Cheng v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Cheng v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPIC 642
CLAIMANT: Lucy Cheng
INSURER: Allianz
MEMBER: Shana Radnan
DATE OF DECISION: 28 November 2023
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; miscellaneous dispute; whether for the purposes of section 3.38 the insurer is entitled to reduce statutory benefits payable in respect of the motor accident; the injured person turning left at intersection with four lane road and the insured turning right from holding bay; both entering four lane road and some metres beyond the intersection collision between both vehicle; the insurer alleged injured person 50% negligent; Held – injured person changed lanes into path of insured; for the purposes of section 3.38, the insurer is entitled to reduce statutory benefits payable in respect of the accident by 50%

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

CERTIFICATE

Issued under s 7.36(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 and clause 7.497of the Motor Accident Guidelines

The findings of the assessment of this dispute are as follows:

1. For the purposes of s 3.38 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 the insurer is entitled to reduce statutory benefits in respect of the motor vehicle accident by 50%.

2.     Effective Date: this determination takes effect on 27 November 2023.

3.     Legal Costs: nil as the claimant was not represented.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

Background:

  1. Lucy Cheng (the claimant and injured person) was involved in a motor vehicle accident which took place on 27 September 2022 at the location of Anzac Parade, Maroubra Junction near the intersection of Boyce road.

  2. The insurer made a liability determination on 15 February 2023 and the claimant sought a review of the determination. An internal review was undertaken at the request of the claimant (17 February 2023) and the insurer affirmed their decision.

  3. The claimant has referred the dispute to the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) for determination of the allegation of contributory negligence.

The insurer’s determination – dated 15 February 2023

  1. The insurer admitted breach of duty of care and alleged the claimant’s conduct amounted to  50% contributory negligence.

  2. The claimant sought a review of the determination.

The determination of the review dated 10 March 2023

  1. Lauren Emerson Parker, the internal reviewer affirmed the earlier decision as follows:

    “The effect of this decision is Allianz would pay a percentage of your pre-accident weekly earnings. A 50% reduction will apply to the calculated weekly benefits to account for the claimant’s contribution to the accident. Allianz would also continue to pay the claimant’s reasonable and necessary medical and care expenses required due to injuries sustained in the motor vehicle accident.”

  2. A summary of the reasoning for the determination by Ms Parker is reproduced below:

    “1. The above outcome is consistent with my findings and reasons set below. I have the power to make this internal review decision in accordance with Schedule 2, Clause 3(g) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 ('the Act’) whether the insurer is entitled to reduce the statutory benefits payable in respect of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cheng v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 642
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cheng v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, Cheng, the injured party, sought a review of a decision made by Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the insurer, which found Cheng to be 50% contributorily negligent in a motor accident that occurred on 27 September 2022. The primary legal issue before the court was whether Allianz was entitled to reduce statutory benefits payable to Cheng under section 3.38 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 due to Cheng's contributory negligence. Cheng argued that the insurer's decision was incorrect and that the witness statement provided by a pedestrian, Barry, was not adequately followed up.

The court examined the evidence and found that Cheng was indeed 50% contributorily negligent in the accident. Cheng turned left into Anzac Parade at a green light, but failed to keep a proper lookout and did not anticipate another vehicle turning right from Boyce Road onto Anzac Parade. The court relied on Section 75 of the Road Rules, which states that drivers must give way to those with the right of way, and Section 5B of the Civil Liability Act, which outlines the duty to take precautions to avoid harm. Cheng's failure to adequately keep a proper lookout and take necessary precautions led the court to find that Cheng was 50% contributorily negligent.

Consequently, the court held that Allianz was entitled to reduce the statutory benefits payable to Cheng by 50% under section 3.38 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. This decision was based on the court's determination of Cheng's contributory negligence, which aligned with the requirements of the Act and the principles of contributory negligence as set out in relevant case law.

