Child Support Registrar and Kanavos and Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR & KANAVOS & ORS [2009] FMCAfam 871
CHILD SUPPORT – Credibility of witnesses – non-disclosure – secret trusts – most appropriate form of enforcement.

Family Law Rules 1984 Order 33

Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 r 1.05

French v French (1902) 1 IR 172
Ottaway v Norman (1972) 1 CH 698
Voges & Monaghan (1954) 94 CLR 231
Weir (1993) FLC 92-338
Applicant: CHILD SUPPORT REGISTRAR
First Respondent: MR KANAVOS
Second Respondent: MS KANAVOS
Third Respondent: [W] PTY LTD
File Number: SYC3565 of 2007
Judgment of: Altobelli FM
Hearing dates: 17 September 2007, 20 November 2007, 26 February 2008, 2 April 2009, 3 & 4 June 2009
Date of Last Submission: 4 June 2009
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 20 August 2009

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Quinn
Solicitors for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the first, second and third Respondent: Mr Alexander
Solicitors for the first, second and third Respondent: Graham Chegwidden Solicitors

DECLARATION

  1. The Court makes the following declaration:

    (a)That as at 2 June 2009 there is owing to the Commonwealth in respect of amounts owing under the registered maintenance liabilities of the Respondent the sum of $270,881.77 (being $170,892.47 in arrears of child support and $99,989.30 in late payment penalties).

ORDERS

  1. That the Respondent pay to the Child Support Registrar the sum of $270,881.77.

  2. That payment of the amounts payable in orders 2 and 3 herein be paid to the Applicant by payments as follows:

    (a)by minimum instalment payment of $2,000.00 per month commencing on 7 September 2009 and being payable on or before the 7th day of each month (being inclusive of amounts which may be paid by way of garnishment orders herein); and

    (b)the whole of the remaining balance of the debt payable under these orders as a lump sum on or before 7 September 2012 (or such earlier time in accordance with order 24 hereof).

Garnishment order in respect to [W] Pty Ltd

  1. That a garnishment order be made against [W] Pty. Ltd of the registered office at [address omitted] in the State of New South Wales ("the company"), directing that on or before 7 September at 2009 the company do all acts and things necessary to cause payments to be paid on a monthly basis directly to the Applicant as detailed below:

    (a)the normal deduction rate to be deducted from the Respondent’s earnings is in the sum of 30 cents in every dollar (after tax);

    (b)the amount referred to in sub-paragraph (a) hereof is to be paid to the Child Support Registrar at 130 George Street, Parramatta in the State of NSW.

    (c)the payment shall commence on or before 7 September 2009, or as agreed with the Applicant, should the Respondent prefer these deductions to be consolidated with deductions of current child support.

    (d)the protected earnings rate in relation to the Respondent’s earnings is fixed in the sum of $300.00 per week;

  2. That until further order of the Court, the Respondent…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Child Support Registrar and Kanavos and Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FMCAfam 871
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, the case of Child Support Registrar and Kanavos and Ors was heard and decided. The dispute involved the enforcement of child support obligations. The Child Support Registrar sought enforcement of child support arrears owed by the Respondents, who were the parents of the child. The Registrar also sought to enforce garnishment orders against the Respondents’ company and its customers, as well as a sale of the Respondents’ motor vehicle to satisfy the debt.

The court was required to determine whether the Registrar had the authority to enforce the child support arrears and whether the proposed enforcement measures were appropriate. The court needed to assess the appropriateness of the garnishment orders, the sale of the motor vehicle, and the restraining orders. The legal issues included the enforceability of child support orders, the validity of garnishment orders, and the appropriateness of the proposed sale and restraining orders.

The court found that the Registrar had the authority to enforce the child support arrears and that the proposed enforcement measures were appropriate. The garnishment orders were deemed necessary to ensure that the child support payments were made directly to the Registrar. The sale of the motor vehicle was considered a reasonable measure to satisfy the debt. The restraining orders were also found to be necessary to prevent the Respondents from evading their child support obligations.

The court ordered the Respondents to pay the child support arrears to the Registrar. The court also ordered the enforcement of garnishment orders against the Respondents’ company and its customers, directing that payments be made directly to the Registrar. The court further ordered the sale of the Respondents’ motor vehicle to satisfy the debt, with the proceeds applied to the debt and the remainder, if any, to the First Respondent. The court imposed restraining orders to prevent the Respondents from evading their child support obligations.

Orders

Orders of the court

2.

That the Respondent pay to the Child Support Registrar the sum of $270,881.77.

3.

That payment of the amounts payable in orders 2 and 3 herein be paid to the Applicant by payments as follows:

(a) by minimum instalment payment of $2,000.00 per month commencing on 7 September 2009 and being payable on or before the 7th day of each month (being inclusive of amounts which may be paid by way of garnishment orders herein); and

(b) the whole of the remaining balance of the debt payable under these orders as a lump sum on or before 7 September 2012 (or such earlier time in accordance with order 24 hereof).

Garnishment order in respect to [W] Pty Ltd

4.

That a garnishment order be made against [W] Pty. Ltd of the registered office at [address omitted] in the State of New South Wales ("the company"), directing that on or before 7 September at 2009 the company do all acts and things necessary to cause payments to be paid on a monthly basis directly to the Applicant as detailed below:

(a) the normal deduction rate to be deducted from the Respondent’s earnings is in the sum of 30 cents in every dollar (after tax);

(b) the amount referred to in sub-paragraph (a) hereof is to be paid to the Child Support Registrar at 130 George Street, Parramatta in the State of NSW.

