CHHETRI KARKI (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

CHHETRI KARKI (Migration) [2018] AATA 5280 (22 November 2018)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

APPLICANTS:  Ms Ruby CHHETRI KARKI
Mr Bishal Karki

CASE NUMBER:  1714107

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):           BCC2017/1417879

MEMBER:Karen McNamara

DATE:22 November 2018

PLACE OF DECISION:  Sydney

DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants Skilled (Provisional) (Class VC) visas.

Statement made on 22 November 2018 at 12:38pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Skilled (Provisional) (Class VC) visa – Subclass 485 (Temporary Graduate) –health insurance – adequate arrangements for relevant period – evidence of arrangements not provided in visa application – temporal connection between visa application and provision of relevant evidence – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 65
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2, cl 485.215

CASES
Anand v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2013] FCA 1050
Nguyen v Minister for Immigration & Anor [2016] FCCA 1523

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection on 16 June 2017 to refuse to grant the applicants Skilled (Provisional) (Class VC) visas under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The applicants applied for the visas on 18 April 2017. Visa Class VC contains Subclass 485. (For visa applications made before 1 July 2013, there is also a Subclass 487, however that subclass is not relevant to the present matter.) The criteria for the grant of a Subclass 485 visa are set out in Part 485 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). The primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one applicant. Other members of the family unit, if any, who are applicants for the visa need satisfy only the secondary criteria.

  3. The applicants have provided to the Tribunal a copy of the delegate’s decision record which records on the 16 June 2018, the delegate refused the visa on the basis that the applicants did not meet cl.485.215 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations because they had not provided evidence to the Department that they had adequate health insurance arrangements in Australia. The delegate therefore, found that the applicants did not satisfy the requirements of clause 485.215.

  4. On the 16 October 2018, the Tribunal wrote to the review applicants (dispatched by email to the authorised recipient) inviting the applicants to give evidence and present arguments at a hearing on 14 November 2018 at 10.30am. 

  5. On 13 November 2018 the Tribunal received a submission from the applicants’ representative containing documentation on behalf of his clients. Subsequent to providing this submission on the same day at 6.52 pm the Tribunal received an email from the representative advising that the applicants would not be attending the hearing and requested that the Tribunal make a decision on the documents provided.

  6. In accordance with the representatives’ instructions, the Tribunal has had regard to the information presently before it and for the following reasons the Tribunal has concluded that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read CHHETRI KARKI (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 5280
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the applicants, Chhetri Karki, against a decision by a delegate of the Minister to refuse their applications for a Skilled (Provisional) (Class VC) visa, Subclass 485 (Temporary Graduate) visa. The appeal was heard by Karen McNamara.

The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicants had met the requirements of clause 485.215 of the Migration Regulations 1994. This clause stipulates that when a visa application is made, it must be accompanied by evidence of adequate arrangements for health insurance in Australia, and that the applicant must have maintained such arrangements since the application was lodged.

The Tribunal noted that the visa application form indicated "yes" to holding health insurance. However, the application lodged on 18 April 2017 did not include evidence of health insurance. The delegate subsequently requested this evidence on 18 May 2017, and as of 16 June 2017, no response or indication of compliance had been received, leading to the refusal. While the Tribunal accepted that the applicants had held various health insurance policies, including one with NIB valid until 30 June 2017 and subsequent policies with iman Australian Health Plans from 1 April 2017 and 19 May 2017, it found no financial evidence supporting payment for the earliest iman policy (commencing 29 September 2016). Despite this, the Tribunal was satisfied that the applicants had continued to maintain adequate health insurance from 23 May 2017 onwards, satisfying subclause 485.215(2). However, the critical failure was the lack of evidence accompanying the initial application, as required by subclause 485.215(1).

