Charkey*Papp and Town of Cottesloe

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

CHARKEY­PAPP and TOWN OF COTTESLOE [2007] WASAT 319



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2007] WASAT 319
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No:DR:83/2007DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS
Coram:MR P McNAB (MEMBER)18/12/07
19Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application for review dismissed and decision under review affirmed
B
PDF Version
Parties:JULIA CHARKEY­PAPP
TOWN OF COTTESLOE

Catchwords:

Town planning
Development application
Consulting rooms
Psychiatric practice
Residential area
Land reserved for primary regional road under Metropolitan Region Scheme
Highway
Assessed by Town on delegated authority as if underlying Residential Zone applied
Discretionary use of consulting rooms in Residential Zone after advertising
Principles applicable in the exercise of that discretion
Neighbours' objections including concern over nature of clientele
Weight to be given to such concerns
Neighbouring properties had commercial uses
Subject land refused planning permission in 1995 for chiropractor's rooms
Whether over­concentration of commercial uses in this residential area if proposal approved
Property uses on either side of the highway considered
Scattered non-residential uses demonstrated
Comparative interstate and local cases considered
Tribunal refused to set aside Town's decision
Reasons included the residential nature of precinct, avoiding over­concentration of commercial uses in the immediate locality, upholding consistency of decision-making and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town
Application for review dismissed and decision under review affirmed

Legislation:

Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA)
Town of Cottesloe Town Planning Scheme No 2, cl 4.3.1(a)
Draft Town of Cottesloe Town Planning Scheme No 3

Case References:

Cistulli v Lane Cove Council [2004] NSWLEC 707
Daehli & ors v Bayside City Council [2001] VCAT 2141
Lang v Woollahra Municipal Council [2007] NSWLEC 679
Mandurah Doctors and City of Mandurah [2007] WASAT 57
Patrick & Anor and Shire of Serpentine-Jarrahdale [2003] WATPAT 28
Von Witt v Hobart City Council (1995) 86 LGERA 134
Wogmed Pty Ltd v Corporation of the Town of Gawler & Anor [2004] SAERDC 66


Orders

1. The application for review is dismissed.,2. The decision under review is affirmed.

JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL STREAM : DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES ACT : PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA) CITATION : CHARKEY­PAPP and TOWN OF COTTESLOE [2007] WASAT 319 MEMBER : MR P McNAB (MEMBER) HEARD : DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS DELIVERED : 19 DECEMBER 2007 FILE NO/S : DR 83 of 2007 BETWEEN : JULIA CHARKEY­PAPP
    Applicant

    AND

    TOWN OF COTTESLOE
    Respondent

Catchwords:

Town planning - Development application - Consulting rooms - Psychiatric practice - Residential area - Land reserved for primary regional road under Metropolitan Region Scheme - Highway - Assessed by Town on delegated authority as if underlying Residential Zone applied - Discretionary use of consulting rooms in Residential Zone after advertising - Principles applicable in the exercise of that discretion - Neighbours' objections including concern over nature of clientele - Weight to be given to such concerns - Neighbouring properties had commercial uses - Subject land refused planning permission in 1995 for chiropractor's rooms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Charkey*Papp and Town of Cottesloe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 319
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Charkey*Papp and the Town of Cottesloe involved a dispute over the approval of a development application for a psychiatric consulting room in a residential area. The Town had initially assessed the application on the authority delegated by the Metropolitan Region Scheme, treating the land as if it were in a Residential Zone. The proposal included a discretionary use of consulting rooms in the residential zone, which had been advertised previously. The matter reached the court following objections from the neighbours, who expressed concerns about the nature of the clientele and the potential over-concentration of commercial uses in the area. The Town had previously refused a planning permission in 1995 for a chiropractor's room on the same property, and the court had to consider whether approving the current proposal would lead to an over-concentration of commercial uses.

The legal issues before the court included the appropriate weight to be given to the neighbours' concerns, the residential nature of the precinct, the avoidance of an over-concentration of commercial uses, the consistency of decision-making, and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town. The court also needed to consider the uses of properties on either side of the proposed site, as well as scattered non-residential uses demonstrated in the area. The court examined comparative interstate and local cases to aid in its decision-making. The Town's decision to refuse the planning permission was based on these considerations, and the Tribunal had previously refused to set aside the Town's decision.

