SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Judicial Review)
CHATTAWAY v MINISTER FOR HEALTH AND ORS (No 2)
[2021] SASC 89
Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stanley
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - COSTS
The applicant instituted proceedings for judicial review seeking to review a direction made on 26 January 2020 by the Chief Psychiatrist acting as the delegate for the Minister for Health and Wellbeing. The terms of the direction were to transfer the applicant to Yatala Labour Prison from James Nash House pursuant to s 269V(2)(b) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) (CLCA) for a term of three months. The application for judicial review was commenced on 13 May 2020.
On 17 June 2020 a question as to the construction of s 269V(1) was referred by a case stated to the Full Court. On 1 July 2020 the Full Court answered the question of law. The question of law was answered in accordance with the submissions of the respondents. The Full Court ordered that the costs of the question reserved be the respondent’s costs in the cause. On 26 November 2020 the High Court refused special leave to appeal from the decision of the Full Court. Subsequently the High Court ordered that the applicant pay the respondent’s costs of the application for special leave.
Following the refusal of the special leave application the applicant did not file or serve any documents in these proceedings or otherwise put the respondents on notice as to how he wished to progress the proceedings, if at all. In circumstances where the question of law referred to the Full Court disposed of the ground pleaded at paragraph 8 of the second statement of facts, issues and contentions filed in this matter, but not the ground pleaded at paragraph 9 of that document. The applicant has taken no further steps to advance his application for judicial review since 30 November 2020. It appears the applicant no longer seeks any relief from the court.
The respondents sought an order for their costs of the proceedings on a standard costs basis to be agreed or taxed on the basis that they had been wholly successful in the proceedings. The applicant opposed the application for costs and contended that there should be no order as to costs on the basis that the cause of action in proceedings for judicial review has not been finally resolved and has now become moot.
Held
1. The respondents have been successful on the only aspect of the proceedings determined by this Court, being the question of law answered by the Full Court.
2. Following judgment in that matter, the applicant has not pressed any other aspect of the proceedings. As a result, the only costs incurred in these proceedings have been as a result of the institution of the proceedings, the reservation to and determination of the question of law in the Full Court and this application.
3. There is no proper reason why the respondents…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Chattaway v Minister for Health (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] SASC 89
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included the proper procedure for determining questions of law reserved for the Full Court, the appropriate costs order in the context of a dismissed application, and whether the case had become moot following the applicant's return to Yatala Labour Prison. The court needed to determine whether the application for judicial review should be considered in light of the applicant's return to Yatala, and if so, whether this rendered the matter moot. Additionally, the court had to assess the appropriate costs order given the nature of the proceedings and the applicant's withdrawal of other aspects of the case.
The court found that the respondents were entitled to an award of costs as there was no proper reason why they should not receive compensation for the costs incurred. The Full Court's determination of the question of law was deemed to have re-enlivened the relevant issue, and therefore the case was not moot. The court rejected the applicant's argument that the case had become moot due to his return to Yatala, as the underlying issue of his detention remained relevant. The court concluded that the applicant should pay the respondents' costs on the standard costs basis, to be agreed or taxed.
In conclusion, the court ordered that the applicant pay the respondents their costs incurred in the proceedings. The order was based on the successful determination of the question of law by the Full Court and the dismissal of the application for judicial review. The court did not accept the applicant's argument that the case had become moot, as the issue of his detention remained pertinent. The costs were to be assessed on the standard costs basis, to be agreed or taxed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Held
1. The respondents have been successful on the only aspect of the proceedings determined by this Court, being the question of law answered by the Full Court.
2. Following judgment in that matter, the applicant has not pressed any other aspect of the proceedings. As a result, the only costs incurred in these proceedings have been as a result of the institution of the proceedings, the reservation to and determination of the question of law in the Full Court and this application.
3. There is no proper reason why the respondents should not be entitled to an award of costs.
4. The applicant’s submission that the cause is moot because the applicant was returned to James Nash House in December 2020 is not accepted. Once the applicant was returned to Yatala the relevant issue sought to be agitated by the application for judicial review was re-enlivened.
It is ordered that the applicant pay the respondents their costs on the standard costs basis to be agreed or taxed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the Full Court’s decision, Mr Chattaway was returned to James Nash House in December 2020. Despite this, he did not pursue any further aspects of his original application. The respondents, including the Minister for Health and the Secretary to the Department of Human Services, applied for costs incurred due to the judicial review proceedings, the reservation of a question of law to the Full Court, and the subsequent application. Mr Chattaway argued that the case was moot because he had been returned to James Nash House; however, this argument was rejected by the Court as the return did not negate the relevance of the issues raised in the judicial review.
