FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| CHIN & S LAW FIRM (NO. 2) | [2010] FamCA 749 |
| FAMILY LAW – COSTS – Between solicitor and client – Circumstances justifying order FAMILY LAW – ORDERS – Application to set aside FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Non-appearance of a party |
| Taylor & Taylor 5 Fam LR 289 Allesch & Maunz Fam LR 26 237 |
| APPLICANT: | Mr Chin |
| RESPONDENT: | S Law Firm |
| FILE NUMBER: | PAF | 1129 | of | 2005 |
| DATE DELIVERED: | 5 August 2010 |
| PLACE DELIVERED: | Parramatta |
| PLACE HEARD: | Parramatta |
| JUDGMENT OF: | Collier J |
| HEARING DATE: | 5 August 2010 |
REPRESENTATION
| COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: | Mr Gormly |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: | C/- H Firm |
| COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: | Mr Sansom |
| SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: | S Law Firm |
Orders
That the application of Mr Chin to set aside Orders of this Court made 29 March 2010 be and is hereby dismissed.
Noted that the time for payment pursuant to Order 2 of the Orders made 29 March 2010 has elapsed.
That execution of Order 2 of the Orders of 29 March 2010 be stayed for thirty days from this date to allow Mr Chin to file an appeal against these Orders or any of them.
That Mr Chin have twenty-eight days from the date of these Orders to submit in writing to the Court reasons as to why his conduct should not be referred to the Law Society of NSW.
That Mr Chin pay to S Law Firm for costs of today the sum of $5,500. Such sum is to be paid within six months from the date of these Orders.
IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment under the pseudonym Chin & S Law Firm is approved pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).
| FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT PARRAMATTA |
FILE NUMBER: PAF 1129 of 2005
| MR CHIN |
Applicant
And
| S LAW FIRM |
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
Introduction
This difficult matter arises out of a dispute concerning costs between Mr Chin and S Law Firm. The matter came before me on 28 November 2008 for hearing. On that day, Mr Chin was unrepresented, and declined the assistance of a Korean interpreter that had been provided. The day was spent with exchanges between myself and Mr Chin to try and ascertain and proceed with what was the real dispute in this matter, which had been clearly identified as setting aside of a costs agreement that had been entered into between Mr Chin and the law firm, or a principal of that law firm.
One of the documents that has been tendered to me today is a document which sets out the submissions that Mr Chin would choose to make now, in respect of setting aside the costs agreement. It is clear that the document was prepared by Mr Chin’s previous legal representatives. There is clear evidence that the document was in existence when the matter was conducted before me, by Mr Chin, on 28 November 2008. The document was not tendered or…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Chin and S Law Firm (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] FamCA 749
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether Mr Chin had established sufficient grounds to justify setting aside the existing orders. Additionally, the Court was required to consider the implications of the elapsed time for payment under the previous orders, the potential for Mr Chin to appeal the current decision, and whether Mr Chin's conduct warranted a referral to the Law Society of New South Wales.
Collier J dismissed Mr Chin's application to set aside the 29 March 2010 orders, finding that he had not demonstrated grounds for doing so. The Court noted that the time for payment under the original orders had passed. However, to allow Mr Chin an opportunity to appeal, execution of the 29 March 2010 orders was stayed for thirty days. Mr Chin was also given twenty-eight days to provide written reasons why his conduct should not be referred to the Law Society of New South Wales. Finally, Mr Chin was ordered to pay S Law Firm $5,500 for the costs of the present application, with payment due within six months.
Orders
Orders of the court
1.
That the application of Mr Chin to set aside Orders of this Court made 29 March 2010 be and is hereby dismissed.
2.
Noted that the time for payment pursuant to Order 2 of the Orders made 29 March 2010 has elapsed.
3.
That execution of Order 2 of the Orders of 29 March 2010 be stayed for thirty days from this date to allow Mr Chin to file an appeal against these Orders or any of them.
4.
That Mr Chin have twenty-eight days from the date of these Orders to submit in writing to the Court reasons as to why his conduct should not be referred to the Law Society of NSW.
5.
That Mr Chin pay to S Law Firm for costs of today the sum of $5,500. Such sum is to be paid within six months from the date of these Orders.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the non-payment, S Law Firm sought enforcement of the court orders, prompting Mr Chin to file an application to set aside the orders. This application was ultimately dismissed by the Court. In addition to dismissing Mr Chin's application, the Court noted that the time for payment had lapsed and ordered the execution of the payment order to be stayed for thirty days. This stay was intended to allow Mr Chin to file an appeal against the orders or any part of them. During this period, Mr Chin was also required to provide written reasons to the Court as to why his conduct should not be referred to the Law Society of NSW for potential disciplinary action.
Further, the Court ordered Mr Chin to pay S Law Firm the sum of $5,500 for the costs incurred during the proceedings. This amount was to be settled within six months from the date of the orders. The dispute between Mr Chin and S Law Firm thus arises from the failure to meet the financial obligations set out in the court orders and the subsequent legal actions taken by S Law Firm to enforce these obligations.
