Chen v Insight Investment Management Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Chen v Insight Investment Management Pty Ltd (No 2) [2025] FCA 937

File number: VID 423 of 2024
Judgment of: NESKOVCIN J
Date of judgment: 6 August 2025
Date of publication of reasons: 13 August 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for deemed service under r 10.23 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – application for substituted service under r 10.24 – failed attempts to effect personal service – whether personal service not practicable – application allowed
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 10.23, 10.24
Cases cited:

Commissioner of Taxation v Caratti (No 2) [2018] FCA 1500

Kosmos Capital Pty Ltd v Turiya Ventures LLC [2019] FCA 528

University of New England v Boerner [2024] FCA 191

Division: General Division
Registry: Victoria
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 27
Date of hearing: 6 August 2025
Solicitor for the Respondents: S T E McMahon of Tisher Liner FC Law

ORDERS

VID 423 of 2024
BETWEEN:

LUYI CHEN

First Applicant

SHIHONG SHEN

Second Applicant

AND:

INSIGHT INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD

First Respondent

JOHN YANG XU

Second Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

INSIGHT INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (and another named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Claimant

AND:

REC CAPITAL PTY LTD (ACN 638 222 107) (and another named in the Schedule)

First Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

NESKOVCIN J

DATE OF ORDER:

6 AUGUST 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Deemed and substituted service

1.The requirement under r 15.08(2) of the Federal Court Rules2011 (Cth) for the respondents/cross-claimants to personally serve the notice of cross-claim dated 23 June 2025 on the second cross-respondent is dispensed with.

2.Pursuant to r 10.24 of the Rules, service of the notice of cross-claim dated 23 June 2025, statement of cross-claim dated 13 June 2025, originating process dated 20 May 2024, concise statement dated 20 May 2024 (Originating Documents), orders dated 12 June 2025, 3 July 2025, 24 July 2025 and these orders (Orders) be effected by:

(a)handing a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders to any person apparently over the age of sixteen years, but, if this is not possible, leaving them in the letterbox or affixing them to the front door in a sealed envelope addressed to Mr Yuan-Sheng Xie at 24 Kuranda Crescent, Berwick, Victoria, 3806, Australia;

(b)sending a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders by pre-paid post addressed to Mr Yuan-Sheng Xie at 24 Kuranda Crescent, Berwick, Victoria, 3806, Australia;

(c)sending a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders by email to kim@reccapital.com.au with the subject line “Court Orders and Documents attached – VID423/2024 LUYI CHEN & ANOR v INSIGHT INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD & ANOR”;

(d)sending a text message to 0402 676 956 in the following terms:

(i)Court proceedings have been commenced against you by Insight Investment Management Pty Ltd and John Yang Xu in the Federal Court of Australia, proceeding number VID423/2024. On 6 August 2025, orders were made that service of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chen v Insight Investment Management Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 937
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Luyi Chen and another, filed a proceeding against the respondents, Insight Investment Management Pty Ltd and John Yang Xu, alleging that the respondents made false or misleading representations in an investment brochure and investment guide, causing the applicants to invest $400,000 in another company’s pre-IPO investment. The applicants seek damages against the respondents under various sections of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth). In response, the respondents filed an interlocutory application seeking leave to file a Notice of cross-claim and a statement of cross-claim, alleging that Mr Xie provided the investment brochure and investment guide to Mr Xu, who passed them on to potential investors, including the applicants. The respondents seek damages against Mr Xie and Rec Capital. The primary legal issue before the court was whether it was "not practicable" to serve the Notice of cross-claim and related documents on Mr Xie personally, thus permitting the respondents to apply for deemed and substituted service under the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). The court found that the term "not practicable" should be interpreted broadly to facilitate the just resolution of disputes. The respondents had made numerous attempts to effect personal service on Mr Xie, including attempts at his former residence, a business address, and a mobile phone number. All attempts had failed, and it appeared that Mr Xie was attempting to evade service. The court was satisfied that the respondents had demonstrated that it was not practicable to serve Mr Xie personally. Additionally, the respondents provided evidence that the proposed methods of substituted service, including leaving documents at a known address, mailing them, emailing them, and sending a text message to a responsive email address, were likely to bring the documents to Mr Xie's attention. The court was satisfied that the proposed methods of substituted service would likely reach Mr Xie and thus granted the application for deemed and substituted service. The court made orders for deemed and substituted service of the Notice of cross-claim and other documents on Mr Xie, including leaving the documents at his known address, mailing them, emailing them, and sending a text message. The Originating Documents were to be taken as served 14 days after the respondents completed these steps. Service of any other document in the proceeding was to be effected by mail and email until Mr Xie filed a notice of address for service. The respondents were also required to file an affidavit verifying compliance with the orders and stating whether they received any notification indicating that Mr Xie did not receive the email. The court reserved costs and directed the cross-claimants to file an amended notice of cross-claim before serving the Originating Documents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Deemed and substituted service