The Court found that the respondents were entitled to an award of costs on the standard costs basis. The proceedings were initiated by Mr Chattaway, and the Full Court’s decision revived the issues he sought to address through his application for judicial review. Therefore, the Court ordered Mr Chattaway to pay the respondents their costs, which are to be agreed upon or taxed. This decision pertains to the procedural and evidentiary aspects of the case, focusing solely on the factual background and the progression of events leading to the costs determination.
This case, Chattaway v Minister for Health (No 2), represents a judicial review proceeding that came before the court following a Full Court determination. Initially, the applicant, Chattaway, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Minister for Health, which pertained to his placement in a mental health facility. After the Full Court answered a certified question of law, the matter returned to this Court for the determination of costs. The proceedings involved a series of applications and interlocutory orders, most notably the certification and determination of a question of law by the Full Court. The applicant did not pursue other aspects of the proceedings after the Full Court's determination, limiting the current costs to those associated with the institution of the original proceedings, the reservation and determination of the question of law, and the current costs application. The Court rejected the applicant's argument that the matter had become moot, as the issue of his placement in a mental health facility was re-enlivened upon his return to Yatala. Consequently, the Court ordered that the applicant pay the respondents' costs on the standard costs basis, to be agreed upon or taxed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the applicant is entitled to costs following the determination of the proceedings, given the respondents have been successful on the only aspect of the proceedings decided by the Court.
2. Whether the respondents are entitled to an award of costs on the standard costs basis, considering the applicant's argument that the cause is moot due to the applicant being returned to James Nash House in December 2020.
3. Whether the issue sought to be agitated by the application for judicial review was re-enlivened once the applicant was returned to Yatala.
Held
1. On the question of whether the applicant is entitled to costs, the Court concluded that since the respondents were successful on the only aspect of the proceedings determined, there is no entitlement to costs for the applicant. The result is that the applicant does not receive costs.
2. Regarding whether the respondents are entitled to an award of costs on the standard costs basis, the Court rejected the applicant's argument that the cause is moot. The Court held that the respondents are entitled to their costs. The result is that the respondents are awarded costs on the standard costs basis.
3. Concerning whether the issue sought to be agitated by the application for judicial review was re-enlivened once the applicant was returned to Yatala, the Court held that the issue was indeed re-enlivened upon the applicant's return to Yatala. The result is that the issue was not rendered moot.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court in Chattaway v Minister for Health (No 2) addressed the issue of costs following the determination of the proceedings. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that the party that has been successful on the matters decided by the Court should be entitled to an award of costs. In this case, the respondents had been successful on the only aspect of the proceedings that had been determined by the Court, specifically the question of law answered by the Full Court. The Court acknowledged that the only costs incurred in these proceedings were those related to the institution of the proceedings, the reservation to and determination of the question of law in the Full Court, and the application itself. The Court held that there was no proper reason why the respondents should not be entitled to an award of costs, reflecting the general rule that the successful party in legal proceedings is entitled to costs.
The Court also considered the applicant's argument that the cause was moot due to the applicant being returned to James Nash House in December 2020. The Court rejected this submission, explaining that once the applicant was returned to Yatala, the relevant issue sought to be agitated by the application for judicial review was re-enlivened. This reasoning aligns with the principle that a case becomes moot if subsequent events make it impossible for the court to grant any effective relief. However, in this instance, the Court determined that the issue remained live and capable of resolution, thus negating the mootness argument.
Furthermore, the Court deliberated on whether the respondents were entitled to an award of costs on the standard costs basis. The Court noted that the applicant had not pressed any other aspect of the proceedings following judgment. This led the Court to conclude that the respondents were entitled to an award of costs, as the applicant had not pursued any further claims. The Court's decision to award costs on the standard costs basis followed from its assessment that the proceedings had resulted in a definitive resolution of the issues put before it.
The Court's decision also touched on the procedural aspects of awarding costs. The Court held that the costs should be agreed upon or taxed, which is a common practice in judicial review cases in Australia. This approach ensures that the costs awarded are reasonable and proportionate to the work involved in the proceedings. The Court's decision to order the applicant to pay the respondents' costs on the standard costs basis reflects a clear application of the legal principles concerning costs in judicial review proceedings.
In summary, the Court in Chattaway v Minister for Health (No 2) applied well-established principles concerning the award of costs in judicial review proceedings. The Court's ratio decidendi is that the successful party is entitled to an award of costs, and that the issue of mootness does not apply where the relevant issues remain live and capable of resolution. The Court's decision also reinforces the principle that costs should be awarded on the standard costs basis where the proceedings have resulted in a definitive resolution of the issues. This decision provides clear guidance for practitioners on the award of costs in similar judicial review proceedings.