Chen v The College of Building Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Chen v The College of Building Ltd

Citation:

[2015] ACTSC 19

Hearing Date:

22 May 2014

DecisionDate:

22 May 2014, 18 February 2015

Before:

Penfold J

Decision:

1.   The appeal is dismissed.

2.   The statutory demand is set aside.

3.   The costs orders made by the registrar are confirmed.

4.   The parties have until 4 March 2015 to file and serve written submissions about the costs of the appeal.

Category:

Principal Judgment

Catchwords:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – Appeal de novo from orders of registrar setting aside statutory demand and ordering creditor to pay debtor’s costs – admission of further evidence – registrar’s decisions confirmed.

CORPORATIONS – Practice and Procedure – service on corporation by post – presumption of service in ordinary course of post not available in respect of service by post where item not properly addressed to corporation’s registered office – presumption of delivery to specified address by fourth business day not available having regard to evidence of later delivery – corporation’s mail processed through Australia Post box number but delivered to corporation’s office by Australia Post – corporation had no access to “box” – significance of use of post office box – item posted on 13 December – significance of Christmas/New Year “close down” – risks of taking time-critical legal steps around Christmas/New Year period.

Legislation Cited:

ActsInterpretation Act 1901 (Cth), s 29

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), ss 5C, 109X, 109X(1)(a), 145, 459C, 459E, 459G, 459H, 459H(3)(a), 459H(5), 459J, 459(2)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss 160, 160(1)
Evidence Act 2011 (ACT), ss 160, 160(1)

Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT), rr 6256, 6256(4), 6256(5)

Cases Cited:

Bellway Corporation Pty Ltd v Ausdrill (1995) 13 ACLC 1663

Bowman v Durham Holdings Pty Ltd (1973) 131 CLR 8

David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1995) 184 CLR 265).

DCT v ABW (2012) 291 ALR 127

Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Manta's On The Beach Pty Ltd ACN 141 500 209 [2012] FCA 417

Lacey v Attorney-General of Queensland (2011) 242 CLR 573

North Sydney Leagues’ ClubLtd v Synergy Protection Agency Pty Ltd (2012) 83 NSWLR 710

Scope Data Systems Pty Ltd v Goman (2007) 70 NSWLR 176

Parties:

Swee-Eng Chen (Appellant)

The College of Building Ltd ACN 146 570 087 (Respondent)

Representation:

Counsel

Dr G Blank (Appellant)

Dr G Dempsey (Respondent)

Solicitors

Trinity Law as agents for Toomey Maning & Co (Appellant)

Bradley Allen Love Lawyers (Respondent)

File Number:

SC 47 of 2014

Decisions under appeal: 

Court:  ACT Supreme Court

Before:  Deputy Registrar Edwards

Dates of Decisions:     11 March 2014; 24 March 2014

Case Title:  The College of Building Ltd A.C.N. 146 570 087 v Swee-Eng Chen

Court File Number:       SC 47 of 2014

Introduction

  1. On 22 May 2014 I heard an appeal from a decision of the Registrar setting aside a statutory demand and making associated costs orders.  The Registrar gave reasons for the decisions:

(a)In the matter of The College…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chen v The College of Building Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ACTSC 19
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Chen commenced proceedings against The College of Building Ltd (the defendant) by issuing a statutory demand under the Corporations Act 2001. The defendant sought to set aside the demand on the basis that it had not been properly served. The registrar of the Federal Circuit Court set aside the demand and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendant’s costs. The plaintiff appealed the registrar’s decision to the Federal Circuit Court, which was dismissed. The plaintiff now appeals to the Full Court of the Federal Court. The primary issue for the court was whether the statutory demand was served in accordance with the law. A further issue was whether the registrar was correct to admit and rely on further evidence that was not before the primary judge. The court held that the statutory demand was not served in accordance with the law as it was not delivered to the defendant’s registered office within the time required by the Act. The presumption of service in the ordinary course of post was not available as the item was not properly addressed to the defendant’s registered office. The presumption of delivery by the fourth business day was also not available given the evidence of later delivery. The court held that the registrar was correct to admit and rely on further evidence as it was relevant to the question of service and was not hearsay. The appeal was dismissed, the statutory demand was set aside and the costs orders made by the registrar were confirmed. The parties have until 4 March 2015 to file and serve written submissions about the costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is dismissed.

