Charmaine Collett and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 86 min read

[2013] AATA  56

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/0372

2011/5124

Re

Charmaine Collett

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Senior Member K Bean

Date 1  February 2013
Place Adelaide

1.  In application 2011/0372:

(a)  the reconsideration decision of 24 January 2011 is set aside and in substitution for that decision it is decided that:

(i) the respondent is liable to pay compensation to the applicant pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) for the condition of "L5/S1 disc rupture resulting in an incomplete cauda equina syndrome" sustained on 27 August 2010; and

(ii) the matter is remitted to the respondent for determination of the applicant's entitlements under other provisions of the SRC Act.

(b)  the Tribunal:

(i)  reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and

(ii) orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by the applicant pursuant to s 67(8) of the SRC Act.

2.  In application 2011/5124:

(a)  the Tribunal grants liberty to the parties to provide written submissions within 14 days as to why the reconsideration decision of 29 November 2011 should not be set aside and the matter remitted to the respondent to be reconsidered in accordance with these Reasons, and/or why the costs of the proceedings should not be paid by the respondent; and

(b)  orders that in the absence of any such submissions:

(i) the reviewable decision of 29 November 2011 is set aside and the matter is remitted to the respondent pursuant to s 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 to be reconsidered in accordance with these Reasons; and

(ii) the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by the applicant pursuant to s 67(8) of the SRC Act.

........................................................................

Senior Member K Bean

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION - Lumbar disc rupture and cauda equina syndrome - Whether injury occurred in course of employment - Whether applicant's account of circumstances of injury should be accepted - Balance of the evidence establishes injury occurred in course of applicant's employment - Respondent liable to pay compensation - Effects of earlier aggravation of back injury subsumed by disc rupture - Question of liability to pay medical expenses and incapacity payments associated with that aggravation proposed to be remitted to respondent - Decisions under review set aside.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 5A, 5B, 14, 16, 19

CASES

Health Insurance Commission v Van Reesch (1996) 45 ALD 302 

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member K Bean

1 February 2013

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Ms Collett, has been employed by the respondent, Australia Post, as a postal delivery officer or “postie” since 2003.  Whilst she had some history of prior back problems, she says these had resolved before she started working for Australia Post. 

  2. However in May 2004 she suffered an episode of back pain while carrying out her duties.  This settled, but…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Charmaine Collett and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Charmaine Collett, an employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, was involved in a legal dispute regarding the cause and liability for her disc rupture. The primary issue was whether her disc rupture was caused by an event at work on 27 August 2010, as she claimed, or by an event over the weekend of 28 and 29 August 2010. The court had to assess the credibility of the various testimonies and the weight of the medical evidence provided. Significant inconsistencies in the accounts of the events and conversations over the relevant weekend complicated the matter further. The court was required to decide if the injury was caused by an event at work or another event over the weekend, and if it constituted an "injury" within the meaning of the relevant statute.

The court found that there was no evidence pointing to any specific event over the weekend that was more likely to have caused the disc rupture than the event described by Ms Collett at work. Although inconsistencies in the testimonies of Ms Collett, Ms North, and Ms Parish complicated the matter, the court accepted Ms Collett's evidence, along with the medical evidence from Doctors Ng, Guirguis, and Chase, over that of Associate Professor Bauze. It was concluded that the disc rupture was caused by events described by Ms Collett on 27 August 2010 and was an "injury" under the statute, leading to incapacity for work and impairment. Therefore, the Australian Postal Corporation was found liable to pay compensation for the injury. The court also ruled that the injury of 8 June 2010 was still ongoing, and the respondent remained liable for that injury.

Background

Background to the litigation

Charmaine Collett, an employee of the Australian Postal Corporation (APC), suffered a disc rupture on 30 August 2010, which she attributed to an incident that occurred on 27 August 2010 during her duties. Ms Collett claimed that she had lifted a heavy mailbag at work, which caused her back to lock up and subsequently led to the disc rupture. However, there were discrepancies in the accounts provided by Ms Collett and other witnesses regarding events over the weekend of 28 and 29 August 2010, potentially indicating alternative causes for her injury. There was no direct evidence pointing to an event over the weekend that could be more likely than the incident described by Ms Collett as the cause of her disc rupture.