Consequently, the Tribunal found that the applicants did not satisfy the criteria for the grant of the visa. The decision under review was affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants, Ruby Chhetri Karki, applied for a Subclass 485 (Temporary Graduate) visa on 18 April 2017. The application was made in response to the requirement under cl.485.215 that the applicants must have had adequate arrangements for health insurance in Australia at the time of the application and since then. The application did not include any evidence of such arrangements, but it did state that the applicants had health insurance. Following the application, on 18 May 2017, the Department sent a correspondence to the applicants requesting evidence of their health insurance arrangements from the time of their visa application and confirmation that the arrangements were still in place. The applicants did not respond to this request by the specified deadline of 16 June 2017. Consequently, the delegate was not satisfied that the applicants met the health insurance requirement and refused their visa application.

On 13 November 2018, the applicants’ representative submitted a statement with additional documents to the Tribunal. These documents included an email from Aust Health dated 13 June 2017 and various letters from iman Australian Health Plans from dates between 29 September 2016 and 21 August 2017. The Tribunal found that the applicants had held student health insurance with NIB until 30 June 2017 and had multiple policies with iman Australian Health Plans starting from 1 April 2017, 19 May 2017, and 29 September 2016. Bank records showed that the applicants had made regular monthly payments for policies 39086575 and 39086581 from 23 May 2017 onwards. However, there was no financial evidence to support payment for policy 37033293. Based on the evidence provided, the Tribunal concluded that the applicants had maintained adequate health insurance for the purposes of cl.485.215(2).

The applicants, Ruby Chhetri Karki and another, sought a review of a decision by the Department of Home Affairs, which refused their application for a Subclass 485 (Temporary Graduate) visa. The application was lodged on 18 April 2017 but was refused on the basis that the applicants did not provide evidence of adequate health insurance arrangements at the time of application and subsequently. The matter was then referred to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for review. The AAT received submissions and additional evidence from the applicants on 13 November 2018. The Tribunal's role was to determine whether the applicants met the health insurance requirements under cl.485.215, specifically whether they had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance both at the time of application and continuously thereafter. The Tribunal reviewed the evidence, including bank statements and health insurance policy details, and found that while the applicants had held various health insurance policies, there was insufficient evidence to support continuous coverage from the date of application. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the original decision of the Department, finding that the applicants did not satisfy the criteria for the grant of a Subclass 485 visa.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In accordance with the representatives’ instructions, the Tribunal has had regard to the information presently before it and for the following reasons the Tribunal has concluded that the decision under review should be affirmed.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEHealth insurance requirements The issue in the present case is whether the applicants meet cl.485.215 which provides as follows: 485.215(1) When the application was made, it was accompanied by evidence that the applicant had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance; and (2) The applicant has had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance since the time the application was made. The visa application on the Department’s file indicates that in response to the question “Do you and all applicants included in this application hold health insurance? ” the word “yes” is recorded. The Tribunal has had regard to all the evidence before it that being the Department’s file and the Tribunal’s file. It notes that the visa application was lodged on 18 April 2017 and it was accompanied by various documents regarding the applicant but did not include evidence to support the applicants had adequate arrangements in Australia for health insurance. The delegate’s decision, records that correspondence was sent to the applicant on 18 May 2017 requesting that they provide evidence that they held adequate health insurance from the time the visa application was lodged and that the arrangements were still in place. The decision further records that as at 16 June 2017, the applicant had not responded to the request to provide supporting evidence, nor indicated that they intended to comply with the request. Consequently the delegate was not satisfied that the applicants met cl.485.215 and the application was refused. The Tribunal received a submission from the applicants’ representative on the 13 November 2018. It was accompanied by a written statement with documents from the applicant. The attached documents included the following:·An email from info@austhealth.com dated 13 June 2017·Statement by applicant, Ruby Chhetri Karki dated 13 November 2018·Letter from iman Australian Health Plans dated 19 May 2017·Letter from iman Australian Health Plans dated 29 September 2016·Internet banking statement NAB 23 May 2017 to 6 November 2018·NIB Confirmation of Health Cover dated 19 October 2016·Bank statement NAB 6 May 2017 to 6 July 2017·Email from CustomerService@austhealth.com dated 19 May 2017·Letter from iman Australian Health Plans dated 21 August 2017·Letter from iman Australian Health Plans dated 5 August 2017 The Tribunal has considered the information provided to the Tribunal and accepts that the applicants student health insurance with NIB was valid until 30 June 2017 and that the applicant has held numerous policies with iman Australian Health Plans being policy 39086581 start date 1 April 2017, policy 39086575 start date 19 May 2017 and policy 37033293 start date 29 September 2016. Bank records provided by the applicant show that from 23 May 2017 the applicant has made regular monthly payments for policies 39086575 and 39086581. There is no financial evidence before the Tribunal to support payment of policy 37033293. Accordingly, the Tribunal is satisfied that the applicants have continued to maintain adequate health insurance for the purposes of cl.485.215(2).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Based on the Tribunal’s findings it follows that the applicants do not satisfy the criteria for the grant of a Subclass 485 visa. As this is the only relevant subclass in this case, the decision under review will be affirmed. DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision not to grant the applicants Skilled (Provisional) (Class VC) visas.Karen McNamaraMember

