Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy [2021] FCA 875

File numbers: QUD 214 of 2021
QUD 215 of 2021
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 2 August 2021
Catchwords:

CORPORATIONS LAW – winding up – applications to set aside statutory demands – whether existence of judgment debts capable of genuine dispute – genuine dispute not otherwise shown to exist – defect in demand would not cause substantial injustice – no other grounds for setting aside statutory demands – applications dismissed

COSTS – indemnity costs – plaintiff continued applications after being made aware of absence of any relevantly sustainable grounds – prior history of abuse of process – application either high-handed or oppressive – order made for indemnity costs

Legislation:

Constitution s 118

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 459H, 459J

Judiciary Act 1901 (Cth) s 78B

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CG Berbatis Holdings Pty Ltd (1999) 95 FCR 292

Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Builder Pty Ltd & Anor [2018] QDC 218

Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Builders Pty Ltd & Anor [2018] QDC 248

Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Building Pty Ltd & Anor [2019] QCA 229

Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Building Pty Ltd & Anor [2020] QCA 219

Grandview Ausbuilder Pty Ltd v Budget Demolitions Pty Ltd (2019) 99 NSWLR 397

In the matter of Fewin Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 1945

In the matter of World Marketing Pty Limited [2014] NSWSC 981

In the matter of Wyse Accounting Pty Ltd [2016] NSWSC 1772

Meehan v Glazier Holdings Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 24

Oakland Property Holdings Pty Ltd v JP Morgan Trust Australia Ltd [2008] NSWCA 360

Re Douglas Aerospace Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 167

Sagacious Legal Pty Ltd v Wesfarmers General Insurance Ltd (No 3) (2010) 184 FCR 516

Spencer Constructions Pty Ltd v G & M Aldridge Pty Ltd (1997) 76 FCR 452

Tomlinson v Ramsey Food Processing Pty Ltd (2015) 256 CLR 507

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 57
Date of hearing: 27 July 2021
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Mr M Ohlson of Ohlson’s Lawyers & Barristers
Counsel for the Defendant: Mr P Travis
Solicitor for the Defendant: Axia Litigation Lawyers

ORDERS

QUD 214 of 2021
BETWEEN:

CHAPEL OF ANGELS PTY LTD ACN 154 327 867

Plaintiff

AND:

JOHN PAUL HENNESSY

Defendant

QUD 215 of 2021
BETWEEN:

CHAPEL OF ANGELS PTY LTD ACN 154 327 867

Plaintiff

AND:

HENNESSY BUILDERS PTY LTD ABN 45 151 515 376

Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

DERRINGTON J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 AUGUST 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.In action QUD 214 of 2021:

(a)the application filed on 1 July 2021 to set aside the statutory demand is dismissed.

(b)the plaintiff is to pay the defendant’s costs of and incidental to the application on an indemnity basis.

(c)the defendant has leave to make any application as he sees fit…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 875
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Court was an application by Chapel of Angels to set aside two statutory demands made by Mr Hennessy and Hennessy Building under s 459H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The statutory demands were based on the amounts owing pursuant to two judgments of the District Court of Queensland. Chapel of Angels sought to set aside the statutory demands on the basis that there was a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debts claimed. The legal issues the Court was required to decide were whether there was a genuine dispute for the purposes of s 459H(1)(a) of the Corporations Act and, if not, whether the Court should exercise its discretion to set aside the statutory demands under s 459H(2). The Court found that there was no genuine dispute as to the existence of the debts, as the statutory demands were founded upon judgment debts. The Court also found that there were no other grounds for setting aside the statutory demands. The Court dismissed the applications and ordered Chapel of Angels to pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to the application on an indemnity basis.

