Chirenda v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

[2015] AATA   64

Division

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2014/3425

Re

Kundayi Chirenda

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member C R Walsh

Date 6 February 2015
Place Perth

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

......(Sgd) CR Walsh.........................................

Senior Member C R Walsh

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – applicant eligible for Australian citizenship by conferral – applicant a permanent resident and aged under 18 years - whether discretion to refuse applicant becoming an Australian citizenship should be applied - best interests of the child – general residence requirement - significant hardship or disadvantage - decision under review affirmed  

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 – s 21(1) - s 21(5) – s 22(1) – s 22(1A) – s 22(1B) -  s 22A – s 22B – s 23 – s 21(5) – s 24(1) – s 24(1A) - s 24(2)

Migration Act 1958 – s 6 – s 30(1)

CASES

Kamahi v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] AATA 730

Park and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 886

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Australian Citizenship Instructions – Chapter 5 – 5.11.1 – 5.11.2 – 5.12 – 5.17.2

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member C R Walsh

6 February 2015

INTRODUCTION

  1. At issue in this application is whether the Tribunal should exercise the discretion in s 24(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Citizenship Act) to refuse Mr Chirenda, who was aged under 18 years when he applied for Australian citizenship, becoming an Australian citizen despite him being eligible to become an Australian citizen under s 21(5) of the Citizenship Act.

    FACTUAL & PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

  2. Mr Chirenda is a Zimbabwean national born on 17 July 1996 who is currently 18 years of age.

  3. In 2008, Mr Chirenda was granted a Subclass (Business (Long Stay)) visa.

  4. Mr Chirenda first arrived in Australia on 19 December 2010, but he subsequently departed and returned to Australia twice.

  5. On 12 May 2011, Mr Chirenda was granted a Subclass 856 Employer Nomination (Residence) (Class BW) visa as a member of his father’s family unit.

  6. By a signed “Application for Australian citizenship – Other situations” form, dated 17 December 2013, Mr Chirenda applied for Australian citizenship by conferral.  Mr Chirenda’s citizenship application was not, however, received by the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Department) until 30 May 2014, (Citizenship Application). 

  7. Mr Chirenda was 17 years of age at the time of the Citizenship Application.

  8. The Department’s movement records for Mr Chirenda show that he had spent 45 full days in Australia at the time of the Citizenship Application.

  9. On 5 June 2014, a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Minister) decided to refuse the Citizenship Application under s 24(1) of the Citizenship Act (Citizenship Decision).[1] 

    [1] The Citizenship Decision erroneously refers to the Citizenship Decision as having been made under s 24(1A) of the Citizenship Act,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chirenda v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 64
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr Chirenda, a Zimbabwean national, appealed a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection that refused to grant him Australian citizenship. The primary issue before the court was whether the Minister correctly exercised his discretion under section 24 of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 to refuse Mr Chirenda's citizenship application. The court also needed to determine if the Minister considered Mr Chirenda's best interests when exercising his discretion. Given Mr Chirenda was under 18 years old at the time of the application and decision, the court considered the relevant Ministerial policy and guidelines, specifically those set out in the Australian Citizenship Instructions, which outline the requirements for applicants aged 16 and 17.

The court found that Mr Chirenda met the general residence requirement and had been a permanent resident at the relevant times. However, the court concluded that Mr Chirenda did not demonstrate significant hardship or disadvantage that would warrant an exception to the general residence requirement. The court considered Mr Chirenda's submissions regarding his aspirations to join the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) and his family's financial situation. The court held that Mr Chirenda's desire to join the RAN was a personal aspiration, not a personal need that would amount to significant hardship or disadvantage under the Ministerial policy. The court also noted that any financial benefit Mr Chirenda could have derived from joining the RAN could potentially be offset by income from alternative employment.