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal began by examining the applicants' compliance with the health insurance requirement under cl.485.215(1) and cl.485.215(2). Initially, the visa application, lodged on 18 April 2017, indicated that the applicants held health insurance, but it did not include any evidence to support this claim. This initial submission was insufficient to meet the requirements of cl.485.215(1), which mandates that evidence of adequate health insurance arrangements must accompany the visa application. Consequently, the Tribunal held that the applicants did not satisfy the first prong of cl.485.215 at the time of the visa application.

The Tribunal then considered the applicants' failure to provide evidence of adequate health insurance arrangements within the timeframe requested by the delegate, who had asked for such evidence by 16 June 2017. The applicants did not respond to this request, leading the delegate to reasonably conclude that they did not meet the health insurance requirement. This non-compliance with the delegate's request for evidence further impacted the applicants' visa application, as the delegate could not be satisfied that the applicants had met the health insurance requirement under cl.485.215(1).

The Tribunal examined whether the applicants' provision of evidence of health insurance arrangements after the visa application was lodged and after the delegate's request met the requirements under cl.485.215(2). The Tribunal accepted that the applicants had maintained adequate health insurance arrangements from 23 May 2017, as evidenced by bank records showing regular monthly payments. However, this evidence was submitted to the Tribunal on 13 November 2018, well after the visa application and the delegate's request for evidence. The Tribunal found that while the applicants had maintained adequate health insurance, this evidence was not provided within the required timeframes, and thus, the applicants did not meet the requirement under cl.485.215(2).

Given the applicants' failure to meet the health insurance requirement under cl.485.215, the Tribunal considered whether the delegate's decision to refuse the visa application was justified. The Tribunal concluded that the applicants did not satisfy cl.485.215 at the time of the visa application and failed to provide evidence within the requested timeframe. Consequently, the Tribunal held that the delegate's decision to refuse the visa application was justified based on the applicants' non-compliance with the health insurance requirement.

Finally, the Tribunal assessed whether it had sufficient evidence to conclude that the applicants had maintained adequate health insurance arrangements from 23 May 2017 and whether this was sufficient to overturn the delegate’s decision. While the Tribunal accepted the evidence of ongoing health insurance, it noted that this evidence was submitted well after the relevant timeframes had passed. The Tribunal held that the late provision of evidence did not meet the requirements of cl.485.215, and thus, the delegate's decision could not be overturned on this basis.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that failure to provide evidence of adequate health insurance arrangements within the required timeframes, despite maintaining such arrangements later, is insufficient to meet the requirements under cl.485.215. The Tribunal distinguished prior authority that may have considered late evidence if it were provided within a reasonable period, as the evidence in this case was provided significantly outside the required timeframes. The Tribunal followed the principle that compliance with visa requirements must be demonstrated at the time of application and in response to specific requests from the delegate.