The Court found that the statutory demands were based on judgment debts, and therefore, the existence of the debts was beyond dispute. The Court noted that it was well settled that a judgment debt was beyond dispute while it stood, even in the case of a default judgment. The Court held that the plaintiff's attempt to challenge the validity of the judgments and orders of the District Court was not a genuine dispute for the purposes of s 459H(1)(a) of the Corporations Act. The Court also found that there were no other grounds for setting aside the statutory demands. The Court dismissed the applications and ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to the application on an indemnity basis. The Court noted that the plaintiff had continued the applications after being made aware of the absence of any relevantly sustainable grounds and had a prior history of abuse of process. The Court considered the application either high-handed or oppressive.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In action QUD 214 of 2021:

(a) the application filed on 1 July 2021 to set aside the statutory demand is dismissed.

(b) the plaintiff is to pay the defendant’s costs of and incidental to the application on an indemnity basis.

(c) the defendant has leave to make any application as he sees fit for any further order for costs against any person who is not otherwise a party to these proceedings.

2. In action QUD 215 of 2021:

(a) the application filed on 1 July 2021 to set aside the statutory demand is dismissed.

(b) the plaintiff is to pay the defendant’s costs of and incidental to the application on an indemnity basis.

(c) the defendant has leave to make any application as it sees fit for any further order for costs against any person who is not otherwise a party to these proceedings.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

