Charters and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

Charters and National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 4762 (21 December 2021)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/6715

Re:Meghan Charters

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member
Senior Member M Griffin QC

Date:21 December 2021

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision made on 30 September 2019, which affirmed the decision made on 4 February 2019 to refuse the Applicant’s access request, is affirmed.

.

......................................[sgd].................................

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME - access to the scheme – disability requirements not met – whether applicant meets early intervention requirements  – where applicant has permanent impairments under s 25(1) – Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome – Narcolepsy – whether provision of early intervention supports is likely to reduce the applicant’s future needs for supports in relation to disability – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 25, 43

National Disability Insurance Act 2013 (Cth) ss 20, 21, 24, 25, 33, 99, 100, 103

CASES

Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2019) 266 CLR 250

Grant v Repatriation Commission (1999) 57 ALD 1

McLaughlin v National Disability Insurance Agency [2021] AATA 496

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

.

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Access to the NDIS Operational Guideline

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Becoming a Participant) Rules 2016 (Cth)

National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member
Senior Member M Griffin QC

21 December 2021

Introduction

  1. The Applicant, Ms Charters, seeks access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the NDIS).

  2. She is 29 years old.  The Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (SoFIC) listed the following “current” diagnoses:

    (a)Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS);

    (b)Narcolepsy; 

    (c)Chronic Pain Syndrome/Fibromyalgia;

    (d)Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome (POTS)/Orthostatic Intolerance;

    (e)Cervical Spondylosis; and

    (f)Scoliosis.

  3. The SoFIC also stated that the Applicant has also been diagnosed with anxiety and depression for which she takes Lexapro daily.

  4. The Applicant lodged her access request form with the Respondent on 9 January 2019.  Her request was refused on 4 February 2019.  That decision was affirmed on 30 September 2019 on internal review.  The 30 September 2019 decision is the reviewable decision in the Tribunal.  

    The issues

  5. The Applicant concedes that she does not meet the disability requirements for entry into the NDIS pursuant to subsection 24(1) of the National Disability Insurance Act 2013 (Cth) (the Act).  She claims that she meets the criteria for early intervention in section 25 of the Act, which is set out below.  The Respondent conceded that the Applicant satisfies subsections 25(1)(a) and (c) of the Act.

  6. The questions to be decided are therefore whether the Applicant satisfies the criteria in subsection 25(1)(b) and, if so, whether subsection 25(3) applies.

  7. It is necessary to determine whether the Applicant’s condition Cervical Spondylosis (CS) can be considered when deciding whether the Applicant satisfies the early intervention criteria.  The date of onset was September 2019[1], around the time the reviewable decision was made and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Charters and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4762
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Ms Charters against a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse her access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The dispute centred on whether Ms Charters met the early intervention requirements for access, specifically whether the provision of early intervention supports was likely to reduce her future needs for supports in relation to disability. The case was heard by Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Ms Charters met the criteria for access to the NDIS under section 25(1) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). This involved assessing whether she had permanent impairments under section 25(1)(a) and, crucially, whether the provision of early intervention supports, such as physiotherapy and exercise programs, was likely to benefit her by reducing her future needs for disability-related supports, as stipulated in section 25(1)(b). A key legal issue was the interpretation of the term "disability" within section 25(1)(b) and whether it was limited to the specific impairments that qualified her for access to the NDIS.

The Tribunal considered extensive medical evidence detailing Ms Charters' diagnoses, including Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), narcolepsy, and immune deficiency. The Senior Member reasoned that while EDS itself was a permanent condition, the focus for early intervention was on whether supports like physiotherapy and exercise could mitigate future needs. The Tribunal drew upon previous interpretations of "disability" in similar NDIS contexts, noting that the term in section 25(1)(b) was not necessarily confined to the impairments that granted initial access. The evidence indicated that consistent physiotherapy and exercise had previously led to significant improvements in Ms Charters' functioning and that these supports were essential for managing her condition and reducing the risk of complications such as osteoarthritis and osteoporosis.

The Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision, finding that Ms Charters did not meet the early intervention requirements for access to the NDIS. The Senior Member concluded that the evidence did not establish that the proposed early intervention supports were likely to reduce her future needs for disability-related supports to the extent required by section 25(1)(b) of the Act.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by Meghan Charters for access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS) for early intervention supports. Meghan Charters suffers from Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), a group of rare inherited conditions affecting connective tissue, which results in joint hypermobility and instability, and other related conditions such as narcolepsy and immune deficiency. She argues that her EDS is likely to affect her in various ways throughout her life and may result in other conditions that typically occur in individuals with EDS. Ms Charters contends that without regular physical therapy and exercise, her mobility could become compromised, and she may require mobility aids ranging from walking sticks to wheelchairs.

Historically, Meghan Charters has received various medical assessments and reports detailing her conditions and the need for ongoing management. Dr Louise Tofts, a Rehabilitation Fellow, noted the significance of joint hypermobility syndrome and the importance of maintaining exercise levels and good posture to manage pain. Dr David Barnes, a neurologist, confirmed her narcolepsy diagnosis and recommended Dexamphetamine therapy. Dr Roberto Russo, a rheumatologist, highlighted concerns about probable secondary fibromyalgia and suggested cognitive behavioural therapy. Dr Stephen Reddel, a neurologist, and Professor David Sillence, a clinical geneticist, further assessed her immunological issues and the impact of her joint hypermobility on her overall health. Dr J M Spies, a neurologist, recommended a targeted program to build up resistance in the lower limb anti-gravity muscles.

In the context of her application for NDIS access, Meghan Charters submitted a statement asserting that her EDS requires significant treatment not adequately covered by mainstream funding. She emphasised the need for regular physical therapy and exercise to maintain her health and mobility. She estimated the after-tax cost of $14,000 annually for physiotherapy, including at least weekly sessions, and noted that Pilates and gym memberships were not funded through any mainstream service. Mr Zhang, a physiotherapist, supported her application by detailing the benefits of consistent physiotherapy sessions, including improved strength, mobility, and participation in daily activities.

The National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) considered Meghan Charters' application for NDIS access, focusing on the provision of early intervention supports. Mr Zhang noted the benefits of maintaining an exercise program to increase bone density and decrease the risk of osteoporosis. However, he also highlighted that it had been difficult to see Ms Charters consistently due to financial concerns. Despite this, he recommended two dynamic physiotherapy sessions per week in addition to fortnightly one-on-one sessions to maintain her progress. The NDIA ultimately decided to refuse access to the NDIS for early intervention supports, a decision Ms Charters sought to have internally reviewed.

This case concerns the applicant's application for access to the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS), focusing on the eligibility for early intervention supports based on her disabilities arising from Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS), narcolepsy, and specific antibody immune deficiency. The applicant originally applied for access to the NDIS, but the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) refused the application on the grounds that her disabilities did not meet the criteria under section 25(1) of the NDIS Act. The applicant then lodged an application for internal review of the NDIA's decision, which was also dismissed. Subsequently, the applicant applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for judicial review of the NDIA's decision. The AAT reviewed the evidence provided by the applicant, including medical reports and physiotherapy assessments, to determine whether the provision of early intervention supports would likely reduce the applicant's future needs for supports in relation to her disabilities. Key procedural steps include the filing of the application for internal review and the subsequent application to the AAT for judicial review, with both applications being dismissed. The AAT's decision focused on interpreting the relevant sections of the NDIS Act and the Supports Rules to ascertain whether the applicant's disabilities qualified for early intervention supports. This case underscores the importance of detailed medical evidence and physiotherapy assessments in determining the eligibility for NDIS supports.