1. The requirement under r 15.08(2) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) for the respondents/cross-claimants to personally serve the notice of cross-claim dated 23 June 2025 on the second cross-respondent is dispensed with.

2. Pursuant to r 10.24 of the Rules, service of the notice of cross-claim dated 23 June 2025, statement of cross-claim dated 13 June 2025, originating process dated 20 May 2024, concise statement dated 20 May 2024 (Originating Documents), orders dated 12 June 2025, 3 July 2025, 24 July 2025 and these orders (Orders) be effected by:

(a) handing a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders to any person apparently over the age of sixteen years, but, if this is not possible, leaving them in the letterbox or affixing them to the front door in a sealed envelope addressed to Mr Yuan-Sheng Xie at 24 Kuranda Crescent, Berwick, Victoria, 3806, Australia;

(b) sending a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders by pre-paid post addressed to Mr Yuan-Sheng Xie at 24 Kuranda Crescent, Berwick, Victoria, 3806, Australia;

(c) sending a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders by email to kim@reccapital.com.au with the subject line “Court Orders and Documents attached – VID423/2024 LUYI CHEN & ANOR v INSIGHT INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD & ANOR”;

(d) sending a text message to 0402 676 956 in the following terms:

(i) Court proceedings have been commenced against you by Insight Investment Management Pty Ltd and John Yang Xu in the Federal Court of Australia, proceeding number VID423/2024. On 6 August 2025, orders were made that service of the notice of cross-claim dated 23 June 2025, statement of cross-claim dated 13 June 2025, originating process dated 20 May 2024, concise statement dated 20 May 2024 (“Originating Documents”) and orders dated 12 June 2025, 3 July 2025, 24 July 2025 and 6 August 2025 (“Orders”) are to be served on you by: delivering a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders by hand to 24 Kuranda Crescent, Berwick, Victoria, 3806, Australia; sending a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders by pre-paid post to 24 Kuranda Crescent, Berwick, Victoria, 3806, Australia; sending a copy of the Originating Documents and Orders to kim@reccapital.com.au; and sending you this text message.

3. Pursuant to r 10.23 of the Rules, the Originating Documents will be taken to be served 14 days after the respondents/cross-claimants complete all of the steps in order 2.

4. Until the second cross-respondent files a notice of address for service in accordance with r 15.09 of the Rules, service of any other document in this proceeding be effected by the way provided in order 2(b) and (c).

5. By 4:00pm on 20 August 2025, the respondents/cross-claimants (or a solicitor acting on behalf of the respondents/cross-claimants) file an affidavit:

(a) verifying that order 2 has been complied with; and

(b) stating whether the respondents/cross-claimants received a bounce back email, out of office, return to sender or similar notification which may indicate that the second cross-respondent did not receive the email sent in accordance with order 2(c).

6. Prior to effecting service of the Originating Documents in accordance with order 2, the cross-claimants file an amended notice of cross-claim listing the time and date for hearing as 4 September 2025 at 10:00am.