As a result of the substantially overlapping submissions made in each matter, the two applications were heard together and these reasons are applicable to both.BACKGROUND Though the facts of this matter might be stated relatively briefly, it is necessary to set out the history of the litigation between the parties in some detail in order to properly address some of the more ambitious submissions made by Mr Ohlson on behalf of the plaintiff. On 12 November 2018, Judge Porter QC DCJ delivered judgment in the District Court Proceeding and directed the parties to make submissions as to appropriate orders to reflect his Honour’s findings: Chapel of Angels (No 1). On 11 December 2018, his Honour made orders, inter alia, requiring Chapel of Angels to pay Mr Hennessy’s costs of the proceeding and on an indemnity basis. That order arose as a result of the applicant abandoning its claim against Mr Hennessy on the eve of the trial. A further costs order was made in favour of Hennessy Building, albeit on a different basis.The decisions at first instance The District Court Proceeding was commenced by Chapel of Angels on or about 23 October 2014 and arose out of a building dispute concerning the construction of a building by Hennessy Building for Chapel of Angels. Mr Hennessy is the director and guiding mind of Hennessy Building. The plaintiff’s claim at trial was, first, that Hennessy Building was obliged to return all of the progress payments made to it because some of the work which it had undertaken was beyond the scope of its building licence and, second, that the manner in which certain variations were effected in the course of the construction did not comply with the contractual requirements such that no amounts were payable in respect of them. Judge Porter QC DCJ concluded that Hennessy Building was unlicensed in respect of some of the work required for the construction of the building, with the consequence that Chapel of Angels was entitled to the return of the payments which it had made: Chapel of Angels (No 1) [111]. However, his Honour also found that Hennessy Building was entitled to recover reasonable remuneration for the work which it had undertaken and that amount exceeded the amount which it was required to repay to Chapel of Angels: at [166]. As determined in Chapel of Angels (No 2), the appropriate order reflecting those conclusions was that Chapel of Angels pay to Hennessy Building the sum of $85,989.86: at [6]. The plaintiff was also ordered to pay part of Hennessy Building’s costs as assessed, in part on a standard basis and in part on an indemnity basis.Appeals pursued by the plaintiff On or about 3 May 2019, Chapel of Angels commenced proceedings in the Queensland Court of Appeal seeking an extension of time in which to seek leave to appeal from the decision of Judge Porter QC DCJ. It appears that leave to appeal was required as the amount of the judgment did not exceed the jurisdictional limit of the Magistrates Court of Queensland: District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 118; Magistrates Court Act 1921, s 4(a); Magistrates Court Regulation 2007 (Qld), reg 3. Furthermore, an extension of time was required as the time limited for seeking leave had lapsed. Chapel of Angels also applied for a stay of the District Court judgment although that application was refused: Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Building Pty Ltd & Anor [2019] QCA 229.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 12 November 2018, Judge Porter QC DCJ delivered judgment in the District Court Proceeding and directed the parties to make submissions as to appropriate orders to reflect his Honour’s findings: Chapel of Angels (No 1). On 11 December 2018, his Honour made orders, inter alia, requiring Chapel of Angels to pay Mr Hennessy’s costs of the proceeding and on an indemnity basis. That order arose as a result of the applicant abandoning its claim against Mr Hennessy on the eve of the trial. A further costs order was made in favour of Hennessy Building, albeit on a different basis.The decisions at first instance The District Court Proceeding was commenced by Chapel of Angels on or about 23 October 2014 and arose out of a building dispute concerning the construction of a building by Hennessy Building for Chapel of Angels. Mr Hennessy is the director and guiding mind of Hennessy Building. The plaintiff’s claim at trial was, first, that Hennessy Building was obliged to return all of the progress payments made to it because some of the work which it had undertaken was beyond the scope of its building licence and, second, that the manner in which certain variations were effected in the course of the construction did not comply with the contractual requirements such that no amounts were payable in respect of them. Judge Porter QC DCJ concluded that Hennessy Building was unlicensed in respect of some of the work required for the construction of the building, with the consequence that Chapel of Angels was entitled to the return of the payments which it had made: Chapel of Angels (No 1) [111]. However, his Honour also found that Hennessy Building was entitled to recover reasonable remuneration for the work which it had undertaken and that amount exceeded the amount which it was required to repay to Chapel of Angels: at [166]. As determined in Chapel of Angels (No 2), the appropriate order reflecting those conclusions was that Chapel of Angels pay to Hennessy Building the sum of $85,989.86: at [6]. The plaintiff was also ordered to pay part of Hennessy Building’s costs as assessed, in part on a standard basis and in part on an indemnity basis.Appeals pursued by the plaintiff On or about 3 May 2019, Chapel of Angels commenced proceedings in the Queensland Court of Appeal seeking an extension of time in which to seek leave to appeal from the decision of Judge Porter QC DCJ. It appears that leave to appeal was required as the amount of the judgment did not exceed the jurisdictional limit of the Magistrates Court of Queensland: District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 118; Magistrates Court Act 1921, s 4(a); Magistrates Court Regulation 2007 (Qld), reg 3. Furthermore, an extension of time was required as the time limited for seeking leave had lapsed. Chapel of Angels also applied for a stay of