Chong v Logan City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Chong & Anor v Logan City Council [2016] QCA 12

PARTIES:

TYAM HEONG CHONG
(first applicant)
CHIN-JUI YANG
(second applicant)
v
LOGAN CITY COUNCIL
(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 4904 of 2015
P & E No 3933 of 2012

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

Application for Leave Sustainable Planning Act

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court at Brisbane – [2015] QPELR 484

DELIVERED ON:

5 February 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 September 2015

JUDGES:

Holmes CJ and Gotterson JA and McMeekin J
Separate reasons for judgment of each member of the Court, each concurring as to the orders made

ORDERS:

Leave to appeal granted.1.   

Appeal dismissed.2.   

Appellants to pay the respondent’s costs of the application and the appeal on the standard basis.3.   

CATCHWORDS:

ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING – COURTS AND TRIBUNALS WITH ENVIRONMENT JURISDICTION – QUEENSLAND – SUPREME COURT – LEAVE TO APPEAL – where the applicants are the owners of a fee simple estate interest of land – where the Logan City Council amended the Planning Scheme affecting the zoning of the applicants’ land – where relying on the change to the zoning of their land, the applicants lodged a claim with the Council to be paid reasonable compensation under s 705 SustainablePlanning Act 2009 (Qld) (SPA) – where the Council refused this claim – where the applicants filed an unsuccessful claim in the Planning and Environment Court – where the applicants filed an application for leave to appeal under s 498(2) SPA to the Court of Appeal – where quantum is not in issue – where the learned primary judge identified the issue in the case before the Court as whether a use for a food outlet or for a restaurant subject to being “carried out with but incidental and subordinate to” a public recreation is a use for a public purpose – where the primary judge found that the Council had “satisfied its onus of proof that the subject land could be used for a purpose other than only a public purpose and other than the purpose for which it was being used when the change was made” with the subsequent result that s 705 SPA could not be engaged – whether a restaurant or food outlet lawfully conducted on the applicant’s land would be a use of the land for a commercial purpose, and not for a public purpose – whether leave to appeal should be granted and the appeal allowed

Environmental Planning and Assessment Regulation 2000 (NSW)
Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld), s 255A, s 313, s 493(7), s 498(2), s 703, s 705, s 710(1)(c), s 711

Foodbarn Pty Ltd v Solicitor-General (1975) 32 LGRA 157, considered
Shire of Perth v O’Keefe (1964) 110 CLR 529; [1964] HCA 37, applied
Toner Design Pty Ltd v Newcastle City Council (2013) 198 LGERA 203; [2013] NSWCA 410, considered
Warringah Shire Council v Raffles [1979] 2 NSWLR 299, cited

COUNSEL:

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chong v Logan City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QCA 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Chong v Logan City Council, the applicants, who are the owners of a fee simple estate interest in land, challenged the Logan City Council's amendment to the Planning Scheme which affected the zoning of their land. The applicants sought compensation under section 705 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld), claiming that the amendment rendered their land unusable for the purposes it was intended. The Council refused the claim, and the applicants' subsequent appeal in the Planning and Environment Court was also unsuccessful. The applicants then applied for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was granted.

The central legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether a use for a food outlet or for a restaurant, subject to being "carried out with but incidental and subordinate to" a public recreation, constitutes a use for a public purpose. This determination was crucial because if the land could be used for a purpose other than a public purpose, section 705 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) would not apply. The primary judge found that the Council had demonstrated that the land could be used for purposes other than a public purpose, thus precluding the applicability of section 705.

The Court of Appeal upheld the primary judge's reasoning and dismissed the appeal. The Court concluded that the expression "could be used" in section 705 implies possibility rather than probability, and it was appropriate to consider whether the land could be used for a purpose other than a public purpose despite the zoning change. The Court allowed evidence from a town planner who confirmed that a low-intensity food outlet or restaurant could be approved if carried out in a manner subordinate to public recreation. The Court found no error in the primary judge's approach and upheld the dismissal of the appeal.

Leave to appeal was granted, but the appeal was dismissed. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs of the application and the appeal on the standard basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Leave to appeal granted.1.

Appeal dismissed.2.

Appellants to pay the respondent’s costs of the application and the appeal on the standard basis.3.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Chong, are the owners of a fee simple estate interest in a piece of land within the jurisdiction of the Logan City Council in Queensland. The Logan City Council amended the Planning Scheme, which affected the zoning of the applicants’ land. Based on this change, the applicants lodged a claim with the Council for reasonable compensation under s 705 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld). The Council refused this claim, leading the applicants to file a claim in the Planning and Environment Court, which was also unsuccessful. Consequently, the applicants filed an application for leave to appeal under s 498(2) of the SPA to the Court of Appeal. The issue before the Court of Appeal is whether a use for a food outlet or for a restaurant, carried out with but incidental and subordinate to a public recreation, constitutes a use for a public purpose.