Other

7. Costs reserved.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing, I was satisfied that it was appropriate to make orders for deemed and substituted service of the Notice of cross-claim and other documents on Mr Xie. I made orders substantially in the form sought by the respondents. These are my reasons for making the orders.BACKGROUND On 25 May 2024, the applicants commenced this proceeding against the respondents by an originating process and concise statement which allege that the respondents made false or misleading representations in an investment brochure and investment guide that caused the applicants to invest $400,000 in another company’s pre-IPO investment. The applicants seek damages against the respondents under ss 1022B(1) and/or 1041I of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and/or s 12GF of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (ASIC Act). On 16 May 2025, the respondents filed an interlocutory application seeking, among other things, leave to file the Notice of cross-claim and a statement of cross-claim (Cross-Claim Documents). The respondents allege in the Cross-Claim Documents that Mr Xie provided Mr Xu with the investment brochure and investment guide that Mr Xu passed on to potential investors, including the first applicant. The respondents allege that the investors suffered loss when the investment failed and the funds were not returned to investors, including the respondents. The respondents seek damages pursuant s 236 of the Australian Consumer Law being Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) or s 12GF of the ASIC Act against Mr Xie and Rec Capital, on the basis that it was involved in Mr Xie’s alleged wrongful conduct. Mr Xu said that he met Mr Xie, known to him as Kim Xie, in early 2021. Mr Xu said that he had a number of meetings and telephone conversations and exchanged emails with Mr Xie from time to time between early 2021 and August 2023. Mr Xu said that he used the following details to contact Mr Xie:(a)mobile telephone number: 0402 676 956; and(b)email address: kim@reccapital.com.au. Mr Xu said that he is no longer in contact with Mr Xie. According to a company search extract for Rec Capital, Mr Xie is the sole director of Rec Capital, having been appointed when it was incorporated. Mr Xie’s address noted on the company search extract and the registered office of Rec Capital are the same property address in Mount Waverley, Victoria (Mount Waverley address). Initial attempts by Mr Dunlop to serve Mr Xie at the Mount Waverley address were unsuccessful and enquiries made by Mr Dunlop of the current occupant of the property confirmed that Mr Xie does not reside at that address. Mr McMahon, who undertook searches of Rec Capital’s website, said that the only physical address appearing on the website is an address in Collins Street, Melbourne (Collins Street address). Mr Dunlop attempted service on Mr Xie at the Collins Street address. Mr Dunlop was advised that there was no record of Mr Xie or Rec Capital at that address. Mr Dunlop then made a telephone call to the mobile telephone number Mr Xu had for Mr Xie. Mr Dunlop said that he spoke to a male person, who declined to provide his name, and who advised Mr Dunlop that Mr Xie had given him the telephone number and he has had no further contact with Mr Xie. The respondents submitted that the Court should find that the person who answered the phone was Mr Xie.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The term “not practicable” is also to be interpreted and applied in a way that best promotes the overarching purpose, which is to facilitate the just resolution of disputes according to law, as quickly, inexpensively, and efficiently as possible: University of New England v Boerner [2024] FCA 191 at [8] (Wheelahan J), referring to s 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).CONSIDERATION The precondition to engaging rr 10.23 and 10.24 is that it is “not practicable” to serve a document on a person in a way required by the Rules. That does not require the respondents to demonstrate that there is an inability to effect personal service on Mr Xie or that it is impossible to do so. Rather, the respondents were required to demonstrate that it is not practicable to serve Mr Xie personally, in the sense that it is not sensible or feasible to do so. Therefore, the question was whether, at the date of the application, the respondents, using reasonable efforts, were unable to serve Mr Xie personally. Having regard to the numerous attempts to effect personal service of the Cross-Claim Documents on Mr Xie and his apparent attempts to evade service, I was satisfied that the respondents had established that they, using reasonable efforts, were unable to serve Mr Xie and that it is not practicable to serve Mr Xie in a way required by the Rules. The next matter that the respondents were required to establish was that in all probability the proposed mode of substituted service will bring the Cross-Claim Documents to the attention of Mr Xie. This requires that there be a proper evidential basis upon which to conclude that, in all probability, the proposed mode of substituted service will bring the relevant documents to the attention of the party to be served. The respondents provided evidence of attempts to serve the Cross-Claim Documents on Mr Xie at the Berwick address, which is occupied and listed on the Australian Electoral Roll as an address for “Yuan-Sheng Xie”. The respondents also provided evidence that an email sent recently to an email address, which Mr Xu used for prior communications with Mr Xie, received a response the next day. Thus, the email address is currently in use. The email in response was from a person using an email signature that included the name “Kim Xie” and other contact details for Rec Capital, including the mobile telephone number. I was satisfied that the proposed methods of substituted service, namely leaving the Cross-Claim Documents at and mailing them to the Berwick address, emailing the Cross-Claim Documents to the email address kim@reccapital.com.au and sending a text message to the mobile telephone number, are likely to bring the Cross-Claim Documents to the attention of Mr Xie. Accordingly, I made orders for substituted service substantially in the terms sought by the Respondents.