the District Court judgment although that application was refused: Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Building Pty Ltd & Anor [2019] QCA 229. On 7 October 2020, the Court of Appeal refused Chapel of Angels’ application for an extension of time and ordered it to pay the defendants’ costs of the proceeding before it: Chapel of Angels Pty Ltd v Hennessy Building Pty Ltd & Anor [2020] QCA 219. As might be expected, in determining the question of whether an extension of time should be granted, Fraser JA, in his Honour’s usual precise and erudite manner, carefully considered the issues which Chapel of Angels wished to agitate had the appeal been permitted to proceed. In doing so, his Honour concluded that the trial judge had not misconstrued the Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld) (the QBSA Act) when allowing Hennessy Building to recover reasonable remuneration for its work: at [57]. (The QBSA Act has since been renamed the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld)). Otherwise, his Honour held that the arguments sought to be agitated on appeal had not been advanced to the primary judge and could not support the application for an extension of time: at [65].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On or about 2 March 2021, Chapel of Angels applied to the District Court for orders setting aside the cost assessor’s certificates. That application was dismissed on 18 March 2021 by Judge Muir DCJ.CONSIDERATIONThe absence of a “genuine dispute” for the purposes of s 459H(1)(a) of the Act The principal ground relied upon by Chapel of Angels in seeking to have the statutory demands set aside was an alleged dispute about the existence of the whole of the debts claimed by Mr Hennessy and Hennessy Building pursuant to their respective demands. This ground rested upon the plaintiff’s submission that, in these proceedings, it was entitled to challenge the validity of the judgments and orders of the District Court on which the amounts claimed in the statutory demands were based. In particular, it was submitted that it was open to this Court to consider, first, whether Judge Porter DCJ had erred in his Honour’s decisions and, second, whether there were errors in the costs assessor’s certificates upon which the District Court orders of 17 February 2021 were made. It was submitted on behalf of Mr Hennessy and Hennessy Building that neither the application nor the supporting affidavits gave rise to a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debts to which the statutory demands related for the purposes of s 459H(1)(a) of the Act. It is well established that in order to establish a “genuine dispute” it must be shown that a bona fide dispute in fact exists, as opposed to one which is merely alleged on spurious, hypothetical or misconceived grounds: Spencer Constructions Pty Ltd v G & M Aldridge Pty Ltd (1997) 76 FCR 452 (Spencer Constructions) at 464. Here, the defendant in each action submitted that, as the statutory demands are founded upon judgment debts, there was no scope for the plaintiff to raise any dispute as to their existence. That submission should be accepted. The effect of the judgments of the District Court is that, as between the plaintiff and the defendant in each action, there exists a judicial determination following a contested hearing as to the former’s liability to the latter. As between those parties, the respective liabilities and obligations arising from the issues between them have been settled by a final and binding decision. Questions about which party is liable to whom and in what amount are no longer open. They have been resolved. Such reasoning underpins the now well settled principle that, on an application to set aside a statutory demand founded upon a judgment debt, it is not open to the debtor to raise any genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt. This was clearly articulated by Brereton J in Re Douglas Aerospace Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 167 (Douglas Aerospace), where his Honour stated (at [52] – [53]):52At the outset, it is as well to note certain principles relevant to whether a debt can be the subject of a genuine dispute or offsetting claim that are of more general application – that is to say, their application is not confined to debts arising under BACISOPA and similar legislation.53First, it is well-established that a judgment debt is beyond dispute, while it stands [Barclays Australia (Finance) Ltd v Mike Gaffikin Marine Pty Ltd (1996) 21 ACSR 235; Eumina Investments Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1998) 84 FCR 454; Midas Management Pty Ltd v Equator Communications Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 759; (2007) 25 ACLC 1038; Joadja Whiskey v Abraham [2007] NSWSC 860, [14] (Hammerschlag J)]. This applies even in the case of a default judgment [Diddy Boy v Design [2009] NSWSC 14, [40]; Virtual Technologies International Ltd v Gye [2010] NSWSC 399, [11]-[13]; Timberland Property Holdings Pty Ltd v Schindler Lifts Australia Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 466, [9]-[11]]. It applies also to an arbitration award [Quadwest Development Pty Ltd v Thi [2009] WASC 54]. And it applies notwithstanding that the judgment is subject to an appeal or an application to set it aside, although the pendency of an arguable appeal may provide “some other reason” for setting aside the demand – at least if the judgment is the subject of a stay pending the appeal, or security is given [Wilden Pty Ltd v Greenco Pty Ltd (1995) 13 ACLC 1039; Barclays Australia v Mike Gaffikin Marine; Eumina Investments v Westpac, 457-8; Eagle Homes Pty Ltd v LED Builders Pty Ltd [1999] NSWSC 1049, [20]; Scope Data Systems Pty Ltd v BDO Nelson Parkhill (2003) 199 ALR 6; [2003] NSWSC 137, [17]-[20]; Midas Management v Equator Communications Pty Ltd, [12], [24]; ACN 001 891 103 Pty Ltd v Reiby Street Apartments Pty Ltd [2007] NSWSC 1345, [8], [10]; Australian Beverage Distributors Pty Ltd v Evans & Tate Premium Wines Pty Ltd (2007) 61 ACSR 441, [26]-[41]; Cranney Farm Pty Ltd v Corowa Fertilizers Pty Ltd [2011] NSWSC 9, [57]]. Essentially, that is so because the judgment, so long as it stands, binds the parties and concludes any dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt.