Installed in that helicopter was a modular Arriel 1B helicopter engine (Engine). The Engine was removed in December 2014. It was unserviceable. To be returned to service, the Engine required a “recalendar” to be performed on modules 1, 5 and the fuel control unit (FCU) by the Engine’s manufacturer, Safran.

    The Engine had not been maintained, stored, or preserved correctly in Cambodia nor in Australia. By law, the only means by which the Engine could be returned to service was through a disassembly and inspection of each of the Engine’s modules by Safran.

    The Engine was sent to Airwork. It arrived in October 2015. It was not transported correctly. That of itself required the Engine to be sent to Safran for disassembly for it to be returned to service. Airwork and Choppair entered into an agreement for modules 1, 5 and the FCU to be “recalendared”. Airwork sent the Engine to Pacific Crown Helicopters Pty Ltd (Pacific) who on-forwarded it to Safran. Safran disassembled the Engine and provided a quote of approximately $675,000 to return it to service. That uneconomical sum was attributable to the level of internal damage to every Engine module. At Choppair’s request, the Engine was “bagged and tagged” by Safran and returned to Pacific. Choppair refused to pay for that service. Pacific paid Safran for that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Choppair Helicopters Pty Ltd v AMT Helicopters Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCA 264
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Choppair Helicopters Pty Ltd appealed against a judgment of Judge Barlow KC which found that Airwork had breached a contract to re-calendar specific modules of an Arriel 1B helicopter engine. The appeal was dismissed by McMurdo JA of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal related to the costs of a helicopter engine which had been disassembled by Airwork, a subcontractor of Choppair, when it was returned to Choppair in a non-serviceable condition. Choppair had entered into an agreement with Airwork for the re-calendaring of specific modules of the engine, which was to be subcontracted to a third party. However, Airwork subcontracted the work to Pacific, who then sent the engine to Safran for disassembly. The disassembly caused significant internal damage to the engine, leading to a substantial cost to repair it. Choppair claimed damages for the value of the engine, breach of contract, and other losses, while Pacific counterclaimed for the cost of the disassembly. The primary judge found that Airwork had breached the agreement by disassembling the entire engine, rather than just the specified modules, and that the value of the engine had diminished by $5,000 as a result. The primary judge also found that Choppair had recovered more than the loss of value from its settlement with Pacific. The appeal was dismissed on the grounds that Choppair had failed to provide security for costs and had not demonstrated an ability to meet an adverse costs order. The appeal was also dismissed because Choppair had not provided a valid reason for its failure to provide security for costs, and had instead made unsubstantiated claims about financial difficulties within the company.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

For the following reasons, that application should succeed.Factual background Choppair accepts the description of the factual background in AMT’s written submissions before me at [2] to [19]. I record that description below (footnotes omitted, emphasis in original):“In June 2014, a company related to Choppair, imported a second hand AS 350BA Airbus helicopter from Cambodia. Installed in that helicopter was a modular Arriel 1B helicopter engine (Engine). The Engine was removed in December 2014. It was unserviceable. To be returned to service, the Engine required a “recalendar” to be performed on modules 1, 5 and the fuel control unit (FCU) by the Engine’s manufacturer, Safran.The Engine had not been maintained, stored, or preserved correctly in Cambodia nor in Australia. By law, the only means by which the Engine could be returned to service was through a disassembly and inspection of each of the Engine’s modules by Safran.The Engine was sent to Airwork. It arrived in October 2015. It was not transported correctly. That of itself required the Engine to be sent to Safran for disassembly for it to be returned to service. Airwork and Choppair entered into an agreement for modules 1, 5 and the FCU to be “recalendared”. Airwork sent the Engine to Pacific Crown Helicopters Pty Ltd (Pacific) who on-forwarded it to Safran. Safran disassembled the Engine and provided a quote of approximately $675,000 to return it to service. That uneconomical sum was attributable to the level of internal damage to every Engine module. At Choppair’s request, the Engine was “bagged and tagged” by Safran and returned to Pacific. Choppair refused to pay for that service. Pacific paid Safran for that service and retained possession of the disassembled Engine pursuant to an asserted lien.Choppair instituted proceedings against Airwork and Pacific claiming (in the originating process):(a)the return of the Engine (in the state it was prior to disassembly);(b)damages for the value of the Engine estimated at $675,000 (the Safran quote); and(c)“other damages” for breach of contract and bailment, detinue, conversion and negligence.Pacific counterclaimed for the cost of the “bagging and tagging” of the Engine ($30,047.60). On 15 March 2022, Choppair and Pacific settled their respective claims on the terms that Pacific pay $40,000 to Choppair and return the Engine to it. Both the claim and counterclaim were dismissed.In its further amended statement of claim, Choppair alleged that:(a)it entered into an agreement for Airwork to “re-calendar” module 1, module 5 and the FCU of the Engine for the sum of USD $78,000 subject to findings as a result of an inspection of the Engine, and that such works would not be undertaken by Airwork but would be subcontracted to an overseas maintenance facility and not a facility in Australia;(b)the Engine was delivered to Airwork pursuant to the agreement (giving rise to a bailment relationship) each of which was breached by Airwork providing the Engine to Pacific;(c)Choppair lost the use of the Engine and was required to loan and subsequently purchase another helicopter for $435,000 (i.e., mitigation damages).No claim for damages was pleaded for either the value of the Engine, or a loss of opportunity to acquire a different engine upon trade-in of the Engine.Airwork’s defence was that:(a)the terms of its agreement with Choppair were for the Engine to be sent to a third party for it to be disassembled and, as that is what occurred, Airwork committed no breach;(b)Choppair and Pacific entered into a substitutional bailment thereby terminating the agreement between Choppair and Airwork; and(c)Choppair suffered no loss.The evidence at trial was that on and from (at least) 2014, Safran provided an engine upgrade opportunity for owners of an Arriel 1D1 engine (Upgrade Opportunity) to acquire an Arriel 1B engine at the reduced price of approximately €300,000 and which comprised:(a)the upgrade of the helicopter airframe of an Airbus AS350BA to an AS350B2 (at the customer’s expense);(b)the exchange of an Arriel 1B engine for an Arriel 1D1 engine;(c)a discount off the base price of an Arriel 1D1 engine on account of the helicopter airframe conversion (a discount of approximately €300,000); and(d)an additional incentive in the form of a further discount off the base price of a new Arriel 1D1 engine for the exchange of a second-hand Arriel 1B engine (approximately €100,000).The Upgrade Opportunity was offered to Choppair both in December 2014 (prior to disassembly) and in November 2016 (after disassembly). It was not availed of on either occasion. No evidence was led by Choppair that it had the means to pay, and would have paid, for the upgrade of the helicopter airframe (approximately €200,000 to €350,000) and the discounted cost of the Arriel 1D1 engine (approximately €300,000).The expert evidence of both parties at trial was that the Engine was worth between $25,000 (or less) and $70,000 prior to disassembly in October 2015, and $20,000 to $25,000 as at 2021.Choppair’s pleaded case was not its claim at trial, viz.:(a)first, the mitigation damages claim was abandoned and, over objection because it had not been pleaded, a claim was permitted to be advanced for damages for the value of the Engine;(b)secondly, the value of the Engine was submitted to be the sum of money that Choppair would have received pursuant to the Upgrade Opportunity, contended to be €400,000, but Choppair disavowed on the record making any claim for loss of opportunity; and(c)thirdly, the relevant “breach” was contended to be the disassembly of the Engine (not the transfer of the Engine to Pacific), a matter not pleaded against Airwork.On 1 August 2022, Judge Barlow KC entered judgment for Airwork and found:(a)the agreement was wholly in writing and comprised one document – a quote – sent by Airwork to Choppair on 11 November 2015;(b)the agreement was for the recalendaring of modules 1, 5 and the FCU with only those components to be disassembled (not the entire Engine);(c)Airwork breached the agreement because the entire Engine was disassembled and was not returned to Choppair;(d)the agreement was terminated by mutual agreement on 25 November 2016;(e)the new “loss” claimed by Choppair was a loss of opportunity claim that it had expressly disavowed, but in any event the trial Judge disposed of that argument by finding that the opportunity was not lost from Airwork’s breach because it was available after the relevant breach (the disassembly), and it was Choppair’s decision to not take it up, or it was unable to take it up, or both; and(f)the Engine’s value was $25,000 at the time it was delivered to Airwork, and was worth $20,000 after it had been bagged and tagged, with the result that Airwork’s breach caused a $5,000 diminution in value of the Engine; and(g)Choppair recovered more than that loss of value from its settlement with Pacific.The primary Judge ordered Choppair pay Airwork’s standard costs until 16 December 2021 and thereafter on the indemnity basis because of a joint formal offer made by Airwork and Pacific on 2 December 2021 to pay Choppair $60,000 and return the Engine. Choppair had conceded it should have to pay costs but opposed an order for indemnity costs.On 29 August 2022, Choppair filed a notice of appeal seeking the primary Judge’s orders be set aside and in lieu thereof judgment be entered for Choppair in the sum of €400,000 on the grounds that the primary Judge erred in:(a)finding that Choppair suffered no loss because of its settlement with Pacific;(b)failing to “draw the inference” that Choppair would have “acquired a different Helicopter and would have secured a trade-in for the Engine in the order of AUD $311,000.00”;(c)failing to find that the proper value of the Engine was “in the order of $311,000.00”; and(d)awarding Airwork its costs either at all or on the indemnity basis.On 4 October 2022, Airwork issued correspondence requesting Choppair provide security for costs or alternatively material that demonstrated Choppair would be able to meet an adverse costs order. Despite Choppair’s solicitor advising on two occasions that he would revert following instructions, no substantive response was provided. Choppair then failed to deliver its outline, list of authorities and draft index to record book by the (extended date) of 26 October 2022.On 1 November 2022, Airwork applied for security for costs. On 11 November 2022, Choppair agreed to pay security for costs in the sum of $35,000. That agreement was formalised by an order made by consent by McMurdo JA on 18 November 2022. Pursuant thereto, Choppair was to provide security by 4.00 pm on 25 November 2022. It did not do so. Rather, on 1 December 2022, Choppair’s solicitors forwarded an email from a separate solicitor John Maitland to Airwork’s solicitors wherein it was asserted (without any supporting material) that:(a)Choppair performed the “operational side” of a broader business group whilst another entity, “Red Balloon”, had the “financial side”;(b)the wife of Michael van der Zypp (Choppair’s sole director and shareholder) had “removed substantial sums of money and … prevented Choppair from calling on funds”;(c)Mr van der Zypp “brought the dispute before the Family Court to rectify the problem” which was taking longer than expected and was the reason for the delay in the provision of security;(d)in the circumstances, Choppair should request the appeal be vacated and re-listed on a later date; the appeal should remain stayed; and the matter be listed for directions early in 2023 at which time it was said to be expected the Family Court proceedings would be resolved and money released for the use of Choppair to pay security and proceed with its appeal.On 2 December 2022, Airwork applied for the appeal to be dismissed.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established