Background

Background to the litigation

A summary of the reasoning for the determination by Ms Parker is reproduced below:“1. The above outcome is consistent with my findings and reasons set below. I have the power to make this internal review decision in accordance with Schedule 2, Clause 3(g) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 ('the Act’) whether the insurer is entitled to reduce the statutory benefits payable in respect of the motor accident in accordance with section 3.38 (Reduction of weekly statutory benefits after 6 months for contributory negligence).2. You have lodged a claim for statutory benefits due to injuries arising from a motor accident which occurred on 27 September 2022.3. You seek a review of a decision that you were 50% contributorily negligent in the accident. This decision was made on 15 February 2023.Relevant facts and materials:1. I have reviewed the Application for Personal Injury Benefits dated 7 October 2022 and note the following excerpt:‘I was driving on Boyce rd on the left lane (as seen in image 1). As I approached the intersection, once the traffic lights turned with a left green arrow I turned left on to Anzac parade into the middle lane (as seen in image 2) as I had right of way. Unexpectedly, a car had turned at the same time from Boyce Rd the opposite side onto the lane on Anzac parade. The car had turned right onto my lane. I didn't see the car as I hadn't expected any cars to be turning at the same time as me when mine was on a green arrow traffic light. Barry (0423391660) a pedestrian walking by checked whether I was ok and told me that he saw their car turn right from Boyce rd onto Anzac parade and not give me the right of way I was supposed to have. Please see sketch of the accident in attached "Sketch" pdf.’2. I have reviewed the Factual Report dated 24 January 2023 and note the following excerpt: (italics in original form)Record of Interview with YouQ 57 Yeah. So, for how much time were you driving before the accident?A It was literally just out of our apartment so um, it... our apartment was like um, a quarter away so ...Q 60 Did you have any passengers in your vehicle? A No. It was just me.Q 61 Me. Yep. Alright. Just in your own words and as much detail as you can, can you tell me what happened?A Yeah. I've actually written it down for the insurance company so I can just read that. Urn, so I was driving on Boyce Road on the left lane so I came out of my home ...Q62 Yeah.A ... um, went onto, turn onto Boyce Road um, and had ... I sent you some images Paul as well and when I approached the intersection between Boyce Road and Anzac Parade ...Q63 Yep.A ... um, once the traffic lights turned with a left green arrow, I turned onto Anzac Parade into the middle lane um, as I had the right of way. Unexpectedly, a car had turned at the same time from Boyce Road on the opposite side onto the lane on Anzac Parade ...Q64 Yeah.A ... um, so perpendicular, she was turning and the car turned um, onto the same lane. I didn't see the car as I hadn't expected any cars to be turning at the same time as me when mine was um, on a green arrow traffic light. Um, I actually didn't expect a car so I didn't really know where we crashed or what happened um, and then once I came down from the car, I was in shock. I have a, a witness, Barry. Um, he was a lovely older man. He um, so instantly stopped the car on the side and he made sure I was okay. He was a pedestrian walking by. Checked I was okay and told me that he had ... saw um, other party's carturn right from Boyce Road onto Anzac Parade and not give me the right of way I was supposed to have.Q 65 So,just explain to me how ... so Anzac Parade is three lanes, is that right? A One, two, three, four lanes.3. I have reviewed the Factual Report of Photographs and accident diagrams dated 7 February 2023 and note that the damage to your vehicle was to the front right corner at the headlight assembly and our insured's vehicle was to the front left corner above the wheel. I note your diagram of the accident which you allege that the accident occurred as you were turning left into Anzac Parade at the traffic lights. Further, I note that the Insured has alleged that the accident occurred when you both had already completed the turn into Anzac Parade and that you had swerved from Lane 1 into Lane 3 in which she was travelling in order to avoid a collision with a parked car in Lane 1 and collided with her vehicle.4. I have reviewed your Application for Internal Review dated 17 February 2023 in which you state that the diagram of the accident was incorrect and that your witness was not properly followed up on for key evidence.Reviewer’s findings:5. The assessment of contributory negligence is to be conducted in accordance with the requirements of sections 3.38 of the Act which requires that:‘The common law and enacted law as to contributory negligence that applies to an award of damages in respect of a motor accident applies (except as provided by this section) to weekly payments of statutory benefits’.6. In assessing contributory negligence, I am required to weigh up the respective acts of negligence of the parties involved and determine an appropriate apportionment between them as envisaged in Podrebersek v Australian Iron & Steel (1985) 59 ALR 529. It was said in this case that: “The making of an apportionment as between a plaintiff and a defendant of their respective shares in the responsibility for the damage involves a comparison of culpability ..” Contributory Negligence:7. Having considered the evidence as above, I have determined that you were 50% contributorily negligent in the subject motor vehicle accident. The following is relied on in this respect.8. I accept that the Insured driver turning right into Anzac Parade from Boyce Road and.9. I note that s75 of the Road Rules states: (italics in original form)‘75 Giving way when entering a road related area or adjacent land from a road(1)A driver entering a road related area or adjacent land from a place on a road without traffic lights or a stop sign, stop line, give way sign or give way line must give way to-(a) any pedestrian on the road, and(b) any vehicle or pedestrian on any road related area that the driver crosses or enters, and(c) if the driver is turning right from the road-any oncoming vehicle on the road that is going straight ahead or turning left, and(d) if the road the driver is leaving ends at a T-intersection opposite the road related area or adjacent land and the driver is crossing the continuing road­ any vehicle on the continuing road.”10. I accept that you had right of way and the Insured driver should have given way to you. Further, I note that your comprehensive insurer found our insured driver to be at fault.11. I refer to Section 5B of the Civil Liability Act which states:5B General principles (Italics in original form)(1)A person is not negligent in failing to take precautions against a risk of harm unless-(a) the risk was foreseeable (that is, it is a risk of which the person knew or ought to have known), and(b) the risk was not insignificant, and(c) in the circumstances, a reasonable person in the person's position would have taken those precautions.(2)In determining whether a reasonable person would have taken precautions against a risk of harm, the court is to consider the following (amongst other relevant things)-(a) the probability that the harm would occur if care were not taken,(b) the likely seriousness of the harm,(c) the burden of taking precautions to avoid the risk of harm,(d) the social utility of the activity that creates the risk of harmOther principlesIn proceedings relating to liability for negligence-(a)the burden of taking precautions to avoid a risk of harm includes the burden of taking precautions to avoid similar risks of harm for which the person may be responsible, and(b)the fact that a risk of harm could have been avoided by doing something in a different way does not of itself give rise to or affect liability for the way in which the thing was done, and(c)the subsequent taking of action that would (had the action been taken earlier) have avoided a risk of harm does not of itself give rise to or affect liability in respect of the risk and does not of itself constitute an admission of liability in connection with the risk’12. I note that at the intersection there are no arrows present and there are only standard traffic lights governing the intersection which allows for the possibility for you and the Insured to both have a green traffic light at the same time.13. However, whilst you would have right of way in accordance with Section 75 of the Road Rules, you also have a duty to keep a proper lookout and in accordance with the Civil Liability Act Section 5B has the duty to take precautions to avoid the risk of harm.14. Furthermore, Sibley v. Kais [1967] HCA 43 held ‘The obligation is on every driver no matter from what quarter he enters or is about to enter an intersection, to condition his speed and the handling of his vehicle so as to be able to avoid collision with any other vehicle or vehicles entering.’(italics in original form)15. I am not satisfied that you took adequate precautions to avoid the risk of harm and that you kept a proper lookout as you stated in your record of interview with the Investigator you stated, ‘I didn't see the car as I hadn't expected any cars to be turning at the same time as me when mine was um, on a green arrow traffic light' (Italics in original form)16. Further, you note in your Application for Internal Review that the Investigator did not properly follow up the witness, however the witness was contacted, and a time arranged for an interview however they did not make themselves available at the agreed upon time and has not responded to further attempts at contact.17. Therefore, I accept that you were 50% contributorily negligent in the subject motor vehicle accident.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the insurer is entitled to reduce the statutory benefits payable in respect of the motor accident in accordance with section 3.38 (Reduction of weekly statutory benefits after 6 months for contributory negligence) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.
2. Whether the claimant was 50% contributorily negligent in the accident, as determined by the insurer.

