Chapple and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] AATA 1032 (16 December 2016)
Division
Taxation and Commercial Division
File Number(s)
2015/6334
Re
Mark Chapple
APPLICANT
And
Australian Securities and Investments Commission
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal Deputy President Gary Humphries
Date 16 December 2016 Place Canberra The reviewable decision is affirmed.
........................................................................
Deputy President Gary Humphries
Catchwords
Permanent banning order prohibiting applicant from providing financial services – where conduct misleading or deceptive – nature of serious fraud – effect of recklessness -purpose of banning order – decision under review affirmed.
Legislation
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Crimes Act 1900 (NSW)
Cases
Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs 2 ALD 60
Felden and ASIC 45 ACSR 111
Howarth and ASIC 101 ALD 602
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Daniele 5 ALD 135
Pollard v Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (1992) 8 ACSR 813
Saffron v the Commissioner of Taxation 30 FCR 578
Secondary Materials
ASIC - Regulatory Guide 98
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deputy President Gary Humphries
Background
The applicant, Mark Chapple, is the subject of a banning order made by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) under s 920A of the Corporations Act 2001 (the Act). The effect of the banning order is that Mr Chapple is permanently prohibited from providing financial services, as defined in the Act. On 2 December 2015 Mr Chapple applied to the Tribunal for review of this decision. He seeks that the banning order be revoked, or at least reduced in length to permit him re-entry to employment in the industry.
Mr Chapple has worked in the insurance industry since 1978, specialising in agricultural insurance. It was not disputed before the Tribunal that he had been a successful and well-regarded operator in this industry, and had built a substantial client base in northern NSW. Working independently as an insurance broker and insurance agent and as a subcontractor for an insurance broker, he earned an income through commissions and fees charged to a number of farming clients. In 2004 he was approached to join a specialist rural insurance broker, AgriRisk Services Pty Ltd (AgriRisk), on the basis that he would offer those services in future through the company and head its Tamworth office. He worked as an employee of AgriRisk for the next 9 years until he resigned in 2014.
AgriRisk operates on the basis that, generally speaking, it earns income from the commission paid by insurers in respect of clients for whom it places insurance. It also charges clients a broker administration fee in certain circumstances. These arrangements are disclosed in the Financial Services Guide AgriRisk provides to each of its clients.
When Mr Chapple joined AgriRisk he brought with him a number of clients he had recruited previously as a sole operator. In respect of four of those clients, he continued to invoice them over several years for insurance-related fees payable to his personal company, notwithstanding that the clients were also receiving invoices from AgriRisk for their insurance…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Chapple and Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] AATA 1032
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Tribunal was required to determine whether a banning order should be issued at all, and if so, whether a permanent order was the correct or preferable decision, or if a reduced period of disqualification was appropriate. This involved assessing the seriousness of Mr Chapple's conduct, the purpose of a banning order, and the impact of his personal circumstances on the appropriate penalty.
The Tribunal reasoned that Mr Chapple's conduct, which occurred repeatedly over nearly a decade and resulted in him receiving over $57,000 in unentitled commissions, was serious. Despite Mr Chapple's assertions of not fully appreciating his breach of employer policies and his claims of depression and shame, the Tribunal found his evidence demonstrated an ambivalence regarding the nature of his criminal behaviour. The Tribunal considered it inappropriate and unsafe to reduce the banning period, particularly due to Mr Chapple's tendency to minimise the seriousness of his conduct, which could reinforce his belief that his actions were not criminal and send a similar signal to the community.
The Tribunal affirmed the decision to impose a permanent banning order against Mr Chapple.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Tribunal regards the conduct giving rise to the offences of which Mr Chapple was convicted as serious. The behaviour occurred repeatedly over a period of almost a decade and involved recurring violations both of the law and of his employer’s policies. Over that period he received commissions totalling more than $57,000, payments to which he was not entitled. Mr Chapple gave evidence that he did not have a clear appreciation that his conduct was in breach of his employer’s policies, in part because he had not read some of the policies (despite the fact that he headed his employer’s Tamworth office and the policies sat for years on his desk there). His conduct was not discovered until after he left his employment with AgriRisk.Consideration The jurisdiction to impose a banning order arises by virtue of the eight fraud convictions against Mr Chapple. Standing in the shoes of ASIC to consider the exercise of the discretion in s 920A, the first question is whether a banning order should issue at all: Howarth and ASIC 101 ALD 602 at [151]. The answer to that question must be yes, in that the behaviour in question is serious and fully satisfies the criteria referred to in Regulatory Guide 98. The Tribunal must next consider whether a permanent banning order against Mr Chapple is the correct or preferable decision, taking into account the full circumstances giving rise to his convictions, or whether a reduced period of disqualification from involvement in the industry is called for. Mr Chapple placed before the Tribunal aspects of his personal circumstances which, he argued, should motivate in favour of a lesser period of exclusion from the industry. He emphasised the lack of any other criminal convictions during a long career, the strong and productive relationships he enjoyed over many years with the clients who were the subject of the charges, his firm belief that he never formed any intention to defraud those clients and his full cooperation with the subsequent ASIC investigation. He also told the Tribunal that he was suffering from severe depression during the proceedings in the courts, and that significant shame and embarrassment had been visited on his family, particularly his 13-year-old daughter who had been badly affected by the adverse publicity his case generated. He said that his professional position had been ruined by the proceedings against him, and that he was unemployed and facing bankruptcy. He pointed out that he had worked in this industry all his life, and still had skills which prospective employers had told him they were prepared to use if he was legally free to provide them. However, in undertaking consideration of this issue, the Tribunal is troubled by the ambivalence Mr Chapple demonstrated, in his written and oral evidence, regarding the nature of the conduct which led to the convictions. The authorities suggest that an applicant’s view of his own criminal behaviour is a seminal element in determining what consequences – particularly with respect to periods of disqualification – should flow from that behaviour. Considering the totality of that evidence, the Tribunal has come to the view that it would be inappropriate, or even unsafe, to reduce the period of the banning order. The factor militating most strongly in that direction is the same one referred to by the Tribunal in Howarth as militating against leniency: namely, the tendency of the applicant to minimise the seriousness of the conduct giving rise to the banning order. In summary, the Tribunal is concerned that a decision to reduce the period of the banning order may reinforce Mr Chapple’s apparent belief that his conduct did not really amount to a crime and may even send a similar signal to the northern NSW community where the offences occurred.