Chief Commissioner of Police v Crupi

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GAGELER CJ,
EDELMAN AND BEECH-JONES JJ

CHIEF COMMISSIONER OF POLICE  APPLICANT

AND

VINCENZO CRUPI & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Chief Commissioner of Police v Crupi

[2024] HCA 34

Date of Hearing: 20 August 2024
Date of Judgment: 11 September 2024

M83/2023

ORDER

1.Special leave to appeal is granted in respect of the applicant's first proposed ground of appeal.

2.Appeal allowed.

3.Set aside the orders of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 16 November 2022.

4.Remit the matter to the Supreme Court of Victoria for determination.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of Victoria

Representation

S J Maharaj KC with C J Tran for the applicant (instructed by Victorian Government Solicitor's Office)

D A Dann KC with L Z Richter for the first respondent (instructed by Stary Norton Halphen)

C T Carr SC with H L Canham appearing as amici curiae

Submitting appearance for the second respondent

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. GAGELER CJ, EDELMAN AND BEECH-JONES JJ.   This is an application for special leave to appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria that ordered the Chief Commissioner of Police to produce documents concerning an informer in circumstances where it was found that the information in at least some of the documents was likely to be of substantial assistance to the defence of a person charged with murder. The Chief Commissioner objected to the production, contending that, inter alia, such production was likely to lead to the identification of the informer and seriously risk his or her safety.

  2. The reasons of the primary judge were extremely brief. They did not disclose any process of weighing the competing public interests for and against production as required by s 130(1) of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), and they did not justify the order for production that was made. In not doing so, the primary judge did not comply with his obligation to give adequate reasons. A purported appeal from the primary judge's decision to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria (Emerton P, Niall and Taylor JJA) was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.[1] In the exceptional circumstances of this case, special leave to appeal to this Court from the primary judge's decision should be granted and the appeal allowed.

    Background

  3. On 9 November 2018, the first respondent, Vincenzo Crupi, was charged with the murder of Giuseppe "Pino" Acquaro. The first respondent has been on bail since March 2021. Mr Acquaro was a solicitor who had provided information to the police. He was shot on 15 March 2016 and died from his wounds. The Court of Appeal noted that it was likely that, at his trial, the first respondent would submit that there were other persons who had a motive to kill Mr Acquaro.

  4. The applicant in this Court, the Chief Commissioner…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chief Commissioner of Police v Crupi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] HCA 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered an appeal by the Chief Commissioner of Police against a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria concerning the disclosure of documents in a criminal proceeding. The first respondent, Vincenzo Crupi, was charged with murder, and the Chief Commissioner sought to resist disclosure of certain documents on the grounds of public interest immunity. The core of the dispute involved approximately 600 pages of material, referred to as "PII material," the disclosure of which the Chief Commissioner argued would risk revealing the identity of an informer, known as "Informer Z," and endanger their safety.

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the primary judge had complied with the obligation under s 130(1) of the *Evidence Act 2008* (Vic) to provide adequate reasons for ordering the disclosure of the PII material, and whether the primary judge had properly conducted the required balancing exercise between the competing public interests. Section 130(1) mandates a weighing of the public interest in favour of disclosure against the public interest against disclosure. The Court of Appeal had previously dismissed an appeal from the primary judge's decision for want of jurisdiction.

The High Court found that the primary judge's reasons, which comprised only five paragraphs, were inadequate. The reasons failed to disclose any process of weighing the competing public interests as required by s 130(1) of the *Evidence Act 2008* (Vic). The primary judge's statement that the information "may be of substantial assistance to the defence" and was "likely to be of substantial assistance" did not demonstrate the necessary balancing exercise. Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders of the Supreme Court of Victoria, and remitted the matter to that court for determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Special leave to appeal is granted in respect of the applicant's first proposed ground of appeal.

2. Appeal allowed.

3. Set aside the orders of the Supreme Court of Victoria made on 16 November 2022.

4. Remit the matter to the Supreme Court of Victoria for determination.

Background

Background to the litigation

The reasons of the primary judge were extremely brief. They did not disclose any process of weighing the competing public interests for and against production as required by s 130(1) of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), and they did not justify the order for production that was made. In not doing so, the primary judge did not comply with his obligation to give adequate reasons. A purported appeal from the primary judge's decision to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria (Emerton P, Niall and Taylor JJA) was dismissed for want of jurisdiction.[1] In the exceptional circumstances of this case, special leave to appeal to this Court from the primary judge's decision should be granted and the appeal allowed. [1]Chief Commissioner of Police v Crupi (2023) 72 VR 280. Background On 9 November 2018, the first respondent, Vincenzo Crupi, was charged with the murder of Giuseppe "Pino" Acquaro. The first respondent has been on bail since March 2021. Mr Acquaro was a solicitor who had provided information to the police. He was shot on 15 March 2016 and died from his wounds. The Court of Appeal noted that it was likely that, at his trial, the first respondent would submit that there were other persons who had a motive to kill Mr Acquaro. The applicant in this Court, the Chief Commissioner of Police, disclosed a substantial number of documents to the first respondent about Mr Acquaro and the threats to his life. However, the applicant sought to resist disclosure of additional documents, comprising approximately 600 pages ("the PII material"), on the ground of public interest immunity because disclosure might reveal the identity of an informer ("Informer Z") or enable his or her identity to be ascertained. An application to resist disclosure of the PII material was heard and dismissed by the primary judge on 16 November 2022. The second respondent to this application, the Director of Public Prosecutions (Vic), did not play any active part in the application before the primary judge. The first respondent did not have access to the PII material and, accordingly, did not take any active part in that application either. However, the primary judge had the assistance of submissions from amici curiae who had access to the PII material. The primary judge's reasons consisted of five paragraphs. The only substantive reasoning of the primary judge was as follows:"I am persuaded by the written submissions and the oral submissions of the amici that in relation to [Informer Z] that there is good reason to think that should that information ... be disclosed to the defence, that it may be of substantial assistance to the defence in the conduct of their case.Indeed I would go further and say that based on the reasons advanced by the amici - I make particular reference to their written submissions - it seems to me that it is likely to be of substantial assistance to the defence in the conduct of their case.I am therefore of the view that the [applicant] ... has not made good his claim in relation to what I will call the [Informer Z] material, and ... I reject his application." (emphasis added)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GAGELER CJ, EDELMAN AND BEECH-JONES JJ

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GAGELER CJ, EDELMAN AND BEECH-JONES JJ