The matter was brought before the court to determine whether Ms Collett's disc rupture constituted an injury under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) and whether the APC was liable for compensation. The decision involved a review of the evidence presented by both Ms Collett and the APC, including medical reports and witness statements. The court had to assess the credibility of the various testimonies and evidence to decide on the causation of the injury and the liability of the APC.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, although there is no dispute Ms Collett umpired two hockey matches on Sunday 29 August 2010, there is no evidence of any event occurring during either of those matches or at any other time over the weekend of 28 and 29 August 2010 which is a more probable cause of Ms Collett’s disc rupture than the event she has described which occurred at work on 27 August 2010. Therefore, whilst this evidence does not exclude the possibility of an event occurring over the relevant weekend which caused Ms Collett’s disc rupture, it does not point to any specific event of that kind. Ultimately therefore, any conclusion to the effect that Ms Collett’s disc rupture was caused by an event which occurred over the weekend of 28 and 29 August 2010 must find support elsewhere in the evidence.Inconsistencies in the evidence as to events and conversations on the relevant weekend There were a number of significant inconsistencies in the evidence of the lay witnesses as to activities and conversations over the relevant weekend. The more significant of these inconsistencies arose from the evidence of Ms North and Ms Parish, as compared with that of each other and Ms Collett. Those inconsistencies all related to the events and conversations which took place on Saturday 28 August 2010 and Sunday 29 August 2010. Ms Collett’s evidence as to what occurred on the Saturday was that she had been intending to play golf with Ms Parish but “on Saturday morning I still woke up very sore, and I rang her and cancelled”.[65] She said Ms Parish then suggested she come over to her place, which she ultimately did, together with her husband and her two sons. She said she went over to Ms Parish’s place at about 11am and stayed there until 7pm. When asked what she did at Ms Parish’s place she said she “lay on the couch”.[66][65] Transcript 29.11.11, p 72.[66] Transcript 29.11.11, p 72. However, Ms Parish’s evidence as to the detail of what happened on that day was somewhat different. In her statement she said:“… I recall that we were going to play golf in the afternoon at some point. I remember Char coming to my house and said she cannot play golf because she had hurt her back. She came with her husband Chris. I cannot recall whether their children also came.I recall being a bit frustrated as I was really excited about playing golf. I wish that she had contacted me sooner.”[67]She went on to say in her statement:“All I remember that we did that day was not much. We lazed around on the couch and watched television all day. I think we were watching movies or the football, but I do recall that my husband Craig, myself, Chris and Char were all sitting on the couch watching television together.”[68]Ms Parish also stated that Ms Collett told her “she hurt her back at work the day before”.[69][67] Exhibit 7, [4-5].[68] Exhibit 7, [6].[69] Exhibit 7, [8]. Ms Parish’s oral evidence was broadly consistent with her statement. However she also elaborated somewhat, indicating that when Ms Collett arrived, “… I had my golf clubs out and I was waiting for her, and when she rocked up that’s when I, yes, found out she had a bad back”.[70] She also indicated that from Ms Collett’s mobility and movement, she looked sore and Ms Collett told her she was in pain. She said she did not think she had heard from Ms Collett that day before she arrived at her place.[70] Transcript 23.01.12, p 279.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Notwithstanding the aspects of the evidence relied upon by the respondent, I have therefore concluded that I accept Ms Collett’s evidence, as well the evidence of Doctors Ng, Guirguis and Chase, which I prefer to the evidence of Associate Professor Bauze. It accordingly follows that I am satisfied that the events described by Ms Collett as having occurred in the course of her duties on 27 August 2010 did occur, and further that they precipitated the disc rupture with which she presented on 30 August 2010.Conclusion as to liability As to whether Ms Collett’s disc rupture constitutes an “injury” narrowly defined or a “disease”, I am assisted by the observations of Northrop J in the Full Federal Court decision of Health Insurance Commission v Van Reesch (1996) 45 ALD 302 at 307-308 (referring to the judgment of the High Court in Zickar v MGH Plastic Industries Pty Ltd (1996) 187 CLR 310), as follows:“From a consideration of the reasons for judgment in Zickar, it follows that the first matter that should have been determined by the tribunal in the present case was whether personal injury arising out of or in the course of her employment, was caused to Mrs Van Reesch. It may be accepted that there was evidence before the tribunal to support a finding that she suffered a disc prolapse described by the treating surgeon as a ‘right S1 nerve root compression due to extended nucleus L5-S1’ arising out of or in the course of her employment with the commission during the week commencing 13 October 1986. To adapt the wording of Toohey, McHugh and Gummow JJ in Zickar, the present case is not one of the autogenous disease. Or, to put it more accurately, it is not an autogenous disease upon which Mrs Van Reesch relies. It may be accepted that her back condition was an autogenous disease but her claim to personal injury is based on the disc prolapse which occurred. There is evidence that the disc prolapse was not an inevitable consequence of the disease. The rupture, being the prolapse, has been treated. If there was no rupture there would be no event answering the description of personal injury and Mrs Van Reesch would be driven to rely upon the definition of disease and s 29 of the 1971 Act. But there was such an event and the presence of the disease does not preclude reliance upon that event as personal injury.”Whilst these observations were made in the context of an earlier Act, the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971, I am satisfied that they are equally applicable in the context of the SRC Act. Accordingly, I am also satisfied that the disc rupture suffered by Ms Collett is properly regarded as an “injury” within the meaning of s 5A(1)(b) of the SRC Act, which arose in the course of Ms Collett’s employment. As I am also satisfied that the injury has resulted in incapacity for work and impairment, it follows that the respondent is liable to pay compensation for that injury, pursuant to s 14 of the SRC Act.ONGOING LIABILITY FOR THE INJURY OF 8 JUNE 2010