(c) the payment shall commence on or before 7 September 2009, or as agreed with the Applicant, should the Respondent prefer these deductions to be consolidated with deductions of current child support.

(d) the protected earnings rate in relation to the Respondent’s earnings is fixed in the sum of $300.00 per week;

5.

That until further order of the Court, the Respondent notify the Child Support Registrar at 130 George Street, Parramatta in the State of NSW, immediately (or at least within 7 days) upon either:

(a) his ceasing, or altering the terms of his employment with any person, company or entity; and /or

(b) his commencing employment with any person, company or entity, and that he advise the name and address of that employer.

6.

That there be liberty to restore the matter to the court list upon 7 days notice in respect to compliance with these Orders.

Garnishment order in respect to customers of [W] Pty Ltd

7.

That a garnishment order be made against customers of [W] Pty. Ltd ("the company") as specified in the attached schedule of garnishees directing that each of the said customers so specified (each described hereinafter as a " garnishee") do all acts and things necessary to cause monies which are due to be paid by them to the company, to be paid instead to the office of the Child Support Registrar in satisfaction of debts under these orders (the "garnishment payments") in accordance with the following:

(a) pay at a normal deduction rate to be deducted from monies payable to the company in the sum of 50 cents in every dollar payable (after tax);

(b) any amount payable in accordance with sub-paragraph (a) hereof is to be paid to the Child Support Registrar at 130 George Street, Parramatta in the State of NSW.

(c) the payment shall commence on or before 7 September 2009.

(d) the protected earnings rate in relation to payments under this order is fixed in at 50% [of each invoice transaction];

8.

That the garnishment payments be paid to the Child Support Registrar at 130 George Street, Parramatta in the State of NSW and be identified by the garnishee as payable in CSA case Number [8].

9.

That the garnishment payments be paid to the Child Support Registrar within 7 days of any payment which may be made to the company.

10.

That the company provide to the Child Support Registrar at 130 George Street, Parramatta in the State of NSW marked to the attention of Ms Vanessa Sacco, a copy of each invoice issued by the company to any client for work or services, conducted or of products or materials provided and that the company do so within 7 days of the issuing of any such invoice.

11.

That until further order of the Court, the Respondent notify the Child Support Registrar at 130 George Street, Parramatta in the State of NSW, immediately (or at least within 7 days) upon his commencing employment with any person or entity, the name and address of that employer.

12.

That a person who makes a payment in compliance with these orders is taken to have made the payment under the company’s authority or the authority of any other person concerned and is indemnified in respect of that payment.

Restraining Orders

13.

That the Respondent and all officers of the company be restrained from engaging in business, issuing any invoices for work, service, products or materials, except under the name and payable to [W] Pty. Ltd.

14.

That Mr Kanavos, Ms Kanavos, any person acting as agent or at their request, and any company or entity controlled by them or in which they have an interest, be restrained for a period of two years from approaching, dealing with, or engaging in any business transaction for a period of 2 years with respect to the customers of the business conducted by [W] Pty. Ltd including any customer with whom that company has had a previous dealing.

15.

That Mr Kanavos, Ms Kanavos, any person, company or entity acting as agent or at their request and [W] Pty. Ltd. be restrained, except in the course of ordinary business, from selling or disposing of the business of [W], or selling, transferring, further encumbering, or otherwise dealing with any of the business conducted by [W] Pty. Ltd., including, the sale or transfer, or assignment of any share in the company, the sale, transfer gift or assignment of any of the assets or plant used in the business, and from removing from the principle place of business or of any storage facility (except to the principle place of business) of any tool, machinery, motor vehicle, equipment, or any stock in trade or materials.

General orders applying to the garnishment orders

16.

That a sealed copy of these Orders be released to the Applicant expeditiously.

17.

That a sealed copy of these orders be served on the company and any garnishee specified in the schedule hereto within 10 days of the release of sealed copy of these Order.

Orders in respect to shares of [W] Pty Ltd

18.

That the First and Second Respondent shall within 14 days of the date of these orders do all things and cause all documents to be signed to cause all shares in the company [W] Pty. Ltd. held in the name of the Second Respondent, Ms Kanavos, ("the company shares") to be transferred to the First Respondent.

19.

That the debt under these Orders be charged over the shares of the company [W] Pty. Ltd.

Orders under s.106A of the Family Law Act for signature of documents

20.

That, in the event that the First Respondent or Second Respondent are in default of any request pursuant to any order herein requiring their signature, the trustee, or a Registrar of the Court, shall be empowered to sign all documents and do all things on behalf of the Respondent as may be necessary to transfer the Respondent’s interest in the property into the name of the trustee.

Liberty to apply provision as to execution and implementation of these Orders

21.

That the Applicant be at liberty to apply herein with respect to the terms and conditions and execution of the sale and the implementation of these orders generally.

22.

The Sheriff of NSW be appointed for seizure and sale of the Holden Commodore motor vehicle registered in the name [SS] Pty Ltd (or [SS] Pty Ltd), the details of which are to be provided to the solicitor for the Applicant within 24 hours; to be inserted in these as: Registration No. (to be advised), Engine No. (to be advised), Chassis No. (to be advised).

23.

That the said motor vehicle be realised by the Sheriff and sold at auction for the best price obtainable and the proceeds be applied:

(a) In payment of reasonable costs of seizure and sale;

(b) In payment of the debt herein;

(c) The remainder if any to the First Respondent.

24.

That the debt under these orders be charged over the motor vehicle.

25.

If there is to be an application for costs such application is to be made by way of written submissions, no greater than 500 words, to be filed and served within 21 days.

Any response to an application for costs be made by way of written submissions, no greater than 500 words, to be filed and served within