The applicants initially filed a claim for compensation with the Logan City Council, which was denied. They subsequently took the matter to the Planning and Environment Court, where their claim was also unsuccessful. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the applicants filed an application for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal under s 498(2) of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld). The Court of Appeal considered the application and decided on whether to grant leave to appeal and, if granted, whether to allow the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It remains to note that Table 3.4.10 in Division 4 of Chapter 3 specifies overall outcomes for the Non-Urban and Conservation Locality. For the CZ14 sub-area, the overall outcome of development is the protection and enhancement of the existing and planned character and amenity of the sub-area “that relates to a district level wildlife corridor linking core conservation areas and other remnant bushland to provide multiple benefits, in particular, the protection of bushland and riparian habitats and the establishment of a wildlife corridor across Park Ridge”. For the NU7 sub-area, the overall outcome for development is the protection and enhancement of the existing and planned character and amenity of the sub-area “that predominantly relates to the riparian and terrestrial corridor between Koplick Road and Crestmead Park and provides stormwater conveyance and treatment, local wildlife corridor values and a spine for parks and other open space required for emerging communities”. However, as noted, the code assessability of a proposed development is not referenced specifically to overall outcomes, as it is to specific outcomes.The decision at first instance The learned primary judge identified the issue in the case before him as whether a use for a food outlet or for a restaurant subject to being “carried out with but incidental and subordinate to” a public recreation is a use for a public purpose.[12] That was because argument on the appeal had focused upon whether either of such uses of the applicants’ land would have the consequence that the land would be used for a purpose other than a public purpose. If either use had that consequence, then s 705 could not be engaged.[12]Reasons [80]. That his Honour’s identification of the issue was referenced to those two uses can be traced to a submission for the Council that code assessable uses available for the applicants’ land after the 2009 Amendment included “home business”, “food outlet” and “restaurant”. The submission continued with the proposition that since these code assessable uses were available, it was unnecessary to consider the availability of any impact assessable uses.[13][13]Council’s Outline of Submissions paragraphs 53, 54: AB279. His Honour rejected the Council’s submission insofar as it related to relevance of a “home business” use. He did so on the footing that such a use would be for the purpose for which the land was being lawfully used at the time of the change and therefore within the scope of the exception in s 705.[14] I mention also that his Honour’s use of the qualifying adjective “incidental” in the formulation of the issue is without foundation in the Planning Scheme. Its origin appears to have been a misquotation of ss 3.4.26 and 3.4.33 in the written submissions for the applicants at first instance.[15][14]Reasons [77].[15]AB261. As to interpretation of s 705, the learned primary judge concluded that the expression “could be used” in the section has the connotation of possibility rather than probability.[16] It was appropriate, his Honour said, to enquire whether, notwithstanding the change, it was possible to use the land in question for a purpose other than a public purpose. His Honour also allowed evidence of Mr G Ovenden, a town planner called in the Council’s case, as to the types and scale of a food outlet or restaurant that could be carried out subordinate to public recreation conformably with Specific Outcome 2 (b).[17] There is no challenge to his Honour’s allowance of that evidence in this appeal.[16]Reasons [61].[17]Reasons [64], [65]. Mr Ovenden’s report dated 7 March 2014 (part of exhibit 1 at first instance), to which he was referred in his evidence-in-chief, is not included in the Appeal Record. However, his earlier report dated 3 February 2013 (also part of exhibit 1) is included. In it, Mr Ovenden stated that a low intensity use as a food outlet or restaurant would be capable of being approved: AB161.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue before the court was whether a use for a food outlet or for a restaurant subject to being "carried out with but incidental and subordinate to" a public recreation is a use for a public purpose. The court found that the Council had satisfied its onus of proof that the subject land could be used for a purpose other than only a public purpose and other than the purpose for which it was being used when the change was made. The expression "could be used" in s 705 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (Qld) has the connotation of possibility rather than probability. It was appropriate to enquire whether, notwithstanding the change, it was possible to use the land in question for a purpose other than a public purpose. The court allowed evidence from a town planner who stated that a low intensity use as a food outlet or restaurant would be capable of being approved. The court held that since these uses were possible, the land could be used for a purpose other than a public purpose, and thus s 705 could not be engaged. Consequently, the applicants were not entitled to compensation under s 705. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that a use for a food outlet or for a restaurant, even if carried out with but incidental and subordinate to a public recreation, qualifies as a use for a commercial purpose, not a public purpose, potentially excluding compensation under s 705. The court did not depart from prior authority but clarified the interpretation of "could be used" in the context of the statute.