Chetty v Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Chetty v Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council [2023] NSWPIC 528

APPLICANT: Surayakanthi Chetty
RESPONDENT: Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council
PRINCIPAL MEMBER: John Harris
DATE OF DECISION: 6 October 2023
CATCHWORDS: WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; federal jurisdiction; allegation of injury pursuant to section 4(b); accepted that the applicant interstate resident and respondent an entity of the State of New South Wales; respondent contended that it was arguable that Commission exercising judicial power; Citta Hobart Pty Ltd v Cawthorn referred; Kanajenahalli v State of New South Wales discussed; Finding in Kanajenahalli not of general application; causation of injury relevant to section 4(b); Australian Padding Co Pty Ltd v Zarb and AV v AW discussed; rights of workers arises at time of injury; Hochbaum v RSM Building Services Pty Ltd applied; federal workers compensation scheme may not be analogous with state scheme; discussion of other factors suggesting exercise of power may be administrative or judicial; defence of federal jurisdiction clearly arguable; application to remit matter to President on a question of law refused as question framed could not be determined; Held – opinion that it was arguable Commission exercising judicial power; proceedings dismissed. 

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission opines and orders:

Opinion

1.     The respondent’s defence that the determination of the application is federally impacted is arguable.

Order

2. The proceedings are dismissed pursuant to s 54 of the Personal Injury Commission Act 2020.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Ms Surayakanthi Chetty (the applicant) was employed by Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council (the respondent). The applicant alleged that she suffered injury deemed to have occurred on 8 April 2022 which is pleaded in the following terms:

    “At the time of injury, the Applicant was employed by the Respondent as an engagement officer.

    Throughout the course of her employment, for a period of approximately 5 months, the Applicant was exposed to physical and racial abuse, perpetrated by her colleagues.

    As a result of the nature and conditions of her employment, the Applicant developed a psychological injury, diagnosed as major depressive disorder with anxious distress.”

  2. The applicant sought various statutory entitlements pursuant to the provisions of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act).

  3. The respondent raised various defences including a denial of injury.[1] Given the pleaded date of injury, it is necessary that the applicant establish that the disease was either “contracted … in the course of employment” (s 4(b)(i)) or that the employment “was the main contributing factor to the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of the disease” (s 4(b)(ii)).

    [1] Reply, p 2.

  4. The respondent has raised a defence that the matter is potentially federally impacted and that the proceedings should be dismissed and commenced in the District Court.

LEGISLATION

  1. Section 75(iv) of the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act (the Constitution) provides:

    “In all matters—

    …

    (iv.) Between States, or between residents of different States, or between a State and a resident of another State:

…

the High Court shall have original jurisdiction.”

  1. Section 77(iii) of the Constitution provides…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chetty v Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 528
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Chetty v Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council involved Surayakanthi Chetty, an applicant from South Australia, who sought workers compensation benefits from her former employer, Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council, a body based in New South Wales. The dispute centred on whether the Personal Injury Commission (PIC) had the jurisdiction to determine the matter or if it was a federally impacted matter that should be heard by a State court. The respondent council raised a defence that the matter was federally impacted and should be dismissed by the PIC, which was subsequently refused. The central legal issue was whether the PIC's determination of the applicant's workers compensation claim involved the exercise of judicial power, thereby rendering the matter federally impacted.

The principal member, John Harris, considered the arguments presented by both parties, focusing on the test for determining whether a matter is federally impacted as outlined in Citta Hobart Pty Ltd v Cawthorn. The test requires that the matter involves the exercise of judicial power and that it falls within the jurisdiction of a State court. The member examined various legal precedents, including Kanajenahalli v State of New South Wales, which suggested that certain statutory decisions might not involve judicial power. However, the member found that these precedents were not of general application and did not conclusively resolve the issue in this case. The member also noted the significant differences in causation requirements between workers compensation claims and other statutory benefits, suggesting that the nature of the dispute in this case might indeed involve judicial power. Additionally, the member considered the finality and binding nature of the PIC's decisions, subject to limited reconsideration and appeal rights, and concluded that these factors supported the argument that the PIC exercises judicial power in such matters.

Based on the reasoning provided, the member concluded that the defence of federal jurisdiction was arguable and should be determined by a State court. The member also refused the application to remit the matter to the President of the PIC for a question of law, as the question was incorrectly framed and a binding decision could only be provided by a State court. The proceedings were ultimately dismissed, and the opinion was expressed that the respondent's defence that the PIC exercises judicial power was arguable.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Surayakanthi Chetty, a resident of South Australia, was employed by Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council in New South Wales. Ms Chetty alleged that she suffered a psychological injury, diagnosed as major depressive disorder with anxious distress, as a result of exposure to physical and racial abuse by her colleagues over approximately five months. She claimed this injury occurred on 8 April 2022. The respondent, Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council, raised various defences, including a denial of the injury and a defence that the matter should be heard in the District Court as it was potentially federally impacted.

The matter was listed for a telephone conference on 29 September 2023. Ms Chetty initially submitted that her case did not address the test set out in Citta Hobart Pty Ltd v Cawthorn and was granted leave to file supplementary submissions. The respondent maintained that the defence of federal jurisdiction was arguable and consistent with the correct test. The applicant was further advised that the issue of federal jurisdiction was arguable, and no submissions from the respondent were necessary. The matter was ultimately determined by the Principal Member, John Harris, on 6 October 2023.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the respondent’s defence that the determination of the application is federally impacted is arguable.
2. Whether the proceedings should be dismissed and remitted to the President on a question of law.
3. Whether the opinion that the Commission exercises judicial power in these proceedings is valid.

Held
1. The respondent’s defence that the determination of the application is federally impacted is arguable.
2. The proceedings are dismissed and not remitted to the President on a question of law.
3. The opinion that the Commission exercises judicial power in these proceedings is valid.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the respondent's defence that the determination of the application is federally impacted. The Court applied the test from Citta Hobart Pty Ltd v Cawthorn, which requires a claim or defence to be genuinely in controversy and capable of judicial determination to be considered arguable. The Court found that the respondent's defence met this test as it was not colourable or amounted to judicial nonsense. The Court concluded that the matter required determination by a court of a State because the Commission was not a court of the State and the resolution of the dispute involved the exercise of judicial power.

Regarding the second issue, the Court dismissed the application and refused to remit the matter to the President on a question of law. The Court reasoned that the question was incorrectly framed as it assumed the President could determine the issue when he could only determine whether the issue was arguable. The Court believed that a binding decision on this important issue could only be provided by a court of a State, and remitting the matter to the President would only delay the matter without providing a binding decision.

Finally, the Court expressed an opinion that it was arguable that the Commission exercises judicial power in these proceedings. The Court distinguished the case from Kanajenahalli v State of New South Wales, noting that the finding in Kanajenahalli was not of general application. The Court also considered various factors suggesting that a determination under s 4 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 may be judicial or an exercise of administrative power. The Court concluded that the opinion that the Commission exercises judicial power was valid, and the respondent's defence was arguable.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a court of a State must determine whether a matter involving the exercise of judicial power is federally impacted, and the Commission's opinion that it exercises judicial power is valid if the defence is arguable. The Court distinguished the case from Kanajenahalli, which was not of general application and involved a different statutory provision. The Court also applied the test from Citta Hobart to determine whether the respondent's defence was arguable.