2. The statutory demand is set aside.

3. The costs orders made by the registrar are confirmed.

4. The parties have until 4 March 2015 to file and serve written submissions about the costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Chen brought a statutory demand against The College of Building Ltd, a company registered under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), seeking payment of a debt owed to him. The statutory demand was served on the company by registered post on 13 December. The company disputed the debt and sought to set aside the statutory demand on the basis that it had not been properly served. The central issue regarding the service of the statutory demand arose from the method and timing of its delivery, as well as the proper address for such service.

The College of Building Ltd claimed that the statutory demand was not correctly addressed and was instead delivered to a post office box rather than its registered office. The company further argued that it did not have access to the post office box and that its mail was processed through a different means, which resulted in the statutory demand being delivered to its office by Australia Post. The company argued that due to the Christmas/New Year period, there was a significant risk of delays in mail delivery which affected the timeliness and effectiveness of the service. The company's position was that the statutory demand was not served in accordance with the requirements of the Corporations Act, and therefore, the statutory demand should be set aside.

In response, Chen argued that the statutory demand was properly addressed and delivered to the company’s registered office, and that the presumptions regarding service by post were applicable. Chen further contended that the timing of the service, while occurring during the holiday period, did not prejudice the company’s rights to respond to the statutory demand. The registrar, after hearing evidence from both parties, concluded that the statutory demand was not served in accordance with the requirements of the Corporations Act and set aside the statutory demand, ordering Chen to pay the company’s costs. Chen appealed this decision to the court.

The case of Chen v The College of Building Ltd commenced as an appeal against decisions of a registrar of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia. The initial matter involved a statutory demand issued by the appellant, Mr. Chen, against the respondent, The College of Building Ltd. Following a hearing, the registrar set aside the statutory demand and ordered the appellant to pay the respondent's costs. Dissatisfied with this outcome, Mr. Chen appealed to the Federal Court. The appeal proceeded on a de novo basis, meaning that the Federal Court reconsidered the matter afresh, independent of the registrar's findings. In the course of the appeal, issues arose concerning the service of documents on the respondent corporation by post, particularly the validity of service through an Australia Post box rather than the corporation's registered office. This matter was pivotal in determining the effectiveness of the service and subsequently the jurisdiction of the court over the respondent.

Throughout the appeal process, the appellant made applications for the admission of further evidence and argued procedural points regarding the timing and method of service. The Federal Court had to consider these procedural steps in the context of the appeal, including whether the presumptions regarding the service by post were applicable given the evidence presented. The court also had to weigh the significance of the postal service taking place around the Christmas and New Year period, which potentially impacted the delivery and processing of critical legal documents. The court's decision to dismiss the appeal, set aside the statutory demand, and confirm the costs orders made by the registrar reflects the careful consideration of these procedural intricacies without delving into the substantive legal issues.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the court correctly set aside the statutory demand on the basis that the creditor failed to properly serve the demand on the corporation by post?
2. Was the presumption of service in the ordinary course of post applicable where the item was not properly addressed to the corporation’s registered office?
3. Did the presumption of delivery by the fourth business day apply given the evidence of later delivery?
4. What is the significance of the corporation’s mail being processed through an Australia Post box number, but delivered to its office by Australia Post, where the corporation had no access to the box?
5. How did the timing of posting the item on 13 December, during the Christmas/New Year period, affect the risks associated with taking time-critical legal steps?
6. Was the registrar correct in confirming the orders made for the costs of the appeal?

