Chaudhri v Takeovers Panel

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Chaudhri v Takeovers Panel [2011] FCA 1488

Citation: Chaudhri v Takeovers Panel [2011] FCA 1488
Parties: AMBREEN CHAUDHRI and DATA BASE SYSTEMS LIMITED v TAKEOVERS PANEL, BELLWETHER INVESTMENTS PTY LTD, JAMES STUART CRAIG, AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION and FAROOQ KHAN
File number: WAD 329 of 2011
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 21 December 2011
Corrigendum: 30 January 2012
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS – Takeovers Panel – internal review – application to extend time to consider making a declaration of unacceptable circumstances and consequential orders – power to extend time – undertaking given pursuant to s 201A of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) – uncertainty in undertaking – no declaration – considerations relevant to Court’s discretion to extend time – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Pt 6.10, Div 2

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Takeovers Panel – hearing concluded on undertaking being given – decision to accept undertaking considered to be possibly jurisdictional error or a mistake – whether Panel has power to make later decision or declaration – opportunity to consider whether to make a declaration – whether power has been exercised – whether there is utility in granting an extension of time

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – whether an application is an interlocutory or final – timing of application

Legislation: Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) ss 201A(3), 201A(4)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 657A(1), 657A(2), 657A(3), 657B, 657C(2), 657C(3), 657D(1), 657D(3), 657EA(4), 657EA(5)
Cases cited:

Attorney-General (Cth) v Alinta Ltd (2008) 233 CLR 542
Bentley Capital Limited [2011] ATP 8
Bentley Capital Limited O1R [2011) ATP 13
Chandler v Alberta Association of Architects [1989] 2 SCR 848
Comptroller-General of Customs v Kawasaki Motors Pty Ltd (No 1) (1991) 32 FCR 219
Export Development Grants Board v EMI (Australia) Ltd (1985) 9 FCR 269
Hall v Nominal Defendant (1966) 117 CLR 423
Kabourakis v Medical Practitioners Board (Vic) (2005) 24 VAR 90
Kabourakis v Medical Practitioners Board (Vic) (2006) 25 VAR 449
Licul v Corney (1976) 180 CLR 213
McCann v Pendant Software Pty Ltd (2006) 235 ALR 566
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Kurtovic (1990) 21 FCR 193
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Bhardwaj (2002) 209 CLR 597
Re Takeovers Panel [2002] FCA 1120
Takeovers Panel v Glencore International AG (2005) 55 ACSR 453

Date of hearing: 18 November 2011
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 86
Counsel for the Applicants: JC Giles with P Fletcher
Solicitor for the Applicants: Paul Fletcher & Co
Counsel for the First Respondent: S Dharmananda
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the Second Respondents: The Second Respondents did not appear
Counsel for the Third Respondent: DJ Jackson
Solicitor for the Third Respondent: Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Counsel for the Fourth Respondent: ML Bennett
Solicitor for the Fourth Respondent: Bennett & Co

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Chaudhri v Takeovers Panel [2011] FCA 1488

CORRIGENDUM

1.In paragraph 56 of the Reasons for Judgment, in the fifth…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chaudhri v Takeovers Panel and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1488
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Chaudhri v Takeovers Panel involves a dispute concerning the operation of the Takeovers Panel under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The applicants, including Mr Khan and Mr Chaudhri, sought an extension of time for the Panel to consider making a declaration of unacceptable circumstances and consequential orders after the Panel had concluded its review and accepted undertakings in lieu of making a declaration. The applicants argued that the Panel’s decision to accept the undertakings was potentially a jurisdictional error or a mistake, and that there was utility in granting an extension of time for the Panel to revisit its earlier decision.

The central legal issues revolved around the power of the Takeovers Panel to extend time limits, the completeness of the Panel’s function upon accepting undertakings, and the implications of the Panel's acceptance of undertakings on its ability to revisit its earlier decisions. The applicants contended that the Panel had not fully discharged its function and could revisit its earlier decision to make a declaration of unacceptable circumstances. Conversely, the Panel argued that once it accepted undertakings, its function was complete and it did not have a roving commission to revisit matters.