Held
1. The court held that the insurer is entitled to reduce the statutory benefits payable in respect of the motor accident in accordance with section 3.38 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The court found that the claimant was 50% contributorily negligent in the accident, and thus the insurer's decision to reduce the statutory benefits by 50% is justified.
2. The court upheld the insurer's determination that the claimant was 50% contributorily negligent in the accident.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by noting that the assessment of contributory negligence must be conducted in accordance with the requirements of section 3.38 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. This section stipulates that the common law and enacted law as to contributory negligence that applies to an award of damages in respect of a motor accident also applies to weekly payments of statutory benefits. The court referenced the case of Podrebersek v Australian Iron & Steel to emphasize that contributory negligence involves a comparison of culpability between the parties involved in the accident.

The court examined the evidence presented, including the claimant's statement, witness testimonies, and the accident diagrams. It was established that the claimant had the right of way when turning left onto Anzac Parade, and the insured driver should have given way. The court referred to section 75 of the Road Rules which states that a driver entering a road related area or adjacent land from a place on a road must give way to any vehicle on the continuing road.

Furthermore, the court noted that the claimant had a duty to keep a proper lookout and to take precautions to avoid the risk of harm, as per the Civil Liability Act section 5B. The court highlighted the case of Sibley v. Kais, which underscores the obligation of every driver to condition their speed and the handling of their vehicle to avoid collision with any other vehicle entering an intersection.

The court found that the claimant did not take adequate precautions to avoid the risk of harm, as evidenced by their statement that they did not see the car as they hadn't expected any cars to be turning at the same time as them when their traffic light was on a green arrow. The court also noted that the witness, although contacted, did not make themselves available for an interview and has not responded to further attempts at contact. Consequently, the court concluded that the claimant was 50% contributorily negligent in the accident, thereby justifying the insurer's decision to reduce the statutory benefits by 50%.