The court dismissed the application for review, affirming the Town's decision. The reasons for this included the residential nature of the precinct, the avoidance of over-concentration of commercial uses in the immediate locality, the upholding of consistency in decision-making, and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town. The court found that the Town had appropriately exercised its discretion in denying the proposal, considering the surrounding properties, their uses, and the concerns of the neighbours. The decision was consistent with the principles applicable in the exercise of the Town's discretion, and the court saw no reason to interfere with the Town's decision. The application for review was dismissed, and the decision under review was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is dismissed. 2. The decision under review is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Charkey v Town of Cottesloe pertains to a development application for the establishment of consulting rooms for a psychiatric practice on a property situated within a residential zone in the Town of Cottesloe. The proposed site, located in an area designated for residential use, was also adjacent to land reserved for a primary regional road as per the Metropolitan Region Scheme. The Town of Cottesloe assessed the development application on delegated authority, applying the principles that would normally apply if the land was under a Residential Zone, which permits discretionary uses such as consulting rooms after advertising.

Objections to the proposal were raised by neighbouring property owners, primarily centred around concerns relating to the nature of the clientele and the potential over-concentration of commercial uses in the residential area. Notably, some of the neighbouring properties already had commercial uses. This development application followed a previous refusal of planning permission in 1995 for a chiropractor's rooms on the same property. The Town of Cottesloe considered the cumulative effect of commercial uses in the vicinity, including the proposed psychiatric consulting rooms, and examined the properties on either side of the nearby highway to determine if the proposed use would lead to an over-concentration of commercial activities in the immediate locality.

In assessing the application, the Town of Cottesloe took into account the residential nature of the precinct, the need to avoid an over-concentration of commercial uses in the immediate locality, the importance of upholding consistency in decision-making, and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town. The Town also reviewed comparative interstate and local cases to inform their decision-making process. The Tribunal, upon reviewing the Town's decision, found no grounds to set it aside. Consequently, the Tribunal dismissed the application for review and affirmed the Town of Cottesloe's decision.

The case of Charkey v Town of Cottesloe originates from a planning decision made by the Town of Cottesloe, which involved a development application to establish consulting rooms for a psychiatric practice within a residential area. The site, situated on a land reserved for a primary regional road under the Metropolitan Region Scheme, had previously been assessed by the Town on delegated authority as if it were subject to the underlying Residential Zone. The Town exercised its discretion to permit the use of consulting rooms in the Residential Zone after advertising the proposal, considering the principles applicable in such discretionary decisions. This included addressing objections from neighbours, who expressed concerns about the nature of the potential clientele and the potential over-concentration of commercial uses in the area. The land had been refused planning permission in 1995 for a chiropractor's rooms, which added to the context of the current application.

In response to the Town's decision, Charkey lodged an application for review with the relevant tribunal, challenging the Town's refusal to grant planning permission. The tribunal considered several factors, including the residential nature of the precinct, the importance of avoiding an over-concentration of commercial uses in the immediate locality, the need to uphold consistency in decision-making, and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town. The tribunal also weighed the objections from neighbours, taking into account that the neighbouring properties had commercial uses. After reviewing interstate and local cases for comparative purposes, the tribunal concluded that the Town's decision was appropriate and dismissed the application for review, affirming the decision under review.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Town of Cottesloe correctly exercise its discretion when assessing the development application for consulting rooms for a psychiatric practice in a residential zone, after advertising the proposal as a discretionary use?

2. What weight should be given to the neighbours' objections concerning the nature of the clientele, and how should this be balanced against the need for orderly and proper planning for the Town?

3. Is there an over-concentration of commercial uses in the residential area if the proposal for the psychiatric consulting rooms is approved?

4. How should the comparative interstate and local cases be considered in determining the consistency of decision-making and the appropriateness of the Town's refusal of planning permission?

5. Was the Tribunal correct in refusing to set aside the Town's decision, considering the residential nature of the precinct, the need to avoid over-concentration of commercial uses in the immediate locality, and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town?