The Court considered the statutory framework, including the time limits for making a declaration under the Corporations Act, and the principles of administrative law pertinent to the Panel’s powers. It noted that while there was a common understanding that an extension of time might be granted, the more significant issue was whether the Panel’s function was complete upon accepting undertakings. The Court concluded that once the Panel accepted the undertakings, its function was complete, and it did not have the power to revisit its earlier decision to accept those undertakings. The Court found that the Panel’s acceptance of undertakings concluded its function, and there was no power to revisit the decision. Therefore, the application for an extension of time was dismissed. The Court further ordered that unless contrary submissions were filed within 14 days, the Review Panel was to pay the costs of the applicants and the fourth respondent. If submissions on costs were filed, the applicants and fourth respondent would have a further 14 days to reply, and any issue as to costs would be determined on the papers.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. Unless submissions to the contrary are filed by the first respondent within 14 days, the first respondent is to pay the costs of the applicants and the fourth respondent to be taxed if not agreed.

3. If submissions on costs are filed by the first respondent, the applicants and fourth respondent have a further 14 days to reply.

4. Any issue as to costs will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On the following day, the Review Panel made a decision and delivered reasons in the Review Panel Proceeding explaining why it accepted the undertakings in lieu of making a determination (the Review Panel decision). The Review Panel decision records that the Review Panel accepted undertakings in relation to the affairs of Bentley following review of the first Panel decision, which concerned whether the parties were associates in relation to Bentley. The first Panel had not been satisfied that it could draw the necessary inferences to find the alleged associations. On additional material being made available to the Review Panel, the Review Panel noted (at [1]) that it:… was minded to declare the circumstances unacceptable as it was satisfied that parties were associated in relation to Bentley, resulting in the acquisition of shares otherwise than in accordance with Chapter 6 [of the CA]. However, the parties offered undertakings to remedy the unacceptable circumstances, which the Panel accepted. In the balance of its detailed reasons (199 paragraphs), the Review Panel explained why it inferred that Mr Khan, Mrs Chaudhri and Data Base were acting in concert or perhaps had a relevant agreement in relation to the conduct of Bentley’s affairs, in relation to the acquisition of Bentley’s shares by Data Base on 7 April 2011. Therefore, acquisition by Data Base of a parcel of shares known as the ‘Simpson Parcel’ in April 2011 contravened or gave rise to a contravention of s 606 CA. The Review Panel also inferred that Mr Chaudhri and Mrs Chaudhri were acting or proposing to act in concert, or perhaps had a relevant agreement in relation to the conduct of Queste Communications Limited, an ASX listed company. That association had not been disclosed. The acquisition of the Simpson Parcel, according to the Review Panel, was the acquisition of a substantial interest otherwise and in accordance with Ch 6 CA in circumstances where the market was unaware of the aggregated voting power. In the Review Panel’s view (at [189]), the acquisition of control over voting shares in Bentley did not take place in an efficient, competitive and informed market. The holders of Bentley shares did not have a reasonable and/or equal opportunity to participate in any benefit accruing to the associated parties. By paras 190 to 195, the Review Panel concluded (footnotes and annexures omitted):190. Accordingly, having had regard to the matters in s657A(3), we were minded to declare that the circumstances were unacceptable. We informed the parties and provided a further brief inviting submissions as to proposed orders. The orders we proposed included disclosure of the association and the option of seeking an Item 7 approval, which if not taken or if approval was not obtained, would have been followed by divestiture of the shares.191. We were then offered undertakings based on these proposed orders to remedy the unacceptable circumstances which, as settled, are in Annexures A and B. The effect of the undertakings includes that:(a)disclosure will be made of the association in Bentley that the Panel found(b)[Data Base] will be prevented from exercising any votes attaching to the Simpson parcel(c)shareholders in Bentley, other than [Mr Khan], [Mrs Chaudhri], [Data Base] and any of their associates (Associated Parties), Mr Chaudhri, Orion and Queste or any of their associates will be invited to consider whether the acquisition of the Simpson parcel should be approved under Item 7 of s611(d)if the Item 7 approval is not obtained, the Simpson parcel will be divested by [Data Base]. This will happen by way of pro rata offer to all shareholders other than the Associated Parties, Mr Chaudhri, Orion and Queste. Any of the Simpson parcel shares remaining will be transferred to a stockbroker appointed by ASIC for sale. The Associated Parties, Mr Chaudhri, Orion and Queste will not be permitted to re-acquire them and(e)None of the Associated Parties may take into account any relevant interest or voting power that any of them had in the Simpson parcel for the purpose of the ‘creep’ exemption in Item 9 of s611.192. Mrs Chaudhri submitted that divesting a large parcel of shares in a thinly traded stock “could drive the share price down.” She therefore proposed the intermediate step of the pro rata offer to shareholders before the shares were divested.193. If the share price is driven down, all shareholders, and likely the company itself, could be unfairly prejudiced. In many cases, that consequence may be unavoidable. In this case, we are prepared to accept the offer of this step.194. The applicants submitted that “The serious nature of the unacceptable circumstances in this matter and its effect on Bentley minority shareholders warrants the Panel making a declaration of unacceptable circumstances and orders.” In Pinnacle VRB Ltd (No 5), the Panel preferred not to make a declaration of unacceptable circumstances unless it was necessary to found orders or was justified by bad faith in the conduct of the directors.195. While the nature of the unacceptable circumstances here is serious, the undertakings achieve what orders would have achieved, and indeed more because of the intermediate step of the pro rata offer, and we are prepared to accept them and not make the declaration of unacceptable circumstances we would otherwise have made.The undertakings given to the Panel in lieu of declarations

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Again, the parties are at odds over this issue.CONSIDERATIONIs there power to extend time? In Glencore, Finkelstein J made observations (at [17]), expressly obiter, to the effect that if the Panel believes that the original declaration requires variation, it can make appropriate changes under its power to vary the decision under review (s 657EA(4)(a) CA) and there is no time constraint in the exercise of that power. Those observations, however, preceded the amendments made in 2007 which added s 657EA(5) CA setting up special time limits for the making of a declaration by a Review Panel. It is clear from s 657EA(5) CA that the Review Panel can only make a declaration of unacceptable circumstances, after conducting its review, if the declaration is made within three months after the circumstances occur or, alternatively, within one month after the application for review was made, whichever is the later time. The Court may extend the period on application by the Panel. There is no reason to believe, nor was it argued in this case, that such an application must be made within the original time period. However, delay will clearly be a factor to take into account given the emphasis in the entire Panel regime on expeditious decision-making within a potentially dynamic market environment. Interestingly, although the amendment by s 657EA(5) CA stipulates the time limit within which the Review Panel should make a declaration, it does not impose any express time limit for any of the other acts to which subs (4) is directed, such as varying the decision reviewed or setting it aside, or setting it aside and substituting a new decision. In any event, for the purposes of this application, it is accepted by all parties that an extension of time is necessary if the Review Panel is to be permitted to revisit its earlier decision. To the extent that Glencore might be taken as authority for the proposition that if the Panel believes the original declaration requires variation, it can make appropriate changes under its power to vary the decision under review without any time constraint, in my view, the amendment makes it clear that if a Review Panel wishes to make or vary the original declaration and it has not done so within the time limits, it needs leave to do so. The power to vary consequential orders is not, in my view, the same as the power to make a declaration. Although it is common ground that an extension of time is needed and that it may be sought and granted outside of the original maximum time period, there is another more significant question. That question is whether the function of the Panel is complete. Senior counsel for the Review Panel made the submission that the Panel does not ‘put away the file’ once there has been a declaration or order or an acceptance of undertakings. Counsel for Mr Khan made it clear that ‘putting its file away’ is exactly the effect of the legislation once the Panel has discharged its function. Counsel for the applicants made the point that the Panel does not have a roving commission to enquire into matters generally once it has discharged its function of either making or not making a declaration with or without consequential orders.