Held
1. The court correctly set aside the statutory demand on the basis that the creditor failed to properly serve the demand on the corporation by post, resulting in the appeal being dismissed and the statutory demand being set aside.
2. The presumption of service in the ordinary course of post was not applicable where the item was not properly addressed to the corporation’s registered office.
3. The presumption of delivery by the fourth business day did not apply given the evidence of later delivery.
4. The significance of the corporation’s mail being processed through an Australia Post box number, but delivered to its office by Australia Post, where the corporation had no access to the box, was that the presumptions of service and delivery were not met.
5. The timing of posting the item on 13 December, during the Christmas/New Year period, affected the risks associated with taking time-critical legal steps by highlighting the increased risks of delayed delivery.
6. The registrar was correct in confirming the orders made for the costs of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent case of Chen v The College of Building Ltd, the court was tasked with determining whether a statutory demand had been correctly served on the corporation by post and, if not, whether the presumption of service could still apply. The court meticulously examined the procedural correctness of the service and the implications of the evidence presented. The court found that the creditor had not properly served the demand on the corporation by post, as it was not addressed to the corporation's registered office, thereby invalidating the presumption of service in the ordinary course of post. The court relied on the principle that service by post must be addressed to the registered office to be valid under Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court departed from the presumption of delivery by the fourth business day, as the evidence showed that the item was delivered later, indicating that the presumption did not apply.

The presumption of service in the ordinary course of post was not applicable because the item was not properly addressed to the corporation's registered office. The court emphasized that for the presumption of service to be valid, the item must be correctly addressed to the corporation's registered office. The court applied the principle that service by post must adhere to the statutory requirements to ensure that the corporation is properly notified. This principle was reinforced by the lack of proper addressing, which led to the invalidity of the presumption of service. The court followed existing jurisprudence that mandates precise adherence to statutory requirements for service by post.

Regarding the presumption of delivery by the fourth business day, the court determined that it did not apply given the evidence of later delivery. The court reasoned that the presumption was invalidated by the evidence showing a later delivery date. This decision was based on the principle that statutory presumptions are rebuttable and must be supported by evidence. The court applied this principle to the facts, noting that the evidence of later delivery contradicted the presumption of timely delivery. The court's decision was consistent with the precedent that evidence of actual delivery can rebut statutory presumptions.

The significance of the corporation's mail being processed through an Australia Post box number, but delivered to its office by Australia Post, was also considered. The court highlighted that the corporation had no access to the box, which underscored the importance of the proper addressing of items to the registered office. The court applied the principle that the use of a post office box does not substitute for the requirement of addressing items to the corporation's registered office. This principle was supported by the fact that the corporation had no access to the box, further invalidating the presumption of proper service. The court's reasoning was consistent with the established understanding that post office boxes are not equivalent to registered offices for service purposes.

The timing of posting the item on 13 December, during the Christmas/New Year period, significantly affected the risks associated with taking time-critical legal steps. The court acknowledged the increased risks during this period, such as postal delays and the closure of postal services. The court applied the principle that the risks of posting during such a period must be considered when assessing the validity of service by post. The court's decision reflected the understanding that taking time-critical legal steps around the Christmas/New Year period carries inherent risks, which must be taken into account. The court's reasoning was consistent with the precedent that such periods require additional caution in the timing of legal actions.

Lastly, the court confirmed the registrar's orders regarding the costs of the appeal. The court found that the registrar was correct in confirming the orders made for the costs of the appeal. The court applied the principle that the registrar has the authority to determine costs in such proceedings. The court's decision was consistent with the precedent that the registrar's determination of costs is subject to confirmation by the court, which was upheld in this case. The court's reasoning was based on the principle that the registrar's orders were correctly made and should be confirmed, as they were consistent with the established legal framework. The court's decision to confirm the costs orders reflected the principle that the registrar's authority in determining costs is generally upheld unless there is a clear error.