Held
1. The Town of Cottesloe correctly exercised its discretion when assessing the development application for consulting rooms for a psychiatric practice in a residential zone, after advertising the proposal as a discretionary use. The court concluded that the Town's decision was within its lawful authority and affirmed the decision.

2. The weight to be given to the neighbours' objections concerning the nature of the clientele was considered, and the court concluded that these objections should be balanced against the need for orderly and proper planning for the Town. The court found that the Town appropriately weighed these concerns.

3. Regarding the over-concentration of commercial uses in the residential area, the court concluded that there was no significant over-concentration if the proposal for the psychiatric consulting rooms was approved. The court found that the Town's decision was consistent with planning principles.

4. The court determined that the comparative interstate and local cases should be considered in assessing the consistency of decision-making and the appropriateness of the Town's refusal of planning permission. The court found that the Town's decision was consistent with these cases.

5. The Tribunal was correct in refusing to set aside the Town's decision, considering the residential nature of the precinct, the need to avoid over-concentration of commercial uses in the immediate locality, and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town. The court concluded that the Tribunal's decision was correct and dismissed the application for review, affirming the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Town of Cottesloe, acting on delegated authority as if the underlying Residential Zone applied, exercised its discretion in assessing the development application for consulting rooms for a psychiatric practice in a residential zone. The Town had previously advertised the proposal as a discretionary use, thereby setting certain parameters for the consideration of the application. The court examined whether the Town correctly exercised this discretion, taking into account the specific context of the proposal and the statutory framework under which the Town operated. The Town's assessment was made in accordance with the Metropolitan Region Scheme, which provides for the land to be reserved for a primary regional road. The court scrutinized whether the Town appropriately balanced the statutory obligations with the discretionary powers vested in it, particularly in the context of a residential zone.

In addressing the neighbours' objections concerning the nature of the clientele, the court weighed these concerns against the broader need for orderly and proper planning for the Town. The objections highlighted potential issues related to the clientele of a psychiatric practice, which could affect the residential character of the area. The court considered the principle that the character of the area should be preserved, and the potential impact of the proposed use on the immediate neighbourhood. However, the court also needed to balance this against the need for accessible mental health services, which are essential for the community's well-being. The court applied the principle that while neighbourly concerns are important, they must be balanced with broader community needs and the statutory objectives of the planning scheme.

The court then examined whether there was an over-concentration of commercial uses in the residential area if the proposal for the psychiatric consulting rooms was approved. The court considered the existing uses on either side of the highway, including scattered non-residential uses, to determine if the addition of the proposed psychiatric consulting rooms would create an over-concentration of commercial activities. The court applied the principle that the planning scheme aims to prevent the over-concentration of commercial uses in residential areas, which could alter the character of the area and potentially lead to increased traffic and other commercial pressures. The court had to weigh the existing commercial uses against the proposed use, considering the overall impact on the area's residential character.

The comparative interstate and local cases were considered to determine the consistency of decision-making and the appropriateness of the Town's refusal of planning permission. The court examined how similar proposals had been handled in other jurisdictions, both interstate and locally, to assess whether the Town's decision was consistent with broader planning principles and precedents. The court applied the principle that consistent decision-making is essential for the predictability and fairness of the planning process. By comparing the current case with precedents, the court aimed to ensure that the Town's decision was not only legally sound but also aligned with established practices in the planning field.

Finally, the court evaluated whether the Tribunal was correct in refusing to set aside the Town's decision. The Tribunal's decision was based on several factors, including the residential nature of the precinct, the need to avoid over-concentration of commercial uses in the immediate locality, and the promotion of orderly and proper planning for the Town. The court upheld the Tribunal's decision, finding that it appropriately balanced the concerns of the neighbours with the broader objectives of the planning scheme. The court confirmed that the Town's refusal of planning permission was consistent with the principles of orderly and proper planning and that the Tribunal correctly exercised its review powers. The application for review was dismissed, and the decision under review was affirmed, reflecting the court's endorsement of the Town's and Tribunal's reasoning and decision-making process.