The matter came before the AAT as a judicial review application challenging the NDIA's decision to refuse the applicant access to the NDIS under section 25(1). The applicant's internal review application was dismissed by the NDIA, leading to the AAT review. Throughout the proceedings, the applicant argued that her disabilities, which include EDS, narcolepsy, and specific antibody immune deficiency, warranted early intervention supports to reduce future support needs. The AAT examined the evidence, including historical medical reports and physiotherapy assessments, to determine if the applicant's conditions met the statutory criteria for early intervention supports. The decision-making process involved interpreting sections of the NDIS Act and the relevant rules, particularly focusing on the distinction between "impairment" and "disability" as they relate to early intervention supports. The AAT's final decision affirmed the NDIA's refusal of access to the NDIS, concluding that the applicant's disabilities did not meet the necessary criteria for early intervention supports.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 9.4 of the Guideline requires regard being given to the considerations outlined in Schedule 1 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth) (Supports Rules) when deciding whether the early intervention support is most appropriately funded or provided through the NDIS.Historical Medical Evidence The Applicant provided a number of historical medical reports. The earliest related to a consultation on 30 September 2009 with Dr Louise Tofts, Rehabilitation Fellow, at the Rehabilitation Department of The Children’s Hospital at Westmead. Dr Tofts reported:Meghan is significant symptomatic (sic) from her joint hypermobility syndrome, will need to maintain her exercise levels, work towards keeping a good posture and be conscious of treating symptoms as they arise to maintain a reasonable and tolerable pain level. We find that people with very flexible joints get more problems with pain as they become unfit and deconditioned and the more care and attention that is paid to keeping the body health (sic) pays off in improved endurance and reduced pain symptoms. In a partially obscured report dated in October 2010, Dr David Barnes confirmed the Applicant’s diagnosis of narcolepsy and that he was applying to the Health Department for Dexamphetamine therapy. He thought she would do well. In a report dated 21 October 2010, Dr Roberto Russo, consultant rheumatologist, referred to the confirmed narcolepsy diagnosis and “probable secondary fibromyalgia” for which he was reluctant to introduce any pharmacological treatment until her narcolepsy had been managed. He was concerned about her mood and felt that she would benefit from seeing a psychologist, and if needed, a psychiatrist and said that it may be an opportunity to commence cognitive behavioural therapy to assist her management of the fibromyalgia. Dr Stephen Reddel, consultant neurologist, signed a report typed on 18 May 2011. It was addressed to Professor Sean Riminton at the Immunology Department of Concord Hospital. Dr Reddel referred to Dr Barnes’s diagnosis of narcolepsy and commented that he did not get any history of real cataplexy. He noted the Applicant’s clinical ligamentous laxity, previously diagnosed mitral valve prolapse, and that she has “something of an immunological problem”. After referring to two substances related to a known gene for EDS, Dr Reddel said that he wished to do a “high read cytogenetics but I will find out the most up to date test”. Professor David Sillence, clinical geneticist, signed a report dated 14 November 2011, having reviewed the Applicant at the Outpatient Adult Connective Tissue Dysplasia Service. He related her “constellation of symptoms”, POTS, narcolepsy, respiratory symptoms, and immune dysfunction, to her Joint Hypermobility Syndrome. Dr J M Spies from the Department of Neurology, Institute of Clinical Neurosciences, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital and University of Sydney, wrote a report dated 27 November 2012 about the Applicant’s orthostatic intolerance. Dr Spies wrote that test findings were consistent with orthostatic intolerance but the findings on tilt study did not meet the criteria for POTS. In the doctor’s opinion, there was a spectrum, and the treatment was the same. Dr Spies recommended that the Applicant “commence a targeted program to build up resistance in the lower limb anti-gravity muscles so calf presses leg presses and hip flexion against resistance is a bare minimum”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Zhang noted the Applicant’s presentation with global joint hypermobility which makes her more prone to subluxations or dislocations, and her reports of joint pain which were consistent with the pathophysiology of EDS, along with the possibility for earlier onset of osteoarthritis. Mr Zhang went on to observe that although this was something which cannot change, keeping her on track with an exercise program and progressing to land-based, high impact weight-bearing exercise to increase bone density and decrease the risk of osteoporosis, would be highly beneficial to her quality of life.Application for internal review of decision refusing access Attached to the application for internal review of the decision refusing access made on 4 February 2019 were a statement by Ms Charters and a physiotherapy assessment by Mr Zhang dated 17 April 2019. Mr Zhang reported that the Applicant had seen Mr Zhang 38 times when he wrote his 17 April 2019 report. The report was in almost identical terms to the 18 September 2019 report. The most relevant difference for present purposes was his recommendations for two physiotherapy sessions a week for hands-on