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

I propose to address each of these arguments in turn, by reference to the evidence before me.ConsiderationMs Collett’s failure to report the incident on 27 August 2010 I have set out above in summary form Ms Collett’s account of what occurred on 27 August 2010, and why she left her workplace before reporting the incident. However the respondent relies upon the evidence of its employees, Mr Senior and Mr MacAdam, as well as electronic attendance records, to say that a number of employees were present when Ms Collett returned from her round to whom she could have reported the incident before she went home. In particular, the respondent says that Mr Warren, Mr MacAdam and Mr Kirkbright were likely to have been present at the depot when Ms Collett returned and she could have reported the incident to one of them. In relation to the electronic attendance records, as I understand those documents, they confirm that Mr Warren, Mr MacAdam and Mr Kirkbright all attended work on 27 August 2010, and in each case had not clocked off before Ms Collett clocked off at 12:10pm on that day.[31] However Ms Collett’s evidence, which in this respect which was not disputed by Mr Senior or Mr MacAdam, was that each of them also had mail rounds, and the records do not reveal when they left to carry out those rounds, or when they returned. Indeed in his evidence, Mr Senior acknowledged that the documents did not actually reveal whether any of the relevant staff were present at the delivery centre or not at the time Ms Collett left to go home, that is at 12:10pm.[32][31] Exhibits 13, 14 & 15.[32] Transcript 25.01.12, p 487. Mr Senior, who is the Delivery Manager of the Port Adelaide Mail Centre where Ms Collett was based, also acknowledged that he was not himself at work on 27 August 2010. However he was later asked about who was present when Ms Collett returned from her rounds that day and the resulting record of interview, dated 21 November 2011, was tendered into evidence before me.[33] In the course of that interview, Mr Senior said it was his understanding that the team leaders Leonard Warren, Darren MacAdam and Graham Kirkbright were all present when Ms Collett came back from her round. He stated as follows:“I want to know if it’s been reported, if it was, where you know and to whom. So they and part of my investigation said that the whole 3 of them were around their, their admin desk which is right next to the clock off so they would have, she’d have to lean past them basically to perform her, her going home swipe. They said they were all there and they actually spoke to her on that day so you know, that’s how I know, plus also through our computer records of our system called Work Brain it shows them start/finish times, what their rostered hours were, what time they actually work and it will also show a clock in that shows when they went out on their round and when they came, come back on their round. …”[34][33] Exhibit 12.[34] Exhibit 12, p 8. However Mr MacAdam’s evidence was inconsistent with Mr Senior’s understanding in this respect. In his evidence, Mr MacAdam said that the occasion when he, Mr Kirkbright and Mr Warren were sitting at a computer near the time clock when Ms Collett clocked off, took place on a different day, 25 June 2010.[35] He said he recalled Ms Collett coming in after her round on that occasion and saying that she had “come off” her motorbike. He said that on Friday 27 August 2010, he could not recall whether he was at the depot when Ms Collett returned from her rounds.[36][35] Transcript 25.01.12, p 428.[36] Transcript 25.01.12, p 429.