The court found that the Minister had properly considered Mr Chirenda's best interests in exercising his discretion to refuse the citizenship application. The court held that the Minister's decision was lawful and affirmed the decision under review.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Paragraph 5.12 of the ACIs, titled “Applicants aged 16 or 17”, provides the following guidance in relation to citizenship applicants aged 16 and 17:Applicants aged 16 and 17 at time of application must make an application on a form that contains no other application.Applicants aged 16 and 17 would not usually be approved under s24 unless they are permanent residents at the time of application and decision and also meet the following policy guidelines:· satisfies the residence requirement (unless they would suffer significant hardship or disadvantage if they had to meet this requirement). See section 5.17 Ministerial discretion – significant hardship or disadvantage (s22(6)) for guidance· understands the nature of an application· possesses a basic knowledge of the English language· has an adequate knowledge of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship at the time of decision· is likely to reside or continue to reside, or maintain a close and continuing association with Australia.……..In the case of an applicant who does not meet the policy guidelines above, decision makers must consider the full circumstances of the case, including the best interest of the child (see section 5.11.2 Best interests of the child) to determine whether the application nevertheless warrants approval because of the unusual nature of those circumstances. [Emphasis added] It is uncontroversial that in reviewing a decision, the Tribunal will ordinarily apply a statement of Ministerial policy, such as the ACIs, unless “the policy is unlawful or unless its application tends to produce an unjust decision in the circumstances of the particular case”: see Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634 at 645 per Brennan J. There is no cogent reason why the ACIs should not apply in Mr Chirenda’s case. As stated, Mr Chirenda was 17 at the time of the Citizenship Application. As such, Mr Chirenda is required by paragraph 5.12 of the ACIs (set out in paragraph 18 above) to have been a “permanent resident” at the time of the Citizenship Application and the Citizenship Decision (which he was) and to satisfy the “general residence requirement” (in s 22(1) of the Citizenship Act), unless he would suffer “significant hardship or disadvantage” if he had to meet that requirement.General residence requirement Section 22(1) of the Citizenship Act sets out the “general residence requirement”, and s 22(1A) and s 22(1B) of the Citizenship Act allow an applicant a certain amount of overseas absences for the purpose of satisfying the “general residence requirement”, as follows:22 General residence requirement(1)Subject to this section, for the purposes of section 21 a person satisfies the general residence requirement if:(a)the person was present in Australia for the period of 4 years immediately before the day the person made the application; and(b)the person was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen at any time during that 4 year period; and(c)the person was present in Australia as a permanent resident for the period of 12 months immediately before the day the person made the application. Overseas absences(1A) If:(a)the person was absent from Australia for a part of the period of 4 years immediately before the day the person made the application; and(b)the total period of the absence or absences was not more than 12 months;Then, for the purposes of paragraph (1)(a), the person is taken to have been present in Australia during each period of absence.(1B) If:(a)the person was absent from Australia for a part of the period of 12 months immediately before the day the person made the application; and(b)the total period of the absence or absences was not more than 90 days; and (c)the person was a permanent resident during each period of absence;then, for the purposes of paragraph (1)(c), the person is taken to have been present in Australia as a permanent resident during each period of absence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Chirenda made substantially similar verbal submissions before the Tribunal.Statutory Declaration of Mr Chirenda’s father Mr Chirenda also provided a Statutory Declaration, made by his father (Mr Givemore Chirenda) on 23 October 2014 (Chirenda’s Father’s SD). Chirenda’s Father’s SD repeats many of the claims made by Mr Chirenda in the Chirenda SD regarding the hardship that Mr Chirenda will face if he is unable to obtain Australian citizenship. Relevantly, Chirenda’s Father’s SD states:· There is “no assurance or reason that [Mr Chirenda] will be given another permanent residence visa that would enable him to apply for his citizenship” and once his current permanent residency visa expires [Mr Chirenda] may be in a position “where he is forced to return to Zimbabwe” where he “would face enormous emotional and financial hardship”: Chirenda’s Father’s SD at [15] to [17];· Without Australian citizenship, Mr Chirenda’s options will be very limited, and Mr Chirenda will not be able to go to university as he will not be eligible for a HECS-HELP loan (i.e.as a non-citizen) and his family is unable to financially support him in his studies: Chirenda’s Father’s SD at [21]; and· Without Australian citizenship, Mr Chirenda would not be able to pursue his ambition of joining the RAN and would be forced to “do something irrelevant to his goals”: Chirenda’s Father’s SD at [22].RAN eligibility Australian citizenship is a requirement for entry into the RAN and Mr Chirenda raises his ineligibility to join the RAN as the main form of hardship that he will suffer if he is refused Australian citizenship. As stated above (in paragraph 27), paragraph 5.17.2 of the ACIs provides that “inability to gain employment on the grounds that employment is restricted to Australian citizens” may, in some situations, amount to “significant hardship or disadvantage.” However, paragraph 5.17.2 of the ACIs requires that, for this to be the case, a person must demonstrate that “comparable or alternative employment is not reasonably available”. Mr Chirenda has not demonstrated that refusal of Australian citizenship will prevent him from obtaining “alternative employment”. Instead, his evidence suggests that alternative, albeit “menial”, employment is a possibility for him. Consequently, consistent with paragraph 5.17.2 of the ACIs, Mr Chirenda has not demonstrated “significant hardship or disadvantage” in relation to his “inability to gain employment” as a consequence of being refused Australian citizenship. As submitted by the Minister, properly characterised, Mr Chirenda’s desire to join the RAN is merely an aspiration. It is a “personal want” as opposed to a “personal need” in the sense described in paragraph 5.17.2 of the ACIs: refer to paragraph 27 above. The fact that being denied Australian citizenship prevents Mr Chirenda from joining the RAN and obtaining RAN income, part of which he says he could then contribute to his family, does not amount to significant “financial” hardship or disadvantage as any income he earns from “alternative employment” could be put to the same use. Similarly, any benefit to Mr Chirenda’s family that may result from Mr Chirenda securing RAN accommodation could equally arise from the applicant putting his income from “alternative employment” towards his family’s housing costs.