therapy and exercise prescription with appropriate progressions. They would focus on soft tissue release therapy, joint mobilisations, dry needling, and prescribed independent exercise program for long-term management and injury reduction. He also recommended an additional physio-led and supervised exercise class inclusive of strengthening and reformer Pilates exercises to build up overall body strength. Ms Charters wrote that the Applicant had been diagnosed with three rare diseases which were lifelong, incurable, and can only be managed: EDS, narcolepsy and specific antibody immune deficiency. The latter two are managed with “drugs etc” and “are not the main issue for applying” for NDIS assistance. EDS requires the most treatment “that is not covered adequately by mainstream funding”. EDS are a group of rare inherited conditions that affect connective tissue which provide support to skin, tendons, ligaments, blood vessels, internal organise and bones. People with EDS have joint hypermobility and loose, unstable joints that dislocate easily. EDS is likely to affect a sufferer in different ways through their lifetime and may be diagnosed with many other conditions known to occur in those with EDS. Ms Charters wrote that without regular physical therapy and exercise, the Applicant’s mobility could become compromised and noted that some members of the EDS community use mobility aids from walking sticks to wheelchairs. She summarised the financial costs required for the Applicant to keep herself “healthy” and estimated an after-tax cost of $14,000, including $8,000 for physiotherapy, “at least once a week and ideally twice per week”. She noted that Pilates and gym membership “are not funded through any mainstream service”. The T Documents contained NDIA Interaction Notes with Mr Zhang dated 24 September 2019. He said that it had been difficult to see the Applicant recently due to financial concerns. She often accessed therapy for symptomatic relief but was not able to engage with physiotherapy on a consistent basis. Therapy so far had focused on building strength and mobility to ensure that she is able to participate in activities of daily life to the best of her ability. She was compliant with the exercise programs which focussed on improving baseline strength and posture. He recommended two dynamic sessions per week in addition to a fortnightly one on one physiotherapy session to focus on strength training and ensuring she was on track with her exercises. That level of support would improve her functioning significantly. In the past, she has seen great improvement when she has been able to access physiotherapy consistently.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The principal support in contention in the proceedings was physiotherapy. Pilates and gym classes are also relevant.Can the disability caused by CS be taken into consideration? Before considering the merits of the subsection 25(1)(b) question, it is necessary to decide whether CS and the disability arising from the CS can be considered. It is likely to be permanent as required by subsection 25(1)(a), based on Dr Wong’s evidence. The Applicant put three arguments. The first relied on what was said to be Deputy President Humphries’ consideration of the meaning of “disability” as distinct from “impairment” in McLaughlin and National Disability Insurance Agency.[2] That case was concerned with the interpretation of section 34 of the Act. The Applicant sought a number of supports that did not relate to the impairments in respect of which access to the NDIS had been granted. [2] [2021] AATA 496 (“McLaughlin”). The relevant rule in that case was 5.1(b) of the Supports Rules which provides that a support will not be provided or funded under the NDIS if “it is not related to a participant’s disability” (emphasis added). Deputy President Humphries had to decide, as a preliminary issue, whether the Tribunal had jurisdiction to review a decision to approve supports under section 33(2) of the Act if the supports did not relate to the impairments through which the person gained access to the NDIS. It is significant that the view of the NDIA in that case was that the term “disability” in rule 5.1(b) was not limited to the particular impairments which qualified a person for access to the NDIS under the “disability requirements” under section 24. Deputy President Humphries found accordingly. The Applicant argued that the same interpretation should be applied to disability in subsection 25(1)(b) of the Act. Subsection 25(1)(b) requires the decision-maker to be satisfied that “the provision of early intervention supports for the person is likely to benefit the person by reducing the person’s future needs for support in relation to disability”. The Applicant pointed out that in contrast to subsection 25(1)(a), subsection 25(1)(b) does not refer to a person’s “impairment” but instead, requires consideration of a person’s “disability”. The provision does not require the disability to be “attributable to” one or more impairments, as subsection 24(1) requires. Therefore, the Applicant argued, “disability” in subsection 25(1)(b) does not have to be attributable to an impairment found in subsection 25(1)(a). Chapter 3 of the Act is entitled “Participants and their plans”. Sections 24 and 25 are found in Part 1 of that Chapter which is entitled “Becoming a participant”. They are two of the access criteria specified in subsection 21(1) of the Act. Part 2 of Chapter 3 is entitled “Participants’ plans”. Section 34, with which Deputy President Humphries was concerned, is found in Division 2 of Part 2 which is entitled “Preparing participants’ plans”. That provision is concerned with specifying general and reasonable and necessary supports in a statement of participant supports