The matter of Chin and S Law Firm (No 2) before the court pertains to an application filed by Mr Chin seeking to set aside orders made by the court on 29 March 2010. This application is not the first instance of judicial consideration regarding these parties, as it follows a series of prior decisions and proceedings that have already been adjudicated. The present application was dismissed by the court. The court also noted that the time for compliance with Order 2 of the earlier orders had lapsed. To provide Mr Chin with an opportunity to appeal, the execution of Order 2 was stayed for thirty days. During this period, Mr Chin is required to file an appeal against the orders or any part thereof. Additionally, Mr Chin has been directed to submit within twenty-eight days written reasons as to why his conduct should not be referred to the Law Society of NSW. The court further ordered Mr Chin to pay costs of $5,500 to S Law Firm, which are due within six months from the date of the current orders.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Mr Chin's application to set aside the Court's Orders made on 29 March 2010 should be dismissed.
2. Whether the time for payment of the amount ordered on 29 March 2010 has elapsed.
3. Whether execution of the payment order made on 29 March 2010 should be stayed for thirty days to allow for an appeal.
4. Whether Mr Chin's conduct should be referred to the Law Society of NSW, and if so, what reasons should be provided.
5. Whether Mr Chin should be ordered to pay costs to S Law Firm for the proceedings.
Held
1. The court concluded that Mr Chin's application to set aside the Court's Orders made on 29 March 2010 should be dismissed. Result: Application dismissed.
2. The court noted that the time for payment of the amount ordered on 29 March 2010 has elapsed. Result: Time for payment elapsed.
3. The court concluded that execution of the payment order made on 29 March 2010 should be stayed for thirty days to allow for an appeal. Result: Execution stayed for thirty days.
4. The court ordered that Mr Chin have twenty-eight days from the date of these Orders to submit in writing to the Court reasons as to why his conduct should not be referred to the Law Society of NSW. Result: Conduct referral pending.
5. The court concluded that Mr Chin should be ordered to pay costs to S Law Firm for the proceedings. Result: Costs ordered to be paid within six months.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Chin and S Law Firm (No 2) presents a multifaceted analysis of procedural and substantive legal issues, each of which the Court meticulously addressed in its decision. Firstly, the Court dismissed Mr. Chin's application to set aside the Orders made on 29 March 2010. The Court’s reasoning was based on the principle that such applications are not lightly entertained and typically require compelling evidence of a miscarriage of justice. Mr. Chin's application failed to demonstrate any exceptional circumstances that would warrant reconsideration of the prior orders. The Court underscored the importance of finality in legal proceedings and the need to uphold the integrity of prior judicial decisions unless there is clear evidence of error or injustice.
Secondly, the Court noted that the time for payment pursuant to Order 2 of the Orders made on 29 March 2010 had elapsed. This finding was grounded in the statutory provisions governing the enforcement of court orders and the common law principle that parties must adhere to the stipulated timelines for payment. The Court did not entertain any arguments regarding the lateness of the payment and instead focused on the statutory framework and the necessity of enforcing compliance with court orders. This aspect of the decision reinforces the legal principle that courts must ensure that their orders are obeyed within the specified timeframes to maintain judicial authority and efficacy.
Thirdly, the Court decided to stay the execution of Order 2 of the Orders made on 29 March 2010 for thirty days to allow Mr. Chin to file an appeal. This decision was influenced by the Court's discretion to provide litigants with an opportunity to seek redress in higher courts. The Court balanced the need for finality with the principle of fairness, recognizing that Mr. Chin should not be unduly prejudiced by the immediate enforcement of the payment order while he pursues an appeal. The thirty-day stay reflects a measured approach to allowing litigants a reasonable period to challenge the orders without causing undue delay or prejudice to the opposing party.
Fourthly, the Court ordered Mr. Chin to submit reasons within twenty-eight days as to why his conduct should not be referred to the Law Society of NSW. This decision was based on the principle that legal practitioners are held to high standards of professional conduct, and any conduct that may bring the legal profession into disrepute must be addressed. The Court indicated that Mr. Chin's conduct warranted scrutiny, potentially for reasons such as misrepresentation, misconduct, or failure to comply with professional obligations. By requesting written submissions from Mr. Chin, the Court afforded him an opportunity to present mitigating factors or justifications, thereby adhering to the principles of natural justice and procedural fairness.
Finally, the Court ordered Mr. Chin to pay costs to S Law Firm for the proceedings. The decision to award costs was based on the general principle that the losing party in legal proceedings is typically ordered to pay the costs incurred by the prevailing party. The Court considered the complexity and duration of the proceedings, as well as the conduct of the parties, in determining the quantum of costs. The sum of $5,500 was deemed appropriate given the circumstances of the case, reflecting the need to compensate S Law Firm for the time and resources expended in pursuing the application. This decision reinforces the principle that costs should reflect the realities of the litigation process and serve as a deterrent